What is it like to work on ancient English churches, cathedrals and stone monuments? How does stone, a symbol of permanence, change and decay over centuries? In this interview, I explore the craft of stonemasonry with church conservator Andrew Ziminski.
Andrew Ziminski is a stonemason and church conservator with decades of experience working on some of the greatest cathedrals and churches in Britain. He’s also the author of The Stonemason: A History of Building Britain and Church Going: A Stone Mason’s Guide to the Churches of the British Isles.
The ancient craft of stonemasonry and how the tools have remained unchanged for millennia How stone is damaged over time by settlement, weather, and even the metal used to build with The defining features of Gothic architecture, a movement focused on light and colour, not darkness Why the “Green Man” carvings in churches are Christian symbols of resurrection, not pagan figures How ancient churches can feel imbued with the atmosphere of centuries of human experience
Hello Travellers, I'm Jo Francis-Penn and today I'm here with Andrew Zeminski. Hi Andy!
Hello Jo, if I can call you Jo. Yes, absolutely. So just a little introduction. Andrew is a
stonemason and church conservator with decades of experience working on some of the greatest
cathedrals and churches in Britain. He's also the author of The Stonemason, A History of Building
Britain and Churchgoing, A Stonemason's Guide to the Churches of the British Isles and I'm a fan
and I have the books right here if you're watching the video. So I love them. So thank you so much
for coming on today Andy. So I want to get straight into it because part of why I love
churches and cathedrals is this sense of timelessness, of being small against the backdrop
of history and I wondered how does it feel for you when you're working on these ancient buildings,
doing this ancient craft? Well in theory I should be getting bored of it. I mean I've been doing it
so long but it seems like my interest seems to grow with every project that we work on.
We pretty much only work on ancient churches and medieval bridges, the odd castle every now
and again and there's always something new to discover, be it a particularly local school of
carvers or a type of medieval graffiti that I see carved into the piers of a particular church.
There's so many regional variations in the British Isles that in terms of architecture and materials
and the approach of the people who built these places that I'm always sniffing them out
and as I understand more it makes me want to understand even more if that doesn't sound too
crazy. So yeah I think the day I'll stop nosing around these places will be my last one on the
planet I think. Hopefully not falling off some some spire. Didn't you work on Salisbury spire?
Yeah I started my training at Salisbury. I went to a local stonemasonry college because our part of
England the southwest is renowned for its building stones and there used to be a really nice
and very excellent stonemasonry college at Weymouth on the coast in Dorset as I say in
the southwest of Britain and from there I went up to the top of the tower, not the spire but the tower
which is the square section that supports the octagonal base of the spire which is 404 feet
tall and the tallest medieval structure in Europe that's still in its original condition. It's
pretty amazing I think. It is Salisbury is amazing and you mentioned there ancient churches so some
people listening might be in places where they don't have such ancient architecture as we have
so what time frame are you talking about when you say ancient churches? Well the oldest church I've
worked on is in Bradford-on-Avon in Wiltshire again in the southwest. I tend to focus on the
churches of this part of the world and that was built around the year 1000 and anything from then
onwards really I tend to switch off with Victorian churches because I'm not really that interested in
them. Victorian churches in the UK are generally Victorian interpretations of earlier medieval forms
and I think well I might as well just study the medieval form and not Victorian fakers even though
their craft work is excellent but very often in the churches that we work on we're very close to
the city of Bath where you are as you know is absolutely groaning with Roman ruins and it's not
unusual to see Roman material that the Anglo-Saxons reused in their walls or as part of their altars
or things like that so I've done lots of work in the Roman baths in Bath so I'd say the earliest
oh no just thinking about the earliest structure I've worked on is the West Kenwick Long Barrow
which was built about 3000 BC so it's even got its own postcode
I've worked on a building that's 5,000 years old and that was quite... Which is incredible and
just again coming back to this sort of ancient craft because the stonemasonry is also ancient
obviously the people who built these things were stonemasons so when you decided to get into this
I guess how did you decide because most people don't go into stonemasonry right it's not it's
not a growing profession I mean maybe it is now but it's so fascinating that you chose this
direction like what was it? Well a number of factors came into play my father came here as
a refugee during the war the only options for him as a job were going down the coal mine or
working it's a long story but working as a stonemason on in a granite quarry and we used to
go up to Scotland and I like the permanency of the things he made at that time and he'd say
he was Polish and he'd say son this will last for a million years and they probably will because
they're built of granite they probably will last for a million years so I quite like the permanency
of that from a young age and I've always had a deep interest in history don't know where that
comes from just a weird only child who just read too much and then I thought okay how can I how can
I draw together the worlds of craft and history and going down the what little I knew from my
father seemed like a good a good way and 35 40 years on I haven't looked back it's the best you
there was no career advice it was just you're a doofus go and work in sweet the streets you know
so yeah there you go yeah well I do find it fascinating so totally ridiculous it based on
what you do but I went and did like a weekend of stone carving and so I did actually use some of
the tools and boy my body hurt like you know I'm a writer I'm on my desk so what the physicality
of what you do because like you mentioned there the permanency of stone this is hard material so
is it very physical or is a lot of what you do I don't know now with chemicals or how does the job
work so I'm a conservator first and foremost and that what that means is that I keep as much
original my aim is it's like dentistry I guess if there's a cavity if the stone around the cavity
or the rot is okay I will fill it using a lime mortar which is a very ancient technique that
the Romans used to build construction and repair things but you know you can't lift a quarter of a
ton size piece of stone you've got to use kit so many people are surprised when I'm on site and I'm
with my colleagues and half my colleagues of women it's odd thing to say but very often I find that
women make better you know better stonemasons than some of my more gung-ho
male colleagues who just you know want to bust their backs and destroy their bodies by
lifting things they can't lift and or shouldn't lift but the tools that we use are unchanged
since Roman times or even ancient Egyptian times that my mallet did you use a little mallet yeah
yeah they're quite big like the end is quite big like yeah yeah but that's I mean the head of my
dummy is made of nylon but the ancient Egyptians used mallets made of palm trees turned on a lathe
you know palm trees yeah something like cedars cedar and palm tree turned on a lathe so there's
the materials might be different but the tools and the form of the tools and the approach and
the mindset are exactly the same so the way I would approach cutting a block of stone is not in
any way different to someone who's cutting a limestone block for the Great Pyramid at Cheops
you know Cheops is Great Pyramid or in the Roman Baths in Bath or in the Colosseum or at Notre
Dame it's this sort of really brilliant handing on of the baton over the generations that
goes unnoticed and I like that about craft skills. Are young people coming into it like is there
another generation because I feel like as you say that kind of craftsmanship are we losing that or
is it still here? No there's stonemasons in every hedgerow around here. Oh really? Yeah because it's
a stony area and the local college in Bath is in Stonemasonry College in Bath is really good
no shortage of youngsters coming through at all I mean it's great it's different in other parts
of the country where there isn't such a strong tradition maybe in the north it's not quite as
acute but certainly around here in South West Britain, Southern Britain in London there are
lots of stonemasons but there are other crafts that are suffering from a demise in interest
mainly because people don't know that these jobs exist and I think that's a big problem so I
spent all last week at the Chalk Valley History Festival which got tens of thousands of visitors
and it's just about educating them especially young people that it's possible to earn a living
that's good for your soul good for your body and good for society and bad for your bank balance
yeah undertaking a traditional craft be that stonemason or oak carpenter or a stone slater
all church roofs need stone slaters and that's an area where there is a real shortage and
if you want to become a millionaire in 10 years time become a church stone slater because that
is you know that's what I think I would do actually if I was starting out again I would
focus on that but then you love the stone now I guess and that's that's what you
yeah certainly in your book that's what you love yeah I mean I because our business is tiny
there's just eight of us and we just go from job to job we've had to become generalists so we can
carve pretty much anything we could rebuild any vault we could repair a hole in a wall and plaster
up we've got a broad range of skills but we're not specific and in the craft of stonemasonry
there are lots of different areas you can be you can focus on being a letter cutter
for example and just do headstones or memorials or you could be a sculptor of some sort or you
could be a what they call a banker mason you're just in a workshop making components to be fitted
into a church or a fixer mason but we sort of have to do all of that so we're a bit slower
than the people who choose to specifically focus on one of those types of tasks well I also am
interested in because when I was attracted to this whole sort of area and gothic cathedrals
and it was this sense of things last like you said your dad had said it like this will last
a thousand years or this will last a million years because the stone is there and so we think of stone
as something that doesn't change and it's used as a metaphor for unchanging and unyielding and yet
your very job is fixing stone so what what changes and damages stone over time what are you fixing
so uh settlement within the structure this always is very often the problem very often with when
these buildings were put up say a norman church or cathedral in the 12th century because they
hadn't quite got the engineering right they would tend to settle around the central tower so you get
lots of cracks and settlements in the arches you know you look at a norman arch adjacent to a tower
so norman arch is semi-circular like a roman arch pre-gothic that that will very often have settled
and there'll be some deflection in the arch and it's details like that that always need
maintaining you know you've always got to insert a new piece of slate and point it up or a bit of
oyster shell or some special wiso chemical resin solution but um different stones erode in different
ways in different parts of the country so they've all historically been subject to acid rain and
acid rain in limestones causes a particular problem externally but the core of the stone
will very often be in good condition so that will be repaired as i mentioned earlier with
lime mortars or we'll just do some dentistry and cut out the rods replace it with a new piece of
stone we seldom recreate whole new elements but some stones in this part of the world are very
good and some are rubbish you know like the the church at bradford and even the anglo-saxon church
have you visited that no i think i know the one like i walked past it but i haven't
you're going there tomorrow okay it's just astonishing it's been there you know it's
been there since the year 1000 there's no new stone in it at all it's because the anglo-saxons
had the pick of the quarry the face of the quarry so they knew where the best stone was
so very this is something i've noticed very often the anglo-saxon churches will be a bigger blocks
and later than their later editions and be of a better quality of stone so that
going down the line they're still there and hanging around so as i say they have the pick
of the stone and it's going to be larger and of better quality the very often victorian stonework
is a bit rubbish and the way that the victorians chose to build they didn't build in a sort of
gothic if we're looking at a reproduction gothic victorian church the victorians wouldn't have
built in the gothic style from an engineering perspective i.e you have some squared off stones
on the inside and the outside and it would all be tied together in a rubbly core so the whole
building was the walls were all unified but with the victorians they would just they they would
clad a rubble core with stonework and use cast iron cramps to reach into the core of the building
and the cast iron corrodes because it's type of iron and that causes all sorts of problems so
victorian churches generally aren't that well built either. I've seen that i did visit the
Salisbury stone mason yard and they talked about that and how the metal basically like you said
about dentistry you think that that discoloration and the kind of almost rotting but the stone you
mentioned in Bradford-on-Avon so what is quality when it comes to stone I guess? I think what might
have helped Bradford is that it's in a pretty rural area actually even though there were factories
there whereas Bath is an urban area it's a very similar type of stone in Bath but as I say you're
looking at one when one visits Bath one's looking at Georgian Bath so it's you know so a less
slightly less durable stone has been selected because the Anglo-Saxons and the Normans had a
pick of what was coming out and what tends to happen in Bath is that the coal that was
extracted from the Somerset coalfields was a very high sulfur coal and everyone was burning that in
their grates so consequently all the buildings were covered in a sort of sulfation blackened crust
and that weakens the outside of the stone but with the Saxon church at Bradford-on-Avon I think
there's a simplicity in materials as well that's helped it I mean this the masons who turned up to
build this wonderful little building literally extracted the stone from behind them on the
quarry face that's still there put up this stone this structure with this with stone blocks but
they didn't use a cement mortar or a lime mortar anything like that they just used clay from the
and when we opened up one of the corners there was a bit of movement you just smell the river
from a thousand I know was it two thousand no thousand what year are we now I don't know 2025
1025 years ago you know it was just incredible so we just knocked it up in a bucket put it back in
did you get did you go to the river and get some some more stuff for like no we just knocked up
what was in there and we had some water and um yeah but um but I've noticed that like on the
bridges around Bradford around this little village the small town called Bradford-on-Avon there's
two medieval bridges and we've worked on both of them extensively and they were constructed in the
same way so when they were sinking the piers sort of the central sections that the arches spring from
they would sink them down into the river bed and of course the river beds clay and there's just tons
of clay coming up so they would just use that to glue together the stones so all these incredible
13th century bridges and the tithe the adjacent yeah I mean it's it's astonishing isn't it and
it's just beautiful old stone and clay you know simplicity and you know be there for another
yeah I mean hopefully well I want to come back to gothic because you mentioned the gothic and I love
a gothic cathedral but for people who might not know I mean many of my listeners are also
book people and gothic literature is like dark and quite different whereas gothic architecture
is more about light and airiness and height and all this so make it you talk about what
are the hallmarks of gothic and some of the places that you've worked on yeah I think the whole sort
of giving that form of literature that the name gothic is a bit of a misnomer yeah I think so
the gothic movement is all about light and color it's all about uh you know norman churches these
tall dark churches had tiny windows and thick walls and the gothic movement was all about
getting the actual you know light was the actual essence of god itself so they wanted to flood
the altar and the church itself with with light so consequently you get much bigger windows
pointed windows windows with like a branch network that within to hold the glass that's called
tracery and medieval churches would have been highly colored they would have been lit by candles
they would have been an incredibly sensory it would have been an incredibly sensory experience
so I really don't get the whole gothic the whole gothic movement at all really it's just
completely wrong yeah it is it is a little weird and yeah I feel like people get gothic architecture
wrong because they I guess also like you think of the hunchback of Notre Dame for example and
the darkness and all that but again that's not Notre Dame inside and that kind of whole
architectural thing so where have you worked on in terms of gothic cathedrals um well I trained at
St Salisbury spent a few years a few enjoyable years there learning learning the ropes I've
worked at Wells Cathedral and Somerset or maybe just tell people about the scissor arches at
Wells because that's a very special kind of architecture isn't it okay yeah so what tended
to happen with norman churches which you could say they're sort of early churches they borrowed
roman architectural forms and tried to make them taller they moved on from the sort of basilican
idea so they had thick walls tiny windows and as they got taller and they introduced the gothic
system was was introduced there was a desire for gothic buildings that were built on a norman core
and reach further up into the heavens and at Wells they started to build a central tower
so you look down the main part of the body of the church that's called the nave and you've got
wings coming off the arms of the cross if you like they're called transepts and the most sacred part
as I'm sure all your listeners know is at the east end and that's where the chapels are and
so this big tower that they just started to build without any you know and done a
proper engineering analysis they just started to build the thing and as it went up and they put a
lead spire on the top it just started to sink back down and this this deflection I was talking about
earlier on the side walls of the side arches adjacent to the tower that we quite often have
to repair well it all started to split and come apart so the thing was about to collapse
so the master mason at that time there was a chap called William Joy rather brilliant name
Joy he just came up with this this very practical solution of introducing these scissor arches
and they're called scissor arches because they look like a pair of open scissors placed one
on top of the other with the loop at the central section and that that the loop of the you know
where you would put your fingers takes all the strain from all the surrounding stresses that
are going on from the transips that want to lean into where the tower was and where the tower was
itself it's it's one of the great and I'm sure you'll put a picture up oh yeah yeah definitely
in the show notes it's beautiful I mean you said there it's very like it was architecturally
functional but it's beautiful right stunning church oh it's it's completely mad and Wales
is so great because the carving inside it's got this great west front which is the greatest west
front in Britain it's full of pretty incredible carving that's survived since the 1220s 1240s
the actual carving inside is just as astonishing it's a tour de force really of the medieval
sculptor's art there's this form of leaf called stiff leaf and it's not a real leaf it's a
composite form and it's it just draws together all all architectural leaf carving and you can
you know you know that this if once your stiff leaf eye is in that sounded too weird
um you you you could you can date any church on the basis of the stiff leaf you know so and it
varies in quality but the stuff at Wales is just it's the best in the country but by a mile it is
it is stunning and there's lots of you know I'm sure did you see the toothache did you see all
the last time oh yeah it's kind of all these little strange cartoon like carvings of people
people with toothache holding a mouth open like that yeah there is a lot of comedy in some of
these churches that you think how did they get away with that I mean even the carving I did was
a green man and like people people don't know what a green man is maybe you could explain why we have
things like a green man in a Christian place funny enough you have been carving a green man all this
week at the history festival so green man seems a pretty sort of pagan uh an uncompromisingly pagan
figure but if you actually I refer to the stiff leaf form earlier gothic stone carving is full
of foliate forms doesn't matter where you go in the country as long as there's some stone is
between the 1220s and the reformation just stonemasons were like a school of dolphins or
something they would just carve and carve and carve like you wouldn't believe I mean so much is
missing but so much remains that is just of astonishing quality and sticking a face in these
foliate forms it seems a rational thing to do now these faces they're not the faces of saints
or pagan figures or anything like that it just indicates the abundance of nature which I guess
you could say is a pagan pre-christian consideration but it's it's about rebirth
regeneration and most importantly resurrection so these characters are uncompromisingly christian
in my view I don't think they're a hangover from pre-christian days because there's no sort of
bridge you don't you don't see an anglo-saxon green man you know so you might you you won't
really see a uh a norman green man so there's a period of from the year say 8 900 through to
the early 14th century where you won't see this form and then it just appears and it appears with
all this this wonderfully vital carving that you see in places like Wales but they're a really good
form in ceiling bosses where you have a where you have a vault a ceiling vault you know with the
stone roof that's a big arch with ribs and all that and to lock lock the lock all the stones
together at the top you need a really massive circular feature called a roof called a boss
and decorating that with a green man is a very obvious thing to do so it's you know you've got
to decorate it with something and there's only so many lives of the saints and lives
uh events in christ's life that you can portray so the green man's very very common I did also
want to ask you because in church going talking about more of the spiritual element you said
atmosphere should have its own entry in this book it's usually been as tangible a presence as
anything else so what kinds of those sort of experiences have you had and why do non-religious
people love these places and feel something in these places well you really have read my book
thank you oh yeah it's underlined in everything well post-it notes and all that so um atmosphere
I mean it's it's impossible it's such a personal thing isn't it you know like I go into a church
at six in the morning it's the middle of winter it'll be cold it'll be cold and frosty and the
the heating won't be on but the sun will be coming up and the sun will radiate through the east
window it will and and these sort of first first glimpses of the day will light up the
the moats that are floating around in the church and you can't not be moved by these places I think
I refer to the walls of a church like an old-fashioned night storage heater that slowly
release the births the death the coming together the tragedy the the pathos of life that's taken
place since these are places since these places first went up seven eight hundred years ago and
that's I don't have a particular faith but I think I just I just get by knowing there's something
else going on I can't quite I've yet to meet an incumbent who's sat me down and said right it's
like this it's interesting you say like the storage heater and I feel too that when there is emotion
in a place and it sort of becomes imbued with it and you can perhaps sense some of that emotion
but what's interesting is some places you go and you really do feel something and other churches
you know there's this idea of dead churches and there are some that clearly had worship in them
but do feel dead and other ones you go in and you're like oh yeah like Wells just does have
such a feeling in it and then you go in somewhere else um it's like St Paul's Cathedral in London
I don't feel anything there and that has had lots of people so like why do you think that might be
yeah I'm completely with you about St Paul's it's weird I worked there for a while and it was very
interesting um Tony the guy who was teaching me he was the master carver there and he'd been there
since he was a boy and he was taught after you know he was taught in the 1950s when London
was recovering from the second world war and his education was rebuilding Christopher Wren's city
of London churches and I would you know he would send me off every lunchtime to go and look at a
different church and I found more more of that vibe going on in the churches really than the
people it's a bit too echoey and full of people and not yeah maybe overly military
yeah you've got to pay 30 quid to get in or something that said you've got to pay 30 pounds
to get into Westminster Abbey which I find so appalling but I think charging to get into any
church is appalling but you know unless it's a couple of quid or something but Westminster Abbey
I mean talking about atmosphere it's in the middle of busy busy London and it's just the
most atmospheric of all the it's not a cathedral but it's a it's a royal peculiar it's the church
of the of the monarch and it's just I've shivered a few times in there over the years when I've
managed to plug my way in for nothing through the gift shop wow how interesting I mean that
really has a lot of famous burials and I've got some photos there of this kind of skeletons
there's some really good sculpture there but it is interesting and you're as you said you're not
religious you're not a Christian or I am a bit but not really yeah so but this is interesting
isn't it how how we feel that and feel that in stone well we're almost out of time I could talk
so apart from your own books obviously what are a few that you might recommend because this is the
books and travel podcast what are a few books you might recommend that feature stonemasonry
or architecture or death culture death culture wow that's a good one um uh fiction either
whatever you like if everyone on the planet has to read a month in the country
by um car what's his name car it's a novella about these two first world war veterans that
are working one's working as an archaeologist looking for I won't say what he's looking for
and the other is a is a wall painting restorer working and they're working together in this
church and it's the most wonderful short read that really fills in a lot of spaces
if you're trying to understand what our medieval churches are about I can't emphasize how I can't
emphasize enough what a wonderful wonderful book it is you know um yeah bang so you got that in
terms of understanding because we look at old churches now and we don't really understand what
what they're about they're you know they're a machine of faith you know they're a machine of
sacredness but that sacredness that that machine was designed before the reformation
and the reformed the english reformation and the reformed church just um of after the 1540s just
turned its back on much of what you would see in in these churches so there's a really brilliant
uh really really brilliant book I mean it's a proper brick it's by a chap called damon
duffy and it's called the stripping of the altars it's very entertaining but every page
every page is a winner I've got this book here I'll just go to my bookshelf
this is this is an odd gosh I could go on and on I've got a whole shelf of books here do you want
shall I show you yeah absolutely we love bookshelves okay right right so look there's oh
that's great they're not all church books but um here's my church book pile
country church monuments oh the pilgrim's way I've walked that
where's your your books here somewhere um uh yeah look at that see if someone wants
to get carried away they can just uh be nosy on my um my my books selection this is a lovely book
really nice chap king of dust I have that right next to me that's on my stone mason's list yeah
it's complete it's very specific to a certain area i.e. Cornwall but if you want to understand
the weirdness the weirdness of sorry about that tour no no it's great we should just say that's
yes yeah yeah thoroughly recommended brilliant and then of course we are saying this one old
parish life this is a book it was self-published and self-printed by by the chap who wrote it
and it's just it's wonderful this chap has been spending his whole life raiding um old parish
um accounts so say stop and i'll read you a random thing will be worth it okay okay uh go stop
burial before the reformation in 1556 there was a payment to phelps the tinker for the
mending of the corpse bell of 12 shillings that's awesome yeah love a corpse bell um
so who's that by just so we know um gosh who is the chap he's a bit elusive don't know
Bunbury press but he's jolly brilliant yeah anyway that's fantastic okay so where can
people find you and your books online oh I know if it weren't that yeah my church going books
and available in all the good bookshops I imagine I don't know about it's not in America I don't
think but it's um it's probably on Amazon it'll probably be on yeah I guess you can just get
anything from from anywhere can't you yeah brilliant well thank you so much for your
time Andy that was great thanks Jo nice to meet you