Medieval Combat With Triangle Shields

Shield of Antiquity
8 followers
3 Video Views·Feb 24, 2026
Hello everybody in this video you're going to see our first fighting experiments with the newly made
late medieval shield that I built. This one is a replica of a shield that is now in Marburg
University Museum. It is dated to about 1350 and it is very interesting in as far as two
of the original straps are almost completely intact. Like this one is complete and this one
is still in place although those mounts have not survived. However impressions in the
outer layer of the leather strap are still visible including little holes for the rivets.
Also the lining of that strap which probably is buck hide is also still underneath the upper strap.
Those straps here which I have reconstructed are not in existence anymore. They have perished or
rather they were cut off when the shield was hung above the grave of the unknown knight who
carried that shield. The fixation points are still visible. I'm going to document all this
in a separate video series when I show how I actually made this particular shield. The way
that I reconstructed the straps allows for a number of grips like for instance the most apparent and
one would be slipping through the big straps in the center and then holding the shield
by the little strap here. Here you have quite good control of the shield. You could of course also
if on horseback just slip your arm through the main straps and then hold the reins
or maybe even through the smaller hand strap here. Although I find that a bit restrictive as
this strap is quite short and if you imagine that a fully armored horseman would try to slip his
hand through this rather tight strap he would probably be restricted by the armor or a gauntlet
or whatever kind of hand protection he wears. Now a further way to hold this shield is by just
gripping it with the two main straps and then holding it out for instance much like a buckler.
I still find this grip which I'm also using with my infantry kite shield very convenient and
it allows for excellent control of the shield. So here I just slip my thumb through the outer
main strap and thereby I can get a really good grip off the shield and the weight will be
supported by my forearm as this strap runs over the base of the thumb and the wrist and then you
can hold forward the edge and turn the shield as you please. In the video sequences you will see
that we are striving to bring our shield on top of the opposing one. So one of the principles in
133 one of the classifications of qualities of binds is superior and inferior. So you may be
lying beneath the blade of the opposing party and then you are inferior or on top which is
called superior. Interestingly in German the words for superior and inferior are
which literally means lying on top and lying beneath. So it's quite possible that these terms
are actually derived from fencing. What else? Of course we do have depictions of knights fighting
with the point of the shield being extended forward in this fashion and this is well possible
with this kind of grip on the shield and you should by the way you should not grip this shield
clench this shield with a fist because then the knuckles are almost protruding so it's you have
more control if you just grip it like any tool like you would grip your sword and then particularly
when you have gauntlets or gloves and this allows for excellent control of the shield. What's also
interesting is because I made these straps most of the straps of buckhide and they're quite supple
so if your straps have to be shortened all you do is you just twist them thereby shorten the strap
and then you get exactly the length you want and this is really easily done so you can adapt for
additional thickness that is caused by wearing armor a gambeson mittens whatever
so that's a pretty simple system to shorten straps. The shield is very light
this one doesn't weigh more than a single-handed sword so it's only 1.5 kilograms it's only wooden
planks the original is supposed to be made of linden wood I have to check where this
information actually comes from Jan Kohlmorgen says so in his book but I know that Jan did not
run any according examinations himself so I will check on that one. Linden wood is quite
good for shields because it's fairly lightweight and it's rather soft and softwood is really good
for a shield because although people think that shields are made for blocking and thereby have
to be really sturdy and hard so that they can withstand any blocks sorry any mean attacks by
axes and swords hacking into the shield however I have to say that even when we look at the
treatises it says like in Liechtenauer it says like strike at him as if he doesn't have a sword
in longsword fighting and I think that means that you should go for the man not for the weapons
and in fencing I made the experience that if people start to look at the bind look at the
opponent they instantly lose their fight I can honestly say that I have never been
beaten by anybody in sparring who started looking at the bind they look at the weapons and then I
know okay maybe two more tempi and then it'll be over so same thing here the idea of destroying a
shield is actually in my opinion a pretty feeble one you want to get to the man behind the shield
and should not deal with his weapons if a sword is striking into a shield or an axe and it
strikes really deeply and it's possible if you mount this on a rigid scaffold or some kind of
construction that holds the shield it's really easy to split such a shield it's only a layer
of linen there's gesso on top all of this is connected by hide glue and so yeah it's easy
to destroy it but that will require for your opponent to stand still hold it really really
tight so that it doesn't move so that no power of the strike is absorbed by him giving way
and I doubt you'll ever find an opponent who is willing to do anything like that
so as you can see in the video sequences the shields are constant the shields are constantly
moving and you're trying to get on top of the opposing shield or when he gets on top of yours
you're trying to lever your way out and then come back in so there's a lot of motion and the shields
are at least in a dueling context extended forward and you really don't have much acceleration
a long acceleration path for the blade to actually strike into the shield and plus as I say
you don't really want to be disarmed just because your weapon gets caught in a shield
in this context we tried it out with sharp swords and you can see two you can see two
nicks in here so the swords bit into the shield maybe like 1.8 centimeters so not
so less than an inch and that was a realistic context so coming from the bind and then
striking at the shield and interestingly Cornelius as he struck into the shield he said
it felt like he just instantly bounced off so it's not like the sword was absorbed by the wood
which I expected as I had made that experience in earlier experiments with Viking Age shields and
Viking Age blades now the sword that Cornelius was using was a type 12 sword and
it had a different blade profile than a Viking Age sword so Viking Age swords tend to be rather flat
and they can get apparently they can get caught more easily because that's what we experienced
when we tried it out with a late spartan type sword and a viking shield and here as the sword
cut into the shield because there was more and more material pressing after pressing into
the small gap it just bounced out and so the cuts weren't really very deep so that was a really
interesting effect another thing which I'm looking forward to try out is attaching pyramid shaped
or attaching nails that have pyramid shaped heads the original one the original shield
still does have pyramid shaped nails in three places namely here here and here maybe that one
was a spike like had a spike like head two at one point it was replaced or the spike broke off I
don't know it's probably was repaired at one point and I think this is going to be really
interesting how the shields behave when you have spikes like this yeah so this might be a bit pointy
but this is a nail that I had forged by Arne and I'm going to use these nails with my
next shield replica or maybe I decide to put them into this shield once there are
spikes like this protruding when you have shield contact and this the whole thing
will work very differently I'm pretty sure this will have an effect so you get a you probably
get a really good grip on the opposing shield also you will get better pressure feedback
I guess I mean we will find out because there's less sliding it's like with sharp blades and blunt
blades when you have blunt blades there's always this element of sliding and when you need the
blade to actually get a grip on be it a shield be it a sword and it can get a grip both on the edge
as well as on the flat of an opposing sword then this really helps to get good pressure feedback
so I'm really looking forward to our next experiments with spiked shields and it's not
the only shield that has these spikes there are other examples too there's also one
example where the straps are fastened in such a fashion that there are leather
buttons that are attached to straps and so you can see the leather
button on the outside I actually think it's even rawhide I have to check so it's like a rolled up
strap of rawhide and it's the kind of buttons that you see on some medieval and
viking age shoes and by means of this strap going through a hole drilled in the shield board
the hand straps are fastened now you could say okay this may easily be cut off in combat and then
the strap falls off and you lose control of your shield this may well be however this may have
exactly the same effect or at least partially the same effect that you have like a stopper here
what it also does of course is it protects the surface of the shield now this one held up really
nicely I must say there are hardly any scratches in the painting you can see that there's
that there are some parts where the color has been removed by constant contact with the opposing
shield I will probably paint this over again I'm also going to make a repair of these cuts and see
how you would repair something like that I mean there are many options like I could remove the
linen here put put some high glue with wood dust into the gaps and then seal the whole thing with
another layer of linen and put gesso on top again paint it again and then it will probably be
invisible I'm really looking forward to that experiment too because it means that if you can
repair things like that so that it's so that it's not detectable from the outside anymore
it could mean that some of the surviving shields that we have have actually been repaired
a final word on dueling and formation fighting in the sequences you see dueling so this is what
is my field of expertise I find it extremely challenging to research formation fighting
because imagining doing something like that with sharp swords formation fighting or sharp weapons
sharp spears you would need people who have been doing that for so many years trust each other and
it's not just two persons the geometry will be totally different so that would be a major
challenge and even if you use masks and blunt spears it still doesn't have the same effect
the blunt spear will always bounce off sharp spears sharp spears may get caught so that's
the reason why I don't deal with formation fighting for the moment but as you see in
the single combat sequences it's very dynamic so there's a lot of motion and that means that
anything that hits the shield doesn't develop the same kind of impact that you would expect if the
shield was more static so that means that if you're in a formation of course you cannot expose
yourself in the same fashion as or let's put it this way you would expose yourself
if you would just look at one person's weapons trying to screen off the trying to close his lines
of attack because there would be multiple opponents so if you screen off a sword over there
you may be hit by a spear coming from here so you'd be fighting a lot more statically and the
shield would be held in a more static position so that means that we could expect much deeper
damage much severe damage on shields if they are used in formation fighting
and this seems to be the case there are miniatures in a codex from Bamberg dating to
the late 1100s and there you can see combatants with kite shields and those kite shields have
really deep cuts both on the sides but particularly on the top edge and it looks like the cuts go
that deep and I can easily imagine that it's not very difficult to cut into a shield that deeply
yeah so a lot of really exciting new experiments looking forward to
the work ahead and I hope you enjoy the fighting sequences see you next time
