Sir Roger Penrose. Quantum Consciousness Theorist — Co-creator of the Orch OR model of the quantum nature of consciousness and memory.
Knighted in 1994 for his contributions to science, Sir Roger Penrose OM FRS, is an English mathematical physicist, mathematician and philosopher. The extraordinary scope of his work ranges from quantum physics and theories of human consciousness to relativity theory and observations on the structure of the universe. Penrose is internationally renowned for his scientific work in mathematical physics, in particular for his contributions to general relativity and cosmology. His primary interest is in a field of geometry called tesselation, the covering of surfaces with tiles of different shapes. Among numerous prizes and awards, he received the 1988 Wolf Prize for physics, which he shared with Stephen Hawking for their contribution to our understanding of the universe. He is the Emeritus Rouse Ball Professor of Mathematics at the Mathematical Institute of the University of Oxford, as well as an Emeritus Fellow of Wadham College.
"There is a current view that consciousness is something which arises from some complicated computation. So we have our computers, and people think that because they can do things amazingly fast, and they can calculate very quickly, and they can play chess extremely well, that they are superior to us even, and it is only some complicated aspect of this computational activity that somehow consciousness arises from that. Now my view is quite different from this. I think there is a lot of computational activity going on in the brain, but this is basically unconscious. So consciousness seems to me to be something quite different."
I'm Roger Penrose. I am the Emeritus Rasbal Professor of Mathematics at the University
of Oxford. I've been interested in issues to do with consciousness and its connection with
deep issues in physics for many years. I certainly hope that this conference will
be an opportunity to convey ideas of deep importance in how science is trying to grapple
with these questions of consciousness and to promote these ideas to the general public
and the arguments that go on between different points of view which will go on and which must go
on for a long time to come. There is a current view that consciousness is something which arises
from some complicated computation. So we have our computers and people think that because they can
do things amazingly fast and they can calculate very quickly and they can play chess extremely
well that they're superior to us even and it is only that some complicated aspect of this
computational activity somehow consciousness arises from that. Now my view is quite different
from this. I think there is a lot of computational activity going on in the brain but this is
basically unconscious. So consciousness seems to me to be something quite different. What we do
when we understand something is not computing. There's something else going on. At the same time
I'm a great believer in science and that what's going on in our heads is still
obeying the same laws that are going on in the universe outside us. However those laws
are not things that we necessarily fully understand today. To be understanding something you need to
be aware of it and to be aware of it you're conscious of it and so you are invoking the
consciousness. So to me there is something outside the computational laws of physics and
when I wrote my book The Emperor's New Mind I was trying to develop this idea and I was trying
to say well there is something else out there. What could it be? Where is the biggest gap in our
understanding of physics? There are lots of gaps in there. We don't know what governs the masses
of particles. We don't know all sorts of detailed things but most of these things don't have a direct
bearing on what the brain does. I mean it's the wrong scale. There is a big gap in our understanding
of the laws and this big gap is within present-day quantum mechanics. There are two procedures in
quantum mechanics the Schrodinger equation and the making of the measurement and they're
inconsistent. I say it quite strongly. It's not just that we haven't got the right
interpretation of quantum mechanics. They're just inconsistent. Now that's interesting.
If there was a huge gap maybe that gap is where the theory has to be outside a computational system.
Many people will dispute that and they say well this is taking your logic too far.
It seems to me there is logic in this. The next step though is the one that people mostly question
because if inside our heads we are exploiting that gap that means that we have quantum
development in the system which takes us to a level somewhat beyond present technology
in our experiments. Experiments still support quantum mechanics and we have not yet seen
where something new has to come in. But there are good reasons in my opinion when we look at
going back to these two major revolutions of 20th century physics. Quantum mechanics on the one hand,
Einstein's theory of general relativity, space-time is not flat it's curved, gravity is not a force
it's somehow a curvature. There is something quite different from other kinds of physics
going on there. If you bring these two great theories together we see this conflict
suggests strongly that there must be a change in the rules of quantum mechanics at a certain level
and that certain level is not too unreasonable that it should be relevant in the brain because
it has to do with the movement of mass of a very tiny, it's very big for quantum mechanical
experiments, but very tiny for even for things in biology. So we're looking for a tiny displacement
of mass, that's the Schrödinger's cat you like, they can be in two places at the same time
but then it spontaneously becomes one or the other and in its becoming one or the other it's doing
something non-computational. Now when I wrote The Emperor's New Mind I knew something about
nerve propagation and it just didn't seem to me there's a chance, there's no chance because in
nerve propagation it disturbs the rest of the brain in a way which would completely destroy
the coherence that you would need in your quantum system to be able to probe this new level in
quantum mechanics. But still I thought when I finish writing the book maybe I will see the
answer. No I didn't. But the answer in a certain sense may have come because Stuart Hameroff read
my book and he contacted me and said well look maybe you don't know about these things in the
brain, these microtubules and I thought microtubules, what's that? In my ignorance I didn't know about
them. If I had I might have said well maybe that's a good place to look and it seemed to me that was
a much better place to look because you could conceivably imagine the kind of isolation that
was necessary. It still goes beyond normal people's understanding of the kind of isolation
you would expect to find in a cell but there is a reasonable chance and since it happens,
since we do, we are conscious, we can understand things, we seem to do things which go beyond a
purely computational activity, the logic is well maybe this is in the microtubules because that's
the best candidate I've ever seen. So we got together and the ideas we then developed from there.
My ideas came from the physics and my desire, the feeling that in order to understand consciousness
we need this kind of level of coherent quantum mechanics and the state reduction has to come in
so it's the idea that the OR if you like has to be part of the scheme but then exactly why,
what part of the brain is involved and where, what is the neurochemistry, what are the
structures in the brain, that's all Stuart. So mine is on the physics side and his is on the biological side.