Former Google CEO Eric Schmidt was booed repeatedly by nearly 9,000 graduating students at the University of Arizona.
He was merely telling the grads to "accept AI" and "find a way to say yes."
In Episode 49 of Silicon Valley Front Row, hosts Steve Ispas and David Lam break down the viral moment clip by clip. Are tech executives correct or incorrect when it comes to the next generation, AI and jobs?
Topics include Artisan AI's controversial "Stop Hiring Humans" ad campaign, AI use in college assignments, and whether anyone people can tell the difference between human and AI-written content.
The class of 2026 is entering one of the toughest job markets in recent history, but the students seem to be skeptical about what the billionaires are selling.
Former Google CEO Eric Schmidt was booed by students at Arizona State University after urging them to embrace the AI revolution. The reaction highlights a growing divide between corporate optimism and student anxiety regarding job security, the authenticity of tech leadership, and the disruptive nature of automation in the modern job market.
Eric Schmidt was booed during a speech where he talks about AI.
So many of these people say like, oh yeah, AI is not going to take away jobs.
But it's such a joke.
It's so ridiculous.
I mean, there's already jobs being taken on by AI.
Welcome to another episode of Silicon Valley Front Row.
I'm here with David and today we have some interesting news we want to talk about.
Eric Schmidt was booed during a speech where he talks about AI.
Yeah, and who's Eric Schmidt?
What did I say?
Who's Eric Schmidt?
Just for those that don't know, I mean.
So Eric Schmidt is a former Google CEO.
And I think he's been on the board for a few years, but he's not the CEO anymore.
So I think what happened is 2001 or so when Google was formed, or maybe later,
Larry Page and Sergey Brin, these students guys, right?
They're super smart, but they didn't know how to run a company.
So I guess Mark Zuckerberg from Facebook supposedly knew how to run a company,
so he stayed the CEO.
But these guys hired a CEO.
So they hired Eric Schmidt to be the CEO.
Got it.
But then I think they took over after a while.
So anyway, but sure enough, Eric Schmidt ended up a super billionaire and everything.
Makes sense.
Yeah.
So tech guy, what do you know about this?
He had this speech at Arizona State University, right?
Yeah, the University of Arizona.
And he got booed from basically about 9,000 students,
bachelor's degrees, master's, and several others.
But he started, he was one of the last speakers, I believe.
And he was booed multiple times whenever he mentioned AI and telling the students to accept
it and that they're able to shape it, but they got to accept it.
And they didn't like that.
What's your thoughts on it?
What do you know?
Well, I really think kind of very highly of students.
I think they're really smart.
They're kind of tending not to be politically correct.
And if someone is being told to them that obvious is not true, they kind of see through it.
So, so many of these people say like, oh yeah, AI is not going to take away jobs.
But it's such a joke.
It's so ridiculous.
I mean, there's already jobs being taken on by AI.
There's the whole point of having AI to do some jobs that supposedly people don't want
to do or don't have to do.
So to tell them that, no, we're not going to take your jobs or we're going to take these
jobs or give you different jobs.
I think that's baloney.
I think that it's obvious that jobs are going to be taken.
So I think the students very clearly see through it, especially when it's so hard not to get
a job for a student.
Yeah.
Even with the degrees.
Yeah.
Right?
Yeah.
So they see that, they talk to each other.
So there's a thing like you, you hear someone telling you some top CEO telling you something,
but when you try to get a job, you can't get it.
So you kind of see the reality.
So they're kind of, they're the ones that are feeling the bottom end of it.
Exactly.
Yeah.
I mean, I just want to say like, congratulations to the class of 2026 that graduated.
Yeah.
And hopefully they're able to find, make use of their degrees and move forward.
Yeah.
Well, I think we're going to go through this little short video.
The whole speech was three hours, but we're going to go this video.
But before that, I want to, so I don't know if you, have you seen these ads from Artisan
AI?
It's a company called Artisan AI.
They're based in San Francisco and they have this ads on bus stops and buses.
And you know, they keep saying, stop hiring humans.
Yeah.
I think we, we, we talked about this a while ago, right?
Yeah, we did.
We did.
Yeah.
It's the same company.
Yeah.
But they keep having these ads and, and their CEO, his name is Jasper Carmichael or whatever.
He's saying that he's doing this intentional rage bait or shock marketing to generate attention.
Oh, that's a technique.
I guess it's a technique.
Yeah.
That's what he's saying.
But I think in so many ways, the lines with reality.
So I think people can sense that.
But, but let's, let's play some of this video and kind of analyze it clip by clip.
And again, not the three hour video, but.
Yeah.
So the three hour has like the ceremony and multiple speakers.
We just want to get to the part where Eric Schmidt is speaking.
Yeah.
Right.
Okay.
So here's like some clips.
So we'll start from the very beginning.
So I think the first thing he's saying is that we can only hear the architects.
I'm assuming he's saying like, you are the architects of artificial intelligence.
And they booed.
They booed after that pretty, pretty harshly.
And then he looks kind of surprised.
He's saying, interesting.
There's a lot of booing.
So now the second thing he's saying is that the question is whether you will shape artificial
intelligence.
So he's trying to make it sound like students will get involved, will be in charge, will
take the lead to shape and to make it bigger.
And I guess have jobs in that sense.
Right.
If they have this.
Yeah.
And you would think they would be excited, but there's more booze right after he said
that.
So that's pretty funny to me because they're not taking it.
So let's see what he says next.
We do not know.
I know what many of you are feeling about that.
I can hear you.
So now he's trying to be compassionate and understanding.
And he's saying, I know what many of you are feeling about that.
And there's more booze.
It's definitely an interesting conversation.
But I think the first thing he said that when students booed was that he compared the AI
revolution with the industrial revolution or with the computer revolution or whatever.
Yeah.
So I don't think students took it.
And again, I think they can see through much better than a lot of people.
I'm very impressed with the students.
Yeah, exactly.
Exactly.
And I think they don't have that baggage that older people have, the adults have.
I've been told this, so I have to believe it because there's this top CEO that's telling
me, so he must be correct.
Oh, that's true.
And they can research anything they want.
Like really quick.
Hey, so while we're on this topic about the comparison of computer and AI, how old were
you when the computers started getting more mainstream?
Probably like 20.
Yes.
So were you afraid of it?
Because that was when you were kind of in college, right?
Yeah.
So what did you think about that?
No, I wasn't afraid at all.
It was more like a gadget.
I know, I don't know if you remember Wheel of Fortune used to be a...
The show?
Yeah, the show.
So I know you still have this first computer.
My dad got it.
And you can play Wheel of Fortune on the computer.
So I thought that was really cool.
You know, you press the space bar and the wheel turns and it stops at the letter.
So I used to play that.
But no, no.
But it was a very small part of life, right?
Even though computers are coming out.
Yeah.
But maybe you look at it for 20 minutes per day, you know, and then you forget about it.
And you know, it wasn't like that significant of a change.
I see.
And this was like during like early 2000s?
No, I said late 80s.
Oh, really?
Yeah, like 88, 89.
Yeah.
Okay, okay.
Oh, sorry, sorry.
No, because you're...
Yeah, yeah.
So I'm sure after it accelerated that rate.
But in the very beginning, it wasn't like a big part of one's life.
I see.
Yeah, it didn't take away jobs or it wasn't that impactful.
Still in the early stages.
Yeah.
So AI, it's definitely a bigger impact.
Even, you know, it's hard to compare, you know, in that sense.
But apples to apples.
But it looks like a much, much bigger impact.
Because it's not like you use it for like a few minutes,
and then you're back to your normal life.
It's like your whole normal life changes.
Oh, wow.
That is crazy.
Let's see if there's anything else he says after this.
Because I thought there was...
So now he's trying to reason with them and understand that.
Know what many of you are feeling about that.
He's like, I can hear you.
Booing, a lot of fear.
There's fear, there's a lot of booing.
If you don't care about...
Now he changed.
If you don't care about science, that's okay.
I think he's trying to assume that the students in the audience
are probably like other majors or whatever.
Because AI is going to touch everything else as well.
And then he's saying AI is going to touch everything else as well.
I don't think that's going to...
It's going to have a good impact because it makes it even worse.
Oh, look at the boos.
That's like...
Yeah, it's really loud.
It's a lot harder.
He doesn't see the advice at the end.
I don't know how far I'm going to go with this.
But yeah, now he's trying to convince them.
He's saying, find a way to say yes.
So he's like almost saying there's no other option.
Which might be right in some way, but it's not always absolute.
And being told, hey, you got to accept this.
There's no other way.
Yeah, it doesn't really give people hope.
Exactly.
You know, yeah.
I see why the students did not like that.
Yeah, I mean, it seems like he probably knows something that they don't.
And he's trying to push this on them.
Yes, yes.
But I think...
It looks like some degree of brainwashing, right?
Because you're trying to convince someone of something that they don't agree with.
And to make it like a fact.
And they clearly don't agree with it.
It's some level of brainwashing, I think.
I mean, I think he could have his own opinion.
But it seems like what he's saying sounds like...
There's no other way.
Yeah, he sounds like he's trying to say this is what's going to happen.
Like he has a crystal ball.
So to me, that's a little...
That's got a little bit alarming.
Yeah, yeah.
Like, I mean, I could see why they want students to accept it.
Because then they're the next generation of leaders.
And once the students accept it, it could also bring more acceptance of AI.
And that could help his industry.
Because that's his field.
Right, right.
But it's bad for the students.
Because they clearly can see that we're not helping them.
I mean, it may help some consumer down the street having a robot in their house to do their laundry.
But it's not helping them to get jobs.
Or to have a meaningful life, for that matter.
Did you hear about the students using AI for their projects?
A little bit.
There's many stories.
Yeah.
Yeah, like I recently heard about how one girl saw that...
It was at an Ivy League school that the students have to click this checkmark or something
that says, I did not use AI to complete my homework, right?
And apparently, she saw somebody clicking that.
And then in the next window on the computer, there was ChatGPT open.
And the person was on a yacht, like at a party.
So, I mean, maybe it's coincidental.
Maybe they had it open and didn't use it.
Yeah, but that was pretty...
But again, it is an honor system.
So you just click it.
This doesn't check on you, I guess.
Yeah, we're not sure how accurate it is if it checks for AI, too.
Because now you have these...
Isn't there like AI programs that are called humanize?
Humanize the AI results?
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
So maybe it writes something or does a task.
And then there's another program that you run that humanizes it.
So whatever other tool would check on it to see if it's AI, it tricks that tool.
That's all it does.
Because a human already probably cannot tell.
Can you tell if something's written by AI?
I'm not sure about written.
Yeah, written may be difficult.
But with videos, sometimes it's super obvious.
It's getting harder to tell.
But sometimes it's really obvious.
With writing, I think it's hard.
For me, because I'm on Twitter a lot, looking through to find out information.
And I could tell, or I think I could tell, because usually there's a phrase.
And then it always usually says something like, this is not that, but this is this.
If that makes sense.
It would say something, it would describe something.
Yeah.
And then there would be a sentence that's like, just like a few words.
Saying like, this is, and it would say like, it's very, like as if it was a factual statement.
Right, right, right.
I'm not sure if I'm explaining that right.
So you think that that's like a kind of red flag, that it's AI?
Yeah, I think, to me, I feel like that's a pattern.
If something's AI generated, it usually uses this outline.
Yeah.
And if you could compare it, it kind of makes sense.
Because I've seen it before.
Interesting.
But whatever it is, it may change, you know.
Because if anyone senses that that's the pattern that is going to change, right?
It could, yeah.
Well, I think the difference between reality and either AI or imagination or fakeness,
it's becoming smaller and smaller.
Like, it's going to be harder to tell if something is real or not.
So, yeah.
Let's just, for the heck of it, let's see if he says anything else interesting here.
Let me give you some advice.
First, find a way to say yes.
Listen.
You bring the judgment.
You bring the conscience.
You bring the perspective.
Thank you very much.
He was booed almost throughout.
That's like a shortened version, right?
I think they cut out certain parts of that.
Yeah, yeah.
Maybe they just kept most of the boos.
But even if they did, there's a lot of boos.
Yeah.
So, what are your thoughts about Eric Schmidt's speech and the students' reaction?
Do you feel the reaction was warranted and the students can see through something?
Or was it just a fluke?
That's a wrap for Silicon Valley Front Row.
I'm David.
This is Steve Vispas.
Thank you for watching, and we'll see you next time.
Why, what's kind of interesting, this whole area...