IRF Summit 2026 Holds Discussion on Identifying Red Flags Before Religious Persecution Escalates

Live News Network
1.4K followers
48 Video Views·Feb 3, 2026
The International Religious Freedom (IRF) Summit 2026 holds a panel discussion titled Identifying Red Flags Before Persecution Escalates at 2 p.m. ET on Feb. 2 in Washington, D.C.
Moderator
Rachel Miner, Bellwether International
Speakers
Sarah Cook, International Coalition to End Transplant Abuse in China
Rania Dean, AIDPAC
Jonathan Duarte, Nicaragua Freedom Foundation
AI Generated·May contain errors
Transplants could be scheduled in advance, often within days or weeks.
Something that's impossible in ethical systems that rely on unpredictable deaths.
Now, it may seem far-fetched that this could happen in a modern country like China.
But keep in mind, this is the same place where doctors carried out forced abortions for decades under the one-child policy.
It's the same country where SARS and COVID-19 were covered up and whistleblower doctors were punished.
So we have to be careful not to underestimate what the Chinese Communist Party is capable of making people do.
Indeed, these allegations have been met with skepticism in different quarters, despite studies and books investigating the abuses.
So in 2019, ITAC convened a China tribunal.
An independent tribunal that was led by Sir Geoffrey Naiskusi, who had actually been a prosecutor at the ICTY.
And along with transplant doctors, experts in China studies, human rights lawyers,
they spent 12 months reviewing the evidence that this may be happening and five days of public hearings.
At the end of that, they unanimously and without a reasonable doubt concluded,
quote, forced organ harvesting has been committed for years throughout China on a significant scale.
Falun Gong practitioners, that's a religious minority I'll talk about in a moment,
Falun Gong practitioners have been one and probably the main source of organ supply.
And in regard to the Uyghurs, the tribunal had evidence of medical testing on a scale that could allow them,
amongst other uses, to become a, quote, organ vendor.
The tribunal also found no evidence that the infrastructure behind these abuses had been dismantled,
and so concluded that the practice continues.
Now taking a step back and back to our theme of the red flags, what were some of the early red flags that this was going on?
One, there were longstanding reports in China that executed prisoners, albeit ghetto prisoners, were being used as organ sources.
Foreign patients started reporting that they had gone to China for pre-scheduled transplants within days or weeks.
There's an Israeli transplant heart doctor who was just shocked by the account of a patient who came back and told him what had happened.
He's like, that's not normal.
Prisoners of conscience, especially Falun Gong practitioners and later Uyghurs, reported unusual medical tests,
blood draws, ultrasounds, x-rays, CT scans, inconsistent with their otherwise brutal treatment by prison authorities.
But relevant to assessing organ viability.
And these were different from the tests done to other prisoners.
And four, there was explosive growth in China's transplant industry despite no robust voluntary donation system.
And the surge aligned with the campaign of religious persecution that began in 1999 targeting Falun Gong,
a meditation and qigong practice practiced by millions.
So as detention facilities filled with Falun Gong practitioners, you saw transplant volumes soar.
In 2000, within a year of the start of the crackdown, liver transplants tripled.
By 2005 they had tripled again.
And that far exceeded what was possible in terms of the number of death row prisoners
or the minute number of voluntary donors trying to help in China.
Also, Falun Gong practitioners, because of their practice of qigong and not smoking and not drinking,
were considered to be generally healthier than your average prison population in China,
many of whom have drug issues or other health problems.
Then more evidence emerged.
Undercover calls, as recently as 2018, where officials and surgeons admit they have organs available
within one or two weeks of some Falun Gong organs.
In one verified 2014 call, a former army health minister, Bai Zhong,
stated that Jiang Zemin, the former head of the CCP, directly organ harvesting Falun Gong practitioners.
And more recently, it looks like Uyghurs may have been targeted too.
So a key witness is actually a Uyghur surgeon, who is now in exile,
who in the late 1990s was forced to extract the organs from a Uyghur prison, a Uyghur child.
Since 2017, as you know, there have been mass detentions of hundreds of thousands of Uyghurs.
Some were survivors, again.
Reports, suspicious medical exams, and nighttime disappearances.
And if you've heard of the Xinjiang police files, which was a massive leak,
it includes blood types of many Uyghurs.
And that's an essential data point for organ matching.
Now the Chinese government today claims that they've ended prison warning use since 2015.
But the official voluntary donor figures initially were actually found by a scholar to be falsified,
because they fit a perfect mathematical equation.
And overall, there's a complete lack of transparency.
Other red flags persist.
Large numbers of anonymous prisoner of conscience populations,
reports of short wait times or other anomalies that don't have ethical systems,
continued medical exams on religious detainees,
and no accountability for perpetrators, including doctors.
There's a 2022 academic study that analyzed Chinese doctors' own medical papers,
and found that certain descriptions of the organ procurement indicate
the donor had not in fact arranged it.
Many of these doctors are still practicing in China.
They lead major transplant programs.
So I'm working now with ETAC on a report that will hopefully be out this spring,
looking at whether and in what capacity these abuses continue.
And just one last point before I wrap up.
I think this issue highlights a broader pattern in religious persecution.
The tactics refined against one group can spread to others.
One piece of research I published was that individual Chinese officials
who had been active in the anti-Falun Gong campaign in the 90s
moved on to Tibet, and then to Xinjiang, just as the detentions were starting up.
Now we see what's been refined in Xinjiang, whether it's surveillance or other tactics,
being deployed in other parts of China.
So I think that's one of the reasons why this discussion about the red flags
really becomes vital, because it's so important to understand
not only what can happen in one community within a country, but in India.
Yeah, this is a very serious topic, and serious for a lot of groups that are present,
Falun Gong, Uyghurs, and others, as you pointed out,
and we'll be very eager to see your report.
Organ harvesting itself is a red flag, but obviously there are red flags
that are before this kind of serious, very serious violation.
I heard you talk about detention of those religious minorities
as a precursor to organ transplant, timing of different propaganda campaigns,
which we're going to talk about in a moment.
Let's take a few steps back in terms of the spectrum of red flags
and talk about what precedes that.
And Rania is going to give us a really good example of her red flag
that I think could be the first and maybe the most important that we monitor in real time.
So let's turn to you, Rania, to talk about dehumanization.
Thanks. Thank you. My name is Rania.
First, there are so many red flags.
Some of them you can see and spot, and some of them you cannot see, but you can feel.
And even though you cannot measure, but they exist, and their outcome is so strong.
It's so strong than the evidence is itself.
So I want to focus today on one red flag.
It's called dehumanization.
And dehumanization in general is when humans stop being seen as equal groups
with rights and dignity, and they are seen as someone less human.
And when this happens, literally and operationally,
this group of people are target to persecution, are target to humiliation,
and this can be very dangerous, especially because when the dehumanization happens
to a specific group of people, harming them, and this is the hardest part,
harming them is no more legally wrong or morally wrong.
The people accept it as if it was something to be cheered for, and if it was their duty.
And the rest would stay silent because if they interfere,
they would be caught as people who don't follow the path of whatever they represent,
whether it's a country or agenda or whatever.
This happened many times.
It is a pattern, and I can give you many examples.
Let's take the very famous example of the Holocaust, for example.
The dehumanization of the Jewish people came way before the gas chambers.
They were caricatured. They were humiliated.
Even they had DNA researchers saying that their DNA is harmful to humanity.
Same thing happened with the Armenian people.
It happened with, now I heard someone outside, in another booth,
saying that they are a minority in Pakistan, going through the same thing.
They are dehumanizing them through, you know, literal wording like
or whatever they call them just to curse them.
Same thing happened with the Druze people.
Now, who here by showing hands doesn't know the Druze?
Sorry, because I know not everyone knows the Druze. I have to ask.
Anyone here never heard of the Druze before?
Okay, so the Druze are a very small, ethnoreligious minority.
They are located mainly in the Middle East, in Syria, Lebanon, Israel.
They are very peaceful.
I can say, for one hour I can speak about the Druze people,
but one of the things that the Druze people are going through now
in Syria, in what is called Syria, in a very specific region in Syria
called the Bashan or Sueda, they went through persecution.
But this persecution was, before that, it was like they gave us signs
and one of these signs, a red flag, was the dehumanization.
And I can give you an example.
They were calling them the sons of the donkeys and the monkeys and the pigs.
They were saying, even fatwa, to say that their men should be slaughtered
and their women should be raped and killed.
They even used slavery, the word enslaved.
So they said that their women should be enslaved, raped, and killed.
This is the stark example of dehumanization, slavery,
and that was used against the Druze.
In July, that was one wave of persecution,
but the early signs also appeared way before, before we even noticed it.
But do you know who noticed it first?
The Druze people, because they were persecuted so many times
along the history, and their collective memory could sense these signs
even before the organizations and the countries could sense them.
It starts with hate speech, as I said.
It starts with calling them so many names.
Then it moves from verbal to operational and institutional,
and even institutional before operational.
Now, in Syria, the constitution has elements
that indirectly oppresses the minorities.
Their constitution is based on the Sharia law,
and the Sharia law has no place to minorities such as the Druze,
and I'm giving only the Druze as an example.
There are other minorities there that are facing the same thing.
Their educational system has some elements of early signs of persecution.
Did you know that the last year, they opened 60 to 70 schools in Syria
that teach the Salafi-Jihadi agenda of Ibn Taymiyyah?
For whoever here is not familiar with this Salafi-Jihadi agenda,
it's the same agenda that made ISIS.
So they are teaching it to their kids,
and the core thing in this Salafi-Jihadi agenda
that the infidels or the apostates, how they call them,
which is anyone who is not following the Salafi-Jihadi agenda,
not even the Muslims.
Some Muslims are also part of these so-called minorities
because they do not follow the Salafi-Jihadi agenda.
So whoever follows this Salafi-Jihadi agenda has superiority,
and whoever doesn't is a target for persecution.
And why is this important?
Because the moment it becomes institutional, it turns into operational.
Now, for that moment, I have to say that even dehumanization has two elements.
When it's reversible, when it's just hate speech and religious extremism,
and when it's irreversible, when it turns into operational.
Now, for the Druze, it is in this phase, unfortunately,
and that's why the Druze people in Sweden now seek for self-determination.
127,554 people had signed already a petition for self-determination and separation,
and this is only for survival, not as a separatism as they call it.
And these people represent around 70-80% of the total population, adult population in Sweden.
So the self-determination is not by choice.
It's the only way for them to survive because according to the Salafi-Jihadi doctrine,
Druze people do not even have the right to convert.
So they don't have the right to convert to Islam.
They have to be killed.
So they have no choice.
And any move from them to demand protection is also translated into political
because they are an ethno-religious minority, and this is another point,
when it's an ethno-religious minority that's asked for protection and self-determination
become pictured as political, and that makes it hard to protect them.
Thank you so much.
A lot of really important points there as well.
We're hearing conversion laws can be a red flag and how those are enforced in the country.
While Sharia law is implemented in a lot of different ways,
and I'd encourage you to speak to the amazing lawyers that are in this audience and others
to talk about the nuance of Sharia law.
All law can be weaponized, and Sharia law is no exception.
It can be weaponized against minority groups.
And the last point you made, which of course is really important,
what happens when these red flags escalate past a tipping point?
You've just given a preview for the next session, which I'm going to just advertise briefly.
They are going to talk about when red flags escalate and how do we come back from that.
And there's some really great voices on that panel.
There's lots to discuss, of course.
So we've got two case studies, one looking at a very extreme red flag
that's very hard to come back from, dehumanization, an earlier process in that spectrum.
Jonathan, can you now share with us, specific to your case study,
how all of these red flags start interacting and what those interactions look like
when we start to identify multiple red flags all at the same time?
Yeah. Well, Nicaragua right now is living under the second Sandinista dictatorship.
The first Sandinista dictatorship was openly hostile to faith leaders and believers.
They exiled religious leaders, they ridiculed them, they humiliated them, they tortured them, exiled them,
to the point where when St. John Paul came to Nicaragua when he was Pope,
they heckled him, they threw bags of urine at him.
Nicaragua is a highly Catholic Christian country, so obviously the population was incredibly offended.
And that also led to their downfall in 1990.
We had 16 years of democracy, and then in 2007, the same dictator decided to run.
But this time, he tried to wash his face, so to speak, right?
Came back and positioned himself as a Christian, married his wife in the Catholic Church, took the Holy Communion.
Rosario, the co-dictator, invokes the Virgin Mary, uses scripture to manipulate the people.
And they tried to brand themselves, actually.
They had a saying that they were Christian, supportive, and socialist.
And that was the narrative that they created.
However, that changed completely in 2018 when massive protests started against the government.
They began killing the protesters, and the Catholic Church put their chest between the repressors and their flock.
At that point, the narrative changed completely.
And so one of the very first flags that we saw was a change in narrative.
And as you mentioned, the dehumanization, right?
They were coup plotters, they were terrorists, they were no longer our faith leaders.
They were trying to brainwash society to turn against priests, pastors, reverends.
The other thing that we were seeing early on is the testing of impunity.
We saw incremental escalation.
They started going against rural religious leaders.
And then it eventually escalated to the point where they were attempting to kill bishops.
They were jailing bishops.
They were exiling bishops.
So we definitely saw the red flags.
And they quickly escalated because no one put a stop to it.
And nobody spoke up soon enough in the international community.
Well, now we're going into a speed round.
But this is your five-minute notice.
If you have questions for our panelists, start thinking about those questions.
We will take questions only.
Comments can be shared after the session.
Five-minute notice on that.
I'm going to turn back to the panelists now and just go one layer deeper.
And then we'll wrap up with some final thoughts before questions.
When we think about these red flags, it can be really hard to identify how to engage with them.
And so if you could share, in your specific context,
either examples of how people are engaging with them now
or how people tried to engage with them as they were happening,
certainly in the Druze case, what does that look like?
This is the International Religious Relief Summit.
But it's not lost on anyone here what's happening in the United States,
what's happening in D.C.
People are really wanting to engage with this conversation across the political spectrum.
So how do we engage with those red flags?
And can you kind of narrate for us what that looks like?
Okay.
So first, I would just really second the point about the dehumanization.
And I think in China, the CCP are just experts at it.
And you see it in the propaganda and some of the level of manipulation and fabrications
against communities like Uyghurs, against Falun Gong practitioners.
And I think what you see is it starts to spread through China.
So, well, is Falun Gong really a cult or is it not?
Which it's not.
Are the Uyghurs terrorists or are they not?
Which they're not, right?
And so I think there is that international dimension, too, that helps justify their practices.
I think in terms of red flags and what people are doing and what people can do,
I mean, one is to just really watch what you cite.
If you have a country that has a rapidly escalating transplant capacity,
if it's getting help from China, which we see happening in Cambodia,
there's a Belt and Road transplant capacity new training thing.
And one of the main doctors there is one of the top liver surgeons
who has been heavily implicated in both the organ transplant abuses
and actually in, quote, anti-cult activities in China against Falun Gong.
And this is the guy who's going around the world to pull a training transplant capacity.
So that's where it's so important to be aware.
The other is if there's a large community of dehumanized, anonymous prisoners.
And I think for anyone working with refugees, if you see people coming out,
ask about what medical tests they had done.
Because part of what happened in China is people didn't know.
When you interview, and I've interviewed a lot of refugees,
that's not what they're going to talk about.
They're going to talk about how their faith was oppressed.
A lot of times there's also incredibly humbling, optimistic stories
about how they overcame and how there was actually someone who was kind to them
in the prison and helped them out.
They're not going to tell you about the MRIs and the ultrasounds.
So it was only when the journalists somehow stumbled across this
and started asking that it turned out it was much more widespread.
And I've personally seen examples of people who I interviewed 20 years ago,
and it turned out afterwards that they had had medical exams done
and I hadn't even thought to ask the question.
So I think it's just so critical for those working in this space to do that.
I think the other thing, and this is some of what we start to see movement on,
but we do hope that this report will help with,
is the collaboration and training question.
There's so many intersections, and again, like, you know,
some of these hospitals and the doctors and, you know,
in any other country their career would be over,
and yet there's just so much intersection.
So really being serious about due diligence when it comes to collaborating.
Collaborating with, in this case, hospitals,
but again, any other perpetrators of rights abuses in other places too.
And then I think the last thing I would say would be legislation.
There's been legislation passed in places like Taiwan and Israel and the UK
about not having insurance cover for foreigners to go get organs in China,
or other countries that may have questionable organ transplant situations.
Sanctions for people, and requirements also even for doctors to report
if somebody's come back from somewhere.
So I'll just end on, you know, Iran I think is one country
that has a lot of these warning signs.
Saudi Arabia may have.
So just, if you're working with prisoners of conscience,
just look at what's happening in the transplants.
Well, that was great.
Lots of points there.
We're monitoring legislation.
We're monitoring detention.
We're curious.
We're becoming citizen journalists, which is important for every nation.
Ask the questions.
Understand what's happening behind detention walls,
especially when not reported by government.
Okay, Munea, over to you.
Yes.
First, I want to just tell you that dehumanization always is followed
by human trafficking, by, you know, also organ trafficking,
because they don't look at them as humans anyway.
So for me, what I think, before I think what they can do,
I want to just say how they should look at this thing.
So usually when, in the Druze case, for example,
when the Druze were neutral, they were attacked.
When they asked for help, they were attacked.
So we need to see how they've been attacked
to understand when it's really as part of oppression
or early sign of oppression and when it's really justified.
So for example, when the Druze were neutral,
their neutrality was criticized in the beginning.
Then it was questioned, and then it was punished.
And they punished them for being neutral.
And when they asked for help, when they were massacred,
they asked for help, it was taken as separatism.
They say it's political.
And usually when the religious minority is not only a religious minority,
but also an ethno-religious minority,
when ethnicity and religion goes together,
it's always mistaken by politics.
For example, any attack against them is translated into sectarian violence,
and every demand of them to protect themselves
is translated into political demand, which is not true.
Now, how we can know?
We need to listen to them.
As I said, they have this collective memory.
And when they say we want to separate,
it means they're seeking for help.
They cannot tolerate the oppression against them.
It's not because they want to separate because of the political reasons.
Definitely they are massacred.
And by the way, these massacres always target the vulnerable groups of them.
If we look at the Druze case, it started even before the last massacre.
In 2018, they kidnapped 40 women and children,
and they were translating this into just sectarian incidents.
When it's not, all of them were Druze.
Last time, within the Kurdish case, they excluded the Kurdish doctors,
they massacred them, and left the rest.
So, it's always these red flags.
When it turns into political, you have to understand.
Maybe it's not.
Maybe these people are really seeking for help because they cannot tolerate this.
Maybe because the dehumanization and the persecution is irreversible,
and this is their only chance.
And now I ask everyone here what we can do.
Don't misread the signs.
You have to see when the sign is really for persecution,
and when it's irreversible, and when it's really reversible.
In our case, for example, it's irreversible.
That's why separation and independence is a survival demand.
It's not a political demand.
Well, as I mentioned earlier, the escalation has been incremental in Nicaragua.
It's not that they tried to kill and exile bishops right out of the gate.
One of the red flags that we saw early on was that they started to attack
the economic pillars of these faith-based organizations.
The NGOs that were doing work in the field,
the religious schools in the rural communities.
They started to shut them down before they went for the hierarchy.
So I think that that's a big red flag that everybody needs to look out for.
When they start to apply the foreign agents laws against religious organizations,
they're coming for the churches.
If one group is not safe, then all groups should be on high alert.
And that's the opportunity to step forward.
If you have a question, I'll invite you to step to the microphone
and form a line right here at the microphone.
Step to the mic if you have a question.
We're going to take all three of these questions.
So you have 20 seconds to ask a very clear question.
If you want to comment on your question, stay after the session.
Question number one.
Thank you. My question is for Rania.
You mentioned about the persecution of the Druze.
My question is what are the current threats and challenges they are facing in Sweden?
And what do you think the United States can do?
