$65 vs $400 Arrows

Defending with Past Crossbows
3 followers
Oct 3, 2025
$65 vs $400 Arrows
This is a $65 set of arrows. This is a $200 set of arrows before components. Today I'm going to line
them up side by side and see how they compare and shoot get you some real world results. Let's go.
If you're anything like me you're probably thinking there's no way the $65 arrows are
going to fly as good as the expensive ones right? Well here's the thing I don't know.
Don't know till you try it. Don't knock it till you try it. And I took every precaution I could
when building the $65 arrows. In fact let's cut to that. My mission. Test out the cheapest
hunting arrows Podium Archer sells. The Gold Tip Warrior. 9.3 grains per inch in a 300 spine arrow.
Suspiciously like the Gold Tip Hunter Pro which costs three times as much.
I started with a good clean bear shaft and built them to be as accurate as possible. Spun them on
an arrow shaft spinner to see if there's significant wobble on one side or the other. Cut them down to
size. Squared both sides. Knock end and tip end and did a little silver sharpie trick just to make sure
it was fully squared. Hot melt glued in the stock insert that came with them. Fletched on
three super saber minis with the AAE max helical jig to the left and finally knock tuned them.
Which means I shot every shaft through paper with fletchings on and if there was an inconsistent
tear rotated the knock 120 degrees. Two out of ten needed the knock turned. Other than that these
things are flying true. Let's take them to the range and see what we can do. Here's our target
of choice we're going to go head to head on today. First arrow out of the gate RIP TKO 250 spine.
Has a Podium Archer 30 grain titanium inserts up front and 100 grain tip on that. Total arrow
weights 400 grains and I'll have all the stats right down below. Okay let's jump right into it.
Of course the wind kicked up right as I started doing this but that's real life. That's how real
life goes. Sometimes you have to shoot in the wind and I've gotten a lot of practice at shooting in
the wind this spring. It's been windy here. The reason these have come to be my mainstay arrows
is for a couple reasons. They have a really low GPI which stands for grains per inch which means
I can keep them light if I want to or if I want to add weight to them it adds to the FOC.
They have a slick coating on the outside which I've always thought was good for a 3D
and even if it was zipping through something it might go through with a little less friction
and they've been durable. I beat the heck out of them and they hold up. That's why these have been
a mainstay in my quiver. They're a popular arrow choice for quite a few people and I can see why
for sure. Oh that felt good. I'm shooting pretty good I'm just getting a little bit of right to
left and when I say pretty good I mean pretty good for me. One cool thing about archery is just
you versus you really like you can have targets you can have people but ultimately it's what
what you can do and one shot at a time and I like that I appreciate that about archery.
It definitely has some parallels to golf for me. It's different but it has some similarities.
Just a smidge left. What do you think of the mustache? As this video launches it's like the
middle of July. Hopefully you have your setup ready you're getting arrows down range most days
getting everything tuned getting your broadheads on soon. It'll be here before you know it it's
coming up quick. Oh we got two more arrows and then we'll go see what kind of score I
shot with the first group. That felt good. You want to come give your bold hypothesis?
Don't be peeking at my group down there either all right. I can't tell from here.
They all look like shadows dude how would I know the difference. MFJJ in the house on his what do
dirt bike he has like six of them or something like that. I have two don't be so dramatic. Plus
the trail 90 which is my favorite or trail 120. It's a 110. 110. It's the modern version. That's
my favorite. It's still like 30 years old or something. MFJJ kind of briefed me on how we
can build arrows to the nines to make them as accurate as possible. We did that in the podcast
which I'll have linked down below but I want to know what you're hypothesized for us. What you've
built versus that I bet you see almost zero difference. I mean you're shooting field points.
Yeah shooting field points. I don't think it'll shoot any different. I mean unless unless you
have like an immense amount of wind or something like that or you're testing penetration they'll
shoot the same. We're also going to do a durability test. Make sure you stay around until the end of
the video for that. That one might not be as good. Yeah. Yeah but they're both kind of probably.
That's what I'm actually most excited for. And that's what I'm working on right now so let me
get back to it. All right we'll see you back we'll we'll be back for the durability test in a minute.
One more arrow. We'll go score them up. Oh that felt good. Let's go see what we got.
Four nines 36. Three eights make 60. 67. 73. 78. I'll double check that but I think it's 78.
These are the Gold Tip Warriors. $65 a dozen. 9.3 gpi which I thought was pretty sweet. 246
diameter so they're wider than my TKOs and traditionally a wider arrow get moved in the
wind a little bit more but we're just gonna see how they fly. Let's go. I took a few arrows just
to double check my marks. It seems like I've only lost like one yard. Yeah one yard between going
from 400 to 420 grains right now from 50. It is hot out today. We're getting in that portion of
like a Washington summer where most days are sunny but some days get hot. Best to shoot in the morning
or the afternoon or whatever. Morning or the evening. At just an eye's glance I don't know if
I got lucky with this batch of 12 but they all spin tested pretty well. Like I didn't have
any serious wobble on one end or the other. Maybe just a micro wobble on one end and just cut that
off and yeah they spun pretty well. It's kind of interesting right now because I don't feel like
I'm necessarily shooting better. Like my float might even feel a little worse and my arrows are
kind of stacked in the middle. Oh I do think these Nox are actually kind of nice especially for a
couple shots. Two more. I should have let that one down. Two shots in this group I actually should
have let down. They just kind of felt a little squirrely. Final final. Let's go.
I'd like to have taken those last couple back but what do you do. Got some really good ones in there.
I'm kind of excited to see what the score is. Let's check it out. So that's three in the middle.
30. 39. 39. 47. 55. 62. 69. 69 plus 12 is 81. A little construction destruction test.
Gold Tip Warrior. Rip TKO. Rip TKO with Josh's fancy titanium half outs on the front. We're
going to see how they do versus steel right now. Let's do the Rip TKO first. Let's do the
baller budget also known as no budget. While I'm shooting this why would a person spend $400
on arrows versus less than $100. The place where you'll really see high quality differences in
arrows is traditionally when you start to shoot fixed blade broadheads. Honestly. Mechanicals you
won't see it as much and you can still get really good results it's just at distance you will really
see a noticeable difference when you pay for quality. Okay.
One down one to go. I can't shoot arrow number one. Can't shoot old faithful. I'm too fond of
that arrow. Let's go arrow number nine. Identity your brand new elk. It's intended to get destroyed
that's what it's for. Also before I destroy this arrow subscribe to the channel. I'm about to
destroy two arrows. Built a dozen of these freshies just for this video today. If you want
to support what we do check out puttymarcher.com. Use discount code TIMC. It'll save you some money
on the stuff and it just helps support all the shenanigans we do out here. So final arrow
destruction test. Let's go. Let's go inspect what we suspect. 20 grain difference in the arrow.
That's the main difference. Warrior's 20 grains heavier. That's our difference in carnage. We also
blew out a knock on the gold tip. Which has probably got to do with the movement and vibration
when it hits something hard. Yeah I mean look at that mushroom. If you had a collar on that
that probably wouldn't have broke. Pretty interesting this definitely protected the
front of the arrow. Oh and potentially this arrow is just a little more durable.
The other one's like grenaded away. Definitely not the field point. No the field point's ticked.
Yeah the way around that. Yeah here's the thing no matter where you're at in your archery journey
no matter where you sit today where there's something you want to learn about just get
started first. There's a thing that happens that's called paralysis by analysis. It prevents a lot of
people from getting started. They think they need the best hunting gear, the best archery gear,
the best camera gear, the best filming gear to make youtube video. None of that stuff matters
as much as your experience. First and foremost whatever it is you are doing please from a career
lifelong coach just get started. Get picky later and when you start getting picky recognize that
there's a point of diminishing returns. The difference between a $1,000 rifle and a $10,000
rifle isn't $9,000. It's a very small amount that people are willing to spend that extra money for
because it takes a lot to get a little. Fun little youtube video for me to make.
Get out, shoot your bow, subscribe to the channel. I'm busting up arrows for you
and we will catch you back for the next one.
Josh kind of alluded that broadheads are the big deal so let me know if you want to see a part two
with some broadheads because I'm kind of predicting that we're not going to see as much of a difference
Let me know what you think. I'm off. We'll catch you back for the next one.
