Supercritical Turbines: The NEXT Generation Power Source

Engine Nation
3 followers
The combined cycle gas turbine is one of the most efficient ways to produce power today.
The turbine is really similar to a jet engine. It works by compressing air,
mixing it with fuel, and igniting in the combustor. This creates a high temperature,
high pressure exhaust, and the exhaust flows through a series of blades, or the turbine.
The main difference is that the turbine is utilizing mechanical rotation
to power a generator instead of producing thrust.
Inside the generator, the shaft rotates magnets,
and this provides a moving magnetic field. It's pretty much an inverse electric motor.
This generates electricity in the coils, and this provides power to the grid.
When we look at a unit, we typically measure its efficiency.
The general equation for efficiency is energy output over energy input times 100%.
This is broken down into the turbine and the actual generator,
and these two components are multiplicative of each other to get an overall efficiency of the
system. Aside from hydrogen, natural gas has one of the highest energy contents per mass,
and this is why it has a relatively high efficiency when compared to other fuel sources.
Some of the largest gas turbines in the world, on a single cycle,
can provide around 400 megawatts of power at 40% efficiency,
and this is enough to power 300,000 average North American homes.
Yet, these units can be improved more, and it comes down to the question of
what happens to the hot exhaust gas when it leaves the turbine.
Surely, there is something that we can do to utilize all these hot temperatures
and recover more efficiency, and this is where combined cycle comes into play.
The hot exhaust gases can be sent to a secondary system to boil water.
The water converts into steam, and then this can feed into a secondary generator,
and this is why it's called a combined cycle, because you have the Brayton gas cycle which
is burning the fuel and turning the turbine, and then you have the secondary Rankine steam cycle,
and these two things are thermodynamically coupled,
and this can increase the overall efficiency of the system.
As of right now, there are units that can achieve 64% efficiency,
and this is only superseded by France's turbines that are utilized in hydroelectric dams.
So, what about other power sources like coal?
Well, the problem is that coal is not injected into the turbine itself.
It doesn't have that Brayton cycle capability.
It only has the second half of the combined cycle, where it has to burn
heat water in a boiler and turn it into steam to turn the turbine.
Some coal plants can utilize a multi-stage or multi-turbine system as well.
This would route the steam back to the boiler,
and then be sent to an intermediate pressure turbine to generate more power.
Supercritical units can reach around 50% efficiency,
which is still quite a bit short of a dual combined gas cycle.
When it comes to nuclear energy, there is also the inherent problem of a loss of thermal efficiency,
because it is once again purely working on a steam cycle.
Fission produces the heat, the cooling transfers it, and then steam is produced from water.
Once again, it turns a turbine, and you can achieve about 37% thermal efficiency.
But you have to also keep in mind that there is way higher energy
densities when it comes to nuclear fission.
And a small uranium pellet can produce as much energy as a ton of coal,
or 17,000 cubic feet of natural gas.
Now, I want to make the point that I really oversimplified this video so far,
because I have only talked about efficiency,
which is a good thing to talk about when it comes to the engineering aspect,
but I have not covered the economic viability of each power source.
There is definitely additional costs when it comes to the supply chain of natural gas,
and dependent on geopolitical situations,
it may not be the best answer for every country or every region out there.
Now, what I do like about nuclear power is that it's great for isolated systems like space.
And that also brings me to the next point, which is nuclear fusion.
In the future, we could definitely see nuclear fusion take a prominent stance on power generation.
But one thing to keep in mind is that there has yet to be a reactor which has even come
close to producing net energy gains on the electrical grid.
One of the leaders when it comes to tokamak designs is the spark.
But it only can achieve a Q engineering of approximately 0.5
to sustain the reaction and power all the components in the reactor.
There are predictions that you would need a Q engineering value of 20
just to be competitive with the other fuel sources that I've talked about.
You can arguably say that the wildcard to this type of reactor is the superconducting magnet.
And if we can generate ones that can operate at higher temperatures at greater Tesla,
then maybe this could be a feasible power source in the future, but likely not anytime soon.
And yes, there are other methods to achieve fusion like field reverse configuration.
But once again, it's highly experimental and it's a shot in the dark, so to speak right now.
So it's far from being a mature technology that can deliver.
But we should always look outside the box and maybe there is something there.
So the question still remains, is there anything that will replace
the conventional turbine for power generation?
And in fact, there is a supercritical CO2 turbine that is being produced right now.
And this type of fluid is really interesting because it operates above its critical
temperature and pressure. So it kind of acts like a gas and a liquid at the same time.
And this allows it to be up to 10 times smaller than a conventional steam turbine.
It might even be possible to utilize this in a combined cycle
and it could achieve up to 70% thermal efficiency.
Another method is that natural gas can be burned with pure oxygen.
This would be called an oxycombustion process to produce the high pressure CO2.
And its main advantage is that it would capture all carbon emissions.
However, there are many challenges associated with these types of turbines because CO2
can react with moisture and oxygen.
And this can lead to corrosion of steel and alloys, which is not very good for the turbine.
Innovations in super alloys and thermal barrier coatings are helping to overcome this problem.
The good news is that there are several pilot projects which are utilizing this
elusive supercritical state. But so far they are ranging from a couple to 10 megawatts.
So nothing is really big or game changing just yet.
In conclusion, combined cycle is one of the best sources for power generation.
Nuclear fission still has a long ways to go just to compete with its efficiency
and cost effectiveness. But it's also important to diversify to other energy sources
to avoid price volatility and geopolitical circumstances.
More importantly, I would like to know what you think. So please leave a comment,
like the video if you enjoyed it, and make sure to subscribe to my channel.
