State in General and Recognition | Subjects of International law #internationallaw

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
1 Video View·Feb 10, 2026
Expert legal overview of state responsibility in international law, detailing elements of wrongful acts, standards for establishing breaches, legal consequences, reparations frameworks, and how international tribunals apply the doctrine of state responsibility in resolving interstate disputes within the international legal system.
Dear aspirants. Welcome to our next lecture of International Law. Today, we will discuss our
next topic which is State in General and Recognition. Now, coming over to the outline
of our today's topic. Personality and Statehood in International Law, The Subjects of International
Law, Recognition and Modes of Recognition, Theories of Recognition, Recognition of State
and Government in International Law, Recognition of State and Government in National Law,
we will discuss all of the headings one by one in detail. So, the first heading is,
State in General and Recognition. A state is a sovereign political entity that exercises
control over a defined territory and population. It is typically composed of three elements,
a government, a population, a defined territory, definition of state. Now, definition of
recognition. Recognition is the act of acknowledging the existence and legitimacy of a state.
Recognition is typically granted by other states, but it can also be granted by international
organizations or non-state actors. A state that is recognized by other states is said to be a
recognized state. Now, importance of recognition. Recognition is a crucial aspect of international
law, as it determines which states are considered to be legal actors in the international system.
Recognition can be an important factor in resolving disputes between states,
as it can establish the legal status of a state and its government, and it can also affect the
jurisdiction of international courts and tribunals. It also has an important role in the process of
state building and nation building, as recognition can facilitate the integration of new states into
the international community. Now, discretion and recognition.
Recognition is not automatic, and states have discretion in recognizing other states.
Recognition can be formal, in the form of a diplomatic exchange of notes, de jure or informal,
in the form of de facto recognition. Recognition of a state does not necessarily imply approval
of its government or policies. It is simply an acknowledgment of the state's existence and status
as an independent and sovereign entity. Now, the next heading is, statehood and personality
in international law. Definition of statehood. Statehood refers to the status of an entity as
In order for an entity to be considered a state, it must possess certain characteristics such as a
defined territory, a permanent population, a government, and the capacity to enter into
relations with other states. The concept of statehood is closely related to the principle
of sovereignty, which is the principle that states are supreme within their own territory,
and are not subject to the authority of other states. Now, definition of personality.
Personality refers to the legal capacity of an entity to act as a subject of international law.
It includes the ability to enter into treaties and other international agreements,
the ability to bring and defend claims before international courts and tribunals,
and the ability to participate in international organizations. Personality is not dependent on
statehood, and entities such as colonies, territories, and organizations can possess
personality in international law. Relationship between statehood and personality.
Statehood and personality are closely related concepts in international law. Statehood is a
necessary prerequisite for the exercise of sovereignty and for the participation of an
entity in the international system. Personality is the legal capacity of an entity to act as a
subject of international law, but it is not dependent on statehood. An entity can possess
Now, coming over to the examples of statehood and personality.
Pakistan is a recognized sovereign state under international law, possessing the characteristics
of statehood, and has legal capacity to enter into treaties and other international agreements,
bring and defend claims before international courts and tribunals, and participate in
The colony of Hong Kong, before 1997, was not a sovereign state, but it possessed personality in
international law, as it entered into treaties and other international agreements, participated
in international organizations, and could bring and defend claims before international courts
and tribunals. Now, coming over to the examples of statehood and personality.
Recognition of statehood is the process by which other states acknowledge and accept
the existence of a new state. Recognition is important because it grants the new state access
to the international community and the rights and responsibilities that come with it. Recognition
can be either de jure, meaning formal recognition by other states, or de facto, meaning recognition
in practice. Recognition is not always automatic and may be dependent on certain conditions or
negotiation. Now, challenges to statehood and personality. There are various challenges to
the concept of statehood and personality in international law, such as the emergence of
new entities such as virtual nation-states, supranational entities, and non-state actors.
There are also challenges to the recognition of statehood, such as disputes over territory
or self-determination. These challenges have led to ongoing debates and discussions in the
international community about the definition and criteria of statehood and personality.
Now, coming over to the references from different books.
International Law by Malcolm N. Shaw. Shaw defines statehood as the status of a
community as a sovereign and independent state in the international system, 7th edition p18.
He explains that for an entity to be considered a state, it must possess a defined territory,
a permanent population, a government, and the capacity to enter into relations with other
states. He also notes that the concept of statehood is closely related to the principle
of sovereignty, which is the principle that states are supreme within their own territory
and are not subject to the authority of other states. Shaw also explains that personality
refers to the legal capacity of an entity to act as a subject of international law,
including the ability to enter into treaties and other international agreements,
the ability to bring and defend claims before international courts and tribunals,
and the ability to participate in international organizations.
Now, the second is Principles of Public International Law by Ian Brownlee.
Brownlee defines statehood as the status of a community as a sovereign and independent state
in the international system, 8th edition p17. He explains that for an entity to be considered a
state, it must possess a defined territory, a permanent population, a government, and the
capacity to enter into relations with other states. He also notes that the concept of
statehood is closely related to the principle of sovereignty, which is the principle that
states are supreme within their own territory and are not subject to the authority of other states.
Brownlee also explains that personality refers to the legal capacity of an entity to act as a
subject of international law, including the ability to enter into treaties and other
international agreements, the ability to bring and defend claims before international courts
and tribunals, and the ability to participate in international organizations.
The third is, International Law by Dr. S. K. Kapoor. Kapoor defines statehood as the status
of a community as a sovereign and independent state in the international system, 7th edition
p17. He explains that for an entity to be considered a state, it must possess a defined
territory, a permanent population, a government, and the capacity to enter into relations with
other states. He also notes that the concept of statehood is closely related to the principle
of sovereignty, which is the principle that states are supreme within their own territory
and are not subject to the authority of other states. Kapoor also explains that personality
refers to the legal capacity of an entity to act as a subject of international law,
including the ability to enter into treaties and other international agreements, the ability to
bring and defend claims before international courts and tribunals, and the ability to
Now, reference from the last book which is, Introduction to International Law by J. G.
Stark QC. Stark defines statehood as the status of a community as a sovereign and independent
state in the international system, 14th edition p17. He explains that for an entity to be
considered a state, it must possess a defined territory, a permanent population, a government,
and the capacity to enter into relations with other states. He also notes that the concept
of statehood is closely related to the principle of sovereignty, which is the principle that states
are supreme within their own territory and are not subject to the authority of other states.
Stark also explains that personality refers to the legal capacity of an entity to act as a subject
of international law, including the ability to enter into treaties and other international
agreements, the ability to bring and defend claims before international courts and tribunals,
and the ability to participate in international organizations. He also notes that personality
is not dependent on statehood, and entities such as colonies, territories, and organizations can
possess personality in international law. Let's take a look at the gist from all these
referred books. It is worth noting that in all of these books, the authors provide similar
definitions and explanations of the concepts of statehood and personality in international law.
They all emphasize that statehood is the status of an entity as a recognized sovereign state,
and that personality refers to the legal capacity of an entity to act as a subject of international
law. Additionally, they all note that statehood is closely related to the principle of sovereignty,
and that personality is not dependent on statehood. Now, coming over to the examples of statehood and
personality. First, Recognition of statehood. The recognition of Israel as a sovereign state
by the United Nations in 1948, or the recognition of the State of Palestine by the United Nations
in 2012. Challenges to statehood. The ongoing dispute between India and Pakistan over the
territory of Jammu and Kashmir, where both countries claim statehood over the region.
Examples of entities with personality in international law. The European Union,
which has legal personality and the ability to enter into international agreements and
participate in international organizations, despite not being a sovereign state.
Furthermore, examples of entities without personality in international law. Taiwan,
which is not recognized as a sovereign state by many countries, and does not have legal
personality in the United Nations. Also, example of state not recognizing another state,
North Korea and South Korea. North Korea not recognizing South Korea as a sovereign state.
Another example of state not recognizing another state, Taiwan and China, China not recognizing
Taiwan as sovereign state. These are a few examples of how statehood and personality
can play out in the international arena, and how they can be challenged and debated.
Now, the next heading is, the subjects of international law. The subjects of international
law refer to the entities or actors that are capable of possessing rights and obligations
under international law. These are also referred to as persons in international law. These can
include, 4. States. States are the primary subjects of international law. They possess
the capacity to enter into treaties, participate in international organizations, and bring and
defend claims before international courts and tribunals. 2. International Organizations.
International organizations such as the United Nations, World Trade Organization,
International Monetary Fund, etc., also possess legal personality,
and are capable of possessing rights and obligations under international law.
3. Individuals. Individuals can also be subjects of international law,
particularly in the context of human rights and international criminal law.
4. Non-state actors. Non-state actors such as transnational corporations,
non-governmental organizations, and armed groups, can also be subjects of international law in
certain circumstances. Now, coming over to the references from different books.
International Law by Malcolm N. Shaw. The author defines the subjects of international law as
entities that are capable of possessing rights and obligations under international law,
and notes that this includes states, international organizations, and individuals. He also mentions
that non-state actors can also be subjects of international law in certain circumstances,
such as transnational corporations and non-governmental organizations.
Now, the second is Principles of Public International Law by Ian Brownlee.
Ian Brownlee defines subjects of international law as entities that are capable of possessing
rights and obligations under international law, and notes that this includes states,
international organizations, and individuals. He also explains that the concept of legal
personality is closely related to the subjects of international law, as entities with legal
personality are capable of possessing rights and obligations under international law.
The third is International Law by Dr. S. K. Kapoor. The author defines subjects of
international law as entities that are capable of possessing rights and obligations under
international law, and notes that this includes states, international organizations, and
individuals. He also highlights that non-state actors, such as transnational corporations and
non-governmental organizations, can also be subjects of international law in certain circumstances.
And the last is, Introduction to International Law by J. G. Stark QC.
J. G. Stark defines subjects of international law as entities that are capable of possessing
rights and obligations under international law, and notes that this includes states,
international organizations, and individuals. He also explains that the concept of legal
personality is closely related to the subjects of international law, as entities with legal
personality are capable of possessing rights and obligations under international law.
Let's take a look at the gist from all these referred books.
All these books provide similar definitions and explanations of the subjects of international law,
and the entities that are capable of possessing rights and obligations under international law.
They all mention that states, international organizations, and individuals are subjects
of international law, and that non-state actors can also be subjects in certain circumstances.
Additionally, they all mention that the concept of legal personality
is closely related to the subjects of international law.
Now, coming over to the examples of the subjects of international law.
The United States, China, Russia, Pakistan, India, Afghanistan, etc. are all examples of
states that are subjects of international law, and have the capacity to enter into treaties,
participate in international organizations, and bring and defend claims before international
courts and tribunals. The United Nations, World Trade Organization, International Monetary Fund,
etc. are examples of international organizations that possess legal personality,
and are capable of possessing rights and obligations under international law.
Furthermore,
Examples of individuals who have been subjects of international law in Pakistan and surrounding
countries include military officials, politicians, and leaders of non-state armed groups,
such as Hafez Saeed, who was designated as a global terrorist by the United Nations,
and arrested in Pakistan in 2019, and Mullah Omar, the former leader of the Taliban in Afghanistan,
who has been charged with war crimes by the International Criminal Court.
Non-state actors, transnational corporations such as Nessel, Pakistan's oil and gas development
company, India's Reliance Industries, and Shell, non-governmental organizations such as Amnesty
International, and armed groups such as the Taliban and ISIS, can also be subjects of
international law in certain circumstances. Now, the next heading is, Recognition.
Meaning and definition of the term recognition. Oppenheim defines recognition as,
in recognizing a state as a member of the international community the existing states,
declare that in their opinion, the new state fulfills the conditions of statehood.
It is not a law. It is based on inconsistent practices of the state.
Now, the next heading is, Modes of recognition. Recognition may be of two kinds.
De facto and de jure recognition. The practice of states shows that in the first stage,
the states generally give de facto recognition. Later on, when they are satisfied that the
recognized state is capable of fulfilling international obligations, they confer de
jure recognition on it. That is why, it is sometimes said, de facto recognition of state
is a step towards de jure recognition. We will now discuss in a little greater detail
both kinds of recognition. So, the first mode of recognition is,
de facto recognition. According to Prof. G. Schwarzenberger, when a state wants to delay
the de jure recognition of any state, it may, in the first stage grant de facto recognition.
The reason for granting de facto recognition is that it is doubted that the state recognized may
or it may be able and willing to fulfill its obligations under international law.
Besides this, it is also possible that the state recognized may refuse to solve its main problems.
De facto recognition means that the state recognized possesses the essential elements
of statehood and is fit to be a subject of international law. However, the effects of
de jure recognition are more far-reaching in the words of Oppenheim, the de facto recognition of
the new authority, although actually independent and wielding effective power in the territory
under its control, has not acquired sufficient stability or does not yet offer prospects of
complying other requirements of recognition, such as willingness or ability to fulfill
the international obligation. In the view of Judge Lauterpicht,
de facto recognition shows that the recognizing state wants to establish its relations with the
state without establishing diplomatic relations. As remarked by Prof. Oppenheim, de facto recognition
is, in a sense, provisional and liable to be withdrawn if the absent requirement of recognition
fails to materialize. Furthermore, in the view of Judge Philip C. Jessup,
de facto recognition is a term which has been used without precision. When properly used to
mean the recognition of the de facto character of a government, it is objectionable and indeed
could be identical with the practice suggested of extended recognition without resuming diplomatic
relations. So, the second mode of recognition is de jure recognition. De jure recognition is granted
when in the opinion of recognizing state, the recognized state or its government possesses all
the essential requirements of statehood and is capable of being a member of the international
community. As pointed out by Prof. H. A. Smith, the British practice shows that three conditions
precedent are required for the grant of de jure recognition of a new state or a new government.
The three conditions are as, a reasonable assurance of stability and permanence.
The government should command the general support of the population. And the last is,
it should be able and willing fulfilled to its international obligations.
Recognition de jure results from an express declaration from a positive act, indicating
clearly the intention to grant this recognition, such as the establishment of diplomatic relations.
De jure recognition is final and cannot be withdrawn once given. As pointed out earlier,
for de jure recognition, an express declaration of the intention to grant such recognition
and the intention to establish diplomatic relations are necessary.
Now, coming over to the difference between de facto and de jure.
De jure, 1. It is not a permanent status. It is permanent status.
2. Withdrawal is possible. Withdrawal is not possible.
3. No diplomatic relation between recognizing and recognized state.
There will be diplomatic relation between recognizing and recognized state.
At last, reason of de facto recognition, to show a friendly attitude and to assure
them that they will be recognized as de jure when gain stability.
Now, the next heading is. Theories of Recognition.
1. Constitutive Theory According to this theory,
recognition clothes the recognized state with rights and duties under international law.
Recognition is a process through which a political community acquires international personality
by becoming a member of the family of nations, Hegel, Anzaloti, Oppenheim, etc. are the chief
exponents of constitutive theory. In the words of Professor Oppenheim,
a state is and becomes an international person through recognition only and exclusively.
According to the constitutive theory, statehood and participation in the international legal order
are attained by political groups only in so far as they are recognized by established state.
In this view recognition confers maturity upon state and until and unless a state is recognized,
it cannot acquire rights under international law.
The practice of states, however, indicates the contrary, in practice,
most states accept the declaratory theory. In this connection, Judge Lauterpicht has remarked
that the white acceptance of declaratory theory is due to the reaction against the traditional
conception of recognition as a political act purely and simply. In his view, there is a legal
duty on the part of the state to recognize any community that has in fact acquired the
The constitutive theory is criticized, and the criticism is
Jurists have vehemently criticized the constitutive theory, the view of Judge
Lauterpicht that there is a legal duty on the part of the existing states to recognize any
community that has in fact acquired the characteristics of statehood, does not seem
to be correct. In practice, the state does not accept any such obligation, the practice indicates,
however, that although established states normally recognize new states and new governments
that exist, they have not consented to law norms that obligate them to do so.
Besides this, the constitutive theory presents several other serious difficulties, according to
this theory, if a state is not recognized it can have neither duty nor rights under international
law, this is a very absurd suggestion. Now, if we accept this proposition,
it will create difficulties in the case of a new state recognized by some states but not by others.
The example of China can be cited in this connection, China was not recognized by America
and other Western countries for several years, although China possessed all the essential
attributes of a state, but to assert that China, therefore, did not have rights and duties under
international law, would be an absurd proposition. Furthermore, the second theory of recognition
which is declarative or evidentiary theory. According to this theory, statehood or the
authority of the new government exists as such before and independently of recognition.
Recognition is merely a formal acknowledgment through which facts are accepted, the act of
recognition is merely declaratory of an existing fact that a particular state or government
possesses the essential attributes as required under international law.
The chief exponents of this theory are Hull, Wagner, Reierle, Pitt-Cobbett and Fisher.
According to Prof. Hull, a state enters into the family of nations as of right when it has acquired
the essential attributes of statehood. Furthermore, Pitt-Cobbett has expressed the view that the
existence of a state is a matter of fact, in his words, so long as a political community possesses
in fact the requisites of a statehood, formal recognition would not appear to be a conditioned
precedent to the acquisition of the ordinary rights and obligations incident thereto.
Reierle has also remarked, the granting of recognition to a new state is not a constitutive
but a declaratory act, a state may exist without being recognized, and if it exists in fact,
then whether or not it has been formally recognized by other states, it has a right to
be treated by them as a state. The Soviet view and practice are also in favor of the declaratory
theory of recognition, according to the Soviet view, the birth of a state is the act of internal
law, rather than that of international law, in modern times international personality does not
depend upon recognition. This theory has also been subject to criticism, the view that recognition
is only a declaratory of an existing fact is not completely correct. When a state is recognized,
it is a declaratory act, but the moment it is recognized, there ensue sore, legal effects of
Now, coming over to the conclusion of both theories. In conclusion, the theories of
recognition, namely the constitutive theory and the declarative or evidentiary theory,
present contrasting views on the process and effects of recognition in international law,
the constitutive theory argues that recognition is the means through which a state acquires rights
and international personality, while the declarative theory asserts that recognition
is a formal acknowledgment of existing facts. Although both theories have their merits and
criticisms, the declarative theory has gained wider acceptance in practice, it recognizes that
recognition is important, but not the sole determinant of a state's rights and obligations,
instead complementing the factual existence and attributes of statehood. The precise nature and
consequences of recognition remain subjects of ongoing debate in the international community.
Now, coming over to our second last topic of our today's lecture, which is,
Recognition of State and Government in International Law
Definition. Recognition of a state and government in international law, refers to the formal
acceptance by other states of a particular entity as a sovereign state and its government as the
legitimate one. Recognition is an important aspect of international law, as it determines
which entities have the capacity to enter into treaties and participate in international
organizations, and it also has implications for the rights and obligations of the recognized
entity. Criteria for Recognition. The main criteria for recognition of a state and government
in international law, are control of a defined territory and a population, and the capacity to
enter into relations with other states. A state must have effective control over a defined territory
and a population in order to be recognized as a sovereign entity. Additionally, the state must
have the capacity to conduct foreign relations, such as entering into treaties and representing
itself in international organizations, in order to be recognized as a subject of international law.
Now, coming over to the, Political Nature of Recognition. Recognition is a political act that
is based on the principle of state sovereignty, and it is not a legal requirement for a state to
be recognized by other states in order to exist. The act of recognition is a political decision
made by states, rather than a legal requirement. A state may exist as a sovereign entity without
being recognized by other states, but it may not have the same rights and obligations as a
recognized state. Now, coming over to the, Lack of Clear Legal Rule. There is no clear legal rule
on when recognition should be granted, and it is often based on political considerations. Recognition
is not a legal requirement for a state to exist, and there is no set rule or procedure for when a
state should be recognized. Recognition is often based on political considerations such as a state's
alignment with other states, its human rights record, and its compliance with international law.
Now, coming over to the, Examples from Pakistan and Other Countries. The recognition of Pakistan
as a sovereign state in 1947, by the United Nations and other countries, following its
independence from British India. The recognition of Bangladesh as a sovereign state in 1971,
by the United Nations and other countries following its independence from Pakistan.
The recognition of the Taliban government in Afghanistan by Pakistan, Saudi Arabia,
and the United Arab Emirates during the Taliban regime from 1996 to 2001, despite the lack of
recognition by the United Nations and other major powers. The lack of recognition of the state of
Azad Jammu and Kashmir and Gilgit-Baltistan, by the majority of countries, as they are not
recognized as sovereign entities by the United Nations or other major powers, and are considered
as a part of Pakistan. The recognition of the government of India by Pakistan and other
countries, despite the ongoing disputes over the status of Jammu and Kashmir and other issues.
The recognition of Israel by the United States and other countries in 1948,
following the establishment of the state of Israel after the end of the British mandate in Palestine.
Furthermore, the recognition of the People's Republic of China by the United States in 1979,
following the Chinese Communist Revolution, and the establishment of the People's Republic of
China, as the sole legal government of China. The recognition of the state of Palestine by
various countries, such as Sweden and the Vatican, in recent years, despite the lack
of formal recognition by the United Nations or other major powers. Furthermore, the lack of
recognition of Taiwan by most countries, as the majority of countries, recognize the People's
Republic of China, as the sole legal government of China. The lack of recognition of the Taliban
government in Afghanistan by most countries during the Taliban regime from 1996 to 2001.
The recognition of South Sudan as a sovereign state in 2011, by the United Nations and other
countries following its independence from Sudan. Moreover, the recognition of the government of the
Soviet Union by the United States and other countries in 1933, despite the lack of democratic
elections and human rights abuses under Soviet rule. The lack of recognition of the self-proclaimed
state of Northern Cyprus by the majority of countries, as it is only recognized by Turkey.
The recognition of the state of Eritrea by the United Nations and other countries in 1993,
following its independence from Ethiopia. The lack of recognition of the breakaway territories of
Abkhazia and South Ossetia, by the majority of countries following the 2008 Russia-Georgia war,
as they are only recognized by a few countries, such as Russia and Syria.
At last, note, the above examples are for illustration purpose only and doesn't reflect
any political stance of the writer. Now, coming over to the last topic of our today's lecture,
which is, Recognition of State in Government and National Law, Definition. Recognition of state
refers to the acceptance and acknowledgement of the sovereignty and independence of a particular
state by another state. Recognition of government refers to the acceptance and acknowledgement of
the authority and legitimacy of a particular government by another state. Now, coming over
to the mechanisms. Recognition can be carried out through various mechanisms such as
legislation, recognition can be made through the passage of laws by the national legislature.
Executive actions, recognition can be made through decisions and actions taken by the
executive branch of government. Judicial decisions, recognition can be made through
decisions of the national courts. Now, coming over to the implications. Recognition of state
in government can have significant implications for diplomatic relations, trade commerce, and
other areas of international relations. Recognition of the state enables it to interact with other
states in the international arena, establish diplomatic relations, and participate in
international organizations. Moreover, recognition of government establishes the legitimacy of the
government, enabling it to represent the state in international relations. Now, coming over to the
International Law Malcolm N. Shaw. In his book, Shaw cites the example of the recognition of
Israel by the United States in 1948 through legislation passed by Congress. Principles
of Public International Law Lan Brownlee. Brownlee's book cites the example of the
recognition of the People's Republic of China by the United States in 1979 through an executive
decision by the president. The third is International Law Dr. S. K. Kapoor. Kapoor's
book cites the example of the recognition of Quebec as a distinct society within Canada
by the Supreme Court of Canada. Introduction to International Law J. G. Stark QC. Stark's book
cites the example of the recognition of the State of Palestine by India through an executive
decision by the government. Here are some examples that include Pakistan. Recognition of Pakistan by
the United Kingdom in 1947 through legislation passed by the British Parliament. Recognition
of Bangladesh by Pakistan in 1972 through an executive decision by the Pakistani government.
Recognition of the State of Palestine by Pakistan through an executive decision by the Pakistani
government. Recognition of the Syrian opposition government by Pakistan through an executive
decision by the Pakistani government. And the last is, recognition of the independence of South Sudan
by Pakistan through an executive decision by the Pakistani government.
With this, I come over to the end of our today's lecture. I hope you like and understand the
lecture. Like and subscribe our channel also click the bell icon to get notifications of our videos.
I, thank you all.
