Adding HAND GUARDS on weapons that don't need them

"Echo Blade "
1 follower
Nov 23, 2025
It's not uncommon to see hand guards added to weapons that don't normally have them.
Sensible design choice or just catering to noobs?
Hey folks, Matt Heaton here, scholar gladiatorian. Now many of you familiar with cookeries from my
channel because you all know I'm a big fan. In fact this video isn't cookery specific at all,
this is just a general observation on the design of weapons and this could be modern knives,
it could be Asian weapons like the tolwars and katanas and wakizashis behind me, it could be
European medieval weapons, it could be ancient world Greek and Roman Egyptian weapons as well.
Now one of the things I often talk about on my channel is handguards. Now the reason I've grabbed
a cookery is that these don't have handguards. We'll talk a little bit a bit more about that
in a second but we're going to talk generally about how handguards aren't always there to
protect the hand in the way that you might obviously think. Many of you watching this
channel will know that. And also that in the modern world I think we sometimes fixate on
handguards because of modern cultural bias and also because we don't really understand how to
use those specific tools, certainly in the maybe in some cases limited ways that they were used
historically or ethnographically. I just want to mention incidentally these cookeries are awesome,
I've got a fairly decent collection of cookeries as you know. If you're interested in seeing my
cookery videos and you haven't done already just search for cookery under my videos and you will
find a whole bunch more videos on cookeries. But this specific example is from the Nepalese cash
which came out of Nepal in the early 2000s from with Atlanta Cutlery and also IMA as well. I'll
stick a link below if you're interested in getting one of these. It is, it has to be said, an ever
dwindling supply despite the fact thousands of these came out of Nepal with that Nepalese cash.
These were 100% authentic and used by the Nepal army by the Gurkhas and they are traditionally
made and they're a really great resource. So if you're interested in getting one of these
I highly recommend you check out that link below because as I say they are gradually running out
they're not going to last forever. So I'm very glad I've got a couple of these and I think I'm
probably going to get a few more before all the good ones go. But back to the main topic of the
video. The fact is that a lot of people in the modern world will look at something like this and
go I can improve that by adding a hand guard onto it. Now this isn't a new thing. What I have here
and I have shown this on the channel before but not for a while it's quite a lot probably a couple
of years ago now, is a cookery with a hand guard on it. Now I've noticed I'm actually talking to
a couple of modern cookery manufacturers today who are out in Nepal making cookeries the traditional
way and they get lots of custom requests for custom orders where people essentially look at a
form of traditional cookery but then they make changes to it to suit their modern whims. There's
nothing wrong with that. This isn't a video criticizing that or anything else. I think that's
actually a really cool idea because it's continuing the tradition, continuing the evolution of the
cookery and this happened before. As I mentioned this is a probably end of the 19th century or
early 20th century, essentially probably made for a European, probably British as a hunting knife.
So it's someone who was in India who wanted a big old hunting knife for going hunting tigers or
boars, pig sticking, doing whatever they were doing and they wanted a bush knife, a hunting knife
and so they thought well cookeries are awesome but they made a few changes to it which I've
talked about in previous videos. Obviously it's a almost a bowie knife, European style hunting
grip as is found on lots of Anglo-Indian British empire hunting knives. Then you've got a little
ferrule at the top which is a particularly European style. You've got a, you'll notice it's like a
letter S guard which you find on a lot of hunting knives and particularly from the British empire
of that time and then there's even an adaptation to the blade apart from the fact that it's kind
of bigger than normal to make it potentially suitable for thrusting by adding a false edge
on the spine and you'll notice of course that a traditional cookery is thick and completely blunt
on the back so it only has an edge on the front whereas this one although it's not sharpened on
the false edge it's given a spear point so you could use this for thrusting. Now why did they
add a guard to it? Well they added a guard to it partly because they weren't Nepalese, almost
certainly, they were someone who was used to using a hunting knife and from the shape of the blade we
assume that they were planning at some point to maybe stab something with it. So a hand guard in
that situation is a pretty good thing if you're not trained in the use of cookeries, number one.
Secondly if you're going to use it as a stabbing implement then it's good to prevent it as a hand
stop, sorry to add it as a hand stop and you'll notice that with some of the Japanese swords
behind me although they although they have small suba or hand guards in fact I've got an antique
one here although they've got small hand guards these aren't guards in the way that we often think
about being a hand guard with European swords such as the sabre guard or rapier hilt or whatever
in that they do provide some degree of protection from an opponent's blade certainly if it slides
down your own blade but by and large that hand guard is perhaps there as a hand stop is to
prevent your hand from going up onto the blade and in fact they don't provide an awful lot of
protection to the hand at all certainly not against direct attacks and in fact in Japanese
martial arts there are direct attacks at the hand and at the arm that completely bypass the hand
guard the hand guard doesn't offer any protection in that regard and your protection of your
digits and your limbs in that in that situation is completely dependent on your swordsmanship
skills and your you know moving essentially your distance your timing and putting your hands out
of harm's way so you don't rely on a hand guard for hand protection in that sense but hand guard
nevertheless serves other purposes so when we look at something like a kukri is it a good idea to add
a hand guard well quite simply if you aren't particularly adept at using a kukri in the 19th
and earlier centuries fashion which frankly we don't know an awful lot about we've got basic
descriptions of how kukris were used in the 19th century and earlier but we don't know a huge about
but what we can say is clearly hand guards weren't important to them they knew about hand guards
because the Nepalese had hand guards on the kora which is the native sword and they had access to
tolwars and other types of sword as well and indeed once they started interacting with the
British military they had access to western style sabers as well but nevertheless the kukri they
never regarded that this needed a hand guard with a couple of exceptions very occasionally you do
find sword hilted kukris absolutely so you do find like a tolwar hilt for example or even a
kanjar hilt sometimes on a kukri although by and large it's regarded that these are for Indians
rather than for Nepalese so the typical kukri wasn't regarded as needing a hand guard now
why is that well a number of things okay on a simple kind of overview it's because the way
that the kukri was used didn't require a hand guard so number one it is a short weapon that
you are not usually getting into any kind of blade-on-blade contact with an opponent with
an edged weapon the simple fact is that originally these were used either by themselves or with a
shield and you come to close quarters very very quickly where a hand guard is protecting your hand
is just not a particularly important thing because it's a big chopping knife secondly these weren't
really used to stab with as far as we can tell they were used to slice and chop with okay so
despite the fact they do have a point on here they never really accentuated the requirement for that
to be a particularly sharp point and as I pointed out in previous videos most traditional kukris
have a form of rib around the middle of the grip now what that does is when you're holding the
kukri correctly the bottom two fingers lock in under that rib and prevent the hand from sliding
up so even if you do stab someone with it it's very unlikely certainly if you're gripping it
correctly that the hand can slide up the grip onto the blade because you've got that rib in the middle
of the grip which some people find uncomfortable now the funny thing is in the later 19th century
and into the 20th century a lot of westerners didn't like that rib in the middle of the grip
they found it uncomfortable and so they did away with it and in doing away with it it makes having
a cross guard necessary so you know it's sometimes you have to understand why a weapon is precisely
designed that way to understand why certain elements of it are designed that way and the
things have to interconnect it's a system okay so quite simply when you get things like this with a
hand guard on that are not traditional to that type of weapon it is usually indicative of the
fact that either this weapon is being used by someone who's essentially a noob to that weapon
someone who doesn't really understand the traditional use of that weapon or it's a an
affectation from their culture okay so it could be just simply because because they come from a
culture that has hand guards on their hunting knives they want a hand guard on their hunting
knife they might not necessarily need it they might perfectly know how to use a kukri but they
just want a hand guard anyway well finally it's because they've taken a traditional implement
like this and they're going to use it in a different context and in a different way and
now a hand guard becomes necessary you could extrapolate this to things like the d guard
bowie knife from the confederate side during the u.s civil war as well and various other weapons
throughout history and then if we take another example the kyuganto the japanese sword which
has a saber style guard on an otherwise more or less otherwise a japanese style sword in that case
it's more to do with the fact that they're trying to look like they've got uniforms that look like
european uniforms so they're trying to look like european sources so european forces and try and
modernize and mechanize in an age when in the meiji era where the japanese military was trying to well
was becoming a modern military with battleships and gatling guns and everything else so there are
many reasons why you sometimes get a seemingly inappropriate thing like a guard on a bowie knife
or a d guard on a katana that are explained by numerous means are they necessary well if you're
using it a new way possibly yes they are necessary but sometimes they're not necessary and what i
would say is the good old humble traditional ways of making it could be a kukri it could be a
barong it could be a katana it could be anything you don't have to upgrade or change a weapon
that's perfectly adapted for using in a traditional way if you use it in a traditional way but you have
to know what that traditional way is and you have to learn it of course and once you have done and
you've understood the full system of that weapon then you don't necessarily need to change anything
about it at all for it to continue being an effective tool or weapon i hope this has been
thought-provoking i'll see you again soon back on the channel for another video cheers folks
thanks for watching we've got extra videos on patreon
please give our facebook a like and subscribe if you haven't already cheers folks
