Mary Arthur McElroy never expected to serve in the White House—but when her brother, President Chester A. Arthur, needed a hostess after his wife’s passing, she answered the call with quiet grace. Though she served only during three winter seasons, Mary modernized the social life of the White House, hosted with warmth and charm, and helped shape future First Lady traditions. She also raised her brother’s daughter, honored past First Ladies, and became a trusted presence during a difficult presidency. Reserved but effective, she proved how strength can shine through modesty.
Welcome to American Legends. My name is Tiffany Brannan.
Each culture has its legends, and that could be myths or different stories,
but here in America our greatest legends are the wonderful heroes who are right
from our history pages. Now some of these heroes are very famous
and some are obscure, but each person deserves to be discovered
because each man or woman stands as a great example of how we can be better
The First Lady is the most important woman in the country
because it is her job to be not only the hostess
of the White House, but the closest confidant
to the President, the leader of the whole nation.
Sometimes, however, the President has been a widower
or a bachelor, and thus he hasn't had that helpmate
to assist him as his confidant and hostess.
In that case, he must rely on a friend or relative
to act as his hostess in the position of acting First Lady.
Today we will talk about the acting First Lady
who served alongside the 21st President of the United States.
Her name was Mary Arthur McElroy. Chester Arthur became the 21st President
of the United States in 1881. He was not elected to this position.
He was the Vice President, but he took over in September of that year,
just a few months after the presidential inauguration, when
his presidential running mate, James Garfield,
succumbed to blood poisoning from an assassin's bullet.
Thus, he had to take over as the President.
He did not have a second lady who could become First Lady because
he was a widower. His wife, Ellen, had died in the year 1880,
before the election, as a result of pneumonia which developed from a bad
cold. At the time that he ascended to the
presidency, Arthur was considered the most
eligible bachelor, but he had no interest
in any romantic pursuits. Upon his beloved wife's death,
he vowed to never remarry. Thus, he had to rely on others,
besides his wife, to be the hostess of the White House.
He didn't fill this position immediately because the nation was in mourning for
Garfield, and the President was personally in
mourning for his wife. There wasn't a whole lot of
merriment or many festivities at first, but in January of 1883,
he invited his sister to host a White House event,
which would be her first time as the hostess of the White House.
Arthur was one of nine siblings, and the youngest sibling in his family
was a daughter, Mary. She was born in the year
1841, so she was several years younger than
her brother. By this point, she was a married woman,
and she had to leave her family in Albany
to act as hostess for her brother. As a young girl,
Mary had had a good education, and she ended up going
to the Emma Willard School, where she studied to be a teacher.
There, she studied history, geography, science, and French. This school was
considered quite progressive because in it, young ladies studied basically the
same subjects which men would study at college.
She was intent upon training to become a teacher, and
she did end up teaching in North Carolina.
Little is known about exactly where and for how long she taught.
We do know that on June 13, 1861, at the age of 19,
she married John Edward McElroy. He was a minister and an insurance
salesman who ended up owning his own insurance company.
They had four children together. Mary was granted the role of hostess
because she was already being a great help to her brother
in his condition as a widower. You see, he and his wife had had three
children. Their firstborn son had sadly died at the age of two many
years earlier, but they still had a son and daughter.
The son was a young man in his later adolescent years,
but the daughter turned 10 shortly after her father became president.
Thus, the young girl had no one to raise her
since her father did not remarry, so he relied on his beloved sister
to help raise his daughter, who was Ellen after her mother, but was
nicknamed Nell. Mary became very close to her niece,
Nell, and Nell also became close to her cousin, who was Mary's daughter.
The two girls were of a similar age and became very good friends.
In helping to raise Nell, Mary encouraged her pursuit of music
in honor of her mother, who had loved music very much.
The Arthurs had had a very loving marriage,
yet there had been some strains in their relationship from the fact that he was
frequently absent on his political journeys. He would go
off for different appointments and be very involved at the customs house
or in other political party meetings, and while Ellen
understood, she wasn't too fond of how many nights
he had to spend away from his family to be at the hall meetings.
After her death, in her memory, every day he would have fresh flowers
placed in front of her portrait in the White House.
Across the street from his office in the White House, there was a church
and he commissioned a stained glass window in her honor,
which was in a position that he could see it from his office.
It would be lit at night and he would gaze across the street at it.
Mary felt very unqualified for the position of
White House hostess because she was very shy and
she wasn't accustomed to entertaining on such a grand scale.
She's quoted as saying,
When I went to the White House, I was absolutely unfamiliar with the customs
and formalities. However, she quickly learned and
distinguished herself as a very exceptional First Lady.
She and her brother established a lot of customs which would continue to be used
by future presidents. For one thing, she would always serve tea
after White House gatherings and she established many types of
receptions which became very popular. At some of the later White House events,
she would use both her daughter and Nell as young hostesses to help.
And it was said that her use of children as greeting the guests helped make the
whole atmosphere much less stiff, much warmer and more inviting.
In redecorating the White House, she incorporated frequent use of gas
lighting and many plants. A faction of the
Republican Party at the time was ardently supportive of temperance and
the absolute ban of alcohol in the White House.
There had been previous Republican presidents and first ladies
who had enforced such a ban on alcohol. But despite being pressured to do so
herself, Mary wasn't interested in enforcing
any such ban on alcohol. She was not involved in politics herself
but she considered it her duty to be a charming, welcoming and warm hostess
to everyone who came to the White House during her time there.
She was only there until March of the first year, then returning to
her home in Albany because that winter time was the main
political season. She was given a farewell party when she left.
When she came back the following January, there was another reception
joyously held in her honor. Up to this point,
it had been the custom to curtail entertaining
in the White House during Lent. But she got rid of this practice and
continued having frequent gatherings, including a reception
every Sunday. As her brother's presidency was coming to an end,
she was very welcoming of the incoming president
and his first lady, who was also a sister and an acting first lady, and that was
Rose Cleveland. The two quickly became good friends and
her last official act was hosting a reception for her
shortly before they would leave the White House. And on her last day as first
lady, they held a little reception together.
During her time as first lady, she also had welcomed
previous first ladies, including Julia Grant,
to help her in some entertaining. And this open invitation to first ladies
past and future showed what a gracious woman she was
and how open, warm, and welcoming she was to other ladies.
And she also helped gain honors for the portraits and memories of past
first ladies. After leaving the White House, she of
course returned to her family in Albany. And shortly after that, she would travel
to Ireland to help establish the
preservation of the Arthur family estate there.
She would return to her brother's side when she realized he was dying
and she cared for him during the last stages of his illness.
Afterwards, she arranged his funeral and became the executress of his memory,
establishing some of the memorials in his honor
and unveiling a statue of him. She lived until the year 1917.
She wasn't very active in charities or other public or social
events or causes, as many first ladies were. The strongest political statement
she ever made was that she was very vocally against
women's suffrage. In fact, she was a member of the New York
Anti-Women's Suffrage League. So you could say that her strongest
political position was that women should not be
involved in politics. Although not that much is known about her
private life and her background, especially compared
to some other first ladies, Mary was very highly regarded in her
own day. And in estimates where
acting first ladies have been included, she is well regarded because
she did an excellent job of acting as hostess,
supporting her brother, helping him raise his daughter,
and establishing practices which would be continued in the White House
for many years afterwards. That's very commendable, especially because
she certainly didn't have a full four years to be first lady.
It really was just three brief winter seasons.
Mary Arthur McElroy is a great example of a woman who
felt like she wasn't quite qualified for the role
she was called upon to take. Yet she stepped up to the position
with grace and dignity and proved an excellent hostess for the
United States, being gracious, congenial,
and a loving mother substitute to the sadly motherless daughter of the
president. She's a great example of what a
gracious, modest, and charming lady should be.
Thank you for spending this time with me. I hope you'll join me next time
for more American Legends.