William Howard Taft may be remembered for his size and his mustache, but his true legacy is one of constitutional devotion, legal reform, and a journey unlike any other American president. Pressured into the presidency by Theodore Roosevelt—his close friend turned political rival—Taft preferred courts to campaigns and lawbooks to headlines.
During his single term as the 27th U.S. president, Taft brought more antitrust lawsuits than Roosevelt, lowered tariffs, and laid the foundation for the 16th Amendment establishing income tax. Yet his deliberate, legalistic style clashed with Roosevelt’s bold, populist approach, creating one of the most dramatic political breakups in American history.
After losing reelection in 1912, Taft achieved what he had always wanted: becoming Chief Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court. As the only person in history to lead both the executive and judicial branches, he shaped American law for decades and remained a symbol of integrity, balance, and constitutional principle.
Welcome to American Legends.
My name is Tiffany Brannan.
Each culture has its legends, and that could be myths or different stories.
But here in America, our greatest legends are the wonderful heroes who are right from
our history pages.
Now, some of these heroes are very famous, and some are obscure.
But each person deserves to be discovered, because each man or woman stands as a great
example of how we can be better Americans in our daily lives.
Some people are destined to be leaders.
Others, you could say, have greatness thrust upon them, because they are promoted for certain
important positions by those around them.
This is the case with several men who became U.S. presidents.
Today we're going to talk about one man who was just such a president, William H. Taft.
Some people are remembered for strange incidents or peculiar features about themselves, rather
than for the good things they accomplished.
I'm afraid this is the case with 27th U.S. President William Howard Taft.
He's best remembered as the heaviest U.S. president, having weighed around 330 pounds
during his time in the White House, and the last U.S. president to wear facial hair, since
he had a rather dignified mustache.
However, these bear little to no impact on the real legacy which he had as a very important
leader of the United States.
Taft was from Ohio, like many U.S. presidents who were in office in the late 19th century
and early 20th century.
His father had also been very involved in U.S. politics, having served as an attorney
general and a secretary of war under some other presidents.
As a young man, Taft was quickly attracted to law.
He went to Yale College, graduating second in his class, and then studied law at the
Cincinnati Law School.
From there, he quickly gained a position as a tax collector and, within a few years, was
serving in the county courts in Ohio.
Throughout his political career, he alternated between legal positions, such as serving as
an important attorney or the federal solicitor, other court or legal positions, and political
positions.
This was largely motivated by his wife, who was determined for him to be in important
political positions and wanted him to make inroads in Washington, whereas Taft himself
was more interested in legal pursuits.
In fact, he's quoted as saying,
I love judges and I love courts.
They are my ideals that typify on earth what we shall meet hereafter in heaven under a
just God.
Because of his respect for his wife and other politicians who influenced him, however, he
did pursue various political roles.
He served in appointed positions under the two presidents who preceded him, William McKinley
and Theodore Roosevelt.
McKinley appointed him as the first presiding governor of the Philippines.
One of President McKinley's main accomplishments was acquiring new territories for the U.S.,
and this included the Philippines.
One of Taft's proudest and best accomplishments was helping the Philippines establish a more
Western, democratic way of government, which paved the way for their eventual independence,
making them the only one of the U.S. territories acquired under McKinley to achieve full independence
under its own government.
While serving as the governor of the Philippines, he and his family lived there for several
years at the very beginning of the 20th century.
While there, he gained the trust and admiration of the Philippine people.
He also developed great respect for them, learning about their culture and influencing
their government.
He greatly enjoyed not only this position of influence he had, but the ability to rely
on the law.
Upon returning to the United States, he was appointed as Secretary of War under Theodore
Roosevelt, and in this position, he served in foreign countries for much of the time,
including in the Far East.
Because of this, Taft considered the Far East to be one of the most important territories
for foreign relations during his own time as president.
While serving under Roosevelt in various positions, Taft was offered a position as a Supreme Court
Justice multiple times.
However, he turned them down, largely because of his wife's influence, as he knew that accepting
such a position would forever bar him from having an elected political role, such as
U.S. president.
When Roosevelt won the 1904 election, having previously become president after filling
in for McKinley upon the former's assassination, he made the bold statement that he would not
run for a second term of his own election, which really would be a third term.
He immediately regretted this announcement, but as a man of honor, was forced to stick
by it.
Thus, he chose William Taft as a logical successor to the presidency.
He groomed Taft for this position and named him his heir apparent, preparing him to take
over with a lot of his legislation.
This was certainly not the first time that something had happened in the presidency.
Andrew Jackson groomed not one, but two younger men for the presidency.
Martin Van Buren would be the next presidency, and later down the line, James Polk.
As in these previous situations, Taft received a lot of criticism for just following in Roosevelt's
footsteps.
However, perhaps to show his independence, or perhaps because of his own differing background,
Taft began to break from Roosevelt's policies.
Like Roosevelt, he was a Republican who was very reform-minded, and when campaigning,
he said that he would continue with the party's platform, which included protective tariffs,
the gold standard, and continuing to break up the trusts.
Roosevelt was known as the trust buster because of his antitrust lawsuits, which he brought
forward, which were 40 during his seven years in office.
Although Taft doesn't have as much of that legacy, he brought 70 antitrust lawsuits during
his only four years in office.
This, although a very strong action on his part, began to be his political undoing, because
one of the main trust-busting activities he pursued was U.S. Steel.
Now this wouldn't seem like something particularly controversial, since it had been part of his
party platform, and something which Roosevelt had done as well.
However, U.S. Steel had acquired a Tennessee company with Roosevelt's blessing, and when
Taft approved this lawsuit, he supposedly didn't read the wording very carefully, which
mentioned that Roosevelt had approved this action that was now seen to be an unlawful
monopoly.
This was taken as a direct criticism of Roosevelt, and Roosevelt was very offended by this.
He didn't buy the statement that Taft simply hadn't read that wording, since he thought
it was Taft's job to know exactly what was being said in such things.
This was just the beginning of a rift between them.
There was another trust-busting activity which caused more of a rift between the two, as
well as the fact that Taft began to rely on some different policies.
Now when he was first nominated as the Republican candidate, his opponents, and even his supporters,
made no secret of the fact that they thought he was just following in Roosevelt's footsteps.
He was just taking over where Roosevelt left off, and even taking orders from the former
president.
It was Roosevelt who telephoned him to tell him that he had gained the Republican nomination,
and he went to seek Roosevelt's advice when he was running for president.
Fundamental differences between the two, which went much deeper than individual incidents,
was the fact that Roosevelt controlled things from what was called the bully pulpit.
He used a lot of executive orders to get things done.
Although Taft agreed with a lot of the policies, he felt that these actions and reforms should
be accomplished through changing the legislation.
Above all, Taft believed in supporting the Constitution and defending it through legal
measures and legislation, above all else.
And this harkens back to his background in law, and his first love of legal proceedings.
Taft's opponent in the 1908 election was William Jennings Bryan, a Democrat who was
running for the fourth time to become president.
He had been the opponent of the Republican candidates in the past two elections.
One campaign slogan used for Taft was, vote for Taft now, you can vote for Bryan anytime,
referring to how often he had run for president.
And ultimately, the people still seemed to want the Republican policies.
In his inaugural speech, Taft made a vague reference to the fact that there would be
some tariff reforms.
There had been very high tariffs under McKinley, still pretty high under Roosevelt, although
Roosevelt made it more protective, meaning the main purpose of these tariffs was to protect
American industry from being beaten out by foreign goods, which would be imported.
And that these tariffs would be reciprocal, based on how much foreign countries were charging
us.
Taft, however, sought to lower the tariffs, which he thought were too high, and instead
implement a form of income tax.
Now, there had been income taxes before, but only during mainly wartime.
This was the first time that a tariff was really put into law for the whole country,
and rather than just do it with executive order, he managed to make it the 16th Amendment,
which put it into law.
This made him rather unpopular with other Republicans, because historically, up to that
point, Republicans had favoured tariffs, while Democrats had favoured taxes as a way to fund
the government.
He sought to remove tariffs between the US and Canada, promoting free trade between the
two, which wasn't particularly popular with either Americans or Canadians.
He also sought to have a more open trade policy with the Philippines, seeing it as an American
territory.
He continued the construction of the Panama Canal, which had been begun under Roosevelt.
He also sought the continued advocacy of friendliness with Latin American countries, pursuing the
very old Monroe Doctrine, which was that the United States would support all the other
New World territories to have a more Republican way of government.
By the time the 1912 election was coming around, Taft didn't see that he would have a great
chance at winning re-election.
However, by this point, he was becoming very much opposed to Roosevelt's way of government,
and Roosevelt, meanwhile, was spreading rumours that he would run for the Republican nomination
himself.
Although they had been friends and close colleagues just four years earlier, by this point, they
were very suspicious of each other, Taft saw that Roosevelt was becoming a radical
progressive.
Now, before that, he was known as a progressive, reform-minded Republican, but by this point,
the Republican Party, you could say, was breaking off into two factions.
Taft represented the conservative form of government.
He wasn't too active on the civil rights part of it, and he wanted things to be more slow,
thoughtful, and conservative, whereas Roosevelt was all for reform and bold statements, even
radical ones.
When Roosevelt lost the Republican nomination in 1912, he started his own party, the Bull
Moose Party, which took a lot of Republicans away from the Republican Party to back his
new progressive movement.
This significantly weakened Taft, and ultimately, although Roosevelt was not able to win a third
term, he was able to keep Taft from winning re-election, which he probably wouldn't have
won anyway since he wasn't that popular by this point.
Taft, if anything, did keep Roosevelt from winning a third term, which perhaps he would
have won had Taft not run himself, and this was the main motivating factor.
Taft really didn't want a second term, but he thought that Roosevelt was getting a little
dangerous, and he didn't think he should be allowed to have a third term.
He thought that if he got into the White House again, he would compromise the Constitution
and move the Republican Party into too radical a direction.
At this point, most electorates were more interested in keeping Roosevelt out of the
White House, again, than supporting Taft, and ultimately, Woodrow Wilson, the Democratic
candidate, won the presidency.
This wasn't the end of Taft's political career, however.
He said at the time, the cheerful loser is a sort of winner, and he quickly proved a
very cheerful loser, particularly because he didn't really enjoy being president in
the first place.
He considered going back into the law practice, but since he had appointed so many federal
judges, he thought it would be a conflict of interest to practice law on a federal level.
Thankfully, he was able to get a position teaching at the Yale University, teaching
law and history, and this was a position he enjoyed very much.
He gave a lot of lectures, and also wrote articles, and gave speeches elsewhere, which
earned him a good living at that point.
He still held on to his one remaining hope, which had been his lifelong goal, and that
was to become a Supreme Court justice.
He was holding out hope for when another Republican would get into office as president to give
him this appointment, and his hopes were answered when Warren Harding was elected president
in 1920.
In 1921, Harding appointed Taft as a Supreme Court justice, and by July of that year, he
was made the chief justice of the U.S. Supreme Court, which he'd always said was his ultimate
goal.
Taft said, presidents come and go, but the Supreme Court goes on forever.
While it didn't go on forever, Taft's time as the chief justice lasted for nine years,
from 1921 to 1930, which was indeed the year of his death.
This appointment made Taft the only person to serve as U.S. president and a Supreme Court
justice, and as such, he passed much important legislature and continued to shape the Supreme
Court into what it is today.
Taft, as I mentioned earlier, is best remembered for being quite overweight, and the most popular
story about him is that he got stuck in the White House bathtub.
This was not true, since he was smart enough to order a custom extra-large bathtub before
ever getting stuck in the regular-sized one.
However, in his later years, he realized that he needed to do something about his health,
so he slimmed down considerably in the 1920s, weighing over 100 pounds less as a Supreme
Court justice than he did when president.
He took a great interest in having a more sensible diet and more physical exercise,
and he would walk to and from his office as a Supreme Court justice while serving in that
position every day, which was three miles each direction.
On going back, he would often cross a bridge, and this bridge was later named the Taft Bridge
in his honor.
It's ironic that Taft became such a fierce opponent of Roosevelt when going for a second
term, since the beginning of his presidential career had been riddled with accusations that
he was merely a puppet of Roosevelt.
I guess he proved that wasn't true as he began to break out on his own.
There were many political cartoons at the time showing the two men wrestling, trying
to knife and shoot each other, and it really was quite ironic that they did become such
fierce enemies.
Taft never had the public support that Roosevelt had, nor was he as popular with the press.
He didn't have the charismatic personality or the winning way about him that Roosevelt
did, and I suppose you could say he accomplished less, partly because he didn't have as long
in office.
However, he did have a strong, firm basis, and he helped many things in the country,
including with his service in the Philippines.
On a more personal note, Taft and Roosevelt did reconcile before the latter's death.
In fact, it was Will H. Hayes, who's best known as the motion pictures are a few years
later, but at the time was the head of the Republican National Committee, who helped
the two men become friends again.
In 1918, he encouraged Taft to seek a reconciliation with his former mentor and friend, and he
arranged for a meeting of the two men at a gentleman's club.
Upon seeing each other, the two men embraced, which was met by a round of applause from
all present.
Their relationship didn't really develop beyond that, but it showed that they had become friends
again before Roosevelt died within the year.
After Roosevelt's death, Taft said, had he died in a hostile state of mind toward me,
I would have mourned the fact all my life.
I loved him always and cherish his memory.
Taft made a great many statements which are worthy of being quoted, which could perhaps
be summed up in his quote, the trouble with me is that I like to talk too much.
But some of his most noteworthy quotes are the following.
Too many people don't care what happens so long as it doesn't happen to them.
He also said, we must dare to be great, and we must realize that greatness is the fruit
of toil and sacrifice and high courage.
I think both these quotes are excellent mottos aside from any political or presidential speech.
They're just good advice for life.
One must work hard and be brave if one wants to accomplish anything worthwhile.
Taft, indeed, left a legacy of hard work, fair-mindedness, and following his own intuition
and understanding of, above all, the Constitution.
Thank you for spending this time with me, and I hope you'll join me next time for more
American Legends.