The Conservation of Albrecht Dürer's Adam and Eve Panels

Fine Art Conservation
153 followers
22 Video Views·Sep 14, 2025
George Bisacca, conservator, Department of Paintings Conservation, MMA
The Met collaborates and shares its expertise with institutions around the world, working with partners in a myriad of ways, through excavations, conservation projects, fellowships, advisory relationships, long-term loans, and traveling exhibitions. Join us to hear about the fascinating and complicated work performed by a Met conservator in the Prado conservation studio on two important panels by Dürer.
Good afternoon everyone. It's a pleasure to welcome you to another Sunday at the Met.
My name is Michael Gallagher, Head of Painting Conservation here at the Met.
I'm sorry you had to be subjected to me for six minutes before this, but
I'm very, very pleased. One of the very few days of sunshine we've had this month
that you've taken the time to come to hear George Boussaka today. You won't regret it.
I just wanted to start off by saying that today's lecture is underwritten by the Pearl Ehrlich Fund.
Pearl Ehrlich was a lecturer in the education department and much loved by the staff she
worked with and the public she served. Her family put together a fund in her memory
to broaden the range of lectures to be presented at the museum.
Without their support and other funds like it, the talk we're about to enjoy today would not
be possible. We're truly indebted to her family and the opportunity they're providing to us all.
I think when you think of painting conservation, this is the typical sort of image that comes to
mind. People working at easels and I think one of the great things about that you'll see in today's
lecture is there is a very different side to painting conservation that many people are
unaware of. Within the department, as well as doing this sort of work, part of our role is the
general welfare of the painting. So loans coming in or going out of the museum need to be checked
to ensure that they come to no harm during exhibition, that they are safe to travel,
that they have arrived safely. Also in our work, we look into the paintings as almost
there is a physical art history trapped within them that we can discover a great deal about the
artist. Not only materials and techniques but often what was driving the artist by looking
at the object itself. This is a crucial part of the work we do, this sort of technical examination.
But today's talk is going to concentrate on a completely different aspect from that. I mean,
it's examination, technical examination, the art history is all bound up in this but it's
about the structural treatment of panel paintings and I think many of you won't be aware of this
aspect of painting conservation and it will be presented by our structural specialist,
George Boussaka. And I'd just like to say a little about George in a moment and before he
gives the talk, just to give you a sense that when we had our major refurbishment of the department,
we moved back after 18 months, two years ago. We have a designated 1800 square feet of space
for George's work including not just his office but a panel suite for, as it were, clean work
and workshop to facilitate the type of conservation treatments he does.
George Boussaka graduated cum laude from Middlebury College in 1977 with a double
major in English literature and Italian. He'd spent one academic year at the University of
Florence studying Italian literature and art history and he returned to that city to receive
his general training in the conservation of paintings at the Palazzo Pitti. Between 1979
and 1983, he pursued specialized training for the structural conservation of panel paintings
with conservators of the prestigious Opificio delle Pietre Dure. He worked on paintings from
and from throughout Tuscany including great works from Florence, Siena, Arezzo, Pistoia and Pisa.
During these years, he also received a grant from the National Endowment for the Arts
to pursue an interest in the history of picture frames which involved practical training,
wood carving and gilding from local Florentine craftsmen. He also worked on conservation and
restoration projects sponsored by the German Ministry of Culture in Munich and Stuttgart.
George joined the Met as assistant conservator in November of 1983 and was promoted three years
later to full conservator. During his time here, he has been invited to work on panel paintings
from other international institutions including the J. Paul Getty Museum, the National Gallery of
Art, Norton Simon Museum, Kunsthistorisches Museum in Vienna, Philadelphia Museum, Chrysler Museum
and the Indianapolis Museum of Art. An ongoing and especially rewarding relationship has been
established with the Prado in Madrid where George has performed major structural interventions
on the Descent from the Cross by Roger van der Weyden, Three Graces by Peter Paul Rubens and
the Adoration of the Shepherds by Anton Raphael Mengs. His work with the Prado was officially
recognized in 2001 when he was awarded the title and medal of honor of Alfonso X El Salvio from
the Spanish Ministry of Culture. George is co-chair of the International Advisory Committee of the
Panel Paintings Initiative, a joint project of the Getty Conservation Institute and Getty
Foundation. This addresses training and research issues related to the structural conservation of
panel paintings and that brings us on to really the subject of today's talk.
The Met has, as well as looking after our own collections, we occasionally do deal with and
conserve paintings from other collections. Many of you will be aware that we have an ongoing
relationship with the Frick Collection and recently both the magisterial self-portrait by Rembrandt
was treated by my colleague Dorothy Mahon and I was lucky enough to work on the Frog of Philip.
The Bellini Saint Francis came into the studio last year for examination. The results of that
will be featured in the forthcoming exhibition at the Frick. We also occasionally take on work
from outside collections. These two paintings, for those of you who saw the Gossard exhibition,
were both restored and conserved here at the Met. They were paintings that had been discovered by
Marion Ainsworth, the curator of the exhibition, and the issue was that the collections they came
from, the portrait of the man was from Antwerp, the Christ on the Cold Stone from Budapest.
At that time, the departments there could not take on this conservation work and so
they came to the Met, both for the treatment and also to facilitate Marion undertaking research
into the pictures. Currently, we have this painting from Budapest, Caterina Cornara, Queen of Cyprus,
which is being cleaned and restored. It's a picture by Gentile Bellini and will feature
in the Renaissance Portrait Show that will come to the Met at the very end of this year,
having first opened in Berlin. George, in fact, has been very busy working on the structural
side of this painting. It had this very crude cradling system which was causing severe problems
and he's been working on that for the last few months. I'd just like to end by saying
in my introduction that going through George's CV, which is obviously very impressive,
does not give you a flavour of the man. I think George is one of the
colourful, sounds strange, but I think colourful characters of the museum.
That CV does not give you a sense of the richness of experience that led him to be a world specialist.
He has a curiosity for works of art and for life in general. He's known to friends as being an
expert on wine. If you want to know the best Barolo produced in 2005, look no further.
If you want to know the jazz club that stays open all night in the East Village,
look no further. A motorcycle enthusiast. There's a great passion for life and a great passion for
art. One of George's key strengths is his appreciation of the holistic nature of works
of art that be treated. He is as interested in the whole package, the front, the back,
the history. That is what, it is that intelligence that informs his treatment.
What you're about to listen to is a sort of Everest challenge of a structural treatment.
It is the very, very, very, very few people in the world that could undertake this treatment
safely and responsibly. I mean, you're talking of probably half a dozen and I'd say that George
leads that half dozen. When he gave this talk first, I heard it at a conference that was
devoted to structural treatments and the whole issue of, in a sense, the potential crisis in our
field if conservators do not choose to take the path that George did of devoting themselves to
structural work, that when this sort of challenge is laid before you, if you do not have those
skills, then you cannot help this picture. I said to George after I heard the talk that I felt proud
to call him a colleague. I hope by the end of the next half hour, 40 minutes, you will understand
that it's a really quite extraordinary work that he did. The fact that this painting,
these two paintings, they almost are one, they were created as a pair, but they are preserved
and safe now for future generations is thanks to George. Thank you.
Wow. How do I follow that up?
So good afternoon and thank you all for being here. Before beginning, I'd just like to mention
a few things. You're about to get a glimpse of what's involved in the conservation and
restoration of paintings. Most great masterpieces have accumulated damages over their 500-year-odd
lifespan, some accidental, some caused by climate fluctuation, and many by misguided attempts
to care for the paintings. I just want to preface this talk by saying that while it's true that
most of the old master paintings in museums around the world have minor damages that have
been cosmetically repaired so they don't distract from our apprehension of the painting, the
treatment you're about to see is particularly complex and should not be considered a routine
treatment. The case is very interesting and rare because we have two paintings, two independent
objects which are to be considered one single artwork. The two panels have very similar
treatment histories until one point in the 20th century when only one of the panels received a
radical treatment that the other fortunately escaped. Much of the work here was done to try
and reverse what was done in the past and eliminate the source of deterioration and bring the panels
into aesthetic balance. This required two very different treatments but applying the same
basic principles. The talk follows the structural treatment of Dürer's two famous panels depicting
the Adam and Eve from the Prado in Madrid and this treatment is just the latest
in the long collaboration between the Metropolitan and the Prado and specifically
between José de la Fuente and myself which stretches back nearly 20 years. Here we are in
1990 when we worked on the great Roger van der Weyden deposition from the cross
here seen in various states of disassembly and here's the Rubens' Three Graces which we
completed in 1997 and two images during the work on the board. The conservation of the
Dürer panels represents the first project of, as Michael explained, the Getty Panel Painting
Initiative which was formed in 2008 by the Getty Conservation Institute and the Getty Foundation.
In fact the formative meetings were held here at the Metropolitan in the Eurocenter with a small
group of international experts. The objective is the dissemination of knowledge concerning
the construction care and conservation of panel paintings and the provision of training
opportunities for the next generation of conservators and here in the Prado's
conservation studio are Alan Miller on the left who joined our staff a few years ago after
graduating from the Courtauld in London and he's working specifically with me on structural
supports and then Tom Wilmering from the Getty grants office, myself, Enrique Quintana who's the
head of the paintings conservation studio at the Prado and then of course José de la Fuente.
The project was ideally suited to the panel paintings initiative because it addressed so
many areas of key areas of focus. It fosters the collaborative efforts between two major
institutions, it facilitates the treatment of a great work of art, it promotes exchange between
recognized experts, José and myself, and it provides intensive training for more junior
specialists. Here we have Alan and Sue Ann Chewy from the Getty and it provides assistance to the
staff of other major collections in the care of panel paintings. This is, you see in the background
there, there are an art historian, Dora Sally from Budapest and the person who does the structural
treatments on panel for the Budapest National Museum. The initiative funded the entire project
including three visits by conservators, curators, and the panel specialists from the Budapest
National Fine Arts Museum. So the panels were painted by Dürer in 1507 shortly after the return
from his second trip to Italy. The subject occupied him from 1504 when he begins to experiment with
the composition. The drawing on the left from the Morgan Library shows the figure of Eve on the left
and the famous engraving from the Albertina on the right also from 1504 with the figures reverse
was widely disseminated. Already in 1504 he's thinking about the figures as two
separate pendant works. In these two drawings from the Albertina
he uses the recto and verso of the same sheets to reverse the poses
and the geometric proportional system seen on the lower left
was used to position the figures and it demonstrates a familiarity with Leon Battista
Alberti's Della Pittura and Piero della Francesca's Dei Prospectiva Pingenti as well as other humanist
texts. His study of the subject culminates in the Prado panels. The atom may even reflect a direct
knowledge of the Apollo Belvedere excavated in 1489 and although correlations have been made
between the Eve and the Medici Venus that sculpture may not yet have been unearthed by the time of
Dürer's travels. What is clear is that he had direct exposure to classical sculpture and that
this was pivotal in his development as an artist. With his return to Germany Dürer became a
fundamental conduit for the diffusion of Italian humanist ideas north of the Alps.
A brief chronology dates the panels to 1507 although it's not clear whether or not they
were commissioned by the municipality of Nuremberg or simply given by Dürer to the city.
In the late 16th century they were given to Rudolf II and taken to Prague Castle
where they remained until 1648 when they were taken by the Swedes after their siege of the city.
Christina of Sweden though never really cared much for German painting and she gave them to
Philip IV of Spain in 1655. The panels survived the fire at the Alcázar in Madrid in 1734
and were again threatened by fire when Carlos III decided to have them
burned in 1762 because of their indecent nudity. Fortunately court painter Anton Raphael Mengs
persuaded the Marquis against the move claiming that he could use them for teaching anatomy to
his students at the Academia de San Fernando where they were eventually moved in 1792.
In 1827 they were transferred to the Prado however they were relegated for another decade to the
where nudes were quarantined for fear of corrupting the public morality.
Only in 1838 were they finally integrated into the permanent collection by school in chronology.
Between 1936 and 1938 during the Spanish Civil War 22 shipments of 391 paintings from the Prado
were sent to a medieval fortress outside Valencia to keep them out of harm's way
and then in February of 1939 they were sent to Geneva where they were exhibited publicly.
On September 5th of that year four days after the outbreak of World War II
they were again packed and shipped by train back to Madrid and the Prado. These photos were taken
in January 1938 and they show the two panels being packed for transit to Valencia. They're
particularly important because they provide a glimpse of the reverse of both panels and they
were both in very similar condition having had the same conservation histories with canvas
reinforcement over a few major cracks and three modern cross pieces. When we began treatment the
reverse of the eve panel was virtually identical to the state in which it appeared in the 1938 photo.
While the atom had unfortunately been planed down to half its thickness
and heavily crated at some point during the interim.
Because the eve retained its original thickness and surface coating on the reverse and required
a far simpler and more straightforward intervention we decided to treat that panel first.
I thought I would show you just a few details of how fantastic this painting is so that
you understand why it is we go to such lengths to take care of them.
This is so interesting to me because here what we're seeing is this brownish color under here
just shows you the incredible bravura and an economy that Dürer is capable of. The brown
is a kind of under painting under the entire panel and the black of the background you see
he paints up to a certain level and leaves that in reserve. He just doesn't paint over it as he
does in the rest of the panel and then he's able to just add a few highlights on top and achieve
this sense of volume of the hair. This is incredible bravura and same here this sort of
wet in wet stroke here dragging the black into the white there so that it
works so quickly and so well. Here again he uses the brownish, the beige background color to be
the trunk of the tree and just dabs the surface with a darker brown to achieve this bark.
So in beginning the treatment
I can just say that the panel itself was made composed of three boards and it has this one
black cross member which was original to it and the other three instead as I said were added later.
Now the reverse is painted this black coating and you can see it has this funny
textured surface which is vegetable fibers and sometimes horse hair that is used to they glue
it onto the surface and front and back and it sort of stabilizes the panel. That existed in
four horizontal bands and three vertical bands both on the front and back so that it would have
this effect of stabilization. Also the back is kind of flecked with these red and white
splatters imitating in a very sort of playful way this porphyry or granite
stone. Now the panel certainly had one split which was repaired in 1835 I believe, no 1853 sorry,
which we can see better in sort of a graphic demonstration. They glued it together and they
added cross-grain butterflies in the 1850s and contrary to what people generally believe
those butterflies require skill to insert but they're really always detrimental to the panel.
But anyhow they then covered those with canvas to reinforce the area. At some later point oh and
they added the cross members. At some later point another split formed and that was again
covered with canvas and so when we were about to begin the treatment what happened is these
extra cross members held the panel so rigidly that as it tried to warp it was unable to do
so and it put great pressure on the routed track of the original cross member. So in the area
corresponding to this little square you can see from the side that the cross piece track
which is routed into the panel started to split and it started to lift the wood on the paint
surface and so we began by covering that area with the Japanese rice paper which we glue onto
the surface with a water-based adhesive so that it can easily be removed later. Then we turned
the panel over and then simply by simply by cutting with a scalpel through the through the
canvas we could set up a sash clamp and by turning the clamping pressure very slowly push the cross
piece out. Now it was important to do that before removing the later cross piece because that was
holding it in a flat position. It's very important to get the sequence of steps very carefully
thought out because otherwise you could inadvertently cause damage by by doing things in a
reverse order. If we had removed this first it would have sprung and put more pressure on the
cross piece track and probably split it even further. So as you can see here there's no visible
points of attachment of this cross piece onto the panel and it became clear in x-ray that
they had actually screwed quite big screws right through the front of the panel into the cross
piece on the back. It's incredible as it seems to us maybe that they would treat it this way.
Somehow they felt that this was more secure and they did take care to organize the distribution
of the holes in very non-significant areas easy to retouch. These all fall in the black
or the tree trunk and this one is they're carefully avoiding the flesh tone and so
they at least did think very carefully about the placement. So the first thing we did was
have to clean off from the surface with some acetone clean the the over paints and then
with a scalpel start to open those areas to expose the screw heads. And what we found is on the
outside of the panel you can see that that screw head is tilted inwards and it's pulled underneath
the surface so that we couldn't extract it without causing damage to the paint film.
And this was because as the panel itself continued to shrink the cross pieces couldn't do it because
they were going in a cross grain direction. So as the shrinkage occurred it ended up pulling the
heads of the screws underneath the paint surface and this created a problem for us to to extract
them. So we started off by making some saw cuts in the cross pieces lifting out the sections that
we could and then having the screws isolated in in these little blocks we moved ahead and
you can see here too we left this cross piece for last because since there was one split that was
open the tension had already been released from that area and so it was safer to leave that one
for last because you can see that it sprung right away into a curved into a curved shape
which held under enormous pressure. So then only at that point we could take a screwdriver and hold
the screw in place and unscrew the blocks to remove the to free them and then extract the
screws from the surface. Okay at this point we had to remove the canvas strips and we did that by
mixing up what is called the product called laponite which you can mix with water and it
swells into a gel and the important thing is it stays on the surface so it's only wetting the
surface and that the the water won't penetrate into the panel and swell the panel. So that had
to be because this is all glued on with horsehide glue very very tenacious it took long applications
an hour and a half to to swell so here we are removing pieces of that and then at the same time
we cleared any residue on the back and cleaned the entire back surface. At that point we tried to
proceed just using a glue a very simple fish glue wherever possible whenever the crack was it was a
decent fit but in some cases we had to add also paste adhesives because in this case setting up
a clamp there you can only clamp it until it's perfect level on the surface of the paint film
and then the rest has to be has to be filled so this is just setting up a system of clamps
all over the panel to deal with these individual splits and then finally after just that simple
treatment there was still one more split fairly extensive traveling halfway through the panel
but you can see these are all all these little holes are are are from woodworm infestation and
it had broken up the strength of the panel so so much there that the split actually pulled itself
apart you can see these different different smaller splits because it has no strength anymore
so we were not able to just use glue to to to repair that because there was there was not enough
material left inside the split so in this case oh and you can see that on the surface where the
split was it bowed inwards and and this was a disturbance from for lighting and also its
structural stability so we we decided to open that split with a high-speed router which I'll
show you about more in the second treatment but I just refer to it here and this is vacuuming out
the residue from inside then we set up a very simple clamping system where you can set blocks
outside the panel and then just by pushing in wedges underneath we can adjust the curvature
and it it seems like you're adding a fair amount of pressure but really that's not the case if you
think of it the two individual sides as having a certain curvature each of those segments remains
like they are and as we put pressure down in one area it pushes them up it pushes the panel up in
the other area so that we can achieve a more regular curvature across the surface so here we
are with pieces ready fit and they go all the way down really and touch the preparation level from
the reverse here we're setting in first with the paste the paste adhesive which could penetrate
into the network of woodworm tunnels so that when we fit in our pieces it would have a much
greater durability and here we are trimming jose trimming off the excess afterwards and you can
see that that all it is only open three and a half millimeters wide and it penetrates to a depth of
17 millimeters so it was as little invasive as we could now here we we did decide not to remove the
butterflies except for in this one case the butterflies were stable they didn't appear to
be causing any damage but this one had this crack passing right through it so we decided to replace
that that one so we could better repair the split but in in replacing it we rebuild it in the same
grain direction that the that the panel is because we want to want it not to obstruct the expansion
and contraction so this is fitting in individual pieces and then carving off the excess and then
you can see that the overall surface curvature has been greatly improved after that intervention
now you can still see the holes from the screws that were on the surface and we had to there
build a we had to make little little tiny inserts that are like dowels except for they go across
the grain rather than along the grain and fit those individually into the holes to to repair
those then finally remember we had we had the cross piece the original cross piece was dead flat as
was the the modern cross piece and we had the problem that now the panel had this curvature
and so what were we going to do with this original cross piece it clearly would not fit into the
track so we were faced with the the options of either hanging it forever in storage or somehow
modifying it so that we could fit it into the track and we decided on that course now in order for
for a curved cross piece to slide in the track you have to have a fairly regular curvature so
and and we clearly did not you can see the the irregular curve inside the track
so we took a a piece of plywood and pressed it into the track temporarily just to regularize
the curve and and then we decided to make two cuts in the in the original cross piece
very carefully positioned so that when we reassembled them this this piece of rag board
is actually in between two pieces in the part that goes below the surface level of the cross
piece track we had to build the saw cut thickness back up otherwise it wouldn't fit in properly
whereas above the track it didn't matter so here we are then temporarily screwing the pieces
together to hold them in position spreading an adhesive on all the pieces and then temporarily
just stacking it above our piece of plywood so that after the glue dried you can see that when
it's reassembled here's one of the cuts across here and the other one is just under the surface
of that track and you can see the white paper in there so that the ends are it's nearly invisible
that anything has been done to this however we end up with a curved cross piece which
still didn't exactly fit because of the irregularity of the track we still had to make
in a few points had to make some modifications of it and then we just ironed in some paraffin wax
on the bottom to reduce the friction and then
slid it back into the track and then that was pretty much the extent of that first treatment
now the atom was a different different story obviously the very heavy cradle that was put
on the back of it when it was planed down to half its thickness and held very rigidly in position
they they thought that those cross members that are in there which are were free sliding when
it was made they thought they would allow it to expand and contract but the friction built up
in the cross members and they soon blocked and as stress is built up in there it caused many many
new splits now this is a this is an undated photograph of the reverse of the atom panel
after 1938 and sometime before the cradle was put on now we did not know what what the date of this
cradling was and we found a stash of photographs in the archives that was dated 1971 to 74
and this was very interesting to us because it seemed to indicate we could see that that there
were these little cross members little rectangular sections peeking out from the edge of the panel
which i think were the cradle itself and so we think that it was during that time also three
years for a group of photographs that indicated quite an extensive structural treatment and so
we think that it was really at that time that the that the cradle was was applied now you can
see here there's that white filled area which corresponds exactly to the cross piece track
just like we saw in the eve panel except here it's now missing completely and they've replaced
it with another piece of wood also there were much more extensive damages in the upper part of
the panel which we could we could even detect from this photo now sometime between that application
in 1971 and the present meant that we had maybe 50 or 60 new splits over the surface
and most of those had had been generated at the edges of the of those members of the cradle you
can see they all correspond almost exactly to those spots here's some raking light pictures
of the surface so you can see the extent of the damage when compared with the eve so it was very
very different situation here we're applying the japanese tissue over the most recent of the splits
the ones that seemed in danger of losing some paint from some friction at the edges as we worked on it
so we selectively faced those pieces and then we turned it over to remove the cradle now normally
in removing the cradle we do it pretty much by hand and and we do that if this is the end grain
the end of the cradle on the outside we try to make a cut corresponding to each of the
corners so that then we can we can we can remove those little blocks and then take out the cross
member and and then systematically remove the remaining blocks afterwards but so we began doing
that here and you can see us carving away some material but we quickly realized right after that
that there was far too much movement there that the panels had so many splits in them that it was
too dangerous to do that and we would put the panel at risk so we decided to change our our approach
there and crazy as it may seem we decided to use a high-speed circular saw with a very special
thin kerf blade and you can see a cut across here and lifting out those pieces and then removing the
cross members now we repeated that process many times you can see how many cuts are across there
they're less than a centimeter each and this was a lot safer than you might think because
the cradle members were made by with machined thickness boards and so they were all identical
thickness and the depth setting on our saw was very precise so that we could be sure that we
weren't going anywhere near touching the actual panel itself and now you can see what we decided
to do is we left this kind of c-shaped cleat holding the cross piece in place we decided that
that would be an important thing to do while removing the bulk of the material and it would
hold the whole situation in place because it was so flexible so here we are making these various
cuts and then you can see here we just took a a metal scraper and we could insert it into the
cuts and snap off those pieces very very easily because they were end grain and don't have much
strength so here we are removing those pieces and then systematically going through
and then this is the last cross member available and we did that by hand because there was no place
to set the saw on and that one happened to be accidentally glued across the grain because when
they applied the cradle there was some seepage underneath and so that was very difficult to
remove that piece and then at this point we cleared the surface and with little tiny
planes that are made for violin makers they have slightly curved bottom so that you can plane the
away without risking damaging the original panel and then we're using a scraper here to clear all
the glue residue from the back of the panel and you can see that in the space of 10 centimeters
there's about seven or eight splits across the surface so it was really really quite fragile
so fragile in fact that there was going to be no way to be able to just turn it over
and so we had to construct a panel a curved panel made of foam core that was reinforced inside
and you can see here we we clamped the ends together but the edges on the outside we just
ran a tape along its length because it was all so flexible if you tried to lift it up it would
the whole thing would flex so we had to temporarily secure it with the tape and then very very carefully
turn it over and then we could clean the surface now only from the the gesso fillings that had been
put in the 1850s with retouches that had to be cleared and you can see here now the the
major splits and all the various damages that had been there we exposed those to be able to continue
now some of those damages when we removed them now removing the fillings from there
you can see there were big holes and and quite severe damages and out there where the cross
piece had been set in that whole area had been crushed and then filled with gesso and when we
removed the gesso that whole area was just completely crushed also unfortunately the panel
had had gotten a very severe cleaning with solvents at some point in its history and
really damaged the paint surface so this was in nowhere near the condition that the that the
eave panel was you can see here it's quite wonderful actually to see the drawing underneath
the right through the paint surface and part of that is is just from the natural increasing
transparency of materials and here you can see the difference between the uh where the varnish
is removed and where it still has yet to be removed the varnish of course turns yellowish
brown with age and after about a hundred years natural resins will be very yellowed like this
so unfortunately it just exposes the all the previous damage that was done now again using
this high-speed router was we had so many splits we we used these these special bits which were
developed in milan for us and they can they can cut to a depth of four centimeters and are only
12 degrees wide and and so they can cut at the tip very accurately without burning and that's
amazing it took them a year to develop those those bits and you can see this permits us to
make a cut very very deep and get an incredibly accurate fit in the pieces that we that we insert
in there this is us making the positive pieces to then put into those tracks and you can see that
this is the original panel and the wood that we used came from a stretcher from a rubens
18th century stretcher which was replaced and it happened to be the exact same kind of wood
cut in the same tangential direction as the original and so it was aged already for a few
hundred years and so that was a very good a lucky possibility now when we're doing these cuts we go
down a little at a time if you see here you know you make one you make one pass and then check to
see that you're on the split and then you make a second pass and then maybe a third pass to make
sure that you stay in the full depth right on the split and sometimes the splits are not perfectly
aligned and so you make one pass and you see that you're you're moving off the split and then you
correct or correct again and hopefully englobe the entire split in there sometimes the splits
are so skewed that you would not be able to encompass them with one pass and so in those
cases you would have to use a wider a wider bit and also as you remember the surface had these
these short segments in between the splits that that were curved like this and again just as we
did on the eve we want to adjust that curvature so that we end up instead with something that's
a more regular uniform curve which is easier to light and and makes the pictures be easier
to view afterwards and so needless to say we have to be very careful about the depth that we're
cutting so that we don't pass through the surface and here we're using a what's called
the hacklinger thickness gauge which is developed for violin makers and it has a small magnet
which you can put underneath the panel on the other side and drag it around so that you can
measure the surface very precisely at any point of the panel and this is accurate to a tenth of a
millimeter this is one millimeter between here and here so very very accurate measuring device
which was critical for for setting up the router and i'll sort of speed through these quickly
enough you can see fitting in the fitting in the pieces a few at a time trimming them off
there they are trimmed and and so this went across the entire surface
very short tracks following the splits as carefully as possible
slightly wider bit here where it was more worm infested
so here's an open split all the way down to the surface and then the piece fit in
one repaired split and in these areas i wanted to just show you that now we're looking from
underneath the panel looking up at the at the at the router bit and you can see the
path will come through quite close to the surface and then there's the piece put in
in in the cases where the where the splits were skewed on too much of an angle what we did is we
traced their incidence on the front surface and then transferred that onto the reverse
so that we we could start already shifted over and know that we were going to
end up at the split on the surface so we had to map those cracks very carefully
again this is being added now this was the case where after removing the filling that went across
the surface from here to here you could see there was a huge step in the surface and so
this is just opening opening that up very carefully from front and back and then being
able to push it up with clamping pressure and now you can see right across the split it's it's now
it's level across the surface so this one was much much more difficult what we had here is the the
paint surface was crushed way below the surface level and it was it was very solidly glued and
we couldn't push it up on its own so we had to remove all of the filling you can see right
through the panel and then put the Japanese rice paper to hold everything in in position
and then turn it over and we had trouble still moving it and you can see we already
repaired one split here so in order to get that to shift position we had to reopen it you can see
here that that cut is reopened and then because of all this filling with the worm woodworm
infestation it was still so so solid that we couldn't we couldn't budge it so that in just
that area we carved away some of that material right down to the paint surface here we're less
than a millimeter from the paint surface that's the actual gesso on the panel seen from from the
reverse and then I could glue in these little blocks temporarily to have a point of leverage
under which to push two little wedges so that we could use that to push them up to the surface
where we clamped a a piece of piece of plexi so that we could see the level come up and
hold it in position now we had to rebuild this track and this is sort of like a Wallace and
Gromit film it's adding the individually shaped pieces very carefully calibrated
to fit exactly there and then carve off the excess
so that it's rebuilt up to surface level and you can see there that it makes an accurate surface
level across so finally the panel is gaining real stability after repairing all of these splits
and then we could open the the worst of them in its entire length so that both halves are
stable enough to really change the curvature and move it outward and there's putting in those
pieces and now you can see that Alan is just holding the panel by himself and so it's gained
great great stability compared to before we began inserting the wedges we actually used
I think 388 pieces we we put in you can see this the upper part the middle you can see that they
they planed it just down to the thickness of the cross piece tracks themselves and then the bottom
which had the most extensive damage down here now it was about eight or nine millimeters thick
and we still felt that it was unable to stand on its own and we wanted to add a secondary support
and so what we wanted to do is tailor a support to fit the curvature of the back and it was going
to have five cross members so we organized these boards to support the panel in five places and
then we cut many thin five millimeter pieces that we could stack laminate much the same way as we
did with the cross piece on the on the eave panel here you see us putting that together and sorry
and and those were organized in groups across corresponding with these blocks and here you
see them stack laminated now it seems like an enormous amount of clamping pressure but actually
it's it's really not very much at all because these blocks are taller than the panel surface
so when these stacks go across the panel they it just makes a bridge so as we tighten the clamps
on these beams we can very carefully and slowly move them down until they just barely touch the
panel so they're not they're not really exerting any any pressure on there and in fact that is
clear because when we remove the the blocks they stay exactly in the same position they were
without exerting any pressure at all so now we took those and we started to construct the strainer
and these are these spring mechanisms which we actually developed over the course of a year with
a structural engineer and there are various prototypes and designs that we were playing
around with for a year making actual prototype models but we finally ended up learning a lot
in that process and then simplifying it to a linear tension spring which you see on the inside like
this and this is the actual mechanism itself with a calibrated scale and this button gets glued onto
the panel itself and that's the only point that regulates it and the way it works here's the
exploded view the way it works is that as the panel tries to warp more it can allow the spring
to move and it can also allow the panel to expand and contract in either direction so you can see
here how it how it can move okay so a very simple system and then we had to build the
strainer itself drilling all the holes after we decided on their placement and slots
and we are routing various pieces
and putting the strainer together refinishing the edge on the outside with a sort of a curved edge
just to make it more easily handled and here we're tracing the with a pencil onto the surface
of the panel the circular cutouts and we isolate that with a protective layer so that at any later
moment we can remove these little brass buttons that we attach onto there without causing any
further damage to the panel so here we're putting a little araldite adhesive
dab and then attaching this onto the panel now you see this hole in the slot through it there
and here you see the pieces all arranged in position on the panel and this is the strainer
from the from the underside and it has a little shelf on the bottom of it actually to hold the
panel from sagging over the years with the fatiguing the springs so the mechanisms were
then hooked into the buttons and seated into position and then held with screw and then this
is a couple of details after that treatment and here's that panel after completion and you can
see how the springs work okay and there's alan now holding the panel you can see this slight
curve that the overall panel has now it's quite an acceptable curve and it's improved the surface
enormously here it is in raking light now and if you compare that surface with with the surface
before we began it was it was quite an improvement and these are the panels after the structural
work you can see that just by following the curvature dictated by the panel that the two
curves are very very similar and so there's the two panels after treatment and here's a few details
of the pictures after maite davila completed the cleaning and retouched it not a very good slide but
some beautiful details even though it's quite a bit more damaged than the eve
and here they are uh in the prado in the grand gallery where they've temporarily exhibited them
for some months now standing in the middle of the room so that you can see them from front and
and back and the front and the back as they are now in the galleries so thank you all very much
you're very patient
