We test out the ElevenLabs AI voice technology by recreating our own podcast intro and exploring what this means for actors, filmmakers, and content creators. With celebrities like Michael Caine, Matthew McConaughey, Liza Minnelli, and Dr. Maya Angelou signing deals to have their voices used by AI, we ask the big question: Why are they doing this?
Topics covered:
Live demo of ElevenLabs AI voice generator Why celebrities like Michael Caine and Matthew McConaughey are licensing their voices The cost and convenience of AI voices vs hiring real actors SAG-AFTRA concerns about AI in the entertainment industry Potential use cases: audiobooks, manuals, translations, and accessibility The ethical debate: Is an AI voice still ""real"" even if it sounds perfect?
Silicon Valley Front Row. Join us as we talk tech from a dialectical lens. You will hear about innovations, developments, and the other side too: addictions and potential problems.
You’ll also join the conversation as we bring in experts, look at trends, and solutions to issues that shape how we live.
You're letting your voice be you.
I mean, there could be profanities
or there could be many bad things being said
that's gonna end up being said by the actor, right?
Or cursing at people, who knows, could be anything.
Welcome back to Silicon Valley Front Row.
I'm David Lam, and this is Steve Ispos,
and today we'll be talking about AI-generated voices
from celebrities through 11 labs.
Welcome to another episode of Silicon Valley Front Row.
I am David Lam, and this is Steve Ispos.
We will be talking about AI-generated voices
of celebrities through 11 labs.
All right, wow.
Well, David, the one thing I have to say
is that it got to pronounce my name correctly,
which, you know, it's not easy to do.
Yeah, that's surprising.
Yeah. Yeah, wow.
But before we praise it too much, let's understand more.
So how does this work?
So 11 labs is a private company
that uses AI for audio for people.
The person who read this, is that a celebrity?
So what we use was the very basic free version.
Okay.
So I think it sounds like a generic person.
I don't recognize a celebrity.
As being a celebrity, okay.
But anyways, maybe later we'll ask the audience
which do they prefer.
You can think about it for now.
You like our intro or the AI intro more,
but think about it till the end of the episode.
So what do you know about this company, 11 labs?
They have an office in San Francisco and London.
Yeah.
So they're very close to us.
You can go visit them.
That's right.
They were founded in 2022.
Former Google employee and Palantir employee.
So sounds like they struck a deal
with probably the most known actor of this is Michael Caine,
which is right behind you over there.
They struck a deal with him to have his AI,
I mean, his voice being used.
And Matthew McConaughey.
So that's pretty interesting because these are actors
and what we've seen before is that people,
part of a SAG-AFTRA,
or they are kind of against AI using their talent.
Yes.
So anyways, I mean, what do you think
they're signing on for?
Like for a sign-on bonus
or to help with their getting their reputation up?
Yeah.
I would think I was probably both money and publicity
because especially the first ones, everyone is gonna know.
Right.
Now I'm not sure how much they're gonna be respected
for that.
Maybe some actors maybe care more
about being respected than others.
It's not a huge deal, but still letting your voice be you.
I mean, there could be profanities
or there could be many bad things being said
that's gonna end up being said by the actor, right?
Right.
Or cursing with people, who knows?
Could be anything.
Right.
I wonder what kind of contracts they would sign
and how it'd be used.
You know, why would somebody use a AI voice
compared to hiring the actual person?
I think it comes down to pricing and availability.
Yeah, a lot cheaper.
Absolutely.
Right, and they could do this from their computer.
Like you just did.
Yeah, exactly.
So filmmakers or whoever, it's very easy for their projects.
As far as like tonality and heart and soul,
we're not sure how deep that can get compared to human.
Somewhere where we could see this being used,
I think we were talking about it earlier,
is if there's a manuscript or a manual of something.
Yeah, something super boring.
Yeah, or like the terms and conditions.
A hundred page thing.
Yeah, and for some weird reason, someone needs to read that.
Then yeah, you can use this system.
Right, to have like a familiar voice.
It could also help with people that have trouble hearing.
It sounds like also Lisa Minnelli and Dr. Maya Angelou
are gonna be part of this, or they already are.
It's, yeah, that's a lot of firepower there for them.
Right, right.
Yeah, overall, I still don't think it's a good idea,
mainly because how that voice is gonna be used.
I mean, obviously if the actors don't care,
that's their choice.
But I remember a scene from a movie,
and we'll see if you can guess the movie,
where someone is looking at the Mona Lisa painting
in the Louvre, and then somehow they have to replace it
with an almost exact replica for whatever reason.
I'm not gonna divulge why, right?
So it's almost the exact same piece.
It's a fake, though, right?
So the director of the Louvre looks at it,
and he says, isn't that beautiful?
And he looks at it, yeah, it's beautiful,
but I know it's a fake.
So he doesn't enjoy it as much,
even though you need a computer to tell the difference.
Was it, did they steal it in the movie?
No, no, it's in movie 2012,
when the earth is about to be destroyed.
So then they wanna save a few of the pieces.
So they secretly take out the real one
and put a fake in there,
because they know it's gonna be destroyed.
I don't know if I could guess that one.
But I think it's the same thing.
It's a fake, it's a fake thing.
I mean, it's his voice, but it's not really his voice,
because it's just made up, so.
A little bit about Matthew McConaughey.
He is an investor in Eleven Labs,
and the company would translate his newsletter
into Spanish.
Well, that's interesting.
I think we can ask our audience,
how do you feel about this?
Right.
We are kind of lukewarm.
I don't think we have any strong feelings
one way or the other.
Yeah.
Compared to other episodes.
Right.
So David, what should we ask our audience about this?
Yeah, so this time we wanna ask,
would you use a celebrity AI voice for one of your projects?
And would you feel good about it?
And the second question is,
which intro did you like more,
the ones we did or the AI generated one?
And David, I'm not sure how long
we're gonna keep our jobs for
if they like more the other one, right?
Hopefully we keep doing more episodes.
And we also want to read some of the comments
that we received in our previous videos.
So here's a comment from one of our viewers,
and it's for a YouTube short that we did
based on an indie filmmaker interview
about Tilly Norwood and the filmmaking industry.
So this is Crispy Blazin.
This person said,
I think you could argue that you can use AI for inspiration
like you use Google or other tools.
Yeah, some parts you didn't create,
but if you've never seen a house before in your life,
you can't draw one.
And then someone replied to that.
This is user T24986.
And they just said, don't.
So do you have any thoughts on this interaction
or the comments?
Well, I think what they're saying that don't,
when it's saying don't use AI for inspiration,
and that's probably indeed difficult to use.
Yeah, this one is a little bit more deep,
the comment and the whole thing.
But I think as always, we appreciate your comments.
We'd like to get more of them.
We'd like to address more,
especially if it's direct questions for us to answer.
I'll go one of the questions that I had.
And if you haven't seen my short
on which heater is easier to turn on
between three different cars,
we had a 2015, 2005 and a brand new Tesla.
Which heater is easier to turn on?
So the comment was, it's the oldest car that's easier.
So make sure you watch that short
to see if you agree with him.
If that's the easiest heater to turn on.
Thank you, Agonamin.
Yes, that's from Agonamin, yeah.
Thank you.