Abe Lincoln in Illinois (1940) explores the formative years of one of America’s most revered leaders. Long before the presidency, Abraham Lincoln was a thoughtful young man from the frontier of Illinois, wrestling with questions of ambition, responsibility, and the direction of a divided nation.
Through quiet moments, personal struggles, and the influence of those around him, the film traces Lincoln’s gradual emergence as a voice of moral clarity in turbulent times. With a powerful performance by Raymond Massey, this classic drama captures the humanity behind the legend and the journey of a man who would one day guide the nation through its greatest trial.
My eyes have seen the glory of the coming of the Lord.
He is trembling at the vintage where the grapes of love are stored.
He hath loosed the fateful lightning of his devil's red sword.
His truth is marching on.
Glory, glory, hallelujah.
His truth is marching on.
In the beauty of the lilies, Christ was born across the sea.
With the glory in his bosom that transfigures you and me.
As he died to make men holy, let us die to make men free.
While God is marching on.
Glory, glory, hallelujah.
His truth is marching on.
Have you ever read about Mary Todd Lincoln's life?
Yes, yes I have.
Isn't it shocking?
Yeah, I have to admit I was pretty surprised the first time I watched it.
Especially the fact that she was a cabaret star.
Wait, a what?
A cabaret star.
That's what she did before she married Lincoln.
And she always wanted to return to the stage while he was president.
Mary Todd was never a performer.
Yes, she was.
She resented her husband's presidency because it kept her from returning to the stage.
No, wait just a minute.
Mary Todd always said that she would marry a man who would become the president.
And she actually pushed Abraham Lincoln in his political career.
She gained a bad reputation for nagging him in public.
But she never...
She was actually very devastated when he was killed.
Well that's very different from what I read.
What are you reading?
A review of the Broadway hit, O Mary.
Oh, that's not based in historical fact.
It's a complete farce.
Really?
Yes.
If you want to watch something that's actually historically accurate about the Lincolns,
you need to see Abe Lincoln in Illinois.
I'm Rebecca Brannan.
I'm Tiffany Brannan.
Welcome to Real Thoughts on Cinema.
Abraham Lincoln is consistently ranked as the best and most beloved U.S. president.
In fact, more has been written about him than any other American citizen.
Because of this, it's hardly surprising that he has been represented in many movies,
even if it's just as a small cameo.
Many classic Civil War films feature even a brief depiction of Abraham Lincoln,
oftentimes because he symbolizes freedom and the unity of the states during this time period.
Within a year of each other,
two films focusing on Lincoln's pre-presidency life were released.
One of these films was a very historically accurate film
based on an award-winning play,
Abe Lincoln in Illinois from 1940.
This film was produced by RKO Radio Pictures.
The producer was Max Gordon,
the director John Cromwell,
and it starred Raymond Massey, Ruth Gordon, and Gene Lockhart.
The story begins in 1831,
when young Abe Lincoln leaves his family home
to take a job on a riverboat headed to New Orleans.
When the boat hits a mill dam,
he ends up on the shores of New Salem,
where he meets a very pretty young lady named Ann Rutledge.
It's love at first sight for Abe,
so when the ship owner starts a store in New Salem,
Abe is eager to befriend the young lady.
He quickly subdues the local bullies
and gains everyone's respect,
although he's sad to see that Ann already has a suitor.
Abe is a very honest man
who goes from one job to the next
because he doesn't have any particular aspiration
to do anything besides mind his own business
and leave a simple, happy life.
However, people around him are always encouraging him
that he should strive to do something better,
because he could be a great man.
After Ann Rutledge's death,
he goes to the big city to get involved in politics,
and eventually he meets Mary Todd,
who will become his future wife.
Through the influence of Mary and many other friends,
Abe is reluctantly pushed into a vibrant political career,
but deep down, he's haunted by fears that people will kill him.
This movie was really interesting
because it was based on a very successful play.
Right. The play was written by George S. Kaufman,
and it starred Raymond Massey on the stage as well.
In fact, he wouldn't sell the rights to RKO
unless they promised to put Raymond Massey in the role.
That's true.
And when writing this play,
the creators of the work were inspired by speeches
which Lincoln actually made.
And these were incorporated into the fabric of it
because they wanted to tell the real story of who he was
to get some insight into his nature and his character.
And I would go so far as to say the success of that play,
which was a Pulitzer Prize winner,
was what inspired even the other film about Abraham Lincoln,
which is Young Mr. Lincoln starring Henry Fonda in 1939.
Of course, Abraham Lincoln was extremely popular
during the 20th century
just because everyone regarded him as a great public hero.
But because of this play,
I think that really made people
start to want to make more works about him.
If one play could be really successful,
why not a different film?
Right.
But I think that this movie stands out
from other movies made about him.
And I really like the Henry Fonda film,
but I think this one really stands out
as being less of a Hollywood picture.
It doesn't have some of the, like, standard movie-making tropes.
And it's very realistic.
Yes.
Very historically accurate.
Interestingly, Raymond Massey was a little reluctant
to take the role because he was Canadian.
And he wasn't sure how people would accept
a Canadian playing this most famous American.
But seven years earlier,
he had promised the playwright, who was a good friend of his,
that he would always be there for him if he needed anything.
So he took him up on that offer.
And to get into that character,
Massey really studied the life of Abraham Lincoln.
And you have to admit, he looks a lot like him.
Yes, absolutely.
Just naturally.
He didn't need as much of the use of prosthetics.
He was very tall and thin.
It's hard to tell.
They may have used some kind of prosthetic on his nose,
maybe built up his cheeks a little.
And they definitely used some makeup and perhaps a wig, too.
It does look like he's wearing a wig.
And he has slight lifts in his boots.
But the way he affected that slow, drawing speech,
he got so much into the character of playing Abraham Lincoln
when he was first on the stage and then in movies
that they say he began going to parties
dressed as Abraham Lincoln.
He started speaking like that in daily life.
And people who were his friends commented
that he was so into the character of being Abraham Lincoln
that he wouldn't be happy until he was assassinated.
And he went on to actually play Lincoln four other times, right?
Right, yes.
He played the role five times.
He played it in a couple other movies
and then two filmed versions of the play for television.
And he jokingly quipped that he was the only actor
ever to be typecast as a president.
But interestingly, the play, just reading the synopsis of it,
it follows basically the same itinerary,
but it seems that the play starts a bit later
when he's already in New Salem and he's the postmaster.
So as he's off on the way in film,
it seems like they did flesh it out a bit more.
And it seems they got more into the details of Anne's death.
From the synopsis of the play, it sounds like he just comes in
and says Anne has died instead of seeing that happen.
As it is difficult to change from one location to the other on stage,
you couldn't really show him on a riverboat,
which is exactly what I was commenting on.
I was like, I don't think they could do this on stage.
So it's not surprising as they saw it,
we're going to make this a movie now,
how can we make this story come to life even more?
By showing some backwoods, showing his log cabin.
And the play really struck a chord at the time it was first debuted
because George Kaufman really put a lot of his personal feelings
into the play after having fought in World War I
and World War II was beginning to brew at that point in America.
It had been going on in Europe for a while.
But he was really kind of unhappy with how the post-war world had turned out.
So even though, of course, it's talking about the issues
of Abraham Lincoln's time in slavery and so forth,
Raymond Massey commented that if you replaced the word slavery
with dictatorship everywhere in the script,
it would be a very stirring message for the current time.
Yes, that's so interesting how you see in many golden era movies
that although they're historical pieces,
there could be commentary on World War II.
Or other issues of the day.
And even the talk in one of the speeches that Lincoln gives
about strikes and workers struggling to find work,
still issues lingering from the end of the Great Depression.
Absolutely.
As well as the difficult position of a president
who has to decide to bring his country into war,
even when he hates war.
And that feeling that so many men had, especially after World War I,
now it's supposed to be the war to end all war
and now we're going to get into another war.
So this film really captures all that nuance.
It's interesting to look at whether some of the people in it
are stage performers versus film actors.
Now, this was not the first movie Raymond Massey made.
He'd been in several other films,
but this really brought him to greater prominence
as he was nominated for an Academy Award for his performance.
The only other prominent character who also came from the play
was Howard Da Silva, who plays the bully he first defeats in New Salem.
I didn't realise he was a stage actor, because I've seen him in a lot of movies.
Da Silva had made a couple of uncredited film appearances before that,
but this was his first featured role,
and after that he would be in many other movies, as you mentioned.
And interestingly, he often played historically prominent characters.
Like he played Benjamin Franklin a couple of times,
and he played Thomas Jefferson.
So it's interesting that he got a start in a historical work like this.
Just touching on, though, that you mentioned Raymond Massey
was nominated for the Academy Award for this.
Interestingly, many years later, in 2012, in the film Lincoln,
the actor playing Lincoln won the Academy Award for Best Actor.
That's not the only time the two actors have been nominated for playing the same part.
It's the longest span of time there's been
between two actors being nominated for playing the same character.
That's interesting.
And it's not surprising that multiple actors
have been greatly acclaimed by critics for playing this role,
because, I mean, what a role to play.
Yes.
The most beloved president.
Those are big shoes to fill.
There must be a lot of pressure that goes along with that.
And to not make it too stereotypical, too much of a caricature.
Right, too much of a caricature, exactly.
Of course, no one has heard Lincoln's voice, who is living.
I guess if someone were really, really old in the late 1930s, maybe.
I don't know if anyone involved in this team had.
Maybe the actor who's playing the Revolutionary War soldier,
he's about 100 years old.
But people commented on that he had sort of a...
Some said he had sort of a high nasal voice,
which I think Henry Fonda had.
But he had a rather stilted, awkward way of speaking.
He wasn't smooth. He was...
Honest.
He was honest.
He was uncouth, rough around the edges, a back woodsman.
But that's what people liked him, honest old Abe.
And I think Raymond Massey really captured that.
One of the most striking actors, or actress, in this case, in this film,
to me, is Ruth Gordon.
Right.
Now, at first I thought perhaps she had come from the stage play
because she was quite a prominent stage actress,
but she wasn't in the stage version of this work.
Many people call this her film debut.
That's not completely accurate because she made many silent films,
oftentimes playing smaller, uncredited roles.
So I guess this is really her feature film debut.
And it certainly was the first film she'd made in many years.
I think the last movie she made before this was in 1921.
So it had been a long time.
And she was 44 by this point.
So definitely not your standard Hollywood leading lady.
Absolutely.
Particularly at the beginning of the film,
she's supposed to be pretty young.
But then when they show it's been 18 years,
suddenly you realize, oh, she's looking kind of middle-aged now.
And so they did a good job of making her look younger at the beginning,
but then you see that she is a more mature woman.
I do think that this film isn't that concerned about people's ages
because Raymond Massey is supposed to be in his early 20s
at the beginning of the film, and he's in his 40s.
And he looks like he's in his 40s.
Yeah, he really doesn't age a whole lot.
Maybe they gray his hair a little.
But as you pointed out, if you see early paintings of Abraham Lincoln,
or photographs of Abraham Lincoln, he actually was very old-looking.
There's one picture of Abraham Lincoln from the 1830s
that was recently found, later in the 1830s,
and then a few from the early 1840s.
He looks pretty old because he was so chiseled, almost gaunt.
And so tall.
And so tall and gangly and almost underweight for his height.
That gaunt look made him look perhaps older than he was.
And I thought it was interesting, more than anything visually,
what Raymond Massey did with his voice was really good
for showing the aging of the character.
Not just the tone, but the way he spoke when he was young.
He had that kind of shy demeanor that made him seem younger,
and then you could sort of hear in his tone the way he spoke,
the maturity.
So I thought that was very effective.
Right.
The first time I watched this film, I was really surprised
to see how unfavorable, you could say,
the depiction is of Mary Lincoln.
Now, I guess in my schooling up to that point,
which I'd gone through high school,
I hadn't read anything about Mary Lincoln.
I just figured, we don't like her.
She's a First Lady.
We must like her.
I thought she was great.
I thought she was like Martha Washington.
Don't we love her?
But I was surprised to see how much she's just nagging him,
and she seems kind of shrewish.
And then doing more research about her later,
I realized she was viewed very unfavorably in her own day.
Many people felt she kind of dragged Lincoln down.
But on the other hand, you have to give her credit
for the fact that without her influence,
he probably never would have made it to the White House,
because as the film very accurately depicts,
he didn't want to be president.
He didn't have political aspirations.
And he's not the only president
whose wife really encouraged him in that direction.
Right.
And I think the film does a good job
of not making her look just, like, horrible.
They show her really laying into him in front of people,
and you're just like, oh, my goodness.
But then she'll make comments,
and you see the other side of her,
especially this one political advisor.
She'll say, like, oh, I know you hate me.
Everyone hates me.
And he's like, no, I don't hate you, Mary.
You see, he understands, because he knows
he couldn't get Lincoln to follow
these political ambitions that he had for him.
He saw you could be a great man.
He's like, oh, no, no.
And he realizes, I may not like
how she's talking to him in front of everybody,
but I can't deny the fact
that she has encouraged him
to live up to his potential, you could say.
She was a very determined woman,
and she knew what she wanted,
and she knew what she wanted for her husband.
And I think looking at it as a modern viewer,
I think that's very important to see,
because so many, especially young women,
have been taught this ideology now
that before, like, maybe 50 years ago,
women had no voice, and you're just, like,
chained to the stove and shut up
and don't talk to the men.
And to really see how, particularly Mary Todd Lincoln,
but all the first ladies, if you study them,
how many of them had
such a prevalent political influence.
That's true.
Some of them were, like, a quiet helpmate,
and others, their husbands openly admitted
that they relied on their wives' advice.
Now, Mary Todd Lincoln particularly
was viewed sort of unfavorably
and seen as sort of gauche
because she was so open
about how politically involved she was.
It was all right to do it.
It wasn't really considered proper to talk about it.
So that's why people thought
she was a little bit too forward
and too vocal about that sort of thing.
And even the way she talked to him
in front of other people.
And there's a very dramatic scene in the film
when on election night, actually,
Lincoln very calmly, I might add,
says, don't talk to me like that
in front of people.
It's bad enough you do it when we're alone,
but you're humiliating both of us.
And she's taken aback.
She's like, you've never gotten angry with me before.
And it's such a contrast
because she's always, like, yelling at him,
and he very calmly, privately says,
please don't talk to me like that.
She's like, oh, you're angry with me.
He's like, that was very calm
compared to what you do to him.
But again, it's showing people are people.
There have been strong women
since the beginning of time,
and there have been,
I don't want to call Lincoln a weak man,
but more mild-mannered men.
He was strong in his quiet strength.
That was what was strong about Lincoln,
that he was a peaceful man.
It's interesting to find out more about Ruth Gordon
because first she was this stage
and early screen actress
who was married to this stage performer
who ended up dying when he was only 35.
And then she kind of scandalously, as a widow,
had a child with a prominent producer
to whom she wasn't married.
But they kind of lived together
as a married couple for a while
to raise that child.
And then she married Garson Cannon,
who was a very famous writer
in the early 1940s.
Right, that's a familiar name.
She's more famous in some circles
as part of this writing team.
She and her husband wrote Adam's Rib,
and Pat and Mike,
both very successful films
for their good friends,
Spencer Tracy and Katharine Hepburn.
That's amazing.
I remember seeing that Ruth and Garson Cannon, right?
Yeah.
And actually she won some Academy Awards
and Golden Globes for her writing first.
But along the way,
people would discourage her acting career.
She wasn't pretty enough.
She had kind of an odd voice
and obnoxious personality.
She was getting too old.
So she basically wasn't good enough.
And then she ended up winning an Academy Award
for Best Supporting Actress
for Rosemary's Baby
when she was in her 70s,
making her the oldest woman to win an Academy Award
for Best Supporting Actress in 72.
That's amazing.
And when she made her acceptance speech,
she's like,
thank you for giving me some encouragement.
It's like she'd already done so many things.
And that sort of revived her acting career,
and she made several other successful films after that.
But I think that that unconventional attitude
she had carries across to this.
And the fact that they cast her in this,
instead of a more conventionally attractive actress,
I think she looks very historical.
She does.
She really does.
Women who are important public figures in the past
are not always really beautiful.
It's by modern standards.
And it wasn't really considered good form for women
to wear makeup at this time period in the 1860s,
really any time in the 1800s.
I'm not saying some women didn't,
but it had to look natural.
It had to be unnoticeable.
If you looked like you were wearing makeup,
you were a painted lady.
And I think to reflect that,
she's wearing very minimal makeup.
She doesn't look overly made up.
She has a plainer affect.
And I do think it's a shame that she didn't do more
as a film actress,
because before seeing her in this,
actually I knew she was in this,
but I saw her in another film,
Edge of Darkness,
a World War II film,
and she was absolutely brilliant in that.
It was a supporting part,
but a very complex, multifaceted character.
She didn't have much screen time,
but when she was on screen,
you really noticed her.
She made quite an impact.
I think one of the most standard Hollywood type people
who plays a prominent role in this film is Gene Lockhart,
who plays Stephen Douglas,
the famous opponent of Abraham Lincoln.
And he was his rival throughout life.
Many people believe that he was his rival
for Mary Todd's romantic attentions,
since they definitely ran in the same circles.
I think the film did a good job
of striking closer to historical accuracy,
because some films actually have Mary
being really interested in Stephen Douglas,
or plays, other works.
But in this, he was interested in her,
but she turns him off pretty quickly.
She has her sights set on Abraham Lincoln.
And more in-depth research,
and more senior people found it very unlikely
that they actually were romantically involved,
even though they were in the same circles.
So I think it's good that they hinted at it,
but they didn't go so far
as that she was really interested in him.
And you see right away that she has it in her mind
she's going to marry a man who will become president,
which might seem like over-Hollywoodization,
but that's true.
She really said that as a young girl.
Then later, one of the pivotal parts of the film
is when these speeches are being made
by Stephen Douglas and Abraham Lincoln
as they're both running for Senate.
And that actually happened in 1859,
and that really catapulted Abraham Lincoln
to fame on the national level
because he made these speeches against slavery,
and he captured the public attention.
And they used quotes,
most notably from his famous
house-divided speech in the film.
And Raymond Massey delivers it just as,
as you know, Lincoln must have.
Yes, that was a very impressive scene.
It's very inspiring.
I appreciate the historical accuracy
that you see in the background design,
the way you see open flames burning around
while they're making these after speeches.
You really get the sense of the fact that they,
that was how they used lighting.
Right, and interestingly,
even though location footage wasn't very often done,
a lot of this was actually filmed in Eugene, Oregon.
Oh, interesting.
Standing in for Illinois.
And a lot of the places I filmed
apparently are still there, which is amazing.
Yeah, that's definitely a more rural area.
And I know as late as around that time,
there was no electricity
or indoor plumbing in that area.
So it was a good place for kind of a rustic setting.
Right.
And the costumes,
as well as the makeup and hairstyling of the women,
as well as the men, are very convincing,
and they really make you believe
that it's in that time period.
My outfit is inspired by the fashion of Ann Rutledge,
particularly the first dress we see her wear,
which is a very simple plaid frock like this
with a black belt, a bonnet,
and for most of her screen time, she wears a pendant,
which her betrothed gave her before going away.
My outfit is inspired by the late 1850s, early 1860s styles,
which Mary Todd Lincoln wears for most of the film.
Mrs. Lincoln was known for popularizing
the full hoop skirt,
and the simpler style, as well as the little bonnet
and the pearl jewelry,
reflects her balance between modesty
and a desire for opulence in her fashion.
Why do you think this is a good film for modern audiences?
I think that there will always be a fascination
with American history in a more palatable sense.
You know, we all have to learn about it in school,
but oftentimes it's just the bare bones.
Yes, and it's just, I'll memorize this fact,
write it on the test, and then forget it.
Right, but Abraham Lincoln is one of the names
which will stand out to almost everyone.
Interestingly, right now,
because of that Broadway play, Oh Mary,
I think that people might be thinking more about
who was Mary Todd Lincoln?
Sort of like Hamilton.
Exactly.
Some musical brought about interest in that part of history.
So the play definitely shows that she wasn't
the most conventional first lady,
but it's just insane, you know?
It's so goofy.
So I think that, if anything,
maybe it will encourage people to do a little research
on who was Mary Todd Lincoln.
This can't be real.
Let me look this up.
But a lot of people aren't going to want to read
an in-depth biography, even the long Wikipedia page.
It's pretty heavy to just read historical facts.
But to watch a film, it's less than two hours,
and it comes to life.
And I think because it was inspired by a play
and done in less the typical Hollywood style,
it's a little more edgy, for lack of a better term.
Yes.
I think the film is nicely, I would venture to guess
that they condensed it a bit from the play,
even though I know they expanded some things.
Yeah, because they expanded it earlier,
they might have had to condense later parts.
Right, maybe a little bit less long winded
in some of the more political aspects.
There were places where they sort of did passages of time
and so forth, and that's kind of the way,
oftentimes movies are more fast paced than plays.
So I think even more than a stage production,
this could really be approachable for people,
because the play has been revived multiple times.
One of the notable times was in the early 90s,
and it was nowhere near as well received
as when it first debuted,
and I think that's just a testament to...
Changing times?
Changing times and people's attention span
is getting worse, especially in live theater.
Because of, I don't know, some strange things
that were happening in the society of America,
people don't love Lincoln the way they used to.
Yeah, it came off, they thought it came off
sort of preachy or something.
But I think that the film captures
what was best about that play,
immortalized it, made it more colorful,
and made it more approachable.
And it does something which is so brilliantly seen
in so many classic films,
where it kind of gives you the freedom
to make up your mind.
Yes.
About how you feel about all the people in the story,
instead of just pushing a really strong narrative.
Yeah.
I want to say it's even less dramatically
pro-Lincoln than it possibly could be.
It's just very much showing facts.
And that's the way that it really feels historical.
Yes.
Without being, you know, dry or...
And I have to hand it to you,
this film is very historically accurate.
Like, it's really close to the facts.
And while still being very entertaining.
And probably the greatest historical inaccuracy
is a few times you hear the use of famous Civil War songs,
which hadn't been written yet.
Like, Rally Round the Flag.
Right.
And of course, I can't begrudge them the right
to have the beautiful dramatic conclusion
playing the Battle Hymn of the Republic
as he's going on the train to Washington,
which wouldn't be written until November of the year 1861,
just a few months later.
But it really is...
Close enough.
It's a beautiful moment as he's riding away,
looking so much like Abraham Lincoln,
having just grown his beard.
Yeah, when he gets a little bit further away,
it's like, wow.
It's really moving as you're playing that great song.
So, if you're interested in American politics at all,
or maybe you haven't been,
but you feel like you'd like to know a little bit more
about our greatest president,
I highly recommend watching this film,
because I think you'll find it to be
a very entertaining watch,
as well as very enlightening.
It's available for rent or purchase
on Amazon Prime Video
and many other streaming platforms
in a very crisp black-and-white copy.
It's also available for free on YouTube,
still in a very crisp black-and-white copy.
As we mentioned,
Lincoln has been depicted in countless works
because he is considered our greatest president.
However, in the annals of American history,
there are many other figures
who are remembered for very different contributions.
Join us next time as we discuss another biopic,
this one about a man who could be called
the greatest American composer.
Thank you for watching.
Goodbye.