Britain vs France! - 1845 Pattern Infantry Officer's Swords Compared

"Echo Blade "
1 follower
1 Video View·Feb 3, 2026
Britain vs France! - 1845 Pattern Infantry Officer's Swords Compared
Hi there, Matt Easton here of Eastern Antique Arms and Scholar Gladiatoria. So
what we're looking at today is Britain versus France, that age-old rivalry, but specifically
we're looking at the 1845 Patton sword from France and the 1845 Patton sword from Britain,
in both cases for infantry officers. So first up let's just have a quick look at the swords before
I go into a load of speaking. So this is an 1845 model sword, referred generally to incidentally
in France as a model, in Britain as a Patton. The scabbard of this dictates that this will
often be known as an 1855 model sword in France, however the model of sword essentially is the
same, it's really the scabbard that changed. In 1845 they had a brass and leather scabbard
and in 1855 they got a steel scabbard. Okay so this is the French sword, very nice blade as I'm
sure you can see, with a brass hilt. Similarly the British sword, the 1845 Patton infantry officer's
sword, has a brass hilt and a different style of blade. Now very briefly before I go into comparing
and contrasting these two swords, I'll just show very briefly what went before in both cases. So
in France the 1822 Patton was looking like this, so a slightly more minimalist guard, so slightly
less protective guard, and you can see a blade which is more similar in fact to the light cavalry
1822 Patton blade, a fullered blade with a little bit more curve and a point, this is important,
a point located to the rear of the blade like a cavalry sabre continued to be in France.
Now in Britain we had a pipe backed blade from 1822 until 1845. This is an example of one however
it's not a great example because this is a very unusual one, this is actually an example made by
Prosser that is exceptionally wide and heavier than normal and as such is a better blade than
the typical one. The typical one is more narrow than this and doesn't usually have this flared
sort of false edge or yeoman at the back is what we normally find on navy officers swords,
not usually on infantry officers swords, but this is an infantry officer's sword
marked to William IV, so it's pre-Victorian. And nevertheless this is a pipe back blade,
that being that it has a rod section at the back and then flat more or less in front of that.
Also aside from that, so those are the two swords that came before the 1845s,
interesting to note that in France in 1822 the infantry officers of both France and Britain
obtained new models of sword and then in 1845, again both in France and Britain,
infantry officers gained a new model of sword. I don't think this is coincidence,
I think this is partly to do with Anglo-French relations, competitiveness, keeping up with the
most rivaled neighbours, I don't know, something along those lines. But one thing to mention as
well is that this type of sabre in France was used by junior officers and adjutants and also
non-commissioned officers, so sergeants and corporals. So this was the officer's sabre
and non-commissioned officer's sabre for the lower ranks. The higher ranks, for some reason,
unbeknownst to me, and I don't know anyone else who knows the reasoning, although it might be
contained somewhere in some French text, they used a straight double-edged thrusting blade for the
higher ranks. Maybe, I don't know, maybe they thought it was closer to an epee blade, maybe
they thought it was somehow more representative of higher class, or perhaps it was simply that
they thought that they were less likely to get into combat if they were above the rank of major
or whatever, I don't know. But in Britain, that wasn't the case. In Britain, after 1845,
the officers basically kept the same model of sword right the way up to the rank of general.
When they became a general, there was a general officer's model of sword, the 1831 Mamluk type of
sabre. However, on campaign, generals would generally wear that for dress, but they'd wear
a proper sword, a fighting sword for campaigning. A famous example is Colin Campbell. Photographs
of him from the Indian mutiny show him wearing actually something that looks kind of like that.
It looks like an old 1796 cavalry sabre. So generally speaking on campaign, officers could,
in reality, especially if they were outside Europe, pretty much choose to carry whatever
they wanted. So if they wanted to carry an old family sabre or a cavalry sword because it was
bigger than they could. And in fact, in India, many British officers did elect to wear tolwars,
which isn't necessarily because they thought they were better weapons. I know of one example where
an officer is photographed wearing a tolwar, but actually we know that on service he had a cavalry
sword, a Wilkinson cavalry sword that he used. So it could sometimes just be because it was the
local fashion or because they wanted to show more kind of camaraderie with their Indian troopers.
I don't know, could be many reasons. Right, back to the British and French 1845 patterns.
So in the broadest possible terms, they are similar-ish swords in that they're both
similar weight, similar-ish length, although we'll talk about that in a minute, and they've both got
brass hilts and obviously steel blades. Now there is a bit of a difference. Let's talk about the
blades to begin with, okay. The blades both have what we call a spear point. You'll see that the
points of both are located in the centre of the blade. That makes them better at thrusting.
Remember what I showed with the point of the earlier French sword which was located in line
with the back edge? They generally are worse at thrusting because as soon as you impact with
something, if I just put the British sword down for a second, as soon as you impact with something,
if the point is located at the back, the back end of the sword will want to divert out, or indeed
what will happen is it will skim off the target if there's any kind of resistance. So if it hits
bone, for example, if the point hits bone it will slide off away from it, or if it hits a buckle
or some kind of thick clothing, a thick winter coat, for example, like in the Crimean War,
it's more likely to divert and less of that energy is going to penetrate through what you're trying
to thrust through. So a spear point, much the same reason as a spear or a lance, has a central point.
If you want good penetration with a sword, you want a central point. If the point is located
towards the back on something like this 1803 or indeed a Talwar, it is always going to be more
difficult. It's not to say you can't stab with it, but it is always going to be more difficult to get
good deep penetration with it. Right, so back to the sword. So the French sword, like the British
sword, has a central point, spear point, very similar. Both have false edges, that is they are
edged down the back edge for about six to eight inches. It depends, it varies from sword to sword
and it varies slightly. I'd say the British ones tend to have slightly longer false edge than the
French ones. You'll notice that the British one has a single fuller, much like the earlier French
one actually, and like most other swords with fullers to be frank. But the French sword has not
always, but very very usually and very often, a double fuller and you'll notice there's a thinner
fuller right at the spine there. So we've got the main fuller here and a thin fuller at the back
and that is known as the Montmorency style. Now you'll see in this example that continues all the
way almost to the tip. It doesn't always do that in these French swords, sometimes it only continues
to the beginning of the false edge and ends there. So there is variation between these French blades.
This one is not named on the back, although it may have been once, but the two main centres for
making of these blades as far as I've seen were Klingenthal and Châtellerault, and some being
made in Saint-Étienne, but Saint-Étienne seemed to have made more bayonets and firearms. Right, so
this blade has a double fuller rather than a single fuller. Is there any big difference between
having one broad fuller and in the French case a broad fuller and then a narrow fuller?
I don't know. I haven't conducted extensive testing, but I will tell you that the French
blades are very stiff. It may possibly contribute to the stiffness, it may increase the stiffness
of the blade in the thrust, however it does also increase the weight very slightly I think, because
essentially rather than having one thick ridge here and one thick ridge at the back, you've now
got two thick ridges at the back. So I think that pound for pound in terms of the length of the
blade and the breadth of the blade, the French cross-section is going to be heavier than the
British cross-section, although that's the disadvantage. The advantage is that I think
you gain stiffness, so they've added a bit of weight to add to the stiffness for the thrust,
and it is definitely a good thrusting weapon. You can see that the point is in line with the hilt
and although it's got a slight curve on it to facilitate the cut very slightly, it is more or
less a straight weapon. It is an effective thrusting weapon and there is usually, as on
the British swords, a very slight cant to the grip, meaning that when you grip it with the thumb up,
the point comes more easily on line with the forearm. So the final thing I want to say about
the blade, I talked about the fullers and the weight and the stiffness, is the length. French
swords tend to be, or French infantry officer swords, tend to be shorter than British ones.
Now that being said, there's a lot of variation between makers and there's variation between
individual swords, so it's not always the case. You can find longer French ones, you can find
longer British ones, and you can find shorter of both. However, this French one is fairly typical
and as is typical, it has a 30 inch blade. Now 30 inches is pretty short by British standards,
okay? The standard British infantry officer's sword was 32 and a half inches, so two and a
half inches further, which is about five centimeters extra length on the tip. I think
part of the reason why the French, some of you going, oh the French are shorter than the British,
I don't know that's necessarily true, I think there's maybe like half a centimeters
average height difference, but I think the main reason why the French infantry officer's sword
was made shorter was to keep the weight down, because it's a stiffer, thicker, essentially,
blade. So because it's a thicker, or the cross section has got more volume in it, you need to
make the blade a little bit shorter so that it doesn't become too heavy. At that point, I'll just
speak briefly about weight, because I weighed this. Now I have always known that these 1845
pattern French swords feel heavy-ish in the hand, but they feel, they've got quite a lot of authority,
and I quite like that extra weight, but they feel a good weight to me. But I was surprised when I
weighed this, that it is 1000 grams. Now that's not, I have British swords of a similar size that
weigh the same amount, but they are unusual. Most British swords of this type, for infantry
officers for example, tend to only weigh about 900 grams. So the French sword, for its size,
remembering that it's only got a 30 inch blade, the French sword is quite heavy. But it is stiff,
you know, there's always a plus and to go with a minus. Now the British sword has a lighter,
more nimble blade, it has definitely less mass in the tip. You'll notice that the British blade
transitions from being fullered, and then about 12 inches from the point, about, yeah, let's say
25 centimetres from the point, it turns into what we call a flattened diamond section,
essentially double-edged. So if you imagine a double-edged medieval sword, the end part of
this sword is like that. Whereas the French sword, you will see, the fuller continues all the way to
the tip, as does in this case the Montmorency secondary fuller at the back. So they are quite
different blade sections, especially towards the tip of the blade. And what this means is that the
British sword is very much, if we just sawed off that end of the blade and we sawed off the equivalent
length on the French sword, the end 12 inches of blade, or 10-12 inches of blade, is much lighter
on the British sword. The result is that in the hand, the British sword feels a lot more nimble.
Funnily enough, it feels more like the earlier 1822 French sword. So the British sword's longer,
pound for pound it's slightly lighter, and it's more nimble. The points of balance, let's have a
look at the points of balance. So again, they all vary between examples. This one, just grab my tape
measure. So this example, so this is an example incidentally marked to the Bengal engineers. I
actually know the officer who carried this during the Indian mutiny, and he went on to serve in
India. He in fact was one of the people responsible for building a lot of the railways in India.
But he started out as a junior officer during the mutiny. So it's four and a half inches,
about 11 and a half centimeters. Okay, so yeah, four and a half inches for the British sword,
and bearing in mind that's the 32 and a half inch blade. And then for the French sword,
this looks further out to me, it is five inches out, so about 13 centimeters. So the French sword
is shorter, heavier, and with a point of balance further from the hand. And the result is that it
feels far more choppy. It feels closer to like a cutlass. It's not as heavy as a cutlass, but
it feels like more of a chopping blade. Despite the fact that it's very clearly an effective
thrusting design, it actually feels like a chopper. Whereas the British sword, the 1845 from
Britain, feels a little bit more nimble in the point, and a bit more like a combination cut and
that sharp. Ironically, it is more flexible in the blade. This incidentally was service sharpened
for the mutiny, and remains still incredibly pointy at the end, and fairly well edged as well.
It's been well looked after. I would just mention briefly as well, so the hilts, this is not a
typical example of its time, because it doesn't have the folding in a flap. Okay, if I just grab
another sword to illustrate that point. This sword is a non-typical blade, but you can see
that the British sword from 1845 to 1850, late 1850s to 1860, let's say 1860, 1845 to 1860,
had a folding in a flap to make it more convenient to wear. But from about 1860 onwards, that was
abandoned universally, and a solid guard was instituted instead because it's stronger. This
is a pre-1860 sword, obviously it dates from before the mutiny. In fact, it dates to around
early 1850s, I think. So not all swords from before 1860 had that folding in a guard.
Some of them were solid, as this one is. So, to sum up, they are fundamentally similar sort of
swords. But the general difference between the British 1845 and the French 1845 is that the
French sword, both have brass hilts, both have steel blades of course, the French sword tends
to be shorter, and tends to be heavier and stiffer. Stiffer and heavier often go hand in hand,
not always, but in this case it is the case that the French swords tend to be, and again I'll
reiterate, not always, they do vary, you do get light French ones, you do get heavy British ones,
but they tend to be shorter, heavier and stiffer, these French ones. Finally, just to finish off,
between the hilts, there is not a big difference. The British sword definitely provides more hand
protection. The brass guard on the British sword covers more area, but I would say the French sword
guard is probably stronger. So you'll notice the brass that the hilt is made of, in the British
example, is slightly thinner, slightly slimmer than the French one. The French one is more chunky,
but as you can see, the French one is smaller in terms of the surface area, and especially from the
front, the way you're looking there, but equally looking point on as well. Point on the British
one's bigger, edge on the British one is also bigger. In terms of the grips, the fundamental
difference is that the French sword has a separate pommel cap, and the British sword has a pommel
integrated with a back strap. The British one is a stronger construction. Some people would argue
that the back strap makes for a slightly slippier grip. I don't personally agree, I find the French
sword is just as slippy as the British one is. If you're on campaign, as John Musgrave-Waite advises
in his book, you should wrap the grip with something of a more grippy nature, a bit like
how modern sports people, including people in HEMA and fencing, wrap their sword grips with
something like tennis wrap to give it more traction. They did the same thing in the 19th
century. When they were on campaign, they often wrapped the grip with waxed cord or similar.
So the French grip is made of wood or horn, and it is essentially oval in shape with no back strap.
The British one, however, has a back strap all the way down, it's wood inside with shagreen or
shark skin on the outside. Now, I would say that the British swords are a more expensive construction.
In terms of the materials, I think the British swords, more money went into them. There's shark
skin in there, the wire is much more fancy on British swords, the guards are finer and more
detailed castings, and British swords always have detailed etching on the blades, which French
swords very, very rarely do. French swords are much more basic and utilitarian. For that reason,
some people prefer the French swords, they do look more like issued weapons, whereas the British
swords are very clearly private purchase and very fancy and decided to show off your status. But as
weapons, I don't think there's anything really to pick between them. I have said on a number of
occasions on forums and elsewhere that I think the French infantry officer's sword is almost perfect
in its blade design, not its hilt design. Do I still stand by that statement? Yes, I'm a big fan
of it. If I'd been a British officer in say 1850, 1860, I would have been quite happy to have a
French blade on a British hilt. They are damned good blades and there's no patriotism involved
here at all. I don't feel any patriotism at all towards the 19th century, or indeed really to
today. The swords are the swords and I'm just judging them on that basis. I think the French
have a fantastic design. What the British design has over the French is the fact that it's a bit
lighter because of the cross section, it's a bit lighter for the length, so you can have a longer
blade that actually weighs slightly less, which in some situations could be good. However, I would
say that the French blade has a lot of authority, hits with a lot of authority, and is a very stiff
and robust and strong blade. So I am a fan of both models of sword. I think the hilts are
definitely, I think the hilts and grips are definitely better on British swords from a
utilitarian point of view. They cover more area and I think they're better grips in general.
French swords always get loose because of the way they're constructed. British swords do sometimes
get loose but usually don't, so the British construction seems to be better. But the blade
design of the French sword I do really really like and whilst I do like the British 1845 blade,
I think the French 1845 blade is really really good as well. So different swords for similar
contexts but they came up with slightly different solutions to solve similar problems. There we go,
I'll let you judge which is your favourite. Feel free to post below and give me your views on both
which you think is the nicest sword or indeed if there's another model of sword that you particularly
love and I will see you for the next video. Cheers folks! Thanks for watching, please subscribe,
we have extra videos on Patreon and you can follow us on Facebook.
