Frances Lennard, Deputy Head, The Textile Conservation Centre, University of Southampton, United Kingdom
This two-day symposium gathers leading international scholars to discuss a variety of topics related to the conservation of the tapestry Christ Is Born as Man's Redeemer in the collection of The Cloisters.
On the first day of this two-day symposium conservators and curators discuss the history of tapestry conservation at the Museum. The afternoon sessions feature scholars and specialist technicians who address the preservation of major historic tapestry collections in Europe. Topics for discussion include the restoration, conservation, and preparation of tapestries for exhibition. Museum Director Thomas P. Campbell introduces the event.
The second day of this two-day symposium includes panel discussions on the techniques used to clean, support, display, and handle historic tapestries. The impact of science and technology on conservation treatments is also considered.
This symposium is made possible by the Quinque Foundation.
Additional support has been provided by the Kawasaki Good Times Foundation.
Thank you very much for inviting me to come here to the Symposium. I'm absolutely delighted and
honoured to be here and I'm very much looking forward to seeing the tapestry at the Cloisters.
So I've put up a slide of the tapestry, Christ is Born as Man's Redeemer, just to remind
ourselves really that this is the reason why they're all here. This is to celebrate the
completion of the conservation of this absolutely magnificent tapestry and the conservation that
has been carried out on it looks absolutely stunning. And we're here to explore a bit more
broadly the subject of the conservation of woven tapestry and I think everybody here will agree
that it's one of the most amazing art forms. So I'm going to talk today about conservation
of tapestries in a broad sense. So I'm going to start by looking at what we mean by a tapestry
and then I'm going to look at the range of techniques that are used to conserve tapestries
and I'm not really going to look at the whole range of techniques that are used. I'm only
going to touch briefly on cleaning for example but I'm really going to be talking about those
techniques that are used both to stabilise the structure of tapestries and also to help
redefine the image of tapestry. And then I'm going to finish by looking at some more recent development
and some recent research which has already begun to have an effect on tapestry conservation
and which I'm sure will continue to do so in the future. I should explain a little bit about the
Textile Conservation Centre just so that you know where I'm coming from. As Tina mentioned I've been
working there for the last eight years and the Textile Conservation Centre in the UK was a centre
with three main activities and that was the teaching of textile conservation and also
latterly museum studies and research into textile conservation and also conservation practice.
And as Tina also mentioned the Textile Conservation Centre was closed by the University of Southampton
at the end of October and if anybody's interested I just have brought some cards which give details
of the TCC's website and this is really intended partly as a way of contacting people partly as a
legacy of the TCC's activities and there are some of these cards that you can pick up I think at
the back of the auditorium. I also just wanted to explain that the images that I'm using this
afternoon are from a variety of sources. I'm very grateful to some of my colleagues for giving
me some images to use in my presentation this afternoon and it may be obvious which ones those
are and the remainder are either of tapestries that were treated and conserved at the Textile
Conservation Centre or elsewhere images from the book Tapestry Conservation Principles and Practice.
So just a little bit of broad introduction really. The symposium is primarily about the conservation
of woven tapestry hangings and that's what I'm going to be talking about today.
And tapestries like this one fall into the category of decorative arts. They were originally
intended to provide decoration and warmth in drafty castles in the medieval period
but I would say that the finest examples of tapestry weaving are indisputably in the realm
of fine art and I think that the absolutely magnificent collection of tapestries here at the
Metropolitan Museum of Art demonstrates that very well. This is a 16th century example. It dates from
around 1525. It was made in Brussels and the Low Countries, Flanders, were very much the home of
tapestry weaving, a Western European art form.
And this tapestry is like the one in the pictures that Tina was showing us this morning
and that Lizzie was showing us this morning. It's very typical of 16th century tapestries.
A lot of action, very dense details of figures and story going on across the whole field of the
tapestry and a really important feature of these early tapestries are the dark brown outlines that
are used to delineate the different areas of the design and those often are damaged when
the dark brown wool that is usually used in the West has a tendency to deteriorate and to drop out
as a result either when they have to dig down and iron wool needs to be used.
And that can have a really detrimental effect on the overall image.
And I just put up this one really quickly. I really like this tapestry.
But I think again, as people say this morning, when you look at the faces of these tapestries,
these are human people. The skills of the weavers are very evident.
This is a later tapestry, an 18th century French tapestry from Beauvais
and this comes from a series, the Booking of China series.
A later tapestry, more like a picture really in style and a lot of silk being used
up in the sky and providing the highlights of the design.
And this technique is still being used today to make large-scale tapestry hangings.
And this is an example that was commissioned for the cruise liner
Queen Mary 2 and it's designed by Dutch artist Norbert Broeckman and it's actually a picture
of Queen Mary 2 coming into New York Harbour. So I thought it would be an appropriate picture
to show today. And this tapestry is absolutely enormous and this is me here.
The whole tapestry is about six and a half metres, so that's in excess of 20 feet tall.
Now, Tina has already touched on this this morning but I don't think it hurts to repeat
just a little bit of what we're actually talking about when we're talking about woven tapestry.
And tapestry is a fabric that's woven on a loom. There are two main types of tapestry looms,
again as Tina said this morning. There are either the type of loom which has the warps running
horizontally, that's called the low warp loom, or this type which is high warp loom which has
the warps running vertically. There are warps going up and down and I think you can see here
that the weft thread is not going straight backwards and forwards from one side to the
other, it's being built up section by section. And this shows you the same technique being used
today. This is a high warp loom in operation at the West Ealing Tapestry Studio and West Ealing
is one of only two commercial tapestry weaving studios now growing in the UK.
So they're using exactly the same technique building up colour. This one's not really a
question of building up colour because it's one of the much less in terms of colour but you can
see how different yarns are being used here to build up the design. And this is just a diagram
which shows how different colours are inserted into the warp and then all of these weft threads
are beaten down to cover the warps completely and to make a weft fabric.
So what this means really in terms of tapestry as a fabric is that the tapestry weave is creating
both the image and the structure simultaneously, completely interdependent. And so this also means
that as damage starts to occur, both the structure of the fabric and the image,
the design, are both affected. And you can see here a very typical sort of damage occurring
here where the weft yarns which are going in this direction, here you've got cream coloured silk
weft yarns which have deteriorated. And again this is very typical type of damage that happens
in tapestry and probably caused by some sort of bleaching treatment that's put into the weft yarn.
And as they break over the warp, the yarns are exposed.
And just to remind ourselves really that this same technique is used for other types of textiles
like this Chinese kivi or kosu fabric here. This is a silk fabric. It's very much finer
in terms of its structure than the tapestry panes that we're looking at,
but made using exactly the same technique as is the Caribbean fabric here as well.
So this leads to an interesting point really. These sorts of textiles that I'm showing here
tend to be conserved in much the same way as any other type of black textile.
And the trend within textile conservation over the last 20 to 30 years has been very much towards
treatment to stabilize the structure of the textile and prevent further damage from occurring
rather than from restoring it to its previous appearance.
But one of the main points that I wanted to make today really is that tapestry
conservation is a specialist area of textile conservation and it has rather different concerns.
I mean it's also a different fabric in terms of thickness with the woven tapestry hangings
that we're talking about are very much denser and thicker than these types of textiles here.
And that of course has an impact on the type of treatment that we might carry out.
But I think that primarily it's because we think that it's important to preserve the
image of the tapestry. Often the image is seen as being as important as the structure itself.
That really makes us decide how best to select a treatment for a woven tapestry.
So tapestries are very old. They've often been hanging for a long time,
sometimes even hundreds of years, and they are weak, they're fragile.
Conservation nearly always entails strengthening tapestries so that they're strong enough to hang
and this usually means stitching them onto a new fabric.
And a huge range of techniques has been used to achieve this dual aim of both stabilizing
the structure and helping to restore the image. And working on the tapestry conservation book
which contained contributions from a wide range of authors here in the United States,
in the UK and across mainland Europe, I was really struck by just how great a variety of techniques
are used to just to carry out the act of stitching the tapestry onto a support fabric.
Virtually no two case studies in the book were carried out the same way. It was really quite
fascinating. This is really one end of the spectrum. I think this is more like
the way that any other type of textile, flat textile, might be treated.
In this case, this was a tapestry that had been hanging in a house with a piece of furniture in
front of it and it had rotted away behind the furniture, without anybody noticing.
And so there's really a very large area of tapestry missing and it would be very difficult
indeed to know what went in the missing area and to come up with some way of infilling that.
At the time that this tapestry was treated, it was really best to treat it as a fragment
and just to stitch it onto a neutral coloured blue fabric. So that's what was done.
I think it's a successful treatment of this fragment. And I understand that some conservators
in Germany really favour this sort of technique and would rather not intervene with the image at
all. But a key technique that's been developed and used widely in the UK over the past 20 or 30 years
has been a technique which supports and redefines the tapestry simultaneously.
This is a way of stitching a tapestry onto usually a linen or fabric and
using stitching very much that's designed to be visible, unlike in other forms of textile
conservation, where the stitching is really meant to be unobtrusive and is not designed to show.
But actually using the support stitching as a way of helping to bring back the image.
So this consists of what we call brick stitching, a stitch that goes up over one walk, down under
another walk, passing through the support fabric. But the stitching is colour matched to the weft
yarn that it's replacing. And the yarn type is also chosen to be appropriate in terms of aesthetics
as well as in terms of strength. This isn't the only sort of stitching that's carried out across
the tapestry. There's other stitching that helps to stabilise the whole structure. There's stitching
that simply serves to connect the two fabrics together to attach the tapestry to the linen support
fabric. And also there's stitching to rework the flip stitching that's part of the integral
construction of the tapestry. If that is missing or damaged then that is usually restitched and
that also helps to hold the whole tapestry structure together. But this type of couching
stitching is very characteristic. This shows a very crude repair before treatment and this area
has been supported using this couching stitching. And this area actually would have been woven in
silk originally, pale coloured silk, representing the highlights on the dress, on the fabric.
You can probably see the actual stitching a bit more clearly on this example.
And I think you can see how the technique, even before constipation, you can see how much damage
there is to the dark brown, particularly around the collar and around the hat. And you can see how it
has been redefined by using actually quite widely spaced stitching. So it's really designed that
close to you can see that it's stitching. You don't in any way mistake it from original tapestry.
But from a distance it can be surprisingly successful in really helping to pull the whole
design together. And here also this line has been put back in.
So it works very well in small areas like this, in pale coloured areas. It's perhaps
less successful aesthetically in large areas of dark colour, where it can look a bit unspotty.
And it's quite a time-consuming technique as well.
But it's not always necessary to treat a tapestry in this way.
This is a small tapestry which was treated recently at the Textile Conservation Centre.
And here most of the tapestry was supported to a new linen fabric, simply with an overall grid
of running stitch lines. And there actually was quite a lot of little areas of damage throughout
the whole of this background. But the design is so busy that you don't need to put colour back
into it. You can see looking at it here from a viewing distance you're completely unaware
of those little areas of damage. So it was enough just to stabilise the structure.
But there was one exception on this tapestry and that was the area of the central coat of arms.
And you can see here that there were large areas of bare work here.
So this area was in need both of stabilisation and of helping to redefine the image.
And so again you can see a bit of stitching here with the type of couching stitching that's put in.
Also in this lettering which had dropped out completely.
So the more labour-intensive couching stitching was reserved for the area
that was the focal point of the whole design and where you would notice it wasn't there.
But other institutions use different techniques and often we find that different techniques are
used in different countries. And I think this is an interesting technique that's used in the
Royal Manufacturers in Belgium. And this workshop very much separates out the support
and the ridiculousness of the design functions. So the tapestry is first stitched onto a dyed
support fabric. So all the details are supported onto the fabric. And after that any areas that
need to be visually restored are added with stitching these missing areas. And this is a
loose needle weaving type of technique. It's anchored into the support fabric rather than
into the tapestry itself. And this is a close-up of some of the stitching that's just securing
the warp yarns to the support before the infill needle weaving takes place.
And in this case the stitches are diagonal stitches. So they follow the spin of the yarn,
the spin and the climb of the yarn. So we've already heard a lot this morning from Tina
about a different type of technique and a very traditional technique used for restoring tapestries.
And reweaving, as has been mentioned already, has been used for centuries to repair and to
restore missing areas of tapestries. And Tina has explained how it was used this morning
on the tapestry Christ is Risen as Man's Redeemer. And this is another example from
Metropolitan Museum of Art where missing areas of the tapestry were rewoven. But in this case
this technique is used because in the context of this particular museum the image is really
all-important. And the tapestry is being presented here as an example of fine art.
In the case of the tapestry that we were hearing about this morning,
Tina did mention to me that she felt that the narrative content was felt to be so important
to the tapestry that it was the legibility of the image that was really important.
Different types of techniques again. And this is another time-honoured technique,
simply using printing or painting techniques to infill missing areas. And this is an example
from a tapestry treated by Chevalier Conservation in Paris. And this particular tapestry,
the top and bottom borders were missing. And they were reinstated using completely printed
infill. And this is printing equipment worked on wool, a ribbed weave wool fabric.
And it helps to infill the image that's missing. In this case, details from side borders and also
details from borders of other similar tapestries were used to help to know what was missing.
And I think that that point came across this morning. You really need to know what is missing
before you can recreate it. We don't want to be inventing details for tapestries. We want to be
really very clear that we know what should be there before we reinstate that detail, however
modern technology is helping us to do this. This is a tapestry which belongs to the National Trust
in the UK, from a house called Cotille, which is in Cornwall in the southwest of England.
And as you can see here, there's a large missing area in the bottom right of the tapestry.
And this is about 120 by 160 centimetres, so several feet of tapestry is missing completely.
And so this would have been extremely time-consuming to have infilled using
special techniques. It could have been treated like the first example, the tapestry fragments
that I showed you with just the neutral fabric. But in fact, digital technology has been used
extremely successfully, I think, here. And the whole of this lower right corner has been infilled
with a digitally printed patch, and a second tapestry woven from this same cartoon was used
to provide the detail that was missing. So the Trust were fortunate to have another
tapestry actually in their collection that showed this same theme. And no doubt it was
time-consuming to liaise with the specialist printer and to make sure that the new printed
image was the right size and exactly the right colour to fit in to this corner. But I'm sure
that it was much quicker than stitch tapestry. And I think that visually it's an extremely
successful solution here. But I have to say, it works very well here because of this particular
type of damage. It's often easier to create an infill where there's an area of loss in the
tapestry. Very often what we're faced with are bare warps where the weft yarns have disappeared,
but the warps are still there, and then that can make it relatively difficult.
An even more innovative visual restoration technique has been used recently in the UK
at Hampton Court Palace, which is part of the Historic Royal Palaces.
This shows a tapestry from the History of Abraham series. It was commissioned by Henry VIII. It was
woven with gold and silver threads and was an extremely valuable tapestry. It would have been
a hugely impressive sight when it was first hung at the palace. But 500 years later,
the glory of these tapestries is somewhat diminished. The bright silk has faded and
the metal thread has tarnished. And I'm sure that a lot of visitors hardly give the tapestry
a second glance as they walk around the palace. And so this led to a really innovative research
project, which has resulted in this, which is actually a projection of the original colours
of the tapestry. These colours are projected onto the front of the tapestry to give the
audience some idea, some sense of what the original colours would have been like.
And this is presented as a real show. The audience's interest and enthusiasm is really
cultivated. There's a great sense of anticipation as everybody's waiting for the lights to go on.
And so this early stage of this work may not completely recreate the tapestry's original
appearance. I think we would all agree, probably. But I think it's actually extremely successful
in just making visitors look again at the tapestry. And it really helps them to appreciate
the tapestry's splendour and original appearance.
So moving on now to talk a little bit about some research into tapestry conservation,
tapestry deterioration and tapestry conservation. I'm part of a research team at the University of
Southampton. And my colleague Dianne Estopp and I have been working for a number of years now
with two colleagues from the engineering department at the university, Miss Janice
Barking and Annie Chambers. This slide shows our advisory panel for the engineering project,
which is made up of representatives from bodies like the National Trust and the National Heritage
Centre. We're very fortunate to have such an advisory body. And we've been looking over the
past number of years to see whether any sort of techniques that engineers use to monitor structures,
structures like aircraft and bridges, can actually help us to monitor the condition of tapestries.
So the overall aims of the project really are to see whether incipient damage could be identified
before it's visible for the naked eye. Partly perhaps so that we can avoid damage happening,
partly to help us inform the timing of any conservation treatments that we carry out.
It might help us to decide, for example, which one that the set of tapestries is in most urgently
or it might help us to monitor tapestries over a period of time and just see how quickly they're
deteriorating. And our long-term aim is really to be able to compare the effects of different
conservation treatments as well. I think that would be very valuable. I think it would be
very interesting to work out just how much stitching is actually necessary to stabilise
the structure of tapestries. As I've already said, that wouldn't necessarily answer the question of
how much treatment is needed to help to restore the image, but it might help us to separate out
in our minds just how much stitching we are doing. And I think it's been quite interesting,
this project, because a lot of research projects in the past have focused on chemistry. We know
quite a lot of conservators about chemical means of deterioration of textiles and other objects.
We know rather less, certainly in textiles, about the physical and mechanical effects of cleaning tapestries.
So our current three-year project is coming to an end soon, but we have achieved what we've
set out to achieve, I think. We've been testing and then trialling two different engineering techniques.
One is digital image correlation using two digital cameras, and the other is optical fibre sensors,
where we actually have optical fibres woven into this tapestry and bonded with adhesive
to the back of this tapestry, and you can't see, but here there is a cable connecting it to this computer here.
And here we're testing out both these techniques on a little tapestry that was specially woven for
us for this project. It was woven at West Dean Tapestry Studio. It was actually designed for us by
two textile art students at Manchester School of Art, where WTCC was based, and I think it's really
really interesting little tapestry. It's made as much as possible using the techniques of historic
tapestry, although it's obviously modern in design, but it was inspired by the colours of medieval
tapestries, notably the Anjou tapestry, the apocalypse tapestry from Anjou, and it contains the formula, the engineering formula for stress.
And you can't actually see here, but it also has two words woven into it.
Diffuses and reflects. Those two words really relate to the fact that we're using optical
monitoring techniques on this tapestry. We haven't yet managed to come up with a name for this tapestry.
We really should do, although we do from time to time think it should just be called stress.
That would be a good name for it. So our tapestry is currently being displayed at a children's
hands-on science and technology centre in Winchester. We've got these display panels to tell
the public about the monitoring that's going on, and monitoring is happening in situ periodically.
So this is really part of our dissemination of science, public dissemination of science
agenda as well. We're really trying to let people know what it is that we're doing.
We've also been fortunate to carry out some monitoring at Hardwick Hall, which is a property
that belongs to the National Trust in England. Again, we put up some information to help
disseminate to the public and to let them know more about what it is that we're doing.
We've found some interesting results already from our monitoring. This graph shows a plot.
This actually relates to the display of the little modern tapestry at the TCC,
which you saw in the first slide. It's a plot with humidity here, the top line,
temperature, the green line, and this is strain, which is what we're measuring. It's very difficult
actually to measure stress, but what we are doing is measuring strain, which is a much easier thing
to measure. We're pretty confident that strain equals damage at the end of the day.
We have found that relative humidity is cycling over a 24-hour period.
You can see just how much strain is altering in response to changes in humidity,
probably partly because as relative humidity increases, the tapestry gets heavier.
We found that these are very interesting results to see just how closely the strain is
following changes in humidity. We're hoping that this research will give us a better understanding
of how tapestries deteriorate. What we really want to know is, are tapestries being pulled
apart by their own weight? This is what engineers would call creep. Or is it the fatigue mechanism
that's being caused by constant expansion and contraction of the yarns and the fibers,
the changes in relative humidity that's doing the damage? We're hoping to carry on and find out
some more about this. I should just mention another research project. I know that Mariah
Packer is going to talk more about this on Tuesday, so I don't want to steal her thunder
at all. I just wanted to mention that this is another major research project that has
been undertaken in recent years. This was a three-way collaboration between institutions
in the UK, in Spain, and in Belgium. It was funded by the European Union. Unlike our project,
it had focused on using analytical techniques to identify chemical markers of deterioration
on the whole. But it was also aiming to gain a better understanding of the mechanisms of
deterioration within tapestry. I think it's very exciting that the two projects are really
very complementary, one that's looking more at chemical markers of deterioration and one
that's looking at the physical and mechanical deterioration. Again, I won't say very much,
but just to say that one of the very interesting results of this research project was to tell us
that actually tapestries are much weaker than we might think. The unfaded backs of tapestries
appear to be just as weak as the faded fronts of tapestries, which have obviously been affected
by exposure to light. It seems that perhaps relative humidity does play a greater role
in tapestry damage than we might have thought. I think we've always assumed that light damage
was the overwhelmingly important agent of deterioration. We have had a PhD student working
at the Dept of Conservation Centre jointly with English Heritage, Naomi Luxford. She has been
looking a little bit more at this phenomenon. She's actually been measuring relative humidity
in front of and behind tapestries on display in English Heritage property. She's found a very
marked divergence in the relative humidity, which is very much damper behind the tapestry than it
is in front in the open air. Perhaps this is having a greater effect on the deterioration
than we had imagined. Stefan's just going to touch on cleaning.
I put up this slide really just to say we've come a long way since this slide was taken. This was
15 or 20 years ago. There have been huge strides made in the science and the technology of
tapestry cleaning. Developments have really focused on making the process
gentler so that the tapestry undergoes less handling during cleaning and also in using
less water so the tapestry is less saturated during the cleaning process. I put this slide
up really just to make the point that I think this is one area where it would be really good
to do some more research. I would really welcome some comparative research into the different
types of cleaning treatments that are used nowadays on tapestries to look at their effects
and their benefits and how much soiling is removed, for example,
how much fiber damage is there. I think it would be very good to look at that.
I've argued that tapestry conservation is different in many ways from other forms of
textile conservation because we're focusing very much on the image. When we're treating tapestries
we shouldn't ignore the developments that have taken place in the field of textile conservation
in the past 20 or 30 years. One real change that has been happening
is the developing emphasis on treating a textile or any other artifact as a source of evidence.
This may often limit the amount of treatment that a textile undergoes. Very often we might
decide not to whack in a textile, for example, because we are concerned that such a treatment
might remove evidence perhaps of its construction, perhaps of past use,
the environments where it has been used. It's probably the case usually with tapestries,
but the desire to make the tapestry safe to display safely will predominate over any need
to preserve evidence within the tapestry. But again it's something that we need to think about
and we need to make these decisions consciously. One important area is the need to document
tapestries very carefully, both before and during treatment. The more interventive the treatment,
the more important this is. These two images show the front and back of a little tapestry fragment.
I think you can probably see, I hope you can see, that the colours on the front are really
quite different from the colours on the back. For example, the red here has largely disappeared
on the front. I think it's the red tones particularly that have changed. And so if we
were giving this little tapestry fragment a treatment that's going to cover up the back
with a new support fabric, probably forever, then it's really important that we capture
these differences before the back is covered up. And tapestries can be real sources of evidence.
Again, the National Trust has carried out research into, for example, the breeds of
sheep that have been used to provide the wool that makes the yarns for medieval tapestries.
And this could provide a lot of information. It could shed light, for example, on medieval
farming practices, on trade routes, for example. And such documentation could be used in different ways.
This is another interesting project currently underway in the UK. And this shows, again,
Westin Tapestry Studio, but working on a set of tapestries which are being displayed at
Stirling Castle, which is a property owned by Historic Scotland. And the weaving is actually
taking place in situ at Stirling Castle as a visitor attraction. And you may recognise
the tapestries that are being woven here. And as you see here, these are two of the
completed tapestries, and they are based on the unicorn tapestries that Catherine was
showing us earlier, which are displayed here at the Cloisters Museum. So although the original
tapestries were never at Stirling Castle, the curators there wanted to display something that
was of an appropriate age and style, and so they commissioned Westin to make a new set of tapestries.
And this project is dependent on minute documentation of the original set.
Although these tapestries are woven much more coarsely than the originals,
they're not replicas by any means, but they are a very close representation of the original tapestries.
So, coming to the end. I've tried really to give a very broad overview of tapestry
conservation, but hopefully I've said enough to show that many different techniques have been
used and continue to be used to repair the structure and to restore the image of these beautiful
objects. And I feel very strongly there isn't any right way or wrong way to conserve a tapestry.
It depends completely on the context and on the resources available. What's right for the
The new research is going to help our understanding of the mechanisms causing
tapestries to decay, and also our understanding of tapestry conservation treatment.
While new technology is going to expand our repertoire of treatments,
and perhaps also allow a more cost-effective and less time-intensive intervention.
I was struck by something that David Howell, one of the MODHT project partners, said.
That because these historic tapestries are really very fragile, much weaker than we might think,
then he said the most important thing is to do something. It doesn't matter what we do,
we should just do something. But I think we do also need to think carefully about what is the
right thing to do in each case, and not just always I'm thinking we do the same thing.
I think with tapestry conservation it can be quite difficult to evaluate our own practice.
It's such a long job often, if it's taken years and years to conserve tapestry,
it can be quite hard to step back and think, have we just done the right thing to this tapestry?
I think that we need to be applauded in convening this symposium.
But I think that we do need to spend some time evaluating our practice. It's the only way that
we're going to take things forward in the practice of tapestry conservation.
I think that even if we're using techniques that support the structure and restore the
image simultaneously, I think it would be good for us to separate out in our minds
which functions are being performed so that we've got a better sense, a clearer idea of what we're
doing to stabilize the structure of the tapestry and what it is that we're doing to enhance the
design. And maybe if we think about them as two separate operations, even if we carry them out
simultaneously, it will help us make decisions about treatment. I would just like to thank
all of those who, my colleagues who have very generously provided images for me to use in
my talk this afternoon, all of these institutions mentioned here.
And I just finished putting up my email address in case anybody would like to contact me
afterwards. And also one photo advert for our new publication. Thank you very much.