Jimmy Carter rose from humble beginnings as a Georgia peanut farmer to become the 39th president of the United States. Though often criticized as an ineffective leader, Carter later proved himself one of the most active and respected former presidents in American history. From civil rights advocacy to founding Habitat for Humanity, his legacy was shaped more by compassion and conscience than political power. This episode explores Carter’s journey—from nuclear submarines to Nobel Peace Prize—and the values that defined his life.
Welcome to American Legends. My name is Tiffany Brannan.
Each culture has its legends, and that could be myths or different stories,
but here in America, our greatest legends are the wonderful heroes
who are right from our history pages.
Now, some of these heroes are very famous, and some are obscure.
But each person deserves to be discovered,
because each man or woman stands as a great example
of how we can be better Americans in our daily lives.
When we look at the history of all the U.S. presidents,
we're inclined to find some very unique and stubborn figures.
It's no wonder that it seems very strong and opinionated men
have gravitated toward the position that leads to the White House,
because it takes just such a man to weather the storms
which he'll face before and after he wins the presidency.
Today we're going to talk about a man who asked for peace
when perhaps he should have called for war,
and thus became a more important figure after his presidency than during it.
In the political scene, which anyone alive today can remember,
it's always been common practice to use name-calling and mudslinging
as a way to belittle one's opponent.
In the early days of American politics, this was not the case,
as it was considered very bad form to personally attack your opponent.
It was even considered bad form to campaign for yourself.
As we've journeyed out of the 19th century and into the mid and late 20th century,
it's been interesting to see how more and more presidents
have been very active in the campaigning themselves,
not only making public speeches on the radio and eventually on television,
but traveling around the country, using modern travel techniques
such as first trains and then planes, to reach more citizens right where they live.
President Jimmy Carter became the 39th president of the United States in the year 1977.
He was elected in the year of the bicentennial,
and he came to the forefront of the political scene very unexpectedly as a dark horse candidate,
and he would have to face a lot of great challenges during his presidency.
Jimmy Carter was born in Georgia in the year 1924.
He was the oldest of three children.
His father was originally a store owner, but he ended up starting a peanut farm later.
Jimmy Carter came from a very simple, even impoverished, background.
His full name, of course, was James Earl Carter Jr.,
but he liked the nickname Jimmy so much that that became his official name
even when being sworn in as president.
As a young man, even as a boy, he learned a lot about the family business of farming
when his father gave him a small plot of land on their property to farm himself,
and he used it to grow and sell peanuts very successfully.
Although his father was pro-segregationist, as was very common at the time in the South,
young Jimmy was allowed to play with the children of the black workers on their farm,
and this gave him the beginning of what would later become his civil rights views
and his belief that people should be given a fair deal regardless of their race.
After he graduated from high school, he enrolled in a college for a few years
before transferring to the Naval Academy.
It had long been his dream to go to the Naval Academy,
and he ended up graduating from it with a Bachelor of Science degree in 1946.
He then was commissioned as an ensign.
He spent a few years in the Navy working on submarines that were nuclear-powered,
and in fact he was training to have an important position as a junior lieutenant
on one of the first nuclear submarines.
But in the year 1953, everything changed when his father died.
He considered it his duty to return to Plains, Georgia to take care of the family business.
Although his wife, Rosalyn, was very reluctant for him to make this decision,
he eventually knew it was a thing he had to do,
so he asked to be relieved from his naval position, and he returned to Georgia.
The first few years were very tough for the Carter family back in Georgia
because his father had accumulated a lot of debt,
and so for the first year, he and his wife and children had to live in public housing,
and he had to take out many different loans.
Eventually, though, he paid off all the debts,
and he built the family peanut business into a successful business, which served them well.
In the 1960s, Carter became involved in state politics.
He had already become involved in his community, socially as well as politically,
in his first few years back in Georgia,
as he was very active in his Baptist church community
and in the community leaders in a more non-political form,
but he eventually decided to run for the state legislature.
He served in that capacity in the Georgia State Senate for a few years
before eventually running to become the state governor.
He successfully won in the year 1971.
Now, by this point, Carter already held desegregationist views,
and he believed in civil rights.
This was not a popular opinion in the South at that time, though,
so first when he ran for the state Senate in 1966,
and then when he ran for governor a few years later,
he downplayed his civil rights views.
He didn't exactly make pro-segregationist speeches,
but he basically appeared neutral on the point, enabling him to be elected,
especially since he was a Democrat.
But as soon as he was elected governor,
he made a bold speech saying that he would oppose
any kind of prejudicial ruling or bigotry
and essentially establishing himself as a civil rights advocate.
Many pro-segregationists who had supported him felt utterly betrayed at this point,
but that was the beginning of Carter's establishing himself
as one of the first Southern governors to be a civil rights advocate.
Carter proved a fairly successful governor in his few terms there,
and in the year 1975, he returned to his hometown of Plains,
having ended his time as governor.
But he had already announced his inclination to run for president.
Now, this was a shock to most people,
and he certainly didn't seem to stand a very good chance of winning.
He was one of 16 Democratic hopefuls,
all of whom wanted to gain the candidacy to go against
President Incumbent Gerald Ford.
It seemed that Jimmy Carter didn't have much of a chance,
and the more politically entrenched Democrats
even mocked his attempts to run by saying,
This was highlighting the fact that he really had no image in the Washington scene.
He hadn't served in any national position at all.
He'd only been in Georgia state politics.
He hadn't been in the U.S. House of Representatives or Senate.
When Jimmy realized that people's biggest criticism against him
was that they didn't know who he was,
he decided to make it his goal to answer that question,
Jimmy who?
And he famously would begin his speeches and his appearances by saying,
My name is Jimmy Carter, and I'm running for U.S. president.
He traveled thousands of miles across the country
to gain a public reputation.
He made speaking tours. He appeared on television.
He even published a book in the year 1976, his first memoirs.
And this helped introduce the public to who he was,
both as a candidate and as a man.
He beat out many of his more popular and more influential Democratic competitors
by making these tours and getting directly to speak to the people,
visiting 39 states as he was preparing for the Democratic primaries.
He ended up winning the nomination as a dark horse candidate,
coming out of nowhere.
But it's not too surprising when you really think about this time.
This was right in the wake of the Watergate scandals,
which had led Richard Nixon to leave in disgrace.
And then Gerald Ford had taken over for him,
but people weren't too sure about him after he pardoned his predecessor, Nixon.
So it seemed that maybe the country was ready,
not only for a change in party, going back to the Democrats,
but to elect someone who wasn't a Washington person,
someone who wasn't engulfed in that mess.
He seemed like a very honest, simple person in comparison to Tricky Dick.
And thus, people seemed to like him.
Now, of course, his competitors and his critics at the time of the election
and after he won, loved to bring up the fact that he was a peanut farmer.
And they called him that, oh, that peanut farmer.
But I think it's an example of rather poor debating form.
If we have something to say against someone, let's talk about his policies.
Maybe he's not good fiscally or he doesn't have good foreign policy,
but let's not criticize him for being a common man of the people.
And although this was really the most commonly said thing against him,
I think his background as an agriculturalist, a farmer,
may have been what really endeared him to the public, to the common people.
They saw him as one of them, as opposed to the more elite Washington politicians.
Upon winning the Democratic nomination,
he was surprisingly several points ahead of Gerald Ford right away.
Now, Ford was already becoming very unpopular,
so he didn't stand a very great chance to win his re-election.
They participated in three televised presidential debates.
This was only the second time in history that there had been such presidential debates,
the only previous time having been in the 1960 election.
The first debate was said to have been won by Ford,
but in the second debate, Carter was definitely seen as the winner,
and he began to pull ahead in terms of public approval rating at that point.
Just a few weeks before the election,
Carter participated in an interview with Playboy magazine.
This didn't serve him too well,
and it actually made him drop in popularity among some people
because he was maybe a little too candid,
and it made some critics say that presidents or presidential candidates
should maybe keep their personal life and their political life a little more separate.
And of course, because during this interview,
he made the comment that he had looked with lust on other women besides his wife
and committed adultery in his heart.
The number one question his wife got after that was,
do you think your husband's been unfaithful to you?
Of course, she always said that she was very confident of his fidelity to her.
And this was in response to a question about the pride,
which many people assume goes along with his strong Christian faith,
and the assumed hypocrisy.
So he was saying, many times, I have had lustful thoughts,
and so I've committed adultery in my heart,
so I'm not saying that I'm perfect, but I didn't act on it.
So I think that was often taken out of context.
The election was close, but he ended up winning,
and he confidently took office with a lot of bold claims
to really establish the democratic agenda,
and despite that, he saw himself as a moderate.
When he was first running for public office,
he said, conservative, liberal, moderate, progressive.
I don't think I'm that single-faceted.
I'm more complex than just a label like that.
And he definitely was on the more moderate side,
largely, I'd say, just because of his rather mild nature.
He was very much against war.
He didn't believe in too much nuclear warfare,
largely because of an experience he had when he was in the Navy.
When he and several other young enlisted men
had to try to deactivate this nuclear reactor,
and it was very dangerous.
So I think that made him realize
just how dangerous nuclear energy could be.
One of his first actions was to pardon all Vietnam War evaders,
and he was the first Democrat to be elected from the South
since Zachary Taylor back in 1848.
Now, before Zachary Taylor, most of the presidents
had been from the South,
with many of the early greats being from Virginia.
But because of the Civil War,
many Americans from all sides of the country
were very suspicious of the Democrats,
and then all Southerners in general,
as they were viewed as responsible for that deadly conflict.
It was largely his background as a Southerner
which made Jimmy Carter very anti-war,
because he had grown up in a region
that was still suffering the effects
of that terrible military conflict.
So he saw that the United States must do anything possible
to keep a war from coming to our shores.
Part of his campaign platform
was that he was going to increase taxes among the rich.
As part of his attempts to equalize the nation,
a common Democratic platform that continues to this day,
I would say,
he also was a strong proponent of the Civil Rights Movement.
Now during this time,
the Equal Rights Amendment was a hot topic.
This proposed legislature was intended to give women
fuller equal rights under the law.
And of course, his wife as well as many other women
and men of both sides were very eager
to see this piece of legislature passed.
It was more complex than that though,
and although Carter was publicly in support of it,
it was difficult to get it ratified,
and it ended up not actually passing during his presidency,
and that was one of the things which led to his not being re-elected.
There were so many issues which Carter faced during his presidency,
both at home and abroad.
At home, he faced issues like the energy crisis,
which was largely caused by foreign affairs as well,
such as hostile relations developing with the Middle East.
He also had to deal with issues like the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan.
His response was to boycott the 1980 Olympics in Moscow.
This was not a particularly popular decision,
and he began gaining enemies on both sides.
Naturally, conservatives were very critical of some of his tax incentives
and his more liberal civil rights movements,
whereas Democrats were very critical of the pass
which he gave to certain monopolies in the United States.
Perhaps the most detrimental blow to his legacy was the hostage crisis.
This conflict with Iran began in 1979
when Carter invited the deposed Shah of Iran
to the United States for medical treatment.
This caused one of the worst oil embargoes from the Islamists
who had seized the Iranian government,
and that was one of the things which further heightened the energy crisis.
In response, Iranian militants invaded the U.S. Embassy in Iran
and captured 52 U.S. diplomats and citizens
and held them hostage for 444 days
until after Carter's presidency had ended.
Despite several different attempts,
he was unable to get these hostages released,
and that really lost him a lot of public opinion here in the United States.
People were very upset and disturbed by his perceived weak leadership,
especially abroad.
His very peace-loving attitude just made him seem like a weak character
in view of the hostilities which were rising around the world.
Now, his peace-loving attitude did help him
win some positive peaceful developments internationally.
He was very instrumental in the passage of the Camp David Treaty,
and he helped promote several different meetings and conferences
which led to the reduction of very deadly arms.
A lot of his greatest attempts at achieving things here in the United States
were seen as a lot of talk without a lot of real action to back them up,
such as the energy crisis.
In 1977, he urged the American people to view the energy crisis as a moral war,
that we had to really fight this crisis,
but he never really had any solution for what we needed to do to fight the crisis.
So people weren't too sure how they were supposed to fight it
or whether he really had any clear plan.
In 1980, he went up against Republican Ronald Reagan
as he was bidding for re-election.
He was defeated in a landslide, and that was the end of his presidential tenure.
But because he was relatively young, only 56, when he left the White House,
he would have the longest retirement of any president thus far,
since he would live for another 44 years.
During that time, he wrote 30 books and was very active politically
and, more importantly, as a diplomat.
He and his wife established the Carter Center
as a headquarters for peaceful communications and open conversations.
He also was very instrumental in founding Habitats for Humanity,
a non-profit organization which would help provide safe housing
for underprivileged people.
Alongside his wife, he continued advocating for those who were less fortunate,
such as people struggling with mental illness.
This was also something that he had tried to do during his presidency
because it was the most important project to his wife.
Because of his noble and very successful efforts after leaving the White House,
he won the Nobel Peace Prize in the year 2002,
making him the third out of four presidents to win the Nobel Peace Prize
and the only one to win it after his presidency.
He also was awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom in 1999.
During his long retirement, Carter further established himself
as an elder statesman and a true humanitarian,
showing that he did have a lot to give to the nation,
but perhaps president wasn't the best role for him
since he was a very warm-hearted, open, and generous person
who was perhaps just too warm-hearted, open, and generous to be the president,
especially during such difficult, angry times.
At the end of one war with so many other international conflicts brewing,
Carter made many interesting quotes on the strength of a nation
and what it means, really, to be strong.
He said,
A strong nation, like a strong person, can afford to be gentle, firm, thoughtful, and restrained.
It can afford to extend a helping hand to others.
It's a weak nation, like a weak person,
that must behave with bluster and boasting and rashness and other signs of insecurity.
Speaking to his public spiritedness, he said,
We can choose to alleviate suffering.
We can choose to work together for peace.
We can make these changes, and we must.
He also said,
I have one life and one chance to make it count for something.
My faith demands that I do whatever I can, wherever I am, whenever I can,
for as long as I can, with whatever I have, to try to make a difference.
One of his more humorous anecdotes is,
Go out on a limb. That's where the fruit is.
And he humbly admitted in later days,
I can't deny I'm a better ex-president than I was a president.
Jimmy Carter would be the oldest living president,
as he died very recently, on December 29th, 2024, at the age of 100,
making him the only president so far to live to the age of 100.
It's amazing how much change he saw during his lifetime.
Being born in 1924, he was the first president born in a hospital.
And then, when he died in 2024,
he had enjoyed remarkably good health for a number of years,
having defeated cancer years earlier,
and he also enjoyed the longest presidential marriage,
as he and Rosalind were very happily married from the year 1946 onward,
having four children.
He is consistently ranked as a below-average president,
a reputation which I think he would have happily acknowledged
because he did admit he was a better ex-president.
But I think, although he was perhaps rather weak and not the best president,
I can't help but feel that he was a good man
and that, maybe not a great president, he was a kind president
and, inherently, a rather good person who really tried to do the right thing.
I think, all too often, maybe he was a little too soft-hearted
and he strayed away, perhaps, from some of the Founding Fathers' core ideas
because, all too often, if we're too soft-hearted,
it can make us almost care so much about other countries
that we don't put our own people first.
But, ultimately, I think that we should perhaps give Jimmy Carter
a little bit of grace as someone who tried very hard to do the right thing
and we should remember him as a very public-spirited humanitarian
and that he was much more than just a peanut farmer.
Thank you for watching and I hope you'll join me next time
for more American Legends.