The Untold Story of Old Forester: The Bourbon That Survived Whiskey Row

Brandy Channel
12 followers
#wine #winetasting
In this episode of Whiskeyland, we explore the history of Old Forester and the power of their story through the lens of the Whiskey Row series.
0:00 INTRO
1:42 MEET MASTER TASTER MELISSA RIFT
3:25 MEET CALEB TRIGO
4:35 BROWN FORMAN TOUR
6:15 THE EARLY DAYS OF OLD FORESTER
7:45 1870 ORIGINAL BATCH
8:52 1897 BOTTLED-IN-BOND
9:50 1910 OLD FINE WHISKEY
12:32 1920 PROHIBITION STYLE
14:25 1924 10-YEAR
16:25 CHRIS MORRIS TOUR
20:30 THE STORY IS REAL
22:36 OUTRO
🔥SUBSCRIBE @whiskeylandtv
🔥CONNECT:
Subscribe for more: @whiskeylandtv
E-mail: [email protected]
TikTok: @whiskeylandtv
IG: @whiskeylandtv
Whiskies have had their origins in a number of lands, and from the United States comes bourbon
whiskey, high in the list of preferred beverages wherever smart people congregate. The heart of
Kentucky, bourbon capital of the world. Named for one of Kentucky's pioneer counties, bourbon whiskey
is a distinctive product of a land which is rich in the traditions of gracious living.
The poetry of bourbon is in its deep obligation to history. The alchemical mystique of America's
own spirit draws us in like a ship to a lighthouse, with waves of nostalgia connecting us to the
invisible thread of a bygone era. In whiskey, the past is always present, and there are those who
answer the call and light the torch to show us the way.
Uh, yeah, sure, sure. All right, what do we got here? What are we doing?
Where do we start? Well, I always tell people if we're gonna use a
craft bourbon series to tell our history, probably start at the beginning.
That sounds good to me, yeah.
VIP should at least be able to get a drink of his own whiskey.
Old Forester, I suppose, if you please.
So you're a whiskey taster. What a job. Where do applicants line up?
I'll tell you, my story is not particularly unique in Kentucky bourbon. Fast rises have been
kind of a theme because the industry has grown so much in the last decade. But I started as a
couple and family therapist. That's what I went to school for. So I have a degree in human behavior
and family therapy. And, you know, family systems theory is all about making groups and systems work
more harmoniously together. And really my foot in the door was I started my my job as a therapist
and I just thought, well, there's no reason on the weekends I can't make that same kind of cash
giving bourbon tours, you know, because storytelling, if I had to, like, name one
medium would be kind of what I do. And when I was a therapist, you know, there's lots of
different theories and modalities that you can kind of gravitate towards as a therapist. And
none of them are right. That's the thing about therapy is that it's what you bring to the
conversation with your clients. But narrative therapy was my my go to. And it's all about how
you tell yourself your narrative or receive the feedback from outside and kind of narrate it
within and how you reframe that and restructure the narrative to get unstuck. And so storytelling
is like just so aligned with that. I was working here when Melissa was hired into the master
taster role for Old Forrester. And I was like, I have to meet. I'm so excited. And so when,
you know, kind of moving into this role last year, it was interesting to say we instantly clicked.
And I don't want to sound cliche, but like we kind of just did. And I remember one of the first
things that we did together. It was actually a photo shoot for a local magazine, just kind of
highlighting Old Forrester and such. And we're like, we don't really know each other, but like
we had the best shots of like she and I together just like leaning on. It was like, OK, this is
going to be this is going to be great. This is this is the founding brand of Brown Foreman and
like George Garvin Brown and all the Browns that work at the company that I've worked with for
years. It's like this is sacred. And so it's like no pressure, but pressure like the longevity of
the company is directly tied to Old Forrester. And so at one hundred and fifty five years, I
anticipate that the expectation is that we go for another hundred and fifty five years plus.
Right. Whatever things that we do, that's new. It has to be authentic. It has to tie back to
our history. We can do new things, of course, that we haven't done in the past. But again,
it has to be meaningful to the brand and it has to make sense. I want to tell you about a place
so integral to the history of bourbon that voyaging its very halls can feel like you
are both in a time machine and witnessing a physical blueprint of the future. The Brown
Foreman Distillery, home of Old Forrester. Rooted in Louisville, but anchored in time,
and it has become a living monument of America's spirit and housed in its walls are memories so
deeply connected to the giants of the whiskey industry. You can almost feel the vibrations
of their footsteps. It's a meaningful place. It represents the great connector,
the spirited conversation, the glass full of happy memories. This is a place that has been
hollowed by many with whom we may never know, but they built entire working careers here,
day in and day out, working towards that American dream and celebrating a day's hard work with a
I somehow always envisioned this tremendous boulder being held on the shoulders of these
giants, in which if we dare to climb, we will see a profound new horizon. The world of Old
Forrester, one of America's oldest and most treasured brands, has managed to make this
trip through time, trekking the hills and hollows of the past to pour itself into the zeitgeist
over and over. Its success as a family-owned brand for over a century is due to something
actually quite simple. Honor one's past by being present. Just 20 years ago, Old Forrester,
the founding brand of our company, was about to go out of existence. It had just become irrelevant.
Other brands were cooler, more modern, bigger, better, whatever the term would have been.
Some of us in the company said, we can't allow Old Forrester to fade away.
That led to the realization, which we've talked about for years but had never really articulated
it, that this is the brand of history. This is the most historic brand in the history of our
country. We could use that history and our archival record, our artifacts, films,
photographs, to start building the story again.
It's showtime. Hurry, hurry, it's showtime. Hurry, hurry, in no time. They'll strike up the band.
I am Tim Holtz. I am Brown Forman's historian and corporate storyteller. I get the great
opportunity to be the person who preserves and protects our history.
The company really started, and Old Forrester can't be separated because it was our first brand
from that. So much of the early company history really is engaged with Brown Forman. So it
started out as a partnership between two brothers. This is our origin story. You know, we were
founded by a pharmaceutical salesman, George Garvin Brown, who really just wanted to solve
for a business issue. He wanted to be able to create a product he could guarantee the
consistency and quality of because he knew that there was quality bourbon being made in Kentucky.
And rectifiers, people making counterfeit products or products with harmful additives,
they were undercutting that business. And so he sourced bourbon from three reputable
distilleries across the city of Louisville, batched it together for an original batch,
that's why we call this original batch, and put it in glass bottles. And that was the first
bottle of bourbon in the industry. Because everybody asks, where does the Forman come
from? Mr. Forman was literally just an employee and business partner. So he started out as a
business partner in 1890. He was made a full partner and they named the company Brown Forman
and Company. And they made an agreement that should either one of the others pass away,
the name of the company would still remain Brown Forman. Well, nearly a century later,
we're still dedicated to making whiskey that way. Yes, but now you produce it in such tremendous
quantities. How can you possibly be sure that every bottle is the same? He tastes every bottle,
remember? It's his job. So Bottled and Bond comes 27 years after Old Forrester puts this
stake in the ground when it comes to consistency and quality guarantee. And this is where U.S.
distillers, they're finally fed up with the inconsistencies of the industry and they want
legislation to actually communicate through the package that something's been vetted. And so that
becomes a Bottled and Bond Act, first form of consumer protection legislation ever in this
country. Wow. Yeah. So actually predates the Pure Food and Drug Act by about nine years and kind of
blueprints it a little bit. Wow. So again, Old Forrester history is bourbon history is American
history because everybody's just trying to figure it out as they go along. And so it was
really important they figured out whiskey. The making of whiskeys of which it can truthfully
be said there is nothing better in the market. Louisville and the Browns, George Garment Brown
in particular, set out, as the labels say, to create nothing better than the market.
So in a whiskey city, how do we make sure that our whiskey is the best whiskey that we can make it?
You want to tell the story of 1910? Sure. Yeah. So 1910, this is my absolute favorite story in the
Whiskey Row lineup. It speaks to our authenticity and kind of drawing from really fun historic
moments to kind of bring that to life today in the modern modern day. And so back in 1910,
you know, we're rocking and rolling on Whiskey Row. We have we're at 117 West Main Street,
where our current distillery is today. And, you know, in the sub basement, we had a bottling
operation. So we had, you know, processing, we were dumping barrels, and then we were bottling.
And unfortunately, a fire erupted in the building. Everybody scrambles to like save as much as they
can, including the liquid gold in the tank that we were actively bottling. And so luckily, we had
some new charred oak barrels next to that tank. We emptied that tank into the new charred oak barrels,
rolled them out, saved the building. And then it was interesting because about two years later,
we're going through inventory and we find these barrels and we're like, all right, let's let's
monetize this stock, right? And so we dump the barrels. And then of course, when we taste and
we go to like evaluate these barrels, we found something totally different. We didn't we didn't
find the normal Forester bourbon that we're used to. And we're all about quality and consistency,
right? And it certainly was quality, but it wasn't consistent with what we were bottling at the time.
So we actually bottled those barrels as old fine whiskey. And one of my favorite things that
I kind of talked through with Chris Morris kind of moving into this space was the fact that
one of the Brown family members actually had a case of this in their basement and, you know,
they found it. And so we actually have those exact bottles, a full case of unopened bourbon from 1910
again, like tell that authentic story and what inspired this today. And so to kind of bring it
to life, we we, you know, we dump old Forester, cut it down signature 100 to 100 proof and we put
it into a second barrel, highly charred, low toast to kind of lean into that story of the fire. And
we have this beautiful expression of 1910 prior to prohibition. And even shortly thereafter,
there weren't that many people like Louisville was the hub of the whiskey industry,
Main Street, Whiskey Row. There were 80 whiskey wholesalers, but they were only in an eight block
stretch. So 80 wholesalers were in eight blocks. They were all neighbors for that matter. So as a
matter of fact, like in when the fire that happened that inspired 1910, literally the distiller,
four buildings down, said, just move your offices down here until you can get that rebuilt and then
you can move back down into your office space. And it was, you know, it was just another stiller.
Um, they all knew one another. They all had lunch together. Our distillery actually burned
down during prohibition because we were just selling barrels that we already had stocked in
our warehouses when we got that license, which is why we had to move on to, um, the headquarters
site in 1923, 1924, because we started buying all this barrel stock because nobody could keep
selling. And so we had to concentrate it all in one place. And that's where we start bottling
other products is old Forrester, which we'll get to with the 1924, but 1920 is all about
perseverance and resilience. It's all about figuring out how to make it work with the
landscape ahead of you. And 115 proof was the original medicinal whiskey proof, because if
you think about it, proofing is for recreational consumption, right? 90 proof was for palatability.
If you're coming out with a medicine, you're not trying to make it palatable. You're trying
to make it medicine. So it comes right out of the barrel. It goes right into a prescription bottle
and it comes out about barrel strength back then. Now, today we go on a barrel at a much higher
proof, 125 proof. Back then barrel entry was around 110. And so this would have been basically
your cask strength back then. We are one of the only continuously operating spirits companies in
the United States. And particularly as far as I know, the only one continuously operating under
the same ownership. So we have sold literally whiskey or spirits since our founding in 1870.
And that's because we were given first during prohibition, the ability to sell bottled medicinal
whiskey. We then bought one of the 2830 concentration warehouses where they were housing
the whiskey. So we aged it. And then because we own that aging capacity near the end of prohibition,
we're actually allowed to start distilling again. At every step of the way,
modern science supplements the traditional arts and skills of the old time distiller.
In 1923, as we had to start concentrating all of our barrels into one warehousing site,
we purchased the GL Redmond distillery. It becomes kind of our warehousing site. And then later our
distillation operations. And we talked about how we've evolved in that site for a hundred years now.
And so this really tells that story by showing how much breadth we have as a brand. And Tim,
our corporate historian, told me recently that all of the barrels we acquired
at that time, the highest quality products went under Old Forrester's name. And then they kind of
disseminated the other barrels under the other brand names because we were the founding brand
of the family. Right. And so it was really important to them that they maintain our
quality reputation throughout prohibition. The reason Old Forrester and our whiskeys are so
great is because George Garvin Brown could tell his brother, I'm going to spend the money on this
because it's going to give us a better, higher quality whiskey. And so the science, I think,
is something that really sets us apart. So another person that nobody really talks about,
but is to me an icon of our whiskeys and why they're so great is a man by the name of Dr.
Frank Shipman. And he was our first scientist. So people don't think about the fact, but
there was a huge evolution and growth in chemical and industrial know-how during the 1920s.
Well, our industry was left behind. So most distillers went back in 1933 and just started
making whiskey the way they always ever made it before. Well, George Garvin Brown, the second,
realized, hey, there's a whole lot of stuff we don't know. This could help us. So he literally
hired the head of the chemistry department at the University of Louisville. He was a research
chemist. He brought him in and the oral histories that we have from Dr. Shipman said they gave me
what they considered some of the best casks of whiskey they had in their warehouses.
And Owsley Brown, the first, told me, what I want you to do is figure out how do we produce
whiskey that tastes like this every time. As this diagram suggests, modern bourbon distilleries
like those operated by Brown Forman are complex affairs and involve many separate operations,
which must be carefully integrated. Well, we're in the midst of the Brown Forman campus
and Brown Forman is located here physically beginning in 1923. If you were afforded the
opportunity to tour the Brown Forman distillery with Chris Morris, Master Distiller Emeritus,
you always say yes. The second floor was all engineering, back before there were
computers and cad cams and everything, all the big drafting tables. And I remember all the
engineers having the pocket protectors and everything. They really did. I should get a
Caleb, for example, you could see if you have good eyes that this window has had,
it's been put in, that used to be a door. And when I started here, again, these were public streets.
And if you wanted to apply for a job at Brown Forman, you just walked in because that was the
personnel office. And you walked into a room and it had a formica counter around it and like a
bank teller's office. And you'd say, I want an application. Somebody would slide an application
out. You'd fill it in and slide it back and leave. And hopefully you got a call and might get a job.
So that was the public way to apply for a job at Brown Forman. He is maybe forgotten more than any
of us will ever even learn about bourbon. That is to say, we are currently living in the times
of a legend. And much of his generously shared wisdom comes from a bygone era.
So Mr. Mr. Lyons and his wife, Sally introduced the Cavalier King Spaniels to the United States.
They introduced that breed because they met in Europe. They were married in Europe. He
travel in his Mrs. Brown, Sally Brown was the daughter of a Brigadier General. And
he served in Europe and the various embassies. So they were exposed to a lot of European culture,
European breeds, et cetera. And they fell in love with this type of dog and again,
introduced it to the United States. The story of bourbon requires those who pass through its
universe to carry its truths. And Chris has honored that tradition in deeply meaningful ways.
To be in his presence is to hold reverence for those who came before him and those that will
come after. I know you didn't get my like authentic reaction, but he said he introduced
the dog and I thought he was going to say it like distillery dog to the company. And he said to the
country and I said the whole country. I just, this is the type of thing people could do back then is
they could just introduce new breeds to the country. And I think that's, that's a very fun
fact has nothing to do with whiskey. Like all Forrester history is bourbon history is Louisville
history is Kentucky history is US history. It's all it's all there. All intertwined and
for our dog lovers who have a good yappy hour, this is, this is our legacy. Watching the way he
quietly guides both Melissa and Caleb through history is like a torch bearing time traveler
who understands their higher calling is that of master teacher. My father joined Brown Foreman
in 1946. And he was a mash man in this very building right up in these areas that we're
standing in now. And as he moved into management, his office was in what is now founders hall,
right, right across the courtyard. And I would come down with him on weekends when I was little,
and I would play in the distillery, play in the distillery, the granary with the operators. And
would spend long hours on the rail line that brought the coal in and different things like
throwing chunks of coal at the building and breaking bottles, which I shouldn't have been
doing from the bottling hall. So again, this was this was my playground as as a little boy,
many, many years ago. I love being in whiskey land. And something about what I consider the gateway
to the American South intrigues me. There are these old rules in Kentucky that apply
the minute the airplane lands, or when your car pulls in, they ask you to be polite,
welcoming, and in some ways, mysteriously passive. I think it's just such a hospitality centric place
that their resting position is simply being helpful and kind. We encounter this immediately
with the old Forrester team. And at every opportunity, they provided us with warm insights
into their narrative, working authentically to articulate just how much the thread of time
means to them. And it goes without saying, but Brown Foreman is one of the largest whiskey
makers in the world. And in full transparency, we entered with some preconceived notions
wrapped in the idea that most large organizations have a carefully guarded brand story that could
sometimes feel curated beyond our ability to shape an authentic narrative. But at every turn,
we found a sincere interest in telling the real story beyond just a pretty well-priced bottle.
I mean, when you hear all those stories about these American brands, like it's a story of
perseverance and highlighted probably the best maybe by 1924, when we literally couldn't distill
Old Forrester, the brand still was there. And we still persevered through prohibition,
those dark 13 years. And so I think that that for me resonates the most with Whiskey Row and
history of Old Forrester and being bourbon history, Louisville history, American history,
is that story of perseverance and wanting to continue the legacy of what, you know,
was founded in 1870. It may have been founded in 1870, but Old Forrester is as modern as they've
ever been, which is to say that they know their history without always having to repeat it.
They also know it's a story worth repeating. This is really important, not just to the company,
to our brands, but to the industry, because bourbon is not only the distinctive spirit of
America, it is America's history, its culture, its society, big moments, little moments in what
makes America great. And no company has it recorded in archival records like Brown Foreman does.
What I love about someone with roots as deep as theirs is that they had the brilliant insight
to keep a good archive, to hold their story in the bones of history and the body of their timeless
yet perfectly aged elixir. The good folks at Old Forrester know that a real story has to be earned
and they didn't become one of America's most iconic whiskey brands overnight.
It took guts and gusto to navigate the rowdy seas of time, but anchoring themselves in a belief
that great whiskey is not just the creation, but the creators themselves. Old Forrester isn't just
a story, it's storytelling itself. It's Chris Morris patiently laying the groundwork so that
folks like Melissa and Caleb can be more rooted in something that has legs, that can stand the
test of time, that becomes more gentle and wonderful with each passing season, much like
the juice that they are the chosen guardians of. To hold history in the pocket of your dreams
brings forth something personal and complex, but without continuity you could lose the thread.
So they have remained faithful servants of this elusive juice whose true origin story is time
itself. And for that, I propose a toast. To those in Bourbon that came before us,
we honor your voyage as we remain steadfast to the collective vision. Slow, but steady,
wins the race. Honor your past by being present, or in the words of Guru Ram Das,
be here now. And so here we are, now, ready for another sip of the good stuff.
And if it's the famed single barrel rye, straight from the barrel, well friends,
who am I to argue with a guru? This is Whiskeyland. Cheers.
