Why J.K. Rowling’s Response to Emma Watson Hits So Hard and What It Tells Us About the Culture War

J. K. Rowling - the writer
1 follower
Dec 23, 2025
Emma Watson was saying she was holding space for reckoning with J.K. Rowling's position
on transgenderism and the J.K. Rowling that she knew as a child who was supportive and
created this beautiful world. And I reacted to that last week by saying it seems like
a moment of cultural maturity, maybe personal maturity on behalf of Emma Watson just for being
able to say what should have always been able to be said, which is that you can disagree
bitterly with people, and this goes back to Ta-Nehisi Coates and Charlie Kirk, without
also saying that they're racist hate mongers who are putting trans people's lives in jeopardy when
that's not the case. That is not a fact. You may think it's a fact, but it's a tenuous fact at
best. It's not really a fact. But even if you think it, you should recognize it as an opinion
and an argument you have to make, not a fact that just exists in the world independent of
your ability to build it into some type of argument. So Rowling reacted on X by saying,
I'm seeing quite a bit of comment about this, so I want to make a couple of points. I'm not owed
eternal agreement from any actor who once played a character I created. Goes on to say Emma Watson
and her co-stars have every right to embrace gender identity ideologies. Such beliefs are
legally protected, and I wouldn't want to see any of them threatened with loss of work or violence
or death because of them. However, Emma and Dan in particular have both made it clear over the
last few years that they think our former professional association gives them a particular
right and the obligation to critique me and my views in the public. Years after they finished
acting in Potter, they continue to assume the role of de facto spokespeople for the world I created.
If you're JK Rowling, that must be infuriating. Point taken for sure. When you've known people
since they were 10 years old, it's hard to shake a certain protectiveness until quite recently I
haven't managed to throw off the memory of children who needed to be gently coaxed through
the dialogue in Big Scary Film Studio. For the last few years, I've repeatedly declined
invitations from journalists to comment on Emma, specifically, most notably, on the witch trials
of JK Rowling. Ironically, I told the producers that I didn't want her to be hounded as a result
of anything I said. That's new information and interesting information, and assuming that it's
true, I think very commendable. The television presenter in the attached clip highlights Emma's
all-witches speech, which, if you follow this stuff closely, you know. Rowling continued to
say, in truth, that was a turning point for me, but it had a postscript that hurt far more than
the speech itself. Emma asked someone to pass on a handwritten note from her to me, which contained
the single sentence, quote, I'm sorry for what you're going through. Rowling says she has my
phone number. This was back when the death, rape, and torture threats against me were at their peak,
at a time when my personal security measures had to be tightened considerably, and I was
constantly worried for my family's safety. Emma had just publicly poured more petrol on the flames,
yet thought a one-line expression of concern from her would reassure me of her fundamental
sympathy and kindness. She goes on to critique Emma Watson on a really interesting class basis.
She says she'll never need a homeless shelter. She's never going to be placed on a mixed-sex
public hospital ward. I'd be astounded if she's ever been in a high street charging room since
childhood. Her public bathroom is single occupancy and comes with a security man standing guard
outside the door. Has she ever had to strip off in a newly mixed sex-changing room at a council-run
swimming pool? She goes on to say I wasn't a multimillionaire at 14. I lived in poverty while
writing the book that made Emma famous. The greatest irony here is that, and I'm just reading
chunks of this because it's very long, had Emma not decided in her most recent interview to declare
that she loves and treasures me, a change of tack I suspect she's adopted because she's noticed,
this is the interesting part, full-throated condemnation of me is no longer quite as
fashionable as it was, I might never have been this honest. Emma is rightly free to disagree
with me and indeed to discuss her feelings about me in public, but I have the same right,
and I finally decided to exercise it. So you can see the frustration pouring out, you can sense
the frustration pouring out of J.K. Rowling here, and I do not blame her one bit for this reaction.
In fact, I think it is entirely fair because, and maybe it was a mistake that I made last week,
I actually try to celebrate these moments where we see that shift in culture that J.K. Rowling
herself just mentioned, where she says she suspects she's adopted this tack quote because
she's noticed full-throated condemnation of me is no longer quite as fashionable as it was.
That doesn't mean, I guess I don't think I did this last week, but that doesn't mean anybody has
to be lauded for their bravery and intellect when they failed to act courageously, boldly
for the last 10 plus years, and when they still appear to be on the wrong side of an issue.
And Rowling is right, that people like Emma Watson are on the wrong side of this issue,
in many cases for class reasons, because they don't understand that this is happening at
homeless shelters, at women's shelters, in the locker rooms of kids whose parents can't afford
fancy lawyers. This is real. It's hurting kids who need scholarships and track, for example,
and those scholarships are their ticket to success in higher education or debt-free higher education.
These class concerns are absolutely real and her frustration is so raw and I think well-placed
in this case. So Rowling's reaction to this is eloquent and entirely within the bounds of
reasonable, I would say like a reasonable rebuke of Emma Watson for years not wanting to say
exactly what she said in 2025 when it's easier to say it because especially in the UK, I mean
we talk about the quote vibe shift that's come here to the US and about Donald Trump's Kamala's
for they them ad being something that really changed the election, but if you followed the
Cass report story in the UK and how actually in some sense because they had a centralized place
in the Tavistock clinic to track the the treatment of transgender identifying individuals,
they were actually able to study much more closely and put the lie to a lot of claims
from dubious studies that have been pushed for the left by a really long time about self-harm
and what happens if people go without treatment and that was a sea change in the UK on this
particular issue. So it is opportunistic, it is not, it is not a, I mean it's still a slightly
brave act giving the the circles Emma Watson runs in personally, but professionally it will make her
more palatable. There is an opportunism to that, there's no question to be asked. I still, my
instinct is still to celebrate a moment when we see public pressures catching up with cynical
craven celebrities who are inching towards a better position because they've realized
maybe that they they made a mistake in the past. I wonder actually if Emma Watson like
many members of the public in the UK or the US actually will change their minds on the issue
entirely. I sort of doubt it partially because of those class reasons that Rowling herself
outlined. It's actually pretty hard to go to sleep after wrapping these shows at 11. You
could probably imagine that's the case because live broadcasting gets your adrenaline going like
basically nothing else, but I really mean this. Cozy Earth's bamboo sheets and bubble cuddle blanket
make it much, much easier. I actually get excited to jump into bed even after the high of partying
with our great guests like Mark Halperin who keep making news on the show. So these bamboo sheets
are next level, buttery soft, breathable and they keep you cool all night. You sleep a few degrees
cooler and wake up genuinely refreshed and the bubble cuddle blanket, it is like a warm luxurious
hug. Mid-weight, plush faux fur, equal parts nap worthy and stylish, there's a reason Cozy Earth
offers a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty. They know you'll fall in love and you
will. I'm telling you I get so excited to go to sleep even when I'm all amped up after the show.
Visit CozyEarth.com, use my code EMILY for 20% off. That's CozyEarth.com, code EMILY,
and if you get a post-purchase survey, please let them know you heard about Cozy Earth from
After Party with Emily Jaschinski because home isn't just where you live, it's how you feel.
Let's go home with Cozy Earth.
