The Old Forester American whiskey brand, over the last couple years, has been releasing a series of bourbons designed to showcase the evolution of its whiskey making history as part of the Brown-Forman family. This series includes the 1870 Original Batch, 1897 Bottled in Bond, 1910 Old Fine Whisky and the Old Forester 1920 Prohibition Style. In this review I taste through the whole series to see which ones are worth your time and money. Cheers!
Hope you enjoy the review and thanks for watching the Mash and Drum whiskey review channel!
Please SUBSCRIBE and hit the LIKE button!
Want to purchase one of my custom whiskey challenge coins? Leave a comment that says "Mash and Coin"
Are you on Instagram? Find me at @The_Mash_and_Drum Are you on Twitter? Find me @MashandD Support me on Patreon! / themashanddrum
How we doing everybody and welcome to the Mastin Drum Whiskey Room.
My name is Jason C and if you're a subscriber, thanks so much for coming back and watching
this episode.
If you're new to the channel and you're looking for the latest in whiskey and bourbon news
and reviews, if you have found the right place, hit that subscribe button below and hit that
bell notification so you know when I'm putting out a new video and you can join in on one
of my live streams.
The Old Forrester American Whiskey brand over the last couple of years has been releasing
a series of bourbons designed to showcase the evolution of its whiskey making history
as part of the Brown Forman family.
First started in 2014, Old Forrester's Whiskey Row series, which includes 1870 Original Batch,
1897 Biled and Bond, 1920 Prohibition Style, and the final Whiskey Row member, 1910 Old
Fine Whiskey.
While the 1920 and 1910 have become bourbon enthusiast favorites, I wanted to explore
the whole series today on the Mash and Drum.
Brown Forman has such a rich history in the world of bourbon in Kentucky.
With only about $5,500 in saved and borrowed money, George Garvin Brown, a young pharmaceutical
salesman in Louisville, Kentucky, started JTS Brown and Brothers with his half-brother.
They decided to sell whiskey in sealed glass bottles to assure its quality, which was an
innovative approach at the time when whiskey was commonly sold by the barrel.
Now Old Forrester Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey was the flagship brand and after several
name changes and the dissolution of the original partnership, George Garvin enters into partnership
with George Forman, his accountant and friend, and Brown Forman was then created.
As I mentioned, each bottle in the Whiskey Row series is designed to showcase the evolution
of whiskey making in Brown Forman's long history.
The first bottle in the series is the 1870 Original Batch, which is the year George Garvin
Brown created Old Forrester in Louisville, Kentucky's famous Whiskey Row.
Old Forrester 1870 Original Batch echoes George Garvin Brown's original 1870 batching process.
So in the 1800s, bourbon was sold by the barrel, which caused quality and taste to vary from
release to release, just like it does today.
Now Old Forrester's founder, George Garvin Brown, changed the industry by batching his bourbon.
Back then, Brown-batched barrels obtained from three different distilleries to create
a consistent flavor profile.
To match that process today, barrels are selected from three different warehouses, each barrel
originating from a different day of production, with a different entry proof, and a different
age profile.
Those three expressions of Old Forrester are then batched together to craft Old Forrester
1870 Original Batch.
This is a 90 proof bourbon, it's minimally filtered, and available for about $45.
Alright guys, so the 1870 batch, like I said, it's 90 proof, about $45.
Three different batches blended together to make a consistent flavor profile, just like
they did way back when.
So let's get into the nose and see what we get for this bottle.
This has a ton of fruity, orange type flavors to it.
It's very citrusy, very fruit forward.
There's a honey aspect to it.
There's a very big floral aspect to it, a lot of kind of fresh cut flowers on the nose.
Still that orange, that honey, really kind of dominates the nose here.
Alright, you get a little bit deeper as it opens up, vanilla, caramel starts coming out.
And of course, as with most Brown Forman products, you get that quintessential, that kind of
Brown Forman signature oak note that I get, which adds a little bit of this cinnamon spice
to it, a little bit of a cherry, but I don't know, Brown Forman just has this way of what
they do with their barrels, it just has a very distinct flavor profile to me.
Alright, let's go in for a taste and see what we get, cheers.
So this one is very, again, on the palate, just like the nose, it's very fruit forward,
it's got some honey to it.
There's definitely more of that citrus going on, not as floral, a good mix of oak on that
one.
Man, now I'm getting the cinnamon, a little bit of clove, some baking spices on the back
of the palate.
Let's go in for another sip.
Cheers.
Man, that is a, that's an easy sipper, that's kind of dangerous because, like dangerous
in a good way, because as you keep sipping on it, it stays pretty fruity, really nice
and sweet.
Now the caramel vanillas are coming to the forefront a little bit.
But that finish is still giving you a nice kind of cinnamon, baking spice, oaky flavor
profile that you like in a brown Forman bourbon.
Really nice.
One last sip here.
Okay, third sip.
Third sip, you know, it kind of flattened out a good amount there.
You're still getting some nice flavors on the back end, the oak, little bit of cherry
now coming through too, to go along with those citrus notes.
So I gotta say, I'm pretty impressed with this one.
It's got a really nice flavor profile to it.
It's not overly complex.
The nose really kind of matches the flavor profile.
It's fruity.
It's sweet.
It's got a nice, a little bit of an oaky finish there.
You still get some of those quintessential brown Forman baking spices.
For 45 bucks though, at 90 proof, not a lot of complexity.
I think the price hurts it a little bit in this case, but still a pretty solid bourbon.
So the second release in the Whiskey Rose series is the Old Forrester 1897 Bottled and
Bond, crafted to honor a watershed moment in bourbon history, the U.S. Bottled and Bond
Act of 1897.
So after the U.S. Bottled and Bond Act of 1897, to be labeled as bottled and bond, whiskey
must be the product of one distillation season, one distiller, and from one distillery.
The concept behind the act, the idea of sealed in quality, was something that Old Forrester,
America's first bottled bourbon, introduced in 1870.
Now according to the neck tag on the bottle, this small batch craft expression will be
presented in a lightly filtered old style, reminiscent of a 19th century bourbon.
This is bottled at 100 proof, and available for about 50 bucks.
Alright guys, so let's dive into the 1897 Bottled and Bond in the Whiskey Rose series.
So let's go to the nose first, here we go.
Way more intense on the nose, I really like it.
The nose is really caramel heavy right off the bat.
Definitely get more of that oak impact on this one.
It's definitely coming more to the forefront.
You're still getting a little bit of that fruitiness characteristic, but the oak flavor
is really at the forefront here.
This one is a little bit more dark fruity.
Now I'm getting kind of a cherry type characteristic to it, a cherry syrup.
I mean you can definitely smell the alcohol in this one.
This one, you know, for an old style Bottled and Bond, I'm sure you really kind of felt
that alcohol punch, and you definitely get that in this glass a little bit.
But I really like the nose on this one.
It's kind of a nice mix of fruit, oak, some fruity characteristic.
There is a little bit of that floral quality in here that I was getting in the 1870, but
not as prominent.
I think the oak and the dark fruit type characteristic, also with those vanillas and caramels really
kind of dominate the nose here.
Yeah, really nice nose on this one.
It's a really nice bourbon nose.
Let's go in for the palate and see what we get.
Cheers.
The dark fruit characteristic is really prominent in here.
A lot of cherry, maybe a hint of a raisin characteristic in there.
Definitely some oak.
I mean this definitely, you're going to get a little bit more of a longer finish here.
That 100 proof characteristic, you really kind of feel it.
Really nice.
Let's go for another sip here.
Cheers.
Second sip, now all the caramels and vanillas are coming to the forefront.
All that beautiful oak characteristic is on the finish.
You still get that quintessential brown and foreman, that cinnamon, that spice, cherry,
honey.
It's pretty mouth-coating too, I got to say.
For 100 proof, it definitely sticks to the palate way more than this did.
For five bucks more, this one I think really gives a much fuller flavor profile.
Let's go in for one more sip here.
Cheers.
This just has a really nice balance too on the finish.
It's sweet, it's oaky, it's not leaning really towards one way or the other.
It really provides a nice spicy characteristic.
You're getting that 100 proof type of a finish.
It's not short, but I wouldn't say it's super long either.
It's probably somewhere in the medium range.
So for the Bottled and Bond, the 1897, I really like this.
I think it's a really great whiskey.
I think the only problem is that being labeled Bottled and Bond, and then when you put it
next to a bunch of other really nice budget whiskeys that are out there, other nice Bottled
and Bond bourbons, JTS Brown, Evan and Williams Bottled and Bond, there are some really nice
quality ones out there.
Even Old Grandad Bonded.
It's hard to kind of, when you can get those bottles for sometimes $20 and under, $25 and
under, it's hard to kind of make the jump to a $50 bottle for this particular Bottled
and Bond bourbon.
But what I will say, I do think it's a little bit older.
It's got some more deeper, richer kind of a characteristic, I would think, than just
a four year old bourbon.
I would definitely encourage you to give this a try.
Maybe not buy a bottle right away, but if somebody has it that you know, or if it's
out of bar, definitely give it a try.
Third and probably the most popular in the series is the Old Forrester 1920 Prohibition,
which celebrates the brand continued distillation during Prohibition.
For 13 years, the production, transport, and sale of alcohol was strictly prohibited.
However, Old Forrester was granted a permit to continue distilling on Louisville's Whiskey
Row.
The 115 proof expression represents a barrel sample that company president, Osley Brown,
would have batched at the beginning of Prohibition.
So according to the tag on the bottle, during Prohibition, only six Kentucky distilleries
were granted permits to bottle bourbon for medicinal purposes.
Brown Foreman, maker of Old Forrester, secured permit Kentucky-3.
In 1920, the first bottles under this permit were produced.
It goes on to say, to match the usual barrel proof of that bourbon after maturation, it
is presented at 115 proof.
This bottle is also available for about $60 to $65 bucks.
All right guys, so let's go into the 1920.
This is definitely kind of the darling of the Whiskey Row series.
A lot of people love this bourbon, including me, absolutely in love with it, but it's kind
of cool to kind of go through the series and kind of match them up bottle to bottle.
Let's go into the nose and see what we get here.
Man, this nose just jumps out of the glass at you.
This is just pure cherry, chocolate, oak.
This has a like a creme brulee drizzle with caramel type aspect to it, but man, the chocolate
and cherry note is so prevalent on the nose.
That's what I really love about this.
It just has such a great flavor profile on the nose.
There's a bit of a roasted almond characteristic in here too.
A little bit of a smokiness, I think, which I think is something you get as the bottle
opens up a little bit, along with almost like a used coffee grind type smell to it, kind
of a coffee ground scent.
It's really amazing on the nose.
It just kind of goes all over the place, kind of takes you through.
Now it is 115 proof, you do smell that alcohol a good amount, but there's so many rich flavors
coming through here.
One of my favorite notes I get on here as it opens up is almost like a Christmas gingerbread
cookie.
There's like this spicy, sweet gingerbread cookie aspect to it as well.
Man, I love this stuff on the nose.
I could smell this all day.
Alright, let's get into the palate and see what we get.
Cheers.
So as soon as this hits your palate, you start getting this tingling sensation right on the
front of your tongue.
And that's like this peppery, all spice, kind of cinnamon red hot aspect to it.
As it works its way back, then boom, you're hit with cherry, some chocolate, a little
bit of that nutty character that comes through too.
And once it pairs together, you start getting those vanilla caramels all together at the
same time, leaving a really nice finish on this one.
Let's go for another sip here, cheers.
On the second sip, now it just gets even sweeter.
Once your palate gets used to the proof a little bit, it kind of goes away.
Now there's just tons of sweet flavors here.
There's cherry, there's chocolate, vanilla, caramel.
That gingerbread cookie is still there.
Then on the finish, you're getting all those baking spices.
And then what you're left with is a really nice oak flavor.
It's some beautiful sweet oak that they somehow get into these bottles from Brown Foreign.
It's such a distinct oak and kind of a sweet oak flavor profile.
Absolutely love it.
Let's get into another sip here, cheers.
Such a great finish to this.
The finish, even on that third sip, the oak just pairs with that cherry chocolate flavor.
It's so rich, it's inviting, absolutely delicious.
Even if you put a couple drops of water in this one, it actually opens up the vanilla
caramel flavors a little bit.
It kind of evens it out, gives it a little bit less harshness to it.
Becomes just a really all-around great bourbon.
One of the best buys on the market.
I know it's 60 to 65, it can be pricey for a lot of people, but this is one of those
bourbons where you can just sip on constantly, work on it.
As it goes down the bottle, it opens up, different flavors open up.
Just probably one of the best available bourbons on the market.
So lastly, we have the 1910 Old Fine Whiskey, the final release in the Whiskey Rose series.
Like others in the series, 1910 Old Fine Whiskey represents a specific point in Old Forrester's
nearly 150-year-old history.
In October of 1910, a fire caused the bottling line to be shut down for an indefinite period
of time.
Complicating matters, there was a vat of mature whiskey waiting to be bottled.
Otherwise facing ruin, this whiskey was instead stored in new charred oak containers to rest
until the line could be repaired.
The resulting product, the first documented double-barreled whiskey, was both different
from Old Forrester and remarkable enough to become an entirely new expression.
So to mimic this historic bottling, this unique expression of Old Forrester has undergone
a second barreling in a lightly toasted but heavily charred barrel.
Mature Old Forrester bourbon enters a second barrel at 100 proof, just as it did in 1910.
The second barrel is charred nearly to the point of incineration, almost for a full minute.
So this low entry proof allows more of the wood sugars to be dissolved into the whiskey,
resulting in more flavor.
This is bottled at only 93 proof and available for about $55.
Alright guys, so here's the 1910.
This is my backup bottle that I had.
I just literally finished the bottle I had previous to it.
This is the last pour.
And the reason why I poured this for this review is because this bottle, when I first
opened it, I wasn't that crazy about it, but as it opened up, all these really great flavors
started kind of coming to the forefront.
So let's go into the nose and see what we get.
Extremely oaky and sweet.
That double-barreling, that all those sugars that they're pulling from the wood is really
at the forefront of this one.
This is like extremely vanilla forward, very vanilla cake with like vanilla frosting.
There's just a ton of vanilla on the nose.
I love this chocolate coffee type pairing that it gives.
There's also kind of a chocolate covered raisin aspect to it as well, if you've ever had a
raisinette in the movie theater.
It's just really dark and rich, has a lot of great flavors to it.
And if you give this bottle time, it definitely will reward you with some nicer flavors on
the nose.
Let's go to the palate and see what we get.
Cheers.
So one of the kind of weirdest things too that I found with this bottle is that for
only a 93 proofer, it's extremely viscous.
It's got a lot of great mouthfeel quality to it, it kind of sticks to the palate.
There's a deep, rich mouthfeel characteristic here too, and it's really kind of sticking
to the palate.
For a 93 proofer, it's extremely rich, very creamy.
Let's go in for another sip here.
Cheers.
Oak, caramel.
There's more of that chocolate covered raisin aspect to it.
You still get that cherry note that I got in all three of these.
It's still there.
It's kind of like that underlying, it's like that fabric that runs through all the old
Forrester stuff.
Really, really good.
Really love it.
That pecan note is coming a little bit to the forefront on the finish.
Really nice there as well.
Let's go for another sip here.
Cheers.
Chocolate covered raisins, coffee.
This tastes like you take a nice, deep, rich espresso, like a dark coffee, and you pour
a little vanilla creamer in it, or a caramel creamer.
It kind of all plays really well together.
Really, really delicious.
Has a nice balance.
It's not overly oaked, which you would think would be the case.
When I first opened it, I thought it was a little bit too oaky, but like I said, as this
bottle gets some air into it, it really does make a big difference on the flavor profile.
A lot of those sweet characteristics come out.
The oak kind of takes a little bit more of a backseat.
It's still there, but definitely not nearly as prominent as when you first opened the
bottle.
Let's go for one last sip here.
When I first opened this, like I said, I wasn't super impressed with it.
I thought it was just too over the top with the oak, and there wasn't enough balance there.
As this really gets down the bottle, it really opens up.
It becomes a really beautiful flavored whiskey.
The chocolate, the sugars, the vanilla, the caramels, that raisin type flavor to it.
There's still that cherry aspect to it, some baking spices.
There's almost kind of a leather tobacco note, too, that goes along with it.
I have a couple buddies that really enjoy this whiskey with a cigar, so if you're into
that, this is a really great cigar pairing type whiskey to go with it as well.
This being the final release, I really think it was a great way to end the entire series.
All of these four bottles, I think, have a little bit of something for everyone.
All right, guys, so as you go through all four bottles, the 1870, although I think it's
a really good bourbon, it's really sweet, it's pleasing, it's easy, it's a really nice
sweet bourbon, got a good flavor profile, really nice balance of oak, only a 90 proofer.
I think the problem with this one is the price point.
Being at about $45, I think you can get the Old Forrester Signature, which is 100 proof,
which will give you some more flavor for between $20 and $30, so I think the price on this
kind of hurts it, especially at the proof point, but like I said, I know that they had
to start off with this as kind of the story, and I can appreciate that, but I think Old
Forrester just kind of offers too many other great bourbons for an even cheaper price for
this one.
So the 1897 kind of falls into a weird category for me because it's really good and I really
enjoy it.
I do think it's a little bit older than the four-year bottle and bond limit would suggest,
but with that said, there are so many other good bottle and bonds, like I mentioned, that
you could get for cheaper.
If you're looking for a new bottle and bond bourbon, you don't mind the price point of
it, this, to me, would fall in the category of a try it before you buy it.
I do think it's really good, it's high quality, has such a really beautiful balance to it,
but at $50 when you compare it to some of the other ones on the market, this one can
be a little bit problematic.
So that brings us to the 1920.
Is this still my favorite of the four?
Absolutely.
For the price, for the proof point that you get, for the quality that's in this bottle,
the flavors that kind of come to the forefront as you keep sipping on it, you don't need
to pour a lot of this to enjoy it.
You can pour a little bit, sip on it, and just enjoy it throughout the night.
It's so good, it has so much flavor.
This is one of those bourbons that, no matter where I'm at, I will always, always replace
this bottle.
You can always find it in my whiskey room.
Lastly, the 1910, which, like I said, I admit it, wasn't that crazy about when it first
came out, but this bottle has really grown on me.
As you let this get a little bit of air, the flavors come out, that super oakiness that
you get in the first couple pours really kind of takes a back seat.
The sweet flavors come out, chocolate-covered raisins, cherry, that really beautiful sweet
oak flavor.
This is one of those bottles that I think you might not like at first, but with some
time, I would say that you would absolutely love it.
So if I had to rate them all, I would say first, 1920, second, 1910, third, the Bottle
& Bond, and lastly, the original batch.
All right, guys, so before I go, one last thing I want to mention, one of my favorite
things to do with the 1910 and the 1920 is actually blend them together.
You call it a 1915, it's kind of somewhere in between.
When you blend them together, you actually get a really beautiful balance of oak, cherry,
cinnamon, you get some of the spice characteristic.
It's almost like you're adding a longer finish on the 1910, which is something that the 1910
actually is missing to me a little bit.
So you blend a little bit of the 1920, I feel like you get kind of the best of both worlds.
So I'm going to take a sip of this.
Oh, yeah, see?
The cherry, the chocolate, the raisin, the vanilla, the deep, rich caramels, the brown
sugars, it's all there.
So if you do have these two whiskeys, I would highly recommend you blending a little bit
together to see what that turns into and see if you like it as much as I do.
All right, guys, well, I really hope you enjoyed this review of the Whiskey Rose Series from
Old Forrester.
Hope you enjoyed it.
If you haven't yet, hit the subscribe button below, please hit that like button.
If you haven't yet, find me on Instagram and find me on Twitter.
Let me know if you've had all four from the series, what your favorites are, and as I
always say, it is not about the whiskey, it is the people you share it with.
So cheers, and I'll see you next time.
Take care.