Vishaka Case | Relationship between Municipal and International Law - Sexual Harassment at Workplace

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
2 Video Views·Feb 7, 2026
Expert legal overview of the International Court of Justice 2022 judgment in Democratic Republic of the Congo v Uganda, examining jurisdictional basis, standards for establishing violations, state responsibility, reparations, and implications for the prohibition of force, sovereignty, and obligations under public international law.
Hello Everyone. It was held in Jolly George Vergy's v. Bank of Cochin that international
law per se has not the force or authority of civil law. Still under its inspirational
impact, actual legislation is undertaken. Is it correct? Or I should ask, is this the
correct approach towards international law? How far can we go by undermining the importance
of international law? Well, let us see in a while. Today, in this video, I will discuss
Vishakha case from the lenses of international law. We will try to understand how judiciary
approached international law in this case differently from the previous ones, especially
when there was no law in India on certain issues. So let's start. The facts of this
case are as follows. Bhavri Devi, aged about 50 years old, was a Rajasthan state government
employee who was working as a saathim to fight against the ill-practice of child marriage.
Under the course of her employment as a worker of women development program, she tried to
prevent the marriage of Ramkaran Gujjar's year-old infant girl in a village in Rajasthan.
Although marriage was commenced by the family members, but they did not let Bhavri Devi
to get away. This act of Bhavri Devi enraged those family members. She was subjected to
social boycott and later in September 1992, five men from that community, including Ramkaran
Gujjar, brutally gang-raped her infant of her husband. Bhavri Devi suffered a lot of
mental distress after this incident since no immediate and necessary assistance was
provided to her by police and medical officials. When this matter was brought before the trial
court, the judge ruled accused to be not guilty. It was not necessary for this video to discuss
these grounds, but still I want to discuss them quickly to make you aware of the insensitivity
shown by the judicial system towards women's issue.
First, court said both uncle and nephew cannot rape another woman together. Next, a married
man who is obliged to protect his wife cannot simply stand watching her getting raped when
only two old men were holding him. Next, in Indian rural society, a villager cannot go
to that slope where he will lose all sense of age and caste for committing rape.
Last is Bhavri Devi's delayed report. Well, reports were delayed because of the insensitive
legal system we have that itself delayed all necessary actions. This judgment caused women's
group pressure on the state government to file an appeal before the Rajasthan High Court.
In December 1993, court identified Bhavri Devi to be a rape victim. However, it did
not find the alleged village man to be the accused. In response to this decision, many
social activists and non-governmental organizations clubbed together and filed a public interest
litigation under Article 32 of Indian Constitution on the common platform of Vishaka on the issue
of sexual harassment at the workplace. The injustice and brutal attack suffered by Bhavri
Devi exposes the gravity of sexual harassment in the workplace and the lack of protections
women have against it. Now, based on the PIL, Supreme Court had to perform two functions
in this case. Firstly, finding suitable methods for the realization of the concept of gender
equality and secondly, developing certain guidelines to further prevent sexual harassment
at workplace. So, these are the prominent findings of the Supreme Court where court
found that sexual harassment of women at workplace is in violation of women's human rights and
fundamental rights. It violates Article 14, 15, 91G and 21 of the Indian Constitution.
Now, court started discussing this case from gender equality point of view. Court recognized
sexual harassment as a discriminatory form of violence against women. It held that gender
equality includes protection from sexual harassment and right to work with dignity which is a
universally recognized basic human right. But the biggest challenge before the court
was that there was no law on sexual harassment of women at workplace in India. Matters related
to the sexual harassment of women were dealt under the provisions of Indian Penal Code
that are Section 354 and 509. Women who were sexually harassed at the workplace had to
go to the police and file a complaint. Previously, in Rupan Deol Bajaj v. K. P. S. Gill which
was also a sexual harassment at workplace case, recourse to the limited provisions of
IPC under Section 354 and Section 509 was not found sufficient by the High Court. This
gap in the law was very apparent and the need for further reforms on sexual harassment was
obvious. It is the duty of the legislature and executive to enact the legislation for
guaranteeing the safety and dignity to its individuals. It has been constructed by the
court that where no such enactment is present, then it becomes the responsibility of the
court to fill up the existing vacuum in the legal system through some guidelines. Here
the big question is, can court make a law? Traditional role of judiciary has been to
interpret the law. Well, this case was another example of judicial activism where legislature
has not done its part and subject matter was urgent as it concerns the protection of fundamental
rights. So, judiciary came forward but yes along with certain limitations. Now, what
are those limitations? I will discuss in a while. Now, next question was when law is
not present in the country and court have to issue the guidelines, so how this can be
done? The court held that in the absence of a domestic legislation for guaranteeing gender
equality and enforcing right to work with human dignity under Article 14, 15, 191G
and 21, the provisions of any international convention can be brought into the domestic
law. So, is it that easy? Can provisions of any international convention be brought
in India? To answer this question, let us first understand two theories governing the
relationship between international law and municipal law that are monism and dualism.
Monism provides that international law and municipal law belongs to a same legal order.
Both the regimes are two sides of a same coin. So, if a state becomes a party to any
treaty, the provisions of that treaty can be directly enforced in the state. On the
other hand, dualism provides that municipal law and international law belongs to two different
branches of law. Further, it believes that both the laws operate in different areas.
So here, when a state becomes a party to any treaty, the provisions of that treaty
does not automatically become part of their law. It has to be given a legislative form
and a bill has to be passed in parliament for it to acquire the status of law. Now,
to answer my question, yes, provisions of any international convention can be brought
in India but certain requirements are need to be followed for this purpose. Firstly,
India must be a party to that international convention. Secondly, since India has adopted
dualism, it requires a legislation to place international law into domestic sphere. And
thirdly, such treaty provisions must not be in conflict but in harmony with the provisions
of the constitution of India or any existing law on that issue. Our constitution has prescribed
set of articles that deals with international law. Even the court mentioned that article
51 clause 3 and article 263 to be read with entry 14 of union list under 7th schedule,
parliament is enabled to make such laws. Also, under article 73, union has been granted the
power of parliament to enact laws. However, such powers shall be available to the union
till the parliament enacts any such law on that issue. Now, what are those international
conventions that talk about international human rights and further can be invoked by
supreme court in this case? So, the answer was found in CEDAW i.e. Convention on the
Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women. This case presented a new kind
of situation before the court. The court was having an idea about the conclusion it has
to achieve but does not know the method to arrive at that conclusion. Since no legislation
was available in the country, the court looked at the international arena to ascertain law
on this issue where it found CEDAW. The government of India has ratified CEDAW on 25th June 1993
which prohibits discrimination in the workplace and outlines specific state obligations to
end it. Being a party to CEDAW, India can invoke article 11 and 24 of this convention
that were relevant for this case. Also, in 4th World Conference at Beijing in 1995, Indian
government has officially committed to formulate and operationalize a national policy to enforce
women's rights. There, the court has also referred the case of Neelavati Vehra v. State of Orissa
to illustrate that international conventions and norms can be incorporated in municipal
law which ensures the fundamental rights guaranteed under the constitution. Since in respect of
sexual harassment at workplace, there was no conflicting national law, the international
commitment as laid out in CEDAW would be treated as part of the Indian law. And since it was
to be treated as part of Indian law, what the Supreme Court was doing was not creating
any law but only declaring the law and filling up some gap to better implement the already
existing law. However, court faced a difficulty while incorporating that provision in the
domestic sphere because as per dualism theory, no international law can directly be incorporated
in the domestic law. So, instead of relying upon article 253 of the constitution, the
court invoked the provisions of CEDAW and laid the guidelines. The court has adopted
CEDAW recommendations and you can find these points not only in the guidelines but the
Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace Act of 2013, specially the definition of the term
sexual harassment that is provided under point 23. Now, let us discuss the important points
from this case. First of all, whether court had the authority to invoke international
convention in this case? Yes, the court found support for its action under international
law, both from treaty base and customary law. In its analysis, the court first cited principles
from the 1995 Beijing Statement of the Independence of the Judiciary in the Law Asia region to
establish the propriety of its actions. Specifically, the court noted the importance of Beijing
Statement's article 10 which imposes duties on the judiciary to promote human rights and
ensure equal protection under the law. Thus, the Beijing Statement provided a justification
for the court's issuance of guidelines in the human rights field. Next, this case discussed
two important concepts and placed them together in a highly appreciable manner that are judicial
activism and separation of powers. Now understand this, the judgment was pronounced in a situation
when till 1997 there was simply no legal recognition of sexual harassment. Court found that the
present civil and penal laws in the country do not adequately provide for specific protection
of women from sexual harassment at workplace and the enactment of such legislation would
take a considerable time. So, it is because of the tardiness of legislature and the indifference
of the executive which provides the necessity for judicial intervention. When the court
is apprised of and is satisfied about the gross violations of basic human rights, it
cannot hold its hands in despair and look the other way. In view of the case and the
fact that there was no enacted law to provide for the effective enforcement of the basic
human rights of gender equality and more particularly against sexual harassment at workplace, the
Supreme Court laid down the guidelines and norms for due observance at workplaces or
other institutions until a legislation was enacted for the purpose. The court made it
clear that this was done in exercise of the power available under Article 32 of the Constitution
for the enforcement of fundamental rights and this would be treated as the law declared
by it under Article 141 of the Constitution. So, if I answer this question that can a judge
make a law in India? Does it not hamper the doctrine of preparation of power? My answer
will be no. Judge is not empowered to make law in India. The task of judiciary is to
interpret the law. However, a judge may legislate only between gaps. There will be open spaces
in law. The process being legislative demands the legislator's wisdom. In this case as well,
Supreme Court did not replace the Parliament. What it did was only adopted guidelines till
the time Parliament can come up with a proper legislation. So, they did made a guideline
but they acted only as a bridge between no law and proper law for a limited time period
and a time period that is to be decided by the Parliament itself. Next, this case marked
a turning point for women empowerment by focusing on an untouched issue of sexual harassment
at workplace. Unlike traditional cases, the court proceeded in a different manner. It
gave a new approach where international law is not merely referred for inspiration or
motivation as held in Jolly George Berge's case or Xavier's case but can play an active
role in the domestic law making. The court specially relied on international law and
invited its application in this case. This reflected a progressive approach in comparison
to the previous approaches. Lastly, this case proved to be significant for strengthening
relation between international law and municipal law. In this case, Supreme Court held that
if the Indian government makes some commitment in international forum, it shall be binding
on the government even within the nation and it will be treated as part of national law
unless there is a law within the country which is in direct conflict with such law. This
was the first instance where in the absence of the clear statutory law, the Supreme Court
used international treaty commitments to further Indian law. This case has set a precedent
that when domestic law is not available or adequate, how international law can be useful.
What we should remember is that international law described under international conventions
is important for law making but with a caution that it must not be inconsistent with fundamental
rights and should promote constitutional values of India. So these were the impacts
of this case. Supreme Court of India issued Vishaka guidelines to prevent sexual harassment
of women at workplace. After 16 years, Parliament came up with a legislation on this issue.
This case has also inspired other countries in South Asia to enact law on this issue.
It is unfortunate that the attackers of Bhavri Devi were never convicted. Friends, sexual
harassment is a curse for our society. Earlier when women stayed at home, they were subjected
to crimes like domestic violence and dowry theft. Now when they are coming out of their
homes and contributing to the society, they have to suffer discrimination, rape and sexual
harassment. Unfortunately, this list of crimes is unending. But this can be controlled with
education and awareness among people. So I hope you have enjoyed this video. I am sure
this video must have answered some of your questions and informed you about some basics
in international law. Kindly provide your suggestions in the comment section below.
See you soon in the next video. Thank you.
