The Distortion of Climate Data Using ‘Computer Models’

Facts Matter
2.9K followers
🇺🇸 Try The Epoch Times here: https://ept.ms/RomanSale
♥️ Get a free information kit from Ave Maria Mutual Funds to discover morally responsible investments that align with your pro-life, pro-family beliefs.
Visit https://avemariafunds.com/roman today to request your free kit.
Episode Resources:
🔵 Bill Gates Memo:
https://bit.ly/3LOEZZy
🔵 Heritage Foundation Report:
https://ept.ms/3yM9skJ
🔵 USDA Report Climate Model Report:
https://ept.ms/3V7LYy2
🔵 Drought Conditions:
https://ept.ms/3Vs8TVZ
🔵 Nature Magazine Paper:
https://ept.ms/3V8e3VR
🔵 Tornado Trends:
https://ept.ms/3X9tsYD
-
#billgates #climatechange #doomsday
© All Rights Reserved.
Ahead of the United Nations 30th annual
climate conference, otherwise known as
COP 30, Bill Gates released a memo that
you could say surprised a lot of people.
That's because in his memo, he seemingly
changed his position on climate change,
acknowledging for the first time ever
publicly that there is no doomsday risk
from global warming. Now, the memo
itself is pretty long. It's over 5,000
words and it's filled with data, graphs,
charts, and anecdotes laying out his
argument that climate change is not
going to lead to the end of
civilization. Secondly, that measuring
global temperatures is not the best
measure for progress on this particular
issue and that thirdly, the money being
spent on climate related issues would be
better allocated towards improving human
health as well as human prosperity. To
get an idea of his thesis, here was his
opening salvo in the memo. Quote, "There
is a doomsday view of climate change
that goes something like this. In a few
decades, cataclysmic climate change will
decimate civilization. The evidence is
all around us. Just look at all the heat
waves and storms caused by rising global
temperatures. Nothing matters more than
limiting the rise in temperature.
Fortunately for all of us, this view is
wrong. Although climate change will have
serious consequences, particularly for
people in the poorest countries, it will
not lead to humanity's demise. People
will be able to live and thrive in most
places on Earth for the foreseeable
future. Now, that's wild because that is
a complete 180 from the narrative that's
been pushed over the last decade plus.
And as just one example of thousands,
right here in New York City, over in
Union Square, there's this massive
doomsday clock looking over the city,
which is literally counting down second
by second the time that we have left
before the supposed effects of global
warming become irreversible. That clock,
by the way, it was set up right around
the time when you had several lawmakers
here in the US begin to float the idea
publicly that we only had 12 years left
before the world ends. Here was, for
instance, AOC speaking on this issue
back in 2019.
Millennials and people and you know Gen
Z and all these folks that come after us
are looking up and we're like the world
is going to end in 12 years if we don't
address climate change and your biggest
issue is
your your biggest issue is how are we
going to pay for it? And it was a few
months after that speech when that clock
in Union Square in New York, which by
the way just used to be a normal clock,
which told the time, it was changed to
instead be a countdown doomsday clock.
And so given this context, this new memo
that came from Bill Gates is a real sea
change. In fact, when he was asked
specifically about the way that this
memo will be perceived by the hardline
climate activist types, here is what
Bill Gates said on a segment over at
CNBC. when the climate activists who who
have been very supportive of what you've
done and you've been very supportive of
what they done read this and and if
Greta if Greta Thunderberg is reading
this and saying to herself my goodness
he seems like he is reversing himself
what would you tell her I'd say wasn't
the goal here to improve human lives and
shouldn't we in our awareness of how
little generosity there is to help
measure, you know, should we get them a
measles vaccine or should we do some
climate uh related activity and if if we
could take if we stop funding all
vaccines and that, you know, saved you
0.1 degree, would that be a smart
tradeoff? That's the kind of question we
have to ask. Uh so I'm a climate
activist, but I'm also a child survival
activist. And indeed with the publishing
of that memo, it appears that the
Overton window on this particular
subject has really shifted. In fact, I
mean, there was a period of time just a
few years ago when publishing a video on
YouTube saying basically the same thing
as Bill Gates is saying now would have
gotten your video and maybe even your
channel demoted and then subsequently
the legacy news outlets would come out
and write hit pieces against you. But
now that's changed. For instance, after
he published that memo, the front page
of the New York Times website was
promoting a guest essay that was titled,
"Bill Gates has a point." And so, we're
living basically in a new world. And
just to give you an idea of how drastic
this change in narrative actually is,
let's jutapose Bill Gates's new position
with something that Al Gore said during
a presentation at the 2023 World
Economic Forum. And again, just two
short years ago. And all the greenhouse
gas pollution is now trapping as much
extra heat as would be released by
600,000
Hiroshima class atomic bombs exploding
every single day on the earth. That's
what's boiling the oceans, creating
these atmospheric rivers and the rain
bombs and sucking the moisture out of
the land and creating the droughts and
melting the ice and raising the sea
level and causing these waves of climate
refugees. Then roughly just a year later
in 2024, you had that same apocalyptic
doomsday message echoed by the UN
Secretary General who said the following
during a United Nations environmental
assembly. Quote, "Our planet is on the
brink. Ecosystems are collapsing. Our
climate is imploding. And humanity is to
blame." And so obviously a stark
contrast to the much more measured
statement coming from Bill Gates just a
year later. And so given this new
development as well as at least
supposedly this new paradigm wherein we
can actually discuss this topic openly,
I think it's a good opportunity to look
under the hood and examine how exactly
these doomsday narratives were pushed
over the last several years. Because
despite the huge number of articles that
have been published and speeches like
this saying basically that there's
universal consensus in the scientific
community surrounding the climate, not
all scientists agree. And the ones that
don't agree, they're not quacks. Case in
point, you have Mr. John Clauser who won
the Nobel Prize in physics back in the
year 2022. And Mr. Clauser, he saw the
data a bit differently. Speaking about
the topic, here's what he said. Quote,
"The popular narrative about climate
change reflects a dangerous corruption
of science that threatens the world's
economy and the well-being of billions
of people. Misguided climate science has
metastasized into massive shock
journalism, pseudocience. In my opinion,
there is no real climate crisis." And so
the question that naturally arises out
of this is how can there be such a vast
discrepancy on a topic as extensively
researched as the climate? I mean this
isn't like a small difference of
opinion. These are two completely
different views on the very
fundamentals. On the one hand you had
people saying that the oceans are
literally being boiled and the earth is
on the brink. On the other hand you have
people saying there is no real climate
crisis at all. Well we here at the Epic
Times we were able to speak with Mr.
Steven Kunan. He's a theoretical
physicist, a faculty professor over at
NYU, and he was previously the under
secretary for science in the US
Department of Energy under President
Barack Obama. And having studied the
production of climate related data for
the last several decades, Professor
Kunan told us here at the Epic Times
that quote, "I've watched a growing
chasm between what the politicians, the
media, and the NOS's were saying and
what the science actually said. Nobody
has an incentive to portray scientific
truth and facts." Now, Professor Kunan
published a book several years ago
titled Unsettled: What Climate Science
Tells Us, What It Doesn't and Why It
Matters. That book went on to become a
bestseller. And what it essentially did
is to analyze the process by which
climate data goes from these dense
thousandpage scientific reports into
headline news for public global
consumption. If you want to check out
that book for yourself, I'll throw a
link to the Amazon page for it. You can
find it down in the description box
below, which I should mention is that
description box right below those like
and subscribe buttons, both of which I
hope you smash so this content can reach
ever more people. All right, I'd like to
pause here for a super quick moment in
order to introduce today's new sponsor,
A Maria Mutual Funds. They have a
pro-life and pro-f family focus that
lets you match your mutual fund
investments to your moral beliefs. You
no longer have to choose one over the
other. Basically, when selecting
investment opportunities, a Maria uses a
special moral screening process to
completely eliminate companies that are
engaged in any form of support for
abortion, for pornography, or for
embriionic stem cell research. They also
screen out companies that make any
corporate contributions to Planned
Parenthood. They have a zero tolerance
policy. And so a Maria mutual funds,
they will not invest in any company with
an offending activity, even if that
activity is small in relation to the
company's size. And so even if it's like
a multi-billion dollar company and they
only give a few hundred dollars to some
pro-abortion cause, that's it. That
company is out. They basically have a
zero tolerance policy on such things.
And since their inception in the year
2001, a Maria, they've become the
largest family of Catholic mutual funds
in America, managing over 3.8 8 billion
of assets for investors. The family,
they offer seven different funds with
various investment objectives. This fund
lineup of theirs basically lets you
build a well-balanced, diversified
portfolio to pursue your long-term
financial goals like college, saving up
for retirement, or just creating an
income stream, all the while not having
to compromise on your morals. And so
perhaps take this sponsor read as a
sign. There has never been a better time
for you to align your investments with
your spiritual and your moral beliefs.
Get started now by visiting a
marafunds.com/roman.
And there you can request a free
information kit. You can also request a
kit by simply calling 1866 aaria. That's
avi
and use the promo code Roman over the
phone. And up on your screen right now,
it's like a legal disclosure that we
have to show. You can screenshot it,
maybe pause the video, read it through.
Uh but basically, check them out. They
are a great company and they bridge the
gap between wanting to make money in the
markets and saving up for your future
and your kids and college and
retirement, but at the same time not
having to invest in companies that you
absolutely, ideologically, spiritually,
morally don't believe in it. So check
them out. Again, the link will be down
there in the description box below. I
Maria, thank you so much for sponsoring
this episode. And now back to the video.
Now according to his book, one of the
most ubiquitous sources of this topline
climate data, it comes from an
organization called the IPCC, which
stands for the Intergovernmental Panel
on Climate Change. This particular
organization, it was established back in
the year 1988 by both the United Nations
as well as the World Meteorological
Organization. And according to their
website, the IPCC is a collection of
scientists and government appointees
that are dedicated to assessing the
science on climate change. And as a
practical matter, the IPCC, it functions
as both a scientific body, but also as a
political body. Quote, "The IPCC does
not conduct its own research, but rather
assembles teams of hundreds of
scientists in working groups that
collect reports from scientific journals
regarding climate change, its effects,
and what should be done about it. About
every seven years, an IPCC working group
called Working Group One synthesizes the
latest reports into assessment reports,
often several thousand pages thick,
which are then reviewed and edited by
government appointees from the 195
member nations. Now, two years ago in
2023, the IPCC released their sixth
assessment report. You can see it up on
your screen. However, the information
compiled in that report, while seemingly
objective, was perhaps a little bit less
so. Quote, "The information on which the
assessment reports are based often has a
bias from the start." Critics say,
"Because research grants typically fund
studies that support the prevailing
narrative on climate change, and because
scientific journals often avoid
publishing studies that suggest climate
change is not dire." Meaning that
because most scientific journals have
fallen in line with the prevailing
position regarding climate change,
papers that don't conform to that
prevailing conclusion have a hard time
getting published. And actually, those
papers have a hard time even getting
funded in the first place given the fact
that research grants are typically not
doowled out too easily on studies which
might poke holes in the climate change
narrative. And so even if you wind up
compiling thousands of these types of
studies, you might assume that you're
getting an accurate picture. However,
because there is distortion at the level
of the journals themselves, all the
underlying conclusions in the studies,
they've fallen into a type of group
think. For instance, when describing
this whole situation, you have Professor
William Happer, who is a professor of
physics over at Princeton University. He
told us here at the Epic Times the
following quote, "Any literature that
supports alarmism is promoted, and any
that does not is rejected. The source of
much of today's climate data comes from
centers whose generous funding would
cease if climate hysteria were to abate.
Likewise, you have Professor Richard
Linden, who is a professor of
meteorology over at MIT and who
actually, by the way, served as one of
the scientists on working group one at
the IPCC, which actually releases their
assessment reports. And he told us here
at the Epic Times the following quote,
"The IPCC itself is only studying
anthropogenic man-made climate change.
It doesn't do anything regarding natural
climate change. And there's a severe
technical shortcoming because you can't
do things like attribution unless you
know what natural variability is. And
here's the interesting part. Despite all
that, Professor Coin, he told us that
quote, "When you read the assessment
reports, focusing mostly on the science,
they're actually pretty good. The data
presented in the assessment reports is a
relatively sober analysis. However, it
provides little support for the
narrative of climate catastrophe, at
least as far as what has been observed
to date. As a concrete example of what
he means by this, if you look at chapter
12 of the most recent assessment report,
you'll find the IPCC's assessment on the
impact of extreme weather events. And
the tables that they provide in that
chapter, it show that extreme weather
events that have already emerged are
limited. Furthermore, it states a low
confidence for any increase in floods,
rainstorms, landslides, drought, fire
weather, cyclones, hurricanes,
tornadoes, sandstorms, dust storms,
hail, sea level rise, coastal flooding,
and erosion. It also indicates a low
confidence regarding a decrease in snow,
glaciers, ice sheets, as well as lake,
river, sea ice beyond the Arctic region.
Furthermore, it's perhaps worth noting
that those assessments from the UN's
IPCC are actually supported by the
findings of other organizations as well.
For instance, the National Oceanic and
Atmospheric Administration conducted a
30-year analysis of tornado trends, and
they found that quote, "The number of
strong and violent tornadoes hasn't
varied much since 1970." Likewise,
another report in Nature magazine from
the year 2022, it found a quote
declining tropical cyclone frequency
under global warming. On average, the
global annual number of tropical
cyclones has decreased by 13% in the
20th century compared with the
pre-industrial baseline. Likewise, the
drought severity index which is
published by the EPA, it shows that
quote no material increase in drought in
the United States between 1895 and 2020.
And so given this underlying reality,
you might have a very obvious question.
If all these different analyses,
including I should mention the analysis
from the UN themselves, if all of them
say one thing, why are news reports
inundated with the our climate is
imploding and the oceans are boiling
narratives? And the answer to that
question appears to be twofold. Firstly,
the public statements coming from both
the IPCC as well as the UN, they often
diverge dramatically from from what
their own scientific reports actually
say. And then secondly, the predictions
of a dire future are based on models
rather than observations. That's because
alongside each of these assessment
reports, the IPCC also releases a
summary for policy makers. This summary,
it distills down the large amount of
data in the full report to just a short
list of bullet points. Furthermore, to
make it even easier for news outlets to,
I guess, follow the correct narrative,
the IPCC, it also produces headline
statements as well as press releases to
provide a concise narrative on climate
change. Here is how Professor Kunan
described the effect that all this has.
Quote, the assessment report gets boiled
down to the summary for policy makers.
And while it's drafted by scientists, a
small number of them, the governments
have to approve the summary line by
line. And so you already have the
potential for let's say non-scientific
factors entering the summary for policy
makers itself is 20 to 30 pages and the
media have to cover that and they
typically will cherrypick the most
extreme parts of it. So that's how we
get the distortions and then that is
exacerbated by the politicians seeing
opportunity and distortion and the
NOS's. And so just as an example of what
he means by that, despite having no
increase in the number of tornadoes,
cyclones, droughts, wildfires, or floods
that's attributed to climate change, the
most recent IPCC headline statement, it
warns that quote, "There is a rapidly
closing window of opportunity to secure
a livable and sustainable future for all
with a very high confidence." And so
this actually all gets to the very heart
of the matter because much of the basis
for climate alarmism comes not from
observation but rather from computer
models. Models that are thought to be
highly accurate. For instance, the USDA
conducted a study of climate models
during a 50-year period between 1970 and
2020. And well, here's what they found.
Quote, observed changes in temperature
and precipitation have generally been
consistent with the changes projected by
earlier models. The accurate projections
of future climate and hine casting of
past climate makes us confident that
models can reliably project changes in
the climate. However, here too, if you
look beneath the surface of the climate
modeling industry and you just peel back
a few layers, it all becomes
questionable how reliable these
projections actually are. To that point,
speaking about these IPCC models, here
is what Professor Kunan told us here at
the Epic Times. Quote, "The IPCC draws
upon its predictions based on average
results from dozens of models which
disagree wildly with one another. The
average surface temperatures generated
by the models in IPCC reports vary among
themselves by around 3° C or three times
the amount of warming observed
throughout the 20th century. The
assessment reports downplay this
embarrassment by focusing not on the
actual temperature predictions where
models diverge but rather on the
predicted change in temperatures where
models are more likely to coincide. Then
on top of that there's the process of
tuning the models. Quote the models
typically divide the earth up into grid
cells each a few tens of square miles.
These grid cells are tuned in a process
of hardwiring the results from the cells
to manually account for more random
elements like cloud formations, storms
or humidity which the models can't
predict but are material to temperature
changes. Professor then went on to
outline some of the problems that are
present in that tuning process. Quote,
there are hundreds of such parameters
because the climate system is
complicated and has many different
dimensions. And so as people tune the
parameters differently, they get
different results. Tuning also helps the
models show results closer to observed
data. But this highlights another
shortcoming of the models. While
purporting to predict the future, they
often fail to reproduce historical
temperatures. They also struggle to
separate human influence from natural
phenomena. All of which elevates the
uncertainty of model predictions
regarding human behavior. If you're
trying as a politician or NGO or company
to promote a narrative, you don't want
to talk about the uncertainties. You
just want to say it's going to be 5
degrees warmer and the world is going to
hell. But obviously, I think we all know
up until last week with the publishing
of Bill Gates's new memo, if you
question that official narrative, well,
you are likely to be branded a climate
denier. However, here's the thing. If
you take away all the hyperbole, here's
what the underlying data actually shows
us. At least according to Professor
quote, modest warming since the
1900s, 1.3 degrees Celsius at the global
level. Despite that, by whatever measure
you want to use, lifespan, nutrition,
GDP, death rates from extreme events,
it's all going in a positive direction.
Sea level rise is continuing at just
about a foot a century. But the actual
and projected economic impacts of
warming are in the noise. Even the IPCC
says it's small compared to many other
things that determine human well-being.
And it's exactly the economic impacts
that usually are not discussed.
According to a report that was published
by the Heritage Foundation, quote,
"Modeling the cost and benefits to the
United States of complying with the
Paris Agreement and meeting the Biden
administration's goal of reducing
greenhouse gas emissions to 52% below
2005 levels by 2030 predicts these
policies would reduce global
temperatures by 0.5° at the end of the
century. Even with theoretical
efficiency, we find the cost of the
policy to be staggering. The economy
would in aggregate lose $7.7 trillion
dollars of GDP through 2040, which is
$87,000 per family of four. That's
already pretty bad. But consider that's
what the developed world will suffer. In
terms of the developing world, meaning
the third world, if you would call it
that, depriving them of fossil fuels
will have absolute severe consequences.
To that point, you have Professor Linden
from MIT tell us the following. quote,
"The billions of people who don't have
energy, who don't have modern
conveniences, they will be condemned to
perpetual poverty. CO2 has played an
important role in increasing
agricultural productivity. So, we'll see
everyone paying more for food and more
people starving. You are already seeing
tragic consequences even in the United
States where a whole generation of kids
has been told that they have no future.
They're not having children themselves
because what's the point of having
children in a world that's going to
self-destruct?" which actually brings us
back full circle to Bill Gates's memo.
One of essential arguments is that the
money currently being spent to
supposedly fight climate change has not
been spent well to the detriment of
other projects that could actually help
human development. And by helping human
development and getting people out of
poverty, it'll make them more resilient
to any climate related issues that might
come down the road. Quote, "Is the money
designated for climate being spent on
the right things?" I believe the answer
is no. Sometimes the world acts as if
any effort to fight climate change is as
worthwhile as any other. As a result,
less effective projects are diverting
money and attention from efforts that
will have more impact on the human
condition. He then later goes on to give
a more concrete reason to promote third
world prosperity over amorphous climate
projects. Quote, a few years ago,
researchers at the University of
Chicago's climate impact lab ran a
thought experiment. What happens to the
number of projected deaths from climate
change when you account for the expected
economic growth of low-income countries
over the rest of the century? The
answer, it falls by more than 50%. This
finding is exciting because it suggests
a way forward. Since the economic growth
that's projected for poor countries will
reduce climate deaths by half, it
follows that faster and more expansive
growth will reduce deaths by even more.
And economic growth is closely tied to
public health. So, the faster people
become prosperous and healthy, the more
lives we can save. And so, there you
have it. If you'd like to read the
entirety of Bill Gates's new memo, I
will throw a link to it. You'll be able
to find it down in the description box
below alongside the links to all my
research notes for the rest of this
episode. And leave your thoughts in the
comments below. Do you agree with Bill
Gates's assessment that focusing on
human health and prosperity is just the
best way forward overall? or do you
disagree with him and you believe that
the world is ending so soon that we
should divert all resources going to any
other project to battle the climate
change issue? Love to know your
thoughts. Please leave them in the
comments section below. I'll be reading
them tonight as well as well into the
week. And then until next time, I'm your
host Roman from the Epic Times. Stay
informed and most importantly, stay
free.
