In this episode of Silicon Valley Front Row, we discuss the growing concerns over Chinese Communist Party influence operations in the United States, following the case involving a former California mayor accused of acting as an illegal foreign agent for China.
We talk about allegations against the former Arcadia official, FBI statements surrounding the investigation, and the broader concerns about espionage, propaganda, and foreign influence in American politics and institutions.
We also examine several other high-profile cases involving alleged spying, military secrets, overseas police stations, and intelligence gathering tied to the CCP.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This episode of Silicon Valley Front Row examines the legal dispute between Elon Musk and OpenAI over the company's non-profit mission and provides an in-depth analysis of Chinese Communist Party (CCP) espionage and influence operations within the U.S. government, military, and local communities.
A mayor of Arcadia, California. I guess she was accused of being an illegal foreign agent,
spying for China. To have a government official, like a U.S. government official,
that I guess signs all these oaths that he's there, they are there. Yeah, to represent the
city. That's what the people voted for, right? Voted for her, in reality, to represent the
interest of China, of the CCP. This is Silicon Valley Front Row. I'm David, and this is Steve.
We're back again with another episode. So this week is week three of the OpenAI case, right?
It's starting to wrap up, and I've been watching the case for the past few weeks. The lawyers just
gave their closing arguments, and it's about whether OpenAI breached the non-profit mission.
So we talked about the case last week, and do you think anything changed in your opinion?
After listening to the lawyers, I think the lawyers are so good on both sides,
because these are the top lawyers hired by these tech executives, and their arguments are very
persuasive and good. I think for Steven Molo, Elon Musk's lawyer, he's trying to discredit Sam
Altman in saying that he brought up that Sam Altman was called a liar by at least five different
people that testified, and saying that don't trust Sam Altman. Whereas the other side,
William Savitt, the main lawyer for OpenAI, is saying that Elon Musk is, I guess, the bad person,
and that there was no contract. Elon Musk's donations to OpenAI didn't have any restrictions
to them, so there was no commitment. So they're saying that there was no non-profit mission that
was tied to a contractual basis. I think what's interesting is that this case is so close to us.
It's in Oakland, California, and it involves maybe the top three out of five companies in the world,
like OpenAI. Of course, Elon Musk with his companies, and then Microsoft is involved as
well. The CEO is there testifying as well, right? Yes, it's funny because Microsoft is saying like,
we don't want any part of this. So each time Microsoft people spoke, or even their lawyers,
it was very short. Wow. But I guess they had to be there because they were sued by Elon Musk.
The interesting thing is, well, Sam Altman and Greg Brockman both showed up to the court today
for the proceeding, but Elon Musk wasn't there. Yeah, you know where he is, right? I guess he's
in China, and we'll be talking about China, but yeah, I think him and several others are in China
right now. Well, by the time this is going to air, he's going to probably be back. So do you think
that damages his chances in some way because he wasn't in the courtroom? Technically,
maybe he doesn't have to be there. He already stated his testimony, his piece, but it might
look bad depending on how the jury wants to look at that. I mean, the lawyer for OpenAI
pointed that out. He was saying, oh, look, my clients are here. They really care. Elon Musk
isn't. Of course, he's going to take advantage of that. Well, I think we have some interesting
things to talk about. The main story that we're covering is that recently, there's a mayor,
a mayor of Arcadia, California, which I guess is close to Los Angeles or part of LA. I guess
she was accused of being an illegal foreign agent, spying for China or in some way giving
information to China as an agent. I always say that we hear these all the time, but this is a
little bit different because it's a government official. It's a mayor. It's crazy. I mean,
I was looking at the press release. Yeah, it's all over the news. I mean,
I'm honestly not surprised because we hear about it all the time, but with this person,
she's a government official. Apparently, she started a media company, right? The FBI said
she was spreading propaganda from the Chinese regime, which we know is the Chinese Communist
Party, and spreading, I guess, their propaganda. So, I think it's already kind of crazy enough to
have a spy from China operating freely in the U.S., but to have a government official,
like a U.S. government official that, I guess, signs all these oaths that they are their mayor
to represent the city. That's what the people voted for, right? Voted for her to represent
their city and then, in reality, to represent the interest of China, of the CCP. It's pretty
amazing. Well, anything interesting in the press release that you want to look at?
Let me pull up the press release here. Elon Musk and other business leaders are in China with
President Trump for business relationships, economic relationships, and hopefully human
rights. I know China has a really bad record for human rights. Hopefully, that comes up.
Usually, they don't bring it up. They don't want it to get in the way of business, but
it probably should. Let me pull up the press release. This is from the Justice Department.
Aileen Wang, right? She's 58 years old. She even confessed, saying that she was,
here, this is a quote from the FBI Assistant Director Roman Roshavsky of Counterintelligence.
He said, by her own admission, Aileen Wang secretly served the interests of the Chinese
government. All Americans should be alarmed to learn an elected official was brazenly spreading
propaganda on behalf of the Chinese government. According to her plea agreement from late 2020
through 2022, her and Yaoning Mike Sun, 65 years old, were working at the direction and control of
the PRC government officials. There's a couple of interesting things I noticed. I think it says in
the release that she resigned hours of the case going public on May 11, which is just a few days
ago. She resigned from her position and she pleaded guilty. Now, for me, watching some of
these cases, a lot of these spies do not plead guilty. They plead unguilty, not guilty. Either
there's overwhelming evidence, or she's trying to make a deal, or who knows. Do you think it's
a good thing that she's coming clean? I think it's a good thing, but it could be that she might be
guilty of more things, but then by pleading guilty, she'll get a smaller penalty, or maybe she's
willing to collaborate. I don't know. So she was a city controller when she was carrying out these
tasks for the CCP, and then later she became mayor, but she was still an official in that capacity.
Crazy. Now, what do you know about this guy, Mike Sun? Not that much. Well, so I kind of did a bit
of a search because we have these spy issues and these agents coming all the time. So I did a bit
of a search, and I came up with 13 kind of prominent cases of these either agents or spies
or people giving information to China. So I guess Mike Sun was the guy that kind of influenced
Aileen Wong, and he was the one running that website, which was supposed to serve the Chinese
Americans in the U.S. This site, he was carrying out directives from the CCP
in how to run the site, what information to put on it, and everything else.
So yeah, so that's Mike Sun, and I think he got four years. So he got four years.
I think Aileen, the trial has not happened yet, so I don't think there's any result on that.
But Mike Sun got four years, and as you watch all of these cases where people got sentenced,
you know they go through this long process. Like you've witnessed the Elon Musk trial, right?
There's weeks of people with Jerry, and many times there's a mistrial or other things. So
if they already got sentenced, they already went through that process. But there's a few more.
Do you know others? Well, there was the former congressman, Eric Swalwell. He was accused of
partnering and working with an alleged Chinese spy, nicknamed Feng Feng. He denied the allegations,
but he did resign from his position after some investigation into just crimes.
He recently called off his governor race, but I think there was a different reason.
It wasn't because of the Chinese spy thing. Yeah, it was for, I think, related to the allegations.
Yeah, that was very recent. There was also two, I did a report on this, but two men in the UK
were also like charged for working with, for spying on people in Britain,
and working with Hong Kong police, which allegedly are tied with people in the Chinese
Communist Party. And these guys, at least one of them was a former officer in Britain. But
apparently he would use the databases when he's off duty to find information on certain people,
on what car they drove, where they lived, things like that. And these were advocates that wanted
pro-democracy in Hong Kong. Yeah, there's a few cases like that. You know, of course,
we talk, I think we talk about the Jamestown report that by Sherry Liu, who came up with
close to a thousand Chinese front organizations in the US that are Communist, CCP Communist Party
organizations that act like normal businesses in the US. We still don't have the names of what,
who those are, but I think many of these are connected. Let me go through some of this list
because I was pretty surprised. And again, these are the most significant, the bigger,
the more prominent cases. There's a John Chen, who was also based in Los Angeles, and
he was involved also with Mike Sun and Eileen Wong. Same thing, unregistered agent for the PRC,
and he got 20 months, just last year. So he's going to be out in a few months.
The next couple of ones are pretty major. It's a Harry Lu and Chen Jinping. I guess his name is
Xi Jinping. And these guys were prosecuted, the first ones prosecuted for running Chinese
overseas police station, Chinese overseas police stations. In the US. In the US, exactly. So this
guy, and they were monitoring activists, like you said, the pro-democracy people and activists,
but this guy faces up to 30 years. So yeah, so that's, that's, that's a lot more significant.
How long do you know? Like how long? I mean, why is, why is it so much?
Yeah, I don't know the degree. Obviously he, he must've been involved in a, in a more serious
level in a way. I don't know the details. There's so many. Yeah. There's another guy,
Yuan Jin Tang, unregistered agent for PRC. He got five years. Then it gets more interesting.
Yuan Chen and another guy, Ryan Lai, they're in a clandestine intelligence network,
targeting US Navy. So they gather photos, videos of bases and personnel. Oh, I remember this.
Yeah, I remember. So, and, and they were transmitting this, these results to, to the
CCP. Then we have a former US sailor, and this guy was sentenced for 16 years. So that, that's a big
one. Wei Jinchao. And he was actually on a, on a, on a ship, on a, I guess, USS Essex, that was
the name. And he sold national defense information to a PRC intelligence officer. How much, what was
his sentence? 16, 16 years. So it seems like if you mess with the military or law enforcement,
yeah, it seems more intense or more penalized. I really wonder if it has to do with how good
the prosecutor is or, or the different states or, or whatever, but. Probably. And if they did a plea.
Yeah. Right. Or maybe they want to see like how much they can get, you know, maybe they're willing
to lower the sentencing for something else in return, but. If they spill more details. And
there's this guy from San Jose, remember him, Chen Guang Gong from San Jose. And he's accused of
theft of military trade secrets, stole 3,600 files on advanced infrared sensors for missiles,
including nuclear missiles. So that's, that's really crazy. That was like last year. Remember
that? There's so many cases, to be honest, I don't remember. But it was from San Jose. So
another big one is Linda Sun. I know that rings a bell, but she was the deputy chief of staff
for the governor, for the governor of New York, Katie Hoku. And she was fired in March 2023.
So this is deputy chief of staff, that's pretty high position for, for a New York governor. Anyway,
yeah, there's, there's a lot more. But the last one, I have to go to the last one, because this
guy doesn't sound Chinese. Michael Charles Scanna from Virginia. He got four years and he participated
in a conspiracy to transmit national defense information to the PRC. And what's crazy, he had
top secret clearance. What? Wait, you got four years, you would think people will be screened
and get all these background checks. Yeah, before they get top secret clearance. So it seems like
two things happen. Some of them are maybe agents or spies to begin with. Yeah. But then there are
others, they are trying to recruit other people. So after they get in, maybe they would get bribed
from... Yeah, either bribed or, or maybe, who knows, maybe some of them, they're Chinese nationals in
some way, or, you know, ancestry. And then, yeah, they tell about help China to get all these
secrets from the US, who knows? Yeah. But I think that's what is what happens. In addition to the
original spies, there's these ones who get bought out. Right. So I think maybe we should
kind of talk about like the dangers or like why this is important. I mean, obviously,
military secrets, nuclear weapons, military data, we don't want that going to other countries,
obviously, right. But then let's talk about like, yeah, why is it so bad that the CCP
is getting information from us? Well, so I think what happens also is a lot of these,
these agents, they, they track and monitor dissidents, like pro-democracy, or Hong Kong,
or Falun Gong practitioners, they track them. And they give that information to the CCP. So then
it becomes easier for, for the Communist Party in China to kind of control these people or scare
them or scare their families and all that. Yeah, I think a lot of these were doing that,
or monitoring people and, and even the agents themselves, right, the ones that are doing the
spying. Yeah, they could also be blackmailed. And if they don't do it, exactly, maybe their own
families will be targeted in China. So yeah, so once they did it once, they probably, right,
it's like something to hold on to, right? Yeah. Yeah, I think also, because then they're also
kind of victims themselves, too, right? Like, I think, because we cover a lot about the CCP.
And there's a distinction, like, I like to always point out, right, like,
the Chinese Communist Party is different than the Chinese people themselves, because
those that even like, participate in the CCP, or those organizations, they're victims.
Exactly. Yeah, they are made to do it. One thing I just thought of is that we see all these,
all these news about these Chinese spies being caught. Yeah, but I rarely see like a Brazilian
spy be caught or Indonesian or even Russian for that matter. I'm sure there are some.
But maybe the ratio is 100 to one. You know, it's just amazing. You know, how,
how many more Chinese spies or these agents versus other countries?
I think because there's a lot of money from China. Yeah, right. And they have a lot of,
they have a lot of arms, or their arms reach everywhere. Yeah, they just have this technique,
this strategy of putting a lot of effort into getting our technology and the same time silencing
dissidents and democracy people. And it comes down to like human rights. Because they don't
like pro-democracy. Because like, here we vote for our leaders. But in China, the totalitarian
communist regime, they don't, the citizens don't vote for their leaders. So whoever is in charge,
right, it's like kind of like an endless cycle that whoever's in charge stays in charge.
Well, so you know, it seems like this, this, this person, Eileen Wang, former mayor of Arcadia,
she seems like she pled guilty. And she almost feels like she feel like she's sorry for what
she did. And maybe she wants to, to make up or wants to improve. What, what do you think she
can do? What would be her next step? Like if she really wants to expose what she's been to,
and she wants to kind of, yeah, fix the damage she made? Yeah. To be honest, part of me was kind of
like, I wouldn't say relieved, but I kind of commend her for coming clean. Because like,
people make mistakes, right? But she actually admitted to what she's done. And I think this
could set up like a domino effect for other people that are in her shoes or other officials
that are being extorted, right? Yeah. Or, yeah, I mean, that's, I think that's why they're doing
it. Ideally, it would be for them to come out. Yeah. Before they get caught. Exactly. Or either
to expose it, or at least to not do it anymore, but before they get caught. Right. And so I think
for, for Aileen, who already pled guilty, like, some following steps would be potentially quitting
the CC party if she's part of it, or part of like the youth organizations. Because I've never been
to China, but I know people have worked with people who lived in China. And apparently they
have to, as a kid, right, they have to sign up for the Chinese like Youth League, which is connected
to the CCP. The Chinese Communist Party. Even if they don't really do it or believe it, they just
have to sign into it. Right. So then after they leave China, they're here. Some of that is still
like, I mean, they still signed it. But there is a organization that's calling for people to quit
the CCP. Yes. No matter where they are, right, the Tui Dong Center. Yeah. And the Epoch Times really
helps with this. Yes, yes, especially on our Chinese website, Chinese site, Tui Dong. It's a huge
thing. I think there's millions, I think there's 400, over 450 million people that already signed,
that already signed that they want to quit the CCP. Yeah, the Chinese Communist Party. So you're
right. That would be the right thing for these people to do. And in that way to kind of...
Erase their name, right? Yeah. I think it vindicates their status from being part of the
regime, which a lot of lawmakers and advocates are pushing against the CCP because of the
human rights abuses that's been happening and kind of being pushed away.
So they're telling people to not get their name connected to that. That's a really good point.
And if you think about it, if they are in China, you can be a little bit more understanding that
they will be afraid. But if they're here in the US, at least hopefully they have that much guts to
do it, being in the US and hopefully realizing that they're being protected by the US for doing
this. Right. Yeah. And then with the presidential administration, they're really going on to China
and expressing religious freedom and human rights and the right to all that.
Well, we can see if our audience has any questions on this. What would be your concerns,
catching all these either agents for the Chinese Communist Party or spies transferring information?
Another question is, why do you think there's so many Chinese spies versus other countries' spies,
especially in the Bay Area and California, but pretty much all over the US?
And also, what do you think about lawmakers or government officials like we've seen here
just working with the CCP? Are you shocked? Do you feel like remorse? What's your thoughts? Let
us know. And with that, thank you for watching another episode of Silicon Valley Front Row,
and we'll see you next time.