Illinois lawmakers consider prison oversight watchdog

Fox - 32 Chicago
8 followers
Nov 16, 2026
Welcome back. After years of complaints
about health care gaps, aging infrastructure
and staffing shortages at Illinois prisons,
some lawmakers are saying enough is enough.
They're considering a measure that would create
a watchdog to keep tabs on the Department of
Corrections. Joining us now is Jennifer Volland-Katz,
executive director of the John
Howard Association, the state's only independent
citizen correctional oversight organization.
Jennifer, thanks for being with us.
Thank you so much for having me.
Sure.
We mentioned this during an earlier segment
when we were talking about the Joliet prison
and the amount of fires there that have been set by inmates
who are dealing with some mental
health challenges.
But really, the only governing body that oversees
the Illinois Department of Corrections is
the department itself.
Your organization has gone
in and done some independent investigations, but you can't
see everything though, right?
Correct. So we've actually been given access to the Illinois prisons
by the Illinois Department of Corrections for 125 years.
So we've been going in to all the facilities,
actually adult and juvenile in the state of Illinois that are run
by the state of Illinois to monitor the conditions of confinement
and treatment of the people who are incarcerated.
But we don't have a legislative mandate,
which means we don't have authority to demand access.
Or to investigate, so we see a lot, we learn a lot, we share a lot,
but we don't have the kind of authority that's needed
to really respond to some of the concerns we're hearing
and understand the realities of the situation.
I want to talk to you about House Bill 1643,
because I did read that you
actually support this type of oversight.
This was actually presented by a state
representative, a Democrat out of Chicago,
that would basically be a watchdog, right,
and be responsible for investigating unresolved complaints,
etc. It hasn't advanced up further
yet. There will be a hearing November 10th.
It did happen, but it didn't pass.
What do you think needs to happen
to give real oversight here? I know you can't
Actual changes, what do you think needs to happen
to make some of these changes possible?
So Representative Olakal's bill
is a huge undertaking for the state of Illinois and
a really important piece of legislation that I
do think will advance in the next session.
And I think the hearing on November 10th
was a great way to start really laying the foundation
and educating people about why this is so important.
It sets up in the legislative branch
sort of two things, an office that will both,
number one, be a system oversight entity.
So there will be inspections that go on,
there will be all sorts of audits that are aimed
at understanding systemic issues
and putting forward recommendations to correct them and
compelling the Illinois Department of Corrections
to respond to those recommendations with corrective
action plans.
The other piece it sets up that's
We really don't have it all in the state
of Illinois that's critically important
is creating an ombudsperson specifically
for the Department of Corrections
so that adults who are in state custody have
a way of being heard outside of prison walls
so that their issues, their grievances,
you know, have a way of being resolved.
So there's actual due process built into this.
And I should mention that the ombudsperson will take
in information from not just the
people in custody, but also their loved ones on the outside,
staff people who have a complaint.
A body that can receive information from people inside
the system as well as outside, which
gives them a lot of information,
ability to understand situations, but most importantly,
resolve them.
You said that your organization,
when they did some of the investigations, found some
pretty significant issues.
Were there patterns and what kind of issues did you find?
So over 125 years,
there's pretty much an issue we have not found. Not any kind of
issue that has gone unnoticed.
From aging infrastructure to the horrible, deplorable,
unsafe conditions that many people inside our prisons live in.
We hear a lot about lack of medical care,
lack of mental health treatment, lack of programming,
Staffing deficits, what that means for the people
who work inside our prisons,
mandated overtime for them, feeling stressed out,
feeling overwhelmed, feeling unsafe.
People living in lockdown like conditions without access
to programming on and on that,
you know, the programs are numerous
and it's really important to have outside objective
people inside these facilities in order
to shine a light on what's going on and push
forward recommendations for change.
Is that where you think some of the issues lie?
And the reason why I ask that is because
Already, there is the Department of Corrections,
they have internal investigators.
So do you think that there is something missing?
Are they not really doing their job
because they're already a part of the system, so to
speak?
I think that any government agency,
particularly one that runs a closed system,
which is what prisons are, should have outside oversight.
I think that it is impossible for any agency to objectively,
critically evaluate their
Their own work and and.
Particularly when your job is holding people in custody,
when you have the lives, the safety,
the well-being of human beings as your responsibility,
oversight becomes even more
important. These are not financial audits.
This isn't just understanding the day-to-day work.
Of an agency that pushes paper
or makes decisions that impact bureaucracy but not human lives.
This is an agency that holds people in custody,
who holds people's lives in their hands.
And I believe that we have a responsibility
in the state of Illinois to provide meaningful
Oversight that has authority to intervene
and to make change and really watch what's
going on inside.
So that we are all better positioned to weigh
in on this $2.6 billion a year agency that
again holds people's lives in their hands.
Well, on the flip side,
the IDOC director Latoya Hughes said her department has
plenty of oversight
and she has served for a long time with this organization.
She was chief of staff and chief in
Chief Inspector before her interim role as director,
she was saying right now they have
multilayered oversight from independent external entities,
the courts, federal regulatory requirements
and their own internal compliance functions.
And she said if there was an ombudsperson,
that would draw resources away from existing
oversight functions.
Do you think that's the case?
I don't think that that's the case.
First of all, oversight is typically funded separately
from the agency over which it provides oversight.
So it wouldn't take any resources away from the
Illinois Department of Corrections.
And in many ways, it could serve them better in terms of
resource allocation and use. For instance,
in many jurisdictions, once they stand up prison oversight,
litigation is reduced.
And so many of the things that IDOC is paying hundreds of millions
Of dollars a year to deal with, you know,
they might not have to do that or do it in the same
way. When you talk about court appointed oversight,
I mean, that's due to litigation.
That's because they've already failed.
Those are issues where a judge has said,
well, we got a problem.
We're going to appoint experts to come in, you know,
and provide this very different kind
of specific oversight related to the charges in this case
or what's been filed in this suit.
So, you know, and in terms of internal compliance,
you know, it's just not robust enough.
Again, we are not talking about watching your own auditing practices
in terms of what an agency that holds people in custody requires
in terms of meaningful, independent oversight.
website.
People need to be heard.
Thank you.
Conditions need to be observed,
there needs to be a body that has authority to ask questions,
to resolve complaints, to review camera footage,
to review surveillance video,
to understand exactly what's happening inside.
So I respectfully disagree with the director's assessment
that there's enough oversight.
And I would also strongly disagree
with the contention that it will take resources away
from the agency.
In many instances, there are ways it can be supportive
and helpful in gathering and better
use of resources for the agency.
Yeah, and I would think if nothing's wrong,
you would applaud additional oversight.
Sure.
Very good point there.
Thank you so much for coming on Good Day Chicago this morning.
Absolutely.
Thank you for having me.
