Several Denisovan populations repeatedly interbred with modern humans. A new study of Denisovan admixture reveals that four highly divergent populations mixed with modern humans. Scientists believe that individuals from the most recently discovered hominin group (the Denisovans) who interbred with modern humans passed on some of their genes through a series of distinct interbreeding events that shaped early human history.
The discovery of a new human group in the Altai mountains known as Denisovans was one of the most exciting discoveries in human evolution in the last decade. Unlike Neanderthal remains, the Denisovan fossil record only includes a finger bone, jawbone, teeth, and skull fragments. Using the surviving Denisovan segments in modern human genomes, researchers discovered evidence of at least three previous introgression events from different Denisovan populations into modern humans.
The idea that a robust human skull is a primitive trait is a non-scientific idea.
In hunter-gatherer societies, a thick brow ridge may have been seen as a sign of intelligence.
We'll circle back to this idea later.
Several Denisovan populations repeatedly interbred with modern humans.
A new study of Denisovan admixture reveals that four,
highly divergent populations mixed with modern humans.
Scientists believe that individuals from the most recently discovered hominin group,
the Denisovans, who interbred with modern humans,
passed on some of their genes through a series of distinct interbreeding events
that shaped early human history.
The discovery of a new human group in the Altai Mountains known as Denisovans
was one of the most exciting discoveries in human evolution in the last decade.
Unlike Neanderthal remains, the Denisovan fossil record only includes a finger bone,
jaw bone, teeth, and skull fragments.
Using the surviving Denisovan segments in modern human genomes,
researchers discovered evidence of at least three previous introgression events
from different Denisovan populations into modern humans.
Each of them has varying degrees of relatedness to the sequenced Altai Denisovan,
indicating a complex relationship between these sister lineages.
Here, we examine the evidence that suggests that several Denisovan populations,
which most likely had a wide geographical range,
adapted to different environments and interbred with modern humans multiple times.
We then discuss how archaic variants have been influenced by demographic history,
negative and positive selection,
and conclude by suggesting potential new lines of research.
Subsequent genome analyses revealed that Denisovans diverged from Neanderthals
400,000 years ago,
and that at least two distinct Denisovan populations
interbred with ancestors of modern Asians.
Interestingly, it was once theorized that Neanderthals
evolved from a common ancestor with gorillas,
while humans evolved from a common ancestor with orangutans.
It is a common misconception that humans evolved suddenly and neatly from a single common ancestor,
but as we learn more,
we realize that interbreeding with different human species occurred
and helped shape who we are today.
However, using the surviving Denisovan segments in modern human genomes,
scientists have discovered evidence of at least three previous events
in which genes from different Denisovan populations
found their way into the genetic signatures of modern humans.
Each of these has varying degrees of relatedness to the sequenced Altai Denisovan,
implying a complex relationship between these sister lineages.
Several Denisovan populations,
which likely spanned Siberia to Southeast Asia
and Oceania to South America,
were adapted to different environments.
Given the fact that recent DNA studies
show that Papuan Highlanders interbred with a Denisovan-related group,
possibly as recently as 15,000 years ago,
we should be looking for skulls with so-called archaic-looking features
in Papua and Australia.
However, this archaic population is deeply divergent
from the Northern Denisovans population from Siberia and China.
Scientists identified another Denisovan population
which lived in Southeast Asia
that diverged around 363,000 years ago from the Siberian group.
The Denisovan lineage found in Australia and New Guinea
split off from the Northern Denisovans around 283,000 years ago,
suggesting they arrived in Australia and New Guinean around 300,000 years.
This would have given them ample time
to spread throughout the landmass known as Sahul,
which is the connected lands of New Guinea, Australian and Tasmania
during Ice Age sea levels.
This also means that this so-called Denisovan lineage
is as different from Northern Denisovans
as Neanderthals are from Homo sapiens.
Therefore, the Northern Denisovan skulls,
such as from China,
are not a good indicator of the skull morphology of this population.
Until the Denisovan genome was found,
many paleoanthropologists assumed
that South and East Asian populations of the early-late Pleistocene
were relict populations of Homo soloensis,
representing a relatively static population history
from the initial human habitation of Asia.
The Denisovan genome appears inconsistent with that static model
according to a recent study titled
How Australia Informs the Worldwide Pattern of Pleistocene Human Evolution.
There are no diagnostic skeletal remains of Denisovans to help with this,
and only limited inference is possible from the Denisovan range.
But if we begin with the assessment
that the sum of the ancestry of Australians
is from populations inhabiting regions closest to Australia,
one of the key conclusions of this research,
and are mindful that the Denisovan haplotypes
are unlikely to be from East Asians or Southeast Asian populations
as they are constituted today,
the other potential nearby source of Denisovan haplotypes
would be from the Homo soliensis specimens from the Solo River in Java.
We have no Homo soloensis DNA,
but in view of the anatomical comparisons presented here
and the geography of the region,
where else could the significant Denisovan contribution have come from?
According to the report,
WLH50 is the 29,000-year-old fossil of a large young-to-middle-aged male
found in dune deposits near Lake Ganpung,
one of the Walandra Lakes in New South Wales, Australia.
Its importance stems from the significant similarities
it appears to have with the nearby
and most probably earlier human sample from Java, Indonesia.
Two implications of these similarities are important,
the implications for human ancestry
and the implications for the place of Homo soloensis in human evolution.
Embedded in the bank of the Solo River,
in the shadow of the volcanoes of San Giran,
Homo soloensis remains a part.
Volcanism deeply affected life,
death and fossilization of Homo soloensis in eastern Java,
where the volcanic province has produced 100 fossils.
However, for a long time Homo soloensis did not find a real place in taxonomy
and in the scientific debate,
whereas Neanderthal is still famous for its cultural
or biological struggle against the ancestors of modern humans.
Experts claim that there was no overlap of Homo soloensis
with Homo sapiens in Java,
and that Homo sapiens arrived much later.
But many researchers are not convinced
because Homo soloensis fossil material
from other Javanese sites has yet to be properly dated,
and maybe even more recent.
The Homo soloensis remains are characterized
by more derived traits than more archaic Javan Homo soloensis,
most notably a larger brain size,
an elevated cranial vault,
reduced postorbital constriction,
and less developed brow ridges.
But the forehead is proportionally low
and also has a low angle of inclination.
The new study provides both a systematic
and comprehensive description of the WLH50 fossil
in a comparative context
and an interpretation of its place in human evolution.
A comparative analysis of the WLH50 cranium
is important for understanding its morphological pattern
and addressing its ancestry.
In particular, whether there are multiple ancestors
for WLH50 and other Australians
that include late Pleistocene Indonesians from Java.
Besides these anatomical considerations,
the issues also are framed by genetic analysis,
including both paleogenetics and observations
of mitochondrial and nuclear DNA from modern populations,
and we discuss their implications as well.
Investigators concluded that WLH50b
is a normal specimen
without evidence of pathology or deformation,
and that elements of its anatomy
are found throughout the Australian fossil record,
as it is known today.
The comparisons reveal WLH50
has substantial similarities to the Homo soloensis,
but not identity with them,
and a demonstrable pattern of multiple ancestors
that includes Homo soloensis
as part of the network of human evolution in Australasia.
WLH50 is much more robust
than any Australian hominid found previously.
In fact, it makes the cow swamp remains
look gracile by comparison.
This new specimen greatly reinforces
the regional continuity linking Indonesia and Australia.
The morphological sequence found in Australia
shows clearly that regional features
must be separated from grade features seen worldwide
in order to understand the differing patterns
of late Pleistocene human evolutionary change.
It has been said that WLH50
has many of the same features as Homo soloensis,
but some of WLH50's most notable characteristics include
a thick brow ridge,
unusually thick and dense cranial vault,
a large cranial capacity of 1590 cubic centimetres,
an extended neck area for muscle attachment,
occipital bun, and robust size.
Could this robustness have been seen as a sign of intelligence
rather than as archaic?
We can only speculate what the ancients believed.
According to the recent African origin theory,
the archaic humans from Indonesia
are classified as Homo soloensis,
a different evolutionary species
that could not have contributed
to the ancestry of modern Australasians.
Therefore, this theory of complete replacement
makes clear predictions concerning the ancestry
of the specimen WLH50.
The fossil is potentially only 14,000 years old.
According to gamma spectroscopy
and thermal ionisation mass spectrometry
uranium series dating,
it has been suggested that the latter technique
provides a minimum age for this fossil
due to the fact that uranium uptake
begins following burial.
Meanwhile, ESR dating techniques calculated
that the bone fragment was 29,000 plus or minus
5,000 years old.
However, even under the most generous interpretations
of lineage divergence,
different putative ancestors of WLH50
have not been separated for long enough
for significant reproductive isolation to be expected.
This assessment is also supported
by the analysis of nuclear DNA
and by observed mixtures of both Neanderthal
and Denisovan nuclear DNA
with each other and in many human populations.
Meanwhile, the pattern of variation outside Africa
appears to reflect interbreeding among populations
that were much more separate during the period
before 100,000 years ago,
including the Neanderthals and Denisovans.
This historical pattern is not uncommon among mammals
for which reproductive incompatibility
has rarely evolved in a period
shorter than one million years.
The recurrence of this pattern within and outside Africa
and the geographic specificity
of Denisovan and Neanderthal descendants
both show that interbreeding among these ancient people
recurred within their habitats.
Neanderthals and Denisovans
were part of the biological species Homo sapiens.
Therefore, today's people around the world
are a relict mixture of populations
from an ancient species much more genetically
and morphologically diverse than now.
Accepting that Neanderthals and Denisovans
are sister groups within the species Homo sapiens,
there remains a fundamental difference between them.
As far as the fossil record is concerned,
we cannot identify who the Denisovans are.
While there are almost certainly Denisovan fossils
in the hands of paleoanthropologists today,
we cannot recognize them.
And it is even possible that there never was
a recognizable sample of Denisovans
in the sense that there is a recognizable sample
of European Neanderthals.
Surprisingly, the Denisovan contribution
to the nuclear DNA of populations
from New Guinea and Australia
is some 25 times greater
than the aforementioned contributions
to mainland Asia and the Americas.
The highest frequencies of Denisovan nuclear DNA
in living populations
are found in indigenous Australians
and similar or slightly less in New Guineans.
More broadly, current populations
with significant amounts of Denisovan DNA
are only found east of Wallace's line.
However, speculation surrounds
the exact age of this fossil
and a debate concerning its ancestry
in relation to other late Pleistocene humans
as well as Homo soloensis
due to their close resemblance to one another.
An ongoing debate within paleoanthropology
is whether to place Homo soloensis
as Homo sapiens or Denisovans.
Evaluating this ancestry
is important to our understanding
of modern human origins in Australasia
because the prevailing models of human origins
make different predictions
for the ancestry of this specimen
and others like it.
The Out of Africa theory,
also known as the Replacement theory,
predicts that late Pleistocene Africans
are direct ancestors of WHL50
and that the Homo soloensis
are not direct ancestors of Australians.
With the discovery of the so-called Denisovans,
many now believe that Homo soloensis
could be southern Denisovans.
In fact, evidence of a southeast Asian location
for the Denisovan admixture
thus suggests that Denisovans
were spread across a wider ecological
and geographic region
from the deciduous forests of Siberia
to the tropics
than any other hominin
with the exception of modern humans.
Homo soloensis' last appearance
coincides with a time
when the world shifted from a glacial period
to an interglacial period
and temperatures rose.
Java, which is now mostly rainforest,
was covered in woodlands
during this cold spell.
The coldest and driest conditions
most likely occurred around 135,000 years ago
exposing the Sunda Shelf
and connecting the major Indonesian islands
to the continent.
By 125,000 years ago
the environment had become
substantially warmer and wetter
transforming Java into an island
and allowing tropical rainforests to expand.
Judging by the sheer number of specimens
deposited at the same time,
there may have been a sizable population
of Homo soloensis
before the volcanic eruption
which resulted in their internment
but population is difficult to approximate
with certainty.
The Javanese site was some distance away
from the northern coast of the island
but it is unclear where the southern shoreline
and the mouth of the Solo River
would have been.
Cannibalism and ritual headhunting
have also been proposed
based on the conspicuous lack of any remains
other than the skullcap.
This had been reinforced
by the historic practice of headhunting
and cannibalism
in some recent Indonesian, Australian
and Polynesian groups
which at the time were believed to have descended
from these Homo soloensis populations.
Perhaps the horde was taken by surprise and fled.
Perhaps the skulls were put down
to mark off the area.
It seems that even today
various tribes in New Guinea
demarcate their dwelling or hunting grounds
in a similar manner.
They evidently suppose
that the spirit dwelling in the skull
can help them to defend a particular area
against invaders.
And with that statement
we leave you to ponder the mysteries
of our human history.
Until next time stay curious
and stay questioning.