Harassment at Workplace and Protection of Women's Property Rights

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
Jan 23, 2026
Because this law was passed in Pakistan in 2010.
And the law was basically introduced
after a long struggle from women's movement,
human rights movement, students.
And there were a lot of representatives
from civil society, academia.
And people, those wanted up law against harassment
in this country.
Because earlier in the existing legal framework,
harassment at workplace was not recognized.
So there was an alliance of civil society organizations.
And after having long negotiation
with the parliamentarian, so finally, in Pakistan,
we got protection of women against harassment
at the workplace, 2010 law in this country.
And then, because after this law, at the same year,
there was an 18th constitutional amendment.
So under 18 constitutional amendment,
provinces were given more autonomy as compared to past.
So the provinces, that subject devolved to the province.
So unfortunately, in KP, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa,
it took nine years, nine years to appoint a first ombuds
person as compared to Sindh and Punjab.
Because in Punjab, government of Punjab,
they pass their own legislation in 2012.
So from 2012 onwards, there was a woman ombuds person.
In Balochistan, the woman ombuds person
joined after appointment of KP ombuds person after two months.
And I started as a first woman ombuds person
in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa on past February, 2019.
Since then, we are operating in this province.
And the legal framework, because in Pakistan,
it was totally new idea.
Because people were not used to recognize or acknowledge
the level of harassment at the workplace.
But after this law, at the federal level,
federal ombuds person and the ombuds person,
Sindh, they started process.
So when they received lot of application,
so they were number of people, they
come and directly or indirectly.
When I say people, not directly, the women were coming.
But there were some men were coming,
and they brought cases to the ombuds person's institution
in different part in Pakistan.
Because they said harassment is there,
but there is a very less acknowledgment.
So the first of all, because I briefly
explained the law, in law, because they
define harassment, and according to the law,
the harassment means any unwelcome sexual advances,
request for sexual favors, or other verbal or written
communication.
At the same time, the definition defines
causing interference with work performance,
or creating an intimidating, hostile, or offensive work
environment.
And then the same, because I'm just
reading the relevant part from the definition.
So they also insisted on, for example,
making offensive work environment,
or the attempt to punish the complainant for refusal
to comply to such a request, or are made
a condition for employment.
So they clearly mention about the kind
and how they are defining harassment,
however, still there is a problem,
and we are already in a process to make
some amendment in the law.
Because harassment is defined in the preamble,
and the sexual harassment is under the section
two of the act.
So sometimes the lawyers try to play with the definition.
Then they clearly mention about the abuse of authority.
And under the abuse of authority,
they clearly mention who can be on a superior position.
So they mention about a demand by a person in authority,
such as a supervisor, for sexual favors
in order for the complainant to keep or obtain certain job
benefits, be it a wage increase, or a promotion training
opportunity, a transfer, or the job itself.
So they clearly mention this power imbalance
between the complainant and the accused.
At the same time, when they elaborated
hostile environment, so under hostile environment,
they clearly mention about the physical conduct
of a sexual nature, which interferes
with an individual's work performance.
And at the same time, they said the law,
the action could be a single offensive incident,
or maybe constitute several attempts
to harass your colleague at the workplace.
The law clearly defines the jurisdiction of ombudsperson.
Any person can directly come to the ombudsperson office,
or file a complaint to the management.
And when the law says about the management,
so the management is clearly mentioned in the law,
means a person or a body of person
responsible for the management of the affair
of an organization, and includes an employer.
In Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, although we started late,
after nine years, but they made a very good amendment
within the institution.
Because when this law say about this law,
ombudsperson office has jurisdiction over,
so they not only mention about association, corporation,
government institution, they included education institution
as well.
Because in the main law, in the main federal legislation
and other provinces, education institutions are not included.
So we are lucky enough in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa,
we can access education institution at all level,
from secondary education till university level.
So this is the basically, this law
provide us opportunity to have overview,
or oversee the process in the education institution.
For that reason, because in Pakistan,
two professions are more acceptable for women.
One is education, another is health.
So you can see the women, you will see the number of women
is higher as compared to other institution
in health and education.
So in our database, the complaints
from the government institutions,
both institutions are higher in number.
The law clearly bind all organization,
whether these organization are private
or a government institution, any autonomous body,
commission, directorate.
So the law clearly says, each organization
shall constitute an inquiry committee within 30 days.
30 days mean when there is an application,
an institute does not have inquiry committee.
So this is their legal binding to have this committee.
But now, we have all the ombudsperson
in all four provinces, including the federal territory.
So this is the legal binding of each institution.
They should have their inquiry committee,
whether there is a complaint register or not.
So the committee defines the membership.
So the committee shall consist of three members,
of whom at least one member shall be a woman.
But if the committee or the management
decide two women in the committee, so they can.
So there is no bar.
But you know, there is a sociocultural restriction
for women.
So some of the time, women are not in the decision making
or in a conflict resolution institution.
So for that reason, this reservation, one reservation
is, reservation of one woman is ensuring women
in this process.
So if there are three women in the committee,
so committee is equally legal with the membership
they mentioned in the law.
So then, the law also provides opportunity to the committee
if they want.
Other than three members, they can co-opt members
outside the organization on the basis of the expertise.
And also, they can designate their chairperson
to make the process more convenient
and for smooth communication.
Then, the law also says, in the case
a complaint is made against one of the member of the inquiry
committee, so that member should be stepped down.
So because if the charge is against you,
so you can't be a committee member in that case.
And the committee is fully authorized.
And this is very powerful committee in each institution
because under the minor penalties,
the law clearly says if the accused
made responsible for harassment, so the first category
of the punishment is censure.
Then, withholding for a specific period,
promotion or increment, and stopping for a specific period
at an efficiency bar in the timescale,
otherwise then for the unfitness or cross such bar.
And recovery of compensation payable to the complainant.
In this law, because in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa,
in the recent case, when the one of the committee,
they fined 500,000 to the harasser,
they made penalty for him.
So in the same appeal to the ombudsperson,
we kept the same punishment because the committee,
they had a very good process.
And they had a rigorous investigation.
And the case was proof the complainant application
was accepted.
Then, because in this law, there is a hierarchy.
For example, any person, if he or she,
because the law is equally beneficial for women, men,
and trans.
If women can come against, file an application against men,
men can file application against women,
men can file application against men,
and then the women can file the complaint against the women.
So the law covers all the section of the society,
but only the best part of this jurisdiction
is the person, if he or she feels the management is partial,
and she won't get the justice.
So she directly comes to the ombudsperson institution.
And then from ombudsperson institution,
any party, if they feel they are not satisfied,
so under section 8, they can go to the ombudsperson,
to the governor.
And equally, if there are damages,
or person feel she or he want to go to the high court
after the conclusion of the case,
they also have another window where
they can get support in their respective high court
at the higher level.
Law also give power to the ombudsperson,
because in the sexual harassment cases,
normally people, they won't come as evidence,
because they don't want to create problem for themselves,
because they say, no, no, because we
might lose our job.
So in this law, in the personal statement,
if the complainant says, look, when this guy shouted at me,
or during this period, the guy was harassing me,
or she was harassing me, or he was harassing me,
and so and so is a witness to this.
So if the ombudsperson issue notice to record the statement,
so on the denial to the ombudsperson notification,
we have the equal status of high court judge.
So under that equal status, we can issue contempt of court
notice to the person.
Then the ombudsperson office also
has the authority where any office report can be checked,
or that premises can be visited to assess
the entire environment, how this institution is working.
So this is the basically law.
So I just want to conclude on my access
to the ombudsperson office, how we are facilitating.
Then I will prefer for questions.
So I'm here to answer about the sexual harassment
law and the system.
We are also on the Pakistan citizen portal.
So people can reach to us through citizen portal.
We are also receiving our applications
through Facebook inbox.
We are in a process of a website.
So we are introducing this online application system.
We already introduced a toolkit where people can learn
how they can file applications.
So this toolkit is available on our Facebook in Urdu, English,
and even in a video form.
People are not familiar with Urdu and English.
So they can learn about the law in Pashto or through animation.
Hopefully, soon we will have our website.
So that will be more accessible, because you
just need to fill the form.
We also have a woman desk.
So our helpline is 1083.
So people can, through toll-free number, can access to us.
And at each district level, we have two focal person.
One is the district attorney, a lawyer with the deputy
commissioner office, available for women and any person
who want to file a complaint of harassment to this office.
And then with one of the government department,
social welfare officers are focal person
at each district of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.
And women can go there, and they can use these offices
at the ground or a grassroot level
to use as a post office or for the communication.
Because in Pakistan, the literacy level is not so high.
For that reason, we try to use every means of communication.
We are also available on radio.
And we conduct awareness session at the community level
where we are going, our team, awareness team
is going to the grassroot level where women and the people
can know about the law.
So this is, and also at the same time,
we kept our knowledge corner in hospitals on a metro station
where people can pick information and performance
about the application while they are traveling.
So this is a short introduction of our work
and the legal framework.
Thank you very much, ma'am Naz.
That was really, really useful.
A number of people are asking us questions.
If you want, I can ask you this question.
And secondly, we just want to keep it
both in English and Urdu.
So we don't need to be too elite.
We are talking about Pakistani laws,
so we will mostly talk in Urdu.
I wish we could talk in Pashto,
but we will keep that session in the future.
Ahmed, Salim is asking you,
what's the standard of evidence required to take action
against someone accused of harassment, et cetera?
And second, can you please explain
based on real-life examples of conviction and acquittal?
Okay, thank you.
Look, Salim, basically the evidence in this law
we don't have a suo moto.
If a complainant feels that he cannot explain himself,
he can bring someone with him.
There is no need to be a lawyer for this.
When we talk about evidence,
we definitely collect some solid evidence.
It's very difficult to collect evidence in harassment.
That's why there is so much space in this law
that if there is any evidence that is being hidden from you,
we also do forensic evidence.
For example, in some of our cases,
they used WhatsApp a lot to harass.
So for WhatsApp, we already have a link
with the cybercrime unit.
We have a lot of communication with them
because when we have cases under the cybercrime law,
we refer them to the cybercrime cell.
So we get records from there to prove
that this harassment is happening on WhatsApp.
And in WhatsApp,
especially the official cases that I have received,
wherever there is an official WhatsApp group,
people get directed one-to-one
and then start sending different types of messages.
As I told you,
in the case of the prison department,
in both the cases,
we have executed and it has been proven
that their colleagues
were not only harassing their young colleagues,
but they were also threatening them.
And these formal statements have also been recorded
by the department and documents have also been made.
And as I told you,
we say that we extract mobile data,
whether it is WhatsApp or not.
In WhatsApp, normally,
the complainants themselves submit screenshots.
There are also responses to this.
For example, a medical college
also holds a concealment.
For example, I will not take the name of a medical college.
A complaint came from there,
so when the response came,
the response is because there is a share
that you have given a rebuttal on it or something,
so in that case,
they immediately came there and took back their application.
Because they know that when you file a fake case,
see where the case of administration comes
and administrative issues come,
that is a different thing.
But if the concealment of facts
is caught in this and it is a fake case,
then the way you will pay the fine to the complainant,
in the same way, the person who will be cleared by that law,
he can also claim damages.
So they immediately withdrew their case.
Then in the same way, the cases we have done,
harassment cases are coming to us
a little less due to being a social taboo.
As of now, as long as our office is operating,
from 1st February 2019,
we have 130 cases of harassment.
And in comparison to this,
in 2019, the case we got for property jurisdiction,
we have 235 cases.
If you think about it, you have twice as many cases.
So in execution, the cases we have done so far,
there have been dismissals,
they have also been suspended by the High Court
due to jurisdiction,
or when the other party goes there and takes a stay.
But our recent case, which you can see,
is the one from Islamia College,
from the university,
in which we formally ordered the removal.
And in that, in full detail,
there is a judgment of almost 10 pages.
Because now it has left our office,
so I can talk about it publicly.
So it is already available on the internet,
you can see it.
Yes, Zubair.
Thank you very much.
You gave a very comprehensive answer.
And the next question is from Mr. Muttasarif.
He was asking about the percentage of cases
of harassment and property.
And I think you have already answered that.
So now we can move on to the property part
of your presentation.
Okay, thank you.
Look, in Pakistan, because Article 25
declared women and men and any people in this country
as an equal citizen.
So, and then at the same constitution of Pakistan,
declare safeguard against discrimination in service.
So taking two articles from the constitution of Pakistan,
and then the existing legal framework,
for example, Muslim Family Law Ordinance 1961,
Muslim Personal Law Shariat Application Act 1962,
West Pakistan Muslim Personal Law Shariat
Application Act 1962,
Prevention of Anti-Women Practices Act 2011.
So then the people might think,
So then what was the need to make this new law?
There was another legislation.
And that legislation,
because when we talk about the property rights,
so there was another legislation after 18th Amendment,
that was the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Enforcement
of Women Ownership Rights Act 2012.
Then the same law also provided opportunity
for the women right to ownership was the West Pakistan
Muslim Personal Family Law Act 62
and anti-women social practices.
So why we needed this law?
So the law of this law 2019,
basically called the Enforcement
of Women's Property Rights Act 2019.
Or you love what clearly get the any women deprived
of ownership or possession of a property by any means,
may file a complaint to the ombuds person,
if no proceedings in a court of law are pending
regarding that property.
A job is given to the ombuds person
for suomoto power the harassment.
Provided that the ombuds person on its own motion
or on a complaint filed by any person,
including a non-governmental organization,
may also initiate action under subsection one.
Complaint.
In the same legislation,
other than high court,
even you can come to the court.
And in that,
if in court cases, normally we don't do it.
But when the first attempt or the first contact
is the institution of the ombuds person,
so in this law, the deputy commissioners
are responsible that the complaint that comes to you,
so within three, 15 days,
you will submit a summary report to the ombuds person's office
in which you will tell that this property
is the ownership of this woman
and you can get this ownership,
you can take this property.
So under section five,
the ombuds person has been empowered
to direct the deputy commissioner
to give this property to this woman.
Currently, this law in Pakistan
is only applicable at the federal level,
Punjab and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.
Sindh and Balochistan,
they're still waiting for the legislation.
And in addition to this,
they have done a very good two sections.
One is the Bar of Jurisdiction,
that if the ombuds person has enough evidence,
the report has come from the deputy commissioner,
and you have done this law,
you have ensured the possession of that woman,
then this can't be challenged in any court.
So the Bar of Jurisdiction,
they have put it in section 12,
that any action that ensures the possession of the woman
and her ownership,
against that, if it is done on the basis of enough evidence,
then you cannot challenge it.
Otherwise, under section eight,
you go to the high court and challenge it,
and we have a problem with this,
that those lawyers in some cases,
they have become so personal,
that they have filed a number of writ in the high court
And they want this law to be terminated
from the office of the ombuds person.
And in the same way, in this law,
section 10,
binding imposes
on all the collaborative institutions,
that the order from the office of the ombuds person,
like interim relief,
like sealing a place or property,
or sending a commission,
or giving protection,
in all those, to protect any complainant,
whatever order is issued,
their compliance,
that government institution,
whoever is responsible,
for that, it is very necessary.
For example, when people are responders in property cases,
or they don't come,
then we send our fourth notification,
through district police officer,
that these parties have taken over property,
and they are not appearing,
so you make them appear.
So with this strategy,
we have benefited a lot,
that people's pendency in the civil court,
we have, the first lady,
if any of you access our Facebook,
then you can see the story of Palwasha Bibi,
because Palwasha Bibi has published that story,
with her consent,
she is speaking in Pashto,
and for the last 15 years,
7 years, 15 years,
she had different cases of property,
sometimes in one case,
and sometimes in another case,
she used to go to court,
she's almost 76, 72 year old,
she says that she is sitting at home within two months,
I don't say that all cases are solved in two months,
there are some delays,
because we are struggling,
against the powerful patriarchal setup,
in this province,
where property is linked with the owner,
and the power structures are very strong,
and well connected,
they have access to police,
so the poor women,
those apply for the cases,
even they don't have money for the lawyer,
so we are struggling for that as well,
but at the same time,
we have very good number of cases,
even today,
we concluded two cases of property,
those were filed in our office,
in two months ago,
so the main timeline for us,
to decide property cases,
is two months,
it means 60 days,
but sometimes it takes more than 60 days,
because of the existing weak infrastructure,
at the district level,
sometimes communication,
and sometimes delay,
at the part of deputy commissioner office,
or the revenue staff,
so this is because this is very small legislation,
so if people want to ask something,
so I...
Thank you very much madam,
it was also very comprehensive,
like your work,
and I think this is really amazing,
for me to hear that,
you used to be a researcher,
and women right activist,
and now when you are,
basically the person,
who is implementing the same policy,
which you were recommending,
so how is it like,
how do you feel about this?
You know it's very amazing,
because when I joined this office,
because the KP government,
when they notify,
they said,
you are notified as a first onwards person,
so now you can go home,
and don't worry,
we will send salary to you,
but we don't have right now,
we don't have office,
you can just wait,
so I said no,
so here my activist,
come out from the,
in the government office,
I said no,
just give me a space,
I will start my office,
and then after that,
there was a team,
when these people came,
and I start my office,
they said look madam,
you are not behaving like a bureaucrat,
they don't behave like a bureaucrat,
why did you pick up your bag,
why did you pick up your file,
why did you say this,
you are a first onwards person,
so basically they were trying to groom me,
as a good bureaucrat,
and I was trying to groom them,
as a good service delivery organization,
so luckily in two years time,
I became successful in this,
my staff did many things in this,
actually that was an opportunity for me,
because after fighting for women rights,
and peace,
and human rights issues,
that was an opportunity,
where I can apply some of the things,
for those I criticize,
my government officers at that time,
I used to challenge them,
why can't you do this,
why don't you think out of the box,
so I think to be honest,
this was a test for me,
how I can survive in this system,
the one strategy I used,
because I also behave like a government officer,
for example,
I follow all the protocols,
with the hierarchy,
of within the government institution,
I sat with people,
when the buyers in the modern,
like an under back in negotiation key,
because I was involved in ADR,
and other because I was trained,
under the negotiation skills,
so being on first person,
I was on a very different role,
where I sat with senior bureaucracy,
and for that reason,
I was able to get the first amendment,
2020,
right after within one year,
within one year,
I got the first amendment in the law,
so that's why I did a lot of things,
which was my learning as an activist,
like awareness,
helping people,
I did that too,
but the skills I had,
I applied those too,
where I could get help for myself,
that's why,
first the office of Punjab Ombudsman,
came to me,
that they wanted to see,
how to implement our system,
so today we have Glochistan,
so Islamabad is already the senior,
they have already shared their experience,
so I think this combination,
which people used to think,
in the first three months,
even the media was waiting,
to see that he is an activist,
and people acknowledged me,
but they thought he won't survive in this system,
because of the way red tape is used,
the way people are suppressed,
if one of my documents,
or one summary was rejected,
then the second one was ready,
recently I got it approved,
so I had my staff in the car,
with the computer,
when they objected,
I said I'll get it fixed in your office,
sitting here,
so these things,
when you want to make an institution,
you have to use a lot of strategy,
and a lot of patience,
because I believe,
that with patience,
you can achieve in the long run,
and of course,
the small tips I have,
the ADR,
negotiation skills I have learned,
I apply that too,
even sometimes I play like a lawyer,
because I was a practicing lawyer,
so today when I taught,
at Lochistan Ombudsman's office,
sometimes you have to play like a lawyer,
so use your argument as a lawyer,
at the same time.
What an inspirational example,
you are setting for younger people,
especially our young female students,
they see you as a role model,
that how you have persistence,
that when you are doing research,
your work is very good,
and when you are on the other side of the table,
earlier you were requesting the government,
now you are the government,
but your struggle continues,
it's not that,
now that you have become an Ombudsman,
so now I will do whatever I want to do,
so that is I think an excellent example,
for our younger people,
who are looking for role models,
so here is one excellent role model.
Madam, because we are based in Oxford,
so we want to...
I will tell you one more thing,
that for the younger lot,
join any institution,
don't speak for some time,
learn, learn the system,
learn the terminologies,
if you go to the government,
or any international organisation,
you need to understand the structure of the system,
you need to understand the terminologies,
or you need to connect them,
within the government institution,
within the government set up,
there are champions,
so if you are connected with one or two champions,
within the system,
then they will create spaces for you.
Yes, this reminds me,
Madam Marie Curie's famous saying,
and our institute's motto is,
that nothing in this world is to be feared,
it is to be understood.
So we have a lot of frustration,
because we don't understand,
what is happening in our hearts,
what is happening, right?
That a man who himself,
was born from a woman's body,
a woman raised him,
sisters gave him love,
and through his wife,
he fulfilled his life, right?
How can that person be so cruel,
demeaning towards women?
It's beyond comprehension.
But when we try to understand the system,
I'm sorry, maybe I'm just deviating,
what you wanted to say is that,
oh, head down,
try to understand the situation.
Once you have understood, comprehend,
only then you will have some kind of power,
or some kind of say into it.
So, yeah, I think, all right.
We just want to move on, ma'am,
if it's okay,
because we are based in Oxford,
and we want to say something about our audience.
As you know, British-Pakistanis,
are a large population here.
You have your personal experience,
you also worked here,
for the Citizen Foundation.
So there are a lot of issues,
like, family is here,
you brought a child from there,
or brought a child here,
got married here,
property is there.
So there are a lot of issues.
So what kind of recourse does your Ombudsperson provide?
Look, right now we have a very strong coordination mechanism,
which has 13 institutions,
and every quarter they meet at the Ombudsperson office,
just made child protection,
and family police,
and cyber crime,
and human rights ministry,
and BOLO helpline,
which provides support for domestic violence.
So, I'm sharing that the Ombudsperson office,
I got going to be in terms of protection,
she can file an application,
but we can root out that application to the direct forum,
because we don't have jurisdiction over domestic violence,
and other criminal cases,
but our women desk is there to facilitate that.
Then, since now we have this Property Rights Act,
because some of the women,
and right now,
we have cases from Jeddah, Dubai, Birmingham, London,
Manchester, they filed their property cases,
and we provide this opportunity to them,
they can appear on Skype,
and or a WhatsApp,
because normally some people are not familiar
with Zoom or Skype,
so we also provide opportunity to appear through WhatsApp,
video call,
so we are conducting cases,
we right now,
we have four cases from Britain,
and two cases from Gulf of Arab country,
so we are facilitating them,
so because this law,
especially the property law,
already clearly mentioned about any person,
any organisation on behalf of the complainant,
can file a petition to the ombuds person,
so they can easily file their petition
with their family friend,
or yes, also we have one case from US,
but the one thing I just want to caution people,
never give a general power of attorney in the property case,
because people those are fighting for you sometime,
they grab the property,
so in some of the cases,
we realise the people who got the power of attorney
from people from abroad,
so they become oppressor,
or the grabber for the property,
so for that reason,
the ombuds person institution has the jurisdiction,
to facilitate complainant to get the possession,
or the property,
so you can through online,
already we given our email address,
so through our email address,
or our Facebook inbox,
initial or a Pakistan citizen portal,
you can file your application,
or your application falls under our jurisdiction,
we directly contact you,
and connect you with our women desk,
we have pro bono women lawyer desk,
so you can get support and guidance,
from our pro bono women lawyer desk,
for this services.
This is excellent.
I think you are leading a great revolution,
that through WhatsApp,
the judge took the martyrdom,
and from UK, and US, and UAE,
this is amazing,
so I must say that I really appreciate your work,
I am an admirer of your work as a scholar,
and now I am your admirer of your work as a practitioner,
as an ombuds person,
so I hope that we will have more interactions with you,
so thank you very much for joining us,
and I look forward to interacting with you in future.
Thank you.
