Emma Watson’s Surprising Words About J.K. Rowling and What It Signals About Our Culture Today
Jan 18, 2026
I wanted to roll this clip, came out today, of Emma Watson, obviously Hermione from Harry
Potter, talking a little bit about J.K. Rowling.
The two have had their disagreements, as has Daniel Radcliffe and other Harry Potter actors
with J.K. Rowling over the years, because J.K. Rowling has been adamantly and principally
opposed to the takeover of women's rights by transgender-identifying biological men.
And along very familiar lines at this point, this feud first cropped up in 2020, and I think Emma
Watson at the time put out a statement disagreeing. It was a pretty strong rebuke of what J.K. Rowling
was fairly bravely expressing about the problems raised when gender identity is conflated with
biological sex legally, socially, culturally. Let's go ahead and roll, though, this clip of
Emma Watson reflecting on it now in 2025 with, I have to say, a sense of maturity that you rarely
I can love her. I can know she loved me. I can be grateful to her. I can know the things that
she said are true. And that can be this whole other thing. And my job feels like to just hold,
just to hold all of it. But the bigger thing is just what she's done will never be taken away
from me. So obviously she's using very cringe, like therapeutic language in the clip about how
she just has to hold. Brings us back to Ariana Grande and the Wicked Press tour, of course,
and holding space. But apart from that, this is maybe indicative not just of Emma Watson's
maturity, but of a cultural maturity that we've, since all of the early social media upheaval,
and don't get me wrong, I'm not saying social media upheaval is going anywhere, but one of the
trends that we cover here is whether people in the public eye, whether news outlets, whether
media, Hollywood are able to adapt to some of these changes. And as cancel culture was snowballing,
really after algorithms started to dictate social media feeds, so from Twitter and Facebook at the
time, that was changing everything in ways we were not prepared for. We went from the literal
timelines, which still, of course, were intersecting with the far left progressivism
that had festered on the fringes of academia and Hollywood for a long time, but had never become
as powerful across cultural institutions as it did when algorithms first started dictating
social media feeds. And social media feeds took over the way that we communicated with each other
as human beings. So those two things were happening at the same time, and algorithms
were pushing these fake controversies that were, for whatever reason, I mean, there are many reasons,
but were transmitting to people in C-suites, public relations, human resources, the notion that these
controversies were representative of a wider swath of the public than they actually were.
Don't get me wrong, I still think, we've talked about this on the show many times,
people, particularly in my generation, Millennials, Emma Watson, are very far left on
social, cultural issues in a way that's going to cause strife for years to come. But Gen Z
really isn't in the exact same way. There are a lot more disagreements with Gen Z than there are.
There's a lot more space for argument in Gen Z, at least right now, than there was when Millennials
were the age that Gen Z is now. And as I'm watching this clip of Emma Watson on a podcast
that I saw on social media, by the way, it was an interesting glimmer of hope that maybe the
incentives which drove so much of the strife during peak cancel culture, where algorithms
would pump up these fake controversies, transmit them to center left, sympathetic people in
corporate boardrooms and newsrooms, and make them take these non-traverses much more seriously than
they should have, because it was just a organized group of people getting mad on social media that
wasn't reflective of their broader customer base in every single case. And it drove people to react
in ways that weren't entirely constructive. And what I just heard in Emma Watson's statement
was a reflection. It's so obvious. It was made by the right for years and the kind of heterodox
center, center left for years, that people are complicated. Our disagreements are complicated.
It is quaint. It is obvious. And again, some of us were making this point for a very long time.
But I wonder if for some people and not for everybody, but maybe for somebody like Emma
Watson, who's had an experience like she had with J.K. Rowling becoming such a lightning rod,
both on the left and the right, but such a bitter... What Harry Potter fans have done to
J.K. Rowling has been covered well elsewhere, but the hardcore Harry Potter fans who are still
clinging unhealthily to the Harry Potter world as adults and take so personally the words of
J.K. Rowling on a political disagreement, act as though she's fomenting violence.
What that did, the pressures that apply to people like Emma Watson, I don't want to
underestimate that because she was under a lot of pressure and she's a person of the left.
But this is such a healthier way to react, which is that you disagree with J.K. Rowling.
I'd love to see Emma Watson go even further, of course, and say, J.K. Rowling,
I know to be a good person. J.K. Rowling, by the way, has hit back at Emma Watson. So it's not as
though this isn't going in both directions, but hit back at her in the past, not after this. I
don't know if she said anything about this yet, but I'd love to see Emma Watson even more strongly
come out and say, I know J.K. Rowling to be a great human being who produced this wonderful
world. And we disagree on something I care about deeply, but it doesn't make her a bad person.
That brings us full circle to what we discussed with Michael when it comes to ICE immigration,
when it comes to the assassination of Charlie Kirk, which is fundamentally what powerful people
on the left have been signaling for a long time is that it is OK to classify people who disagree
with you as bigots, bad people, hate mongers, potentially in some cases violent via their words,
via their beliefs and ideas, not even via their actions. And I get people are going to hit back
and come up with all of the different insults that Donald Trump has called Democrats, that
talk radio people have called Democrats. I hear that. I think that's also a problem.
I think I talked to her the other night about overuse of the term groomer as just one example.
If you're not literally a groomer, maybe the right way to say it is that somebody is fueling groomers,
supporting groomers or on the side of the group, whatever. But what I'm saying is when we classify
individuals, literally specific individuals with this language, for example, an ICE agent being
compared to Gestapo, find a different comparison. Seriously, with Harry Potter, read another book,
as everyone says, but find a different comparison that doesn't signify unless you think,
and I actually believe some of them do, that ICE agents are literally on par with the Gestapo,
which is an argument you should flesh out in full and not just use the word as a throwaway pejorative.
Go ahead and make that argument if you really believe it. But if you believe they're engaging in
tactics that are dangerous, un-American, say that, say that. It's this impulse,
and again, I think social media has a lot to do with this, to classify people as hateful, bigoted
when they disagree with you on politics, when actually they're perfectly good substitutes.
If you disagree with someone, say that you think they are causing people to see each other
differently in ways that are unfortunate. You think that they're giving cover to people who
actually are racists, whatever. But when you label an individual human being, as Michael said
earlier, in ways that you wouldn't want to defend to their face if you're in a disagreement with
them and you're arguing and having a serious debate, and they tell you, look, no, I don't
see this person as any less than, I'm a Christian, all have sinned and fallen short of the glory of
God, there is no Jew or Greek, all of that, it falls apart when you're face-to-face with someone.
So unless you think that person literally believes people are lesser than because of
an immutable characteristic, use a different word, read another book, find another comparison.
Interesting, interesting stuff from Emma Watson. Are you looking to support more
made-in-the-USA manufacturing this year? Like I am, definitely. Whether it's home decor,
clothing, or furniture, it's become extremely difficult to find high-quality products that
aren't made overseas. A recent Forbes report revealed that annual earnings for small businesses
across the U.S. have dropped by over 75% just since 2023. Small businesses in this country
are struggling to stay afloat, and with the likes of Amazon and Target dominating the market,
it's no wonder. Basically, any small business owner here in the U.S. will tell you the same
thing. That's where a warehouse comes in, your one-stop shop for artisanal home goods made
exclusively by small businesses. With hundreds of products to choose from, they're deeply
committed to supporting American manufacturers. Their easy-to-navigate online marketplace lets
you browse a wide range of independent makers, and you can feel good knowing that your purchase
supports real people and small family-run businesses. A warehouse believes that true
luxury isn't about fancy labels or big brand names. It's about the dedication, creativity,
and care that goes into every product. Help a warehouse hit their goal of supporting over 100
small businesses this year. Head to awarehouseshop.com and use code PARTY for 15% off your
order. That's awarehouseshop.com, code PARTY.

