69% of China’s top PLA generals are gone—and this time, it’s not rumor. In this deep-dive, we trace how accurate military rumors repeatedly predicted real purges, why the sudden disappearance of key generals signals something far more serious, and what Xi Jinping’s latest promotion ceremony quietly revealed about power inside the PLA. From missing commanders to empty chairs at the top, the evidence points to a military purge that has crossed the point of no return—and a command system under unprecedented strain.
Hi everyone. Hi. Welcome to Lace Real
Talk. Sorry for the delayed start. I had
internet issues.
All right. Well, I'm glad that we're
live. Uh you guys can hear me. Okay.
Yes.
All right. Good.
All right. Um well, let's get started.
Let's hope the internet hold together.
All right, we're going to talk about the
Chinese PLA. Um,
CCP politics are notorious for rumor
mills. We know not all rumors are true,
but have you noticed a pattern? Among
all whispers coming out of Beijing, the
most accurate and consistently prophetic
rumors are those tied to PLA purges.
Again and again, political rumors
surrounding military figures have proven
uncanny precise. If you look back from
the downfall of former defense minister
Lee Shan Fu to CMC Vice Chairman Hi Dong
to political work department chief uh
Meia and even his
supposed supposed successor Hong Jing.
Their political fates were all signaled
in advance by rumors. The accuracy rate,
in my estimate, well over 85%.
And now those rumors are back, not as
scattered whispers, but as a title wave.
So when I heard that, I I asked myself,
hasn't the PLA already being purged dry?
And are there even any generals left to
take down? And this time the spotlight
falls on two key figures. I'll tell you
who they are shortly. And at the same
time, after a full year of inaction,
Giinping finally promoted two generals
to fill two key positions. Who are they
and what roles are they going to assume?
And more importantly, the promotion
ceremony itself revealed some shocking
truth about she's relations with his
rival vice chairman John as well as the
fact that the active duty PLA full
generals may be in single digit and at
least two in three top generals are
gone. And that's what we're going to
unpack today. So, first things first,
the rumors of two more generals
downfalls. The first is China's current
defense minister, Dong Jing.
Uh, there we go.
And, uh,
his actually
well, this this was uh it it came out a
few days ago, but it it was corroborated
by a few other sources.
So it's more than likely true. So he his
um as defense minister his job is to
interface with uh his foreign
counterparts. So his position is our
facing
uh but his his potential downfall would
send shock waves around the world. Now
he was last seen five days ago at a
promotion ceremony which I will mention
later. So if he is removed it must have
happened in the past three to four days.
Now previously rumors about him being
investigated have been circulating
couple of times even though the fin the
financial times reported them and China
watchers have anticipated his downfall
simply because he is closely linked to
the PLA's now disgraced political chief
Mia. both came from the Navy.
Um, now the second figure is far more
sensitive and this is
this guy uh this guy's downfall actually
has started uh almost two years ago.
Uh
what's significant about him is that he
has served for almost 22 years. He's
widely regarded as one of she's most
trusted aids. Often described as the
weather vein of she's influence within
the military. If Joan is taken down, it
means she has completely lost control of
the PLA. So for years, Joan functioned
as the PLA's chief housekeeper, as
director of the general office of the
CMC, controlling access, paperwork,
scheduling, and internal coordination at
the very heart of military power. So
Jung's political decline actually
started last April when he was quietly
transferred to become the political
commasar of the National Defense
University. No announcement, no fanfare,
no explanation.
his transfer
um was
not officially
uh I was it was indirectly announced by
rumor by the rumor mills and then this
August when Singapore's uh ministry of
defense posted on Facebook that
uh its leader had met with Jung
as the political commissar during um the
Singaporean
officials visit to China.
The the outside world then confirmed
through a foreign government that drone
had taken up that that post at the
defense university.
Uh but just 10 days later, the same
person who
uh released the information about his
job change
issued in another leak saying that Jun
Xiaoin had already been removed as the
political commasar of the university of
of defense a national defense
university. It was 10 days after the
Singaporean official posted the picture
on their website uh I mean on Facebook.
Um and it was said that Jo
even was stripped of his military status
entirely.
So at the time that sounded extreme. A
lot of people didn't believe that
including myself.
No one confirmed it. No, no one was able
to confirm it until two months later. In
late October this year, the Chinese
embassy in North Korea announced that
the political commissur of the National
Defense University now
had led a delegation. I have a picture
of Shia
had left uh a letter de delegation to um
to North Korea for a diplomatic
reception.
So that told us that Jang Xiao Jing was
indeed gone because somebody else in
that role now. So replaced quietly
erased.
Um that was in October. Now comes the
most important detail of all. So
according to the latest leak from the
same source, the same person has been
consistently
leaking information about this guy and
then the previous two were all true. So
this time he's saying that Jun Xiao Jun
was taken away by the military
discipline commission.
Now once that happens, it doesn't matter
whether he had officially retired or
whether his uniform had already been
stripped.
That's significant
because if this allegation is true, it
creates an enormous problem for Xiinping
because he has been she's most loyal aid
in the military. He is the equivalent of
Taii in the military playing the role of
the chief of staff. He's called the
weather vein of she's power in the
military. So if he's taken away by the
military uh discipline inspection
that means Xiinping's authority is
completely out.
Um
now if the latest information coming out
of Beijing is prophetically true again
that bring us back to the unavoidable
and increasingly uncomfortable question.
So just how many generals have fallen
since Xiinping began his third term? And
according to Taiwan's Institute of
Chinese Communist Studies reporting
and um I asked Nicole to copy the link
of that report because they did a
thorough report and I believe that's
that's the report that's also the source
uh for a parliamentary
uh update. I I think it was a
parliamentary briefing by the executive
branch in October. So it was well
documented. It was very thorough. Um
that link is is should be in the
description. Anyways, so according to
this Taiwanese Institute and they
reported as of October 21st and it says
the Chinese Communist Party currently
has 35 full generals including 32 active
duty full generals or actually they
meant 35 active duty full generals.
um including 32 active duty full
generals and three lieutenant generals
acting in full general capacity or
positions
and altogether 22 full generals had
encountered serious problem as of
October 21st. So that's according to
this Taiwanese report then since then
since October 21st more heads have
rolled. We now know air force commander
Ching Chu
um
and his political commasar
in the air force that's uh
had fallen
um
even though there have has not been any
official announcement
u but again several sources have
corroborated the same whisper and most
importantly their B
it's almost like the the B's version of
Wikipedia the Chinese Wikipedia
their Wikipedia page in China have been
have disappeared
um returning to the message the page you
are trying to access does not exist
that's a big sign that they are gone uh
there was even rumor
um about Ching Cho had died and there's
no official denial has been
no official. So this this guy the
commander he died while being in
interrogated and there's no official
denial of this claim.
So on top of that we have Dong Jun being
rumored to be taken down. So that brings
total active duty full generals with
serious problems to 24 if Dongjing is
not included and 25 if he is. And the
percentage is 69% without Dong Jing and
71% with Dongjun.
So here's a recent status of active duty
PLA full generals. I'm going to show you
their names in both English and Chinese.
The ones highlighted in yellow or blue
indicate they are still active duty
without rumors to be taken down.
Everyone else who's not highlighted are
either purged, removed, or under
investigation. So, here we go. All
right. Um,
okay. My image got stuck again due to
the internet issue. I have no idea what,
but you can hear me. Okay. Okay. So,
here's the image.
Um,
let me make this bigger.
All right. So, here here here is
here is the central military commission
and then the joint operation command
center and the ministry of national
defense. So, only three people are still
active duty. three full generals. The
ones not highlighted are either expelled
um or rumored to be removed. Okay, so
that's um that's this. And then the next
slide, this is interesting.
This is the service branches. Only one
name is highlighted.
um only the political commasar of the
army is still supposedly active and if
you look at the army commander
um everyone else there were supposedly
10 of them but nine of them are gone
under investigation removed expelled
yeah
all right so of the 10 full generals
actually three removed from the post
three under invest investigation and
three expelled from the military and the
party. And now let's take a look at the
theater commands.
All right. So of the 10 generals,
as you can see, one, two, three, four,
four are still active, five are under in
under investigation,
and one is expelled from the military
and the party.
Okay. And then there are other posts.
So here
so these are uh heads of the equipment
department, the academy of military
sciences, academy of
um the national defense university,
uh the deputy chief of joint staff
and um yeah and then the secretary of
CMC's
political
legal commission.
and the executive director. I mean,
they're just people playing other roles
who are full generals. So, of the eight
people here,
uh, two are still active duty. Two are
normal, uh, removed from the four are
removed from the post, one is under
investigation, and one is expelled.
And then there's another page. Um, so if
you add up everyone I have shown you,
that's 35 people. 35.
Um,
oh, and there's one more page. I don't
have that. What happened to that page?
Um maybe there's one more page that
shows
um there are five
full generals who are being investigated
or removed after leaving uh leaving
office or expelled and but those are
after they've already left office and
there were five of them. So
in total, so the PLE has 35 active duty
full generals.
Um at least 24
have encountered serious problems.
So that that's the current status and
that's 69%.
And if you include Jin, that's 71.
Um and so that's about two in three
generals have been sacked.
Um, I don't know what happened to the
internet. My It's I'm completely froze.
Let me Let me hit enter. Let me see what
happens. This should be
stay on page.
Okay, I'm Can you guys hear me?
Yes. Can you hear me? I have no idea why
this is happening. Am I being attacked?
Am I being attacked? This is completely
frozen, but you can hear me. Okay. Well,
let me keep talking because the
information I have is is is important.
So, um
that's yeah, that's two in three. So,
now let me talk about the two
let me talk about the two generals that
are being promoted on December 22nd.
Uh
let me let me bring this.
Okay, let me show the fold.
Okay, so despite the massive
job vacancy, Xiinping didn't promote
anyone in the first 11 months of 2025.
By contrast, in 2023, he held four
promotion ceremonies and in 2024 he held
three. So finally on December 22nd
Xiinping promoted two generals to fill
two critical PLA positions and let's
talk about who they are. On December
22nd that is Shi CCP held a ceremony to
promote Eastern Theater Command acting
commander Yanging
um and the Central Theater Command Air
Force Commander Hansen Yen to four
generals. So, here's Yang
and here's
um well, let's talk about Yang first.
Now,
both generals came from the Air Force.
Yang became the acting commander of the
Eastern Theater Command in September
after its former commander, one of
Xiinping's favorite generals, Ling
Xangyang, was sacked.
General Young now is now promoted to a
full general and made the commander.
Uh now prior to moving to eastern
theater command, he had been deputy
commander of the western and southern
theaters.
Okay. And and then the second promotion
is someone you're familiar. You could
tell by this picture.
I have mentioned him before. He was the
parade marshal at the September 3rd
military parade.
Um he was at the time a lieutenant
general and the parade marshall was
typically
um played by the commander of the
central theater command who was Wong
Chang at the time and General Wong is
widely rumored to be under
investigation.
So when the when the center um when
General Han was filling in for General
Wong, people were uh suspecting that
General Han may be promoted to uh to the
commander and that is what's happening
here.
Um now the ceremony was presided over by
CMC vice chairman Jang Jang Shiming.
Um
and the uh promotion orders was read
aloud by Jang Yoa.
Now Xiinping personally presented the
certificates.
Um but he looked very tense and and down
throughout the ceremony. He did not say
a word.
Um and the last time he promoted a
general was in December 2024. So, it's
been exactly a year. So, someone
compared this year's ceremony to the one
held a year ago.
See the difference? Last year, when
Xiinping was conferring title, Jang Yua
and other members of C CMC were all
standing. This year, they were all
seated. The that difference shows the
subtle change in Xiinping's relations
with Jang Yosha. And that reminds me of
the picture taken at the two sessions in
the spring this year. Uh remember this
picture when Jang Yua didn't bother uh
to return or to yeah to to to turn
around to watch Xiinping walk off the
stage.
Um, now the promotion of General Yan and
General Han underscores the strategic
importance of Eastern and Central
Theater Commands.
Sorry, I'm just frozen on the screen.
So, instead of showing me, I'm just
going to show you the slides. Um, I'm
complet completely frozen on the screen,
but it's okay. I can talk. So the the
the promotion um just shows you the the
how important the eastern and the
central theater commands are.
Uh well the eastern theater command is
responsible for Taiwan operation and the
central is tasked with the
responsibility of protecting Beijing. So
they're both very important. Now the
promotion also highlight continuing
turmoil in the PLA. The most striking
truth reviewed by the ceremony is the
number of four generals in attendance.
Last time when the PLA held a promotion
ceremony right in December 2024,
a total of 21 full generals attended the
ceremony including the newly promoted
army political sum commasar Chuni. He
was the one uh that the whole ceremony
was set up for. Um so December last year
21 full generals attended.
Among them only 10 later appeared at the
fourth plenum in October.
Now less than two months later only four
of those 10 attended
uh
the fourth plenum made it at this week's
promotion ceremony.
Um, who they are? Who are the four? They
are the three remaining CMC members.
Where are they?
So, the four four generals, the only
four generals who attended this um the
this promotion ceremony on the 22nd of
December this year were these three
guys, the three remaining members of the
CMC plus Dong Jing. And immediately
after that, Dongjun's removal, the rumor
of Dong Jun's removal uh began.
So now think about it. Under normal
circumstances, these four generals would
be required to attend such a ceremony
unless they are sick or on a mission. So
their collective absence indicates that
they're already in an abnormal polit
political or organizational state.
So people say that within the span of
just one year 164 generals about 80% of
the entire uh
yeah 80% have become unable to attend a
promot a promotional ceremony. Hong
Kong's newspaper Shinta Daily said it
says with a total um
with a total force of about 2 million
personnel the Chinese military should
normally have around 40 active duty four
generals. Now there are only six left.
Uh the six include the four existing the
four attending this ceremony uh plus the
two newly promoted ones. That's how they
came up with the six. They say they
usually should have 40 active duty full
generals, but now they only have six.
Uh, which the article continued to say,
which can only be described as a
spectacle.
Now, I have another visuals to show you.
Um,
okay, here's a visual I did.
It's if you're color blind, you can't
really enjoy this picture. So here's
here is a list of 41 full generals who
were
uh
at the well I shouldn't say active
because these are the four 41 full
generals at the time of the 20th party
congress in 2022
um the number
still standing today has dropped to
single digits see the green the pink and
the yellow are purged or removed or or
uh or under investigation.
U or the gray the gray is missing or
rumored to be under investigation.
The green ones are the ones that are
still standing and if you count the
number of names in green there are nine
single digits. So the reality has
reignited a fierce debate over
Xiinping's true grip on power.
and over who's really driving this
unprecedented purge. Um
right so the debate has been over well
so who which one is fully in control.
One school of thought insists that after
13 years at top Xiinping remains
absolutely in control and according to
this view one there's no force within
the CCP that's capable of challenging
him. The brutal purges, they argue, are
the product of his growing paranoia, his
deepening distrust of the very generals
he once promoted. Their very
uh their most important evidence is
straightforward
which is that Xiinping continues to
chair meetings remains the retains the
title of uh chairman of the central
military commission and no one appears
at least publicly to overstep his
authority.
But there is another school of thought
and it tells a very different story.
This camp believes that Xiinping has
lost effective control of the military
to his rival vice chairman Jang Yosia.
Their reasoning rests on several points.
First, you cannot analyze CCP politics
through official statements alone. You
must follow actions, not narratives. And
the pattern is unmistakable. The purge
overwhelmingly targets she's most loyal
handpicked allies. Unless Xiinping has
completely lost his sense of judgment,
it makes little sense for him to
systematically
um
to to systematically
destroy his own base, right? His own
support base. And that just make
absolutely makes no sense at all. Um the
second reason they argue or their second
argument is that
um
Xiinping
um well no it's actually Jaya's behavior
has shifted dramatically.
Uh his sudden newfound confidence and at
times it's visible disregard for
Xiinping in public settings.
um makes
a a a striking and abnormal change,
right? Like the the pictures that that
I've shown you um that's visible and
this should not have existed if Xiinping
is in full control. And the third
argument is CCP politics is a blackbox
system. What is presented to the public
is often the inverse of reality. If we
take Beijing's official storyline at
face value, we're almost guaranteed to
be misled.
So, tell me what you think. Uh, type
one, if you think Xiinping still
controls the PLA. Type two, if you think
uh he has lost power in military
affairs. Type three if you're not sure.
So, while you do that, I will um mention
that this week I released a video about
longevity in my other channel, Lace
Looking Glass. Nicole, if you can copy
the link here to help people see it, I'd
appreciate it. I forgot to mention it in
my live stream on on Thursday, so I want
to mention it here. And so, it's awful.
If I come back, I'm still
I still have this
I still look stuck.
Wow.
Two and threes. So, a lot of twos. A lot
of threes. Some ones.
All right. So, twos and threes are the
most uh late gets younger. All right. I
I just I don't know how what happened to
my internet. This is very awful. Um, I
just I I should have fiber optics and
should be really fast. Um,
all right. So, that's that's um what I
have for you. Let me play the music
while I figure out what what's happening
with my internet. Okay. Is that a fair a
fair plan, a fair decision? Let me do
this.
Heat. Heat.
Heat. Heat.
Heat.
Hey, heat. Hey, heat.
Heat. Heat.
Heat.
Heat.
Heat. Heat.
Heat. Heat.
Heat. Heat.
Heat. Heat.
All right. I'm still stuck.
Someone um someone said, "You look
beautiful tonight, but I look very
stuck."
That's how I feel. I feel stuck
somewhere. All right. Um, well,
someone's gave me a super sticker for
thanking me for the program I did on
Christmas Day about the persecution of
Christians in China. Well, thank you.
Um,
someone say, "You are you're lucky
you're stuck with your eyes looking okay
because you could be stuck with your
face all contorted."
Okay. All right. Yeah, I actually I feel
lucky. It could it could be worse. I
could be making faces and then got
stuck. All right. Um
All right. Um what do I do now?
Oh. Uh yeah,
Daniel McGinness, thank you. You're
awesome. Well, thank you. Thank you very
much. I just feel very awkward because
this is not a live without Lelay moving.
Um, how about we end it sooner here. Uh,
all right. I need to figure out what's
what's going on. And um all right. I'll
be back next week. Let's make it short.
All right. Well, thank you very much and
I'll see you next week.
Bye.