Nature of International Law | Is International Law true law?

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
Mar 14, 2026
Nature of International Law under which we discussed three aspects-
Is International Law really Law?
Is International Law a true Law?
Is International Law a weak Law?
Hi everyone, so once again welcome you all on Lawvita here this is Radhya Gupta and today
in this video we will be discussing the nature of international law.
In the previous one we discussed the general introduction, the definitions of international
law plus what is the difference between public international law and private international
law.
So here we will just discuss the nature, in the nature basically there comes three basic
major questions.
The very first is, is international law really law, is this international law that we are
studying is it really a law, so on this there are two different opinions of different schools.
One is the view of the Austrian who says that international law is not a true law, whereas
Oppenheim's view is that international law is a true law.
The second question is, is international law a true law and the third question is, third
part of nature is that international law is a weak law, so let's begin, one of the
most controversial issues that has been debated and discussed is the status of international
law.
So we are having two views here, one view is that international law is not a true law,
according to it, it is a code of rules of conduct of moral force only.
According to them, international law is a code of rules of conduct of moral force only.
It is a set up of rules of conduct which works only on moral force and is dependent on moral
force only.
And second view is that it is a true law and it is to be regarded as a law in the same
way as that of ordinary law of a state which are binding on the individuals.
So, this school says that international law is just like other ordinary laws but is a
law of a state which are binding on the individuals.
So, it is a law in the same way as that of ordinary law of a state which are binding
upon the individuals.
So, now we will study these opinions in detail.
The very first is Austen's view.
What was Austen's view in terms of the nature of international law?
So, according to Austen, law is the command of sovereign, attended by sanction in case
of violation of the command.
So, here Austen has given the definition of law.
Law is the command of the sovereign.
Sovereign means the supreme ruler.
Law is the command i.e. orders of the sovereign which is attended by sanction in case of violation
of command.
And if the violation of those orders is done, then sanction will be imposed upon it, punishment
will be imposed upon it.
It is law.
So, law is the command of the sovereign which is attended by sanction in case of the violation
of such command.
Clear?
The supreme according to him is a real sovereign.
And according to Austen, the supreme authority of any state, the ruler, the king is the real
sovereign.
All other senses of law according to Austen is regarded as improper law.
And the meaning of this law is derived by Austen.
Other than this, Austen says that all other senses of law are improper law.
All of them are regarded as improper law.
Improper law according to him comprises of...
Now, according to Austen, what is there in improper law?
The laws by analogy and the laws by metaphor.
By analogy means, by logic.
The laws through logic are improper laws.
By metaphor, a bit more imagination that is to be interpreted.
The laws on that basis are improper laws as per the Austen's view.
It was his view that international law cannot be called proper in the true sense.
He said that international law cannot be called proper law because...
Now, he has given a reason.
First, he explained the meaning of law.
Then, he said that international law is not proper law because it consists of opinions
and sentiments current among the nations generally.
He said that international law is based on opinions and sentiments.
It is based on people's thoughts, emotions and sentiments.
And there is no sovereign legislative authority in international law
which should be there in a law.
First, there is no sovereign legislative authority
which formulates the laws to enact the laws.
Nor, there is any adequate sanction.
Nor, there is any proper sanction for those who do not follow the laws.
Moreover, there is no enforcement agency which can enforce it as a body of rule.
Moreover, there is no enforcement agency which can enforce the rules of international law.
For example, there are three pillars of government in our country.
Legislature, Executive and Judiciary.
Legislature forms the law, Executive executes it and enforces it.
And Judiciary acts as a second balance.
So, Austin therefore preferred to call international law as positive international morality
since it lacks a common and determinate sovereign.
Because there is no legislative sovereign authority,
nor there is any sanction, nor there is any enforcement agency.
Therefore, Austin did not call international law as a true law.
He regarded it as positive international morality.
It is a positive international morality
because it lacks a common and determinate sovereign.
There is no proper sovereign in it.
There is no proper ruler
who has the powers to administer the government.
Moreover, since it is based on sentiments and opinions,
Austin called it positive international morality.
According to him, international law cannot be accepted as a legal system.
This was Austin's view in regard to the nature of international law.
Many schools and jurists have criticized Austin's view.
So, let's see that.
Austin's definition of law, commonly known as command theory,
has been criticized by jurists belonging to sociological, legal and historical schools on different grounds.
So, let's see that.
Austin's definition of law, commonly known as command theory,
has been criticized by jurists belonging to sociological, legal and historical schools on different grounds.
Historical schools have criticized that
Austin completely ignored the customary and unwritten laws.
Austin ignored all the unwritten laws in his theory.
Plus, it is not correct to say that laws are observed because of the fear of sanctions behind them.
It is also wrong to say that laws are observed because there is a fear that if they are not followed,
there will be a violation.
This is not the case.
Historical schools have criticized Austin's view in regard to the meaning of laws.
Further, Pollock, a jurist, has declared Austin's view as hard to reconcile with the witness of history.
He has declared that it is very difficult to reconcile the history with the witness of international law.
Plus, Austinian view fails to explain why states themselves regard international law as binding even when there is no sovereign.
Plus, Austin failed to explain that international law is not a true law and there is no sovereign authority in international law.
This is Austin's view that international law is not a true law.
On the other hand, we have Oppenheim's view.
Oppenheim says that law is a body of rules for human conduct within a community,
which by common consent of this community shall be enforced by external power.
Oppenheim says that law is a body of rules for human conduct within a community,
which by common consent of this community shall be enforced by external power.
When a group of people give their common consent,
then only an external power enforces the body of rules on this community.
This is called law.
Law is a body of rules for human conduct within a community,
which by common consent of this community shall be enforced by external power.
It means that it is not necessary that rules should be enacted through a law-making authority
or there should exist a law-administrating court within the community concerned.
Oppenheim contradicted Austin's view and said that
it is not necessary that rules should be enacted through a law-making authority
or there should exist a law-administrating court within the community concerned.
So, the three requirements of this Oppenheim's definition
are satisfied by international law to a greater or lesser extent.
If the answer is given in affirmative, international law may be regarded as law
because every society necessarily has a system of law.
In Oppenheim's view, we can also consider that
if we look at it affirmatively in a positive way,
then international law is a true law and international law is a law
because every society necessarily has a system of law.
If we compare international law with Oppenheim's definition of law,
then they have similar elements and that's what the reason
according to Oppenheim, international law is a true law.
Now, let's look at how international law is a true law.
There are certain points of it.
International law is a true law is evident even if Austin's definition is accepted.
Although Austin said that international law is not a true law,
if we look at Austin's definition,
we can prove that international law is a true law.
Austin regarded international law as a positive morality in the 19th century
when the international community lacked legislation,
a court-sanctioning power, and enforcement machinery.
Austin gave the definition of law in the 19th century
when he called international law a positive morality.
He said that international law is not a true law,
international law is not a law but a positive morality
because there is no legislation, no law-making authority,
there is no court that can sanction powers,
and there is no enforcement agency.
And in view of all these, if we conclude that international law
is not a true law, perhaps he was not wrong.
And if we look at the 19th century,
these things were not there.
So even if Austin said that international law is not a true law,
it was not wrong.
Presently, international legislation has come into existence
as a result of multinational treaties and conventions.
In today's time, international legislation has been established
through multinational treaties and conventions.
If rules are violated by a state,
if a state violates rules of international law,
then sanctions may be applied against it
not only by the aggrieved state itself
but collectively by UNO as a whole.
And not only is a state sanctioned,
but UNO collectively takes action against that state.
Further, presently, international community has a court,
ICJ, that is International Court of Justice,
whose decisions are binding upon the parties of the state.
Apart from this, in today's time,
in international law,
we have an International Court of Justice,
whose decisions are binding upon all parties.
Existence of international legislation,
a court, a sanctioning authority,
and the enforcement machinery
are the development of the present century.
And in the past, these things were not there.
But in today's time,
because of these developments,
we have international legislation,
a court, a sanctioning authority,
and the enforcement machinery.
So in the light of all these developments,
perhaps one would not hesitate
to call international law as a true law,
even if Austin's definition of law is accepted.
And that is why,
looking at all these developments,
if we say that international law is a true law,
we should not hesitate to say that,
even if we take Austin's definition of law.
So here, we conclude that
even if we consider Austin's definition
that was being given in the 19th century
where he regarded international law
as positive morality,
still, in today's time,
we can conclude international law as a true law.
I have told you all the reasons.
This is your nature's part.
There is one last part in nature,
that is, international law is a weak law.
How is international law a weak law?
So, international law is observed
by almost all the nations
almost all the time,
because it is crucial for peaceful relations
and cooperation.
We all know that in today's time,
all the nations observe international law
and follow it,
because it has become very important
to maintain healthy relationships,
friendly relationships, and cooperation
between all the states.
However, it is considered as a weak law.
Its rules are not as effective
as the rules of municipal law.
For example,
the rules of national laws
are not as effective
as the rules of international law.
The rules of municipal law
are more effective
than the rules of international law.
There are four basic reasons
that I will tell you here.
First, the rule of international law
which exists as a result
of international treaties and customs
are not comparable in efficiency
to state legislative machinery.
All the rules of international law
which are made by international treaties
and international customs
in international law
are not as efficient
as the laws
by state legislative machinery.
The rules of international law
are not as efficient.
Second, there is no court in the true sense
which would decide the legal dispute
of all the states.
Although ICJ exists,
it does not have jurisdiction
to decide the dispute
of all the states.
We agree that ICJ exists
in international law
but its jurisdiction
is not as effective.
Even today,
the legal disputes
of all the states
are not decided
in the true sense
because ICJ
does not have jurisdiction
to decide the disputes
of all the states.
Third, the enforcement measures
which are available under the system
are not as effective.
The enforcement measures
are not as effective
as they should be.
The last point is,
the rules of international law
are frequently violated by states
especially during the war
and the claimant of the rights
takes the law into his own hands.
The rules of international law
are frequently and easily
violated by the states
especially during the war
and the claimant of the rights
takes the command
of the law in his own hands.
These reasons are
not as efficient
as the rules
of state legislative machinery
so here we are done
tune with the channel to subscribe the channel
to also click on the bell icon
for receiving all the latest updates
of all the upcoming videos
do like the video if you really like the content
do comment down if you have any doubt
I will meet you up soon in the next video
with the next topic
so this is it, take care, bye bye
