My Whitetail Arrow is Heavier Than my Elk Arrow

The Technology of Old Crossbows
4 followers
1 Video View·May 23, 2026
My Whitetail Arrow is Heavier Than my Elk Arrow
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe speakers discuss the balance between arrow weight, speed, and penetration in bowhunting. They challenge the notion that heavier arrows are always superior, arguing that lighter arrows provide flatter trajectories and better accuracy at longer distances, while penetration is more dependent on arrow tune, spine, and broadhead choice than raw mass.
Comments are disabled for this video.
Oh, I got a 425 arrow, killed two elk with it.
Now I'm going to hunt whitetail.
I'm going to go up to 475 to 485.
People were like, what?
That doesn't make sense.
Maybe, can you explain to them why maybe you did that?
Bison burgers.
Didn't somebody tell you a comment on a video
that you'd shot that you shouldn't talk
on behind the camera?
That wasn't very nice.
Well, a lot of them aren't very nice.
I got another light over there I can pop on.
Any good YouTube comments lately that you were like,
oh, I liked that one.
God, I had one that was,
actually, it was just on the video that came up Monday
of going over the band.
I talked about my elk that I didn't kill,
that somebody else shot and mentioned
that I had 26 inches of penetration
and the arrow broadhead was directly above the heart
and at the angle I shot him at,
there was nothing vital to hit.
And there was a comment that said,
you know, if your arrow was 100 grains heavier,
you probably would have killed that elk.
You're an idiot.
Like, did you not?
So 26 inches of penetration in and out?
Like, really?
Give me a break.
That was ridiculous.
But people are dumb.
They hear a little part of what you said and run with it.
No different than you get the heavy arrow argument,
you get one little part of it,
and then that's all you think about.
You're ignoring all the other steps of this
that are really relevant and that are gonna change.
Like, this is all gonna change a lot.
Like, 10 years from now,
you're not gonna find people shooting 800 grain arrows.
You don't think so?
No, no.
There's enough out there and enough proof of it
going that way farther and farther and farther
that it will stop.
Yeah, you're gonna have some people who like physics
that are gonna argue with you, Ben.
Well, I don't disagree with that,
but those same people,
at one point were probably using 1,000 grains
and they were gonna use 800 grains.
The people that were using 800 grains
are gonna use 600 grains,
and the people that are using 600 grains
are gonna use four or 450,
because there's logic to it.
It's a progression,
no different than our conversations over the years.
You've progressively gotten lighter every year
because you've seen the proof in the pudding,
you've seen the evidence,
you've seen the examples of it,
and it's no different than other people
in that same position as time goes on.
Yeah, I've basically dropped about 20 to 25 grains
total arrow weight on elk every year,
because I'm willing to go a little more
and then go hunt, kill a couple bulls.
Make sure.
Be like, well, that worked pretty good,
so next year, who knows what next year,
what if I'm at like 400?
That's pushing it, but it's a reality.
I mean, if you test it and prove it and see it,
then it's relevant, right?
Yeah.
And it's as long as you're not sacrificing spine or tune.
Spine or tune and the type of broadhead you use
has everything to do with penetration.
It does, it's not physical arrow weight.
We're talking small percentages, okay?
It's not impossible and it's not drastic, it's small.
So if you go 200 grains at a whack,
you're gaining like five to 10% more penetration
for 200 grains.
200 grains is a lot.
After your next bite,
will you explain to my audience why I, in my brain,
I was like, oh, I got a 425 arrow,
killed two elk with it,
now I'm gonna hunt whitetail,
I'm gonna go up to 475 to 485.
People were like, what?
That doesn't make sense.
It does.
Can you explain to them why I maybe did that?
So the whole reason we're talking about these lighter arrows
for elk hunting is it's because it's elk hunting
and you're not shooting just 20 yards or just 30 yards.
You're shooting anywhere from 20 yards to 80 yards,
depending on your skill level or your ability.
And in those scenarios,
the amount of time to target becomes more relevant.
The amount of movement becomes more relevant.
How flat your trajectory is,
like I had three people this year that the elk moved,
they shot and they missed by a lot with a heavier arrow.
That lighter arrow isn't gonna miss by as much
when that happens.
Like everything about shooting a lighter arrow
is a benefit other than penetration,
but it's not as big of a difference
as everybody makes it out to be.
And that's the problem with it.
Now, when you're in a tree stand,
ground blind, 20, 30 yards, et cetera, right?
The weight doesn't matter as much,
the speed doesn't matter as much
because you're shooting a known distance
or close to a known distance.
There's not as big of a difference there.
So you're not as fixated on, oh my God,
this is a 55 yard shot and the animal took three steps.
A 20 yard shot and the animal takes three steps
doesn't change a damn thing.
It's not different,
but you start getting out there in the drop-off points
and it really does matter a lot.
So shooting a heavier arrow out of a tree stand
or a ground blind, I'm very positive about.
Like do it.
It's not gonna make a difference, right?
You're not gaining as much all of a sudden
because it's a close shot.
You know how far away it is.
Now, if you're sitting in a tree stand shooting 50, 60 yards,
now we're back to a different conversation again.
Sure thing.
Yep.
You can shoot a heavier arrow up close.
I shot 500 or something grain arrow last year
just to try it.
But it was 20 yard shot, known distance, known effect.
Right?
And two steps ain't gonna change nothing.
Yeah.
And then I sit there and look at it and I go,
if I can shoot a 400 grain arrow out of a 70 pound bow
with a mechanical broadhead at 32 yards
on a thousand pound animal,
and I'm getting a full pass through, what do I need here?
Like how heavier of an arrow do I need?
Now, if you deliberately want to try to shoot something
in the shoulder and that's your plan,
like if that's literally your goal, then I agree.
Like if you want, like I'm gonna shoot that thing
quartering towards me right in the shoulder.
Okay.
Let's get you the heaviest thing we can find.
And that's fair for like urban hunting out East.
And like, you know, you got like,
you got to kill this deer in someone's backyard.
It's legal.
Yeah.
Put it through the shoulder.
Go heavy.
I get it.
Like there's always exceptions.
Get yourself a big, and I wouldn't go wide.
I would go smaller.
I'd use like an iron will solid beefiest thing you can get
titanium hardware.
Not necessarily a super heavy GPI arrow, but heavier.
Yeah.
Although the most solid combination you can come up with
and durability and put as much weight in the front
as possible.
So when it does hit, because even if you end up with like,
let's say you go a 12 GPI arrow versus a 10 GPI arrow,
same spine.
Yeah.
Right.
You're a 12 GPI arrow.
You can't put as much weight in the front to end up
with the same projectile.
Yeah.
The more weight you put in the front,
the less it'll deviate when it hits something hard.
Aha.
That's important.
Right?
So if your mass is equally spread out throughout the arrow
and it hits something hard, there's more mass back here
when it wants to turn left because of the way it hit
to help pull it that way.
Did you ever see Tim Connors footage of when he shot a deer
with like some two blade and I don't know what the hell
his setup was, but it was like pretty tight quartering too.
And then it exited out of hip or something.
That video is on my channel.
That's the only reason I still get people getting comments
and mad about that video.
But I always wondered like, man, how light was his arrow?
And what was it?
It wasn't, it was heavy.
Was it heavy?
Yeah, it was heavy.
It was like 500 or something.
It was a two blade, which is, which was the argument
when we first started talking to Bill about it.
I've seen a two blade deflect a lot more than a three blade
because it's not a flat surface, right?
A three blade separates your angles, right?
So it's harder to push it that way or push it that way
when you hit something.
Whereas a two blade, if it hits the angle just right,
and this is not every time, but it's sometimes,
you hit the angle just right and hit a hard object,
it'll deflect easier.
And we kind of went back and forth about that,
but he did kind of acknowledge, yeah, I guess if it,
if everything is just right, yes,
it's more likely to happen.
And his is going to do it the least
because of the way his tips design,
the way the blade angles are.
But when you shoot a elongated two blade,
you have a greater likelihood of deflection
than a three blade.
So that's really why I like a three blade
and the whole pattern lining up after you shoot through it.
And I can show you a good visual on that
if you want to see it.
We're going to get you at the very end of the video,
Josh is going to keep it simple, stupid,
and just give you some best practices
so that when you're considering building your arrow for 2024
that you're not confused and you know some things
and you can do some take homes.
But first let's build the bow.
Did you shoot that Buffalo?
Yeah.
Yeah. 400, 400 grain arrow, three blade,
mechanical broadhead, 45 yards, complete full passer.
But I need a heavy arrow though.
That is a real or a short on our YouTube channel
and is the most viewed short.
Yeah.
Josh is definitely like, hey man,
there's people out there that rub you the wrong way.
I know I rubbed some of you the wrong way
and I'm sorry that I'm not sorry.
Josh is going to rub some of you guys the wrong way
and I guarantee he's sorry that he's not sorry,
but you got to just know that.
I'm absolutely sorry that I'm not sorry.
You like that?
I do.
It's the nicest way.
I'm not sorry at all.
It's a respectful way to acknowledge that,
hey man, I am who I am and you are who you are.
That's okay.
But just know at the end of the day,
we're trying to inform, educate, inspire,
and maybe even entertain a little bit.
So.
Yeah. And finally, as promised at the end of the video,
we were starting to confuse some of you at the beginning,
talking about arrows.
I want to dumb it down.
The bottom line is when you are in the market for arrows,
guys should never really go weak.
They should always err on the side of being stiff.
Always err on the side of stiff.
Componentry, don't ever use anything aluminum.
Titanium or steel, aluminum fails.
Titanium and steel don't.
If you're going to put weight in your arrow,
put it in the front.
Don't put it in the back, i.e. less fletches, wraps,
with the exception of a lighted knot,
because God, they're just cool.
Yeah, no doubt.
And then honestly, when it comes to GPI,
it seems like you've converted me.
So I'm just, we tend to lean or gravitate
towards those lighter GPIs and put the weight
where we want it.
If you're shooting a 300 spine arrow,
GPIs over 9.5 are just going to make everything really hard.
So ideally, under 9.5 GPI on a 300 spine
allows you to build an arrow with a good FOC
that doesn't end up stupid heavy.
Guys, we appreciate your support.
Separations in the preparation.
We'll catch on the next one.
