Interview: On Alexander the Great in Ancient Art & Literature w/ Meg Finlayson

The Discovery of Mesopotamia
7 followers
44 Video Views·Sep 17, 2024
Hi there, you're listening to the Hellenistic Age podcast interview episode on Alexander the Great
in Ancient Art and Literature with Meg Finleyson. Hi there everyone, today I have with me Meg
Finleyson in order to talk about the image and legacy of Alexander the Great. Meg is a recent
graduate student having received a Master's in Classics at the University of Edinburgh
Her focus has been largely on the image of Alexander the Great in ancient literature and art
having published a dissertation on the Alexander sarcophagus and its relation to Near Eastern
world iconography. First off, I'd like to say welcome to the show. Thank you very much for
having me. As an up-and-coming classicist, could you give the audience a brief overview of what
led you down the road towards Alexander the Great and the ancient world in general? Yeah,
so I've been studying classics in one form or another for about seven years now. So I first
fell into classics kind of by accident when I was choosing my A-level options which in the UK
is the last two years of compulsory study when you're about 16 to 18. I didn't really have much
of a background in ancient history before then. I think I did one year of Latin in school that
was we just kind of had an elderly teacher and I think it was a bit of a favour to her to tick her
over to retirement. So nobody really took it very seriously. But when it came to choosing my options,
I originally wanted to do something very different. I was quite interested in Russian history and I was
quite good at Spanish as a language, so I thought I would just continue that on. But unfortunately
that didn't work out with the other options I'd chosen for my timetable. So the admin kind of
sat me down and said, oh you're going to have to choose something else. So I thought about it and
just asked, well what do you have that is the closest thing to history? And they said, well the
guy who teaches history also teaches this other subject called classics. So I thought, okay just
put me in that, sounds fair enough. And I wasn't anticipating it to really go anywhere, but when I
started studying for this class, I started reading the text and you know participating in the lessons,
something about classics just really struck me and something about the story of Alexander and
the work that we were doing on the ancient sources, Arian, Plutarch, all the big, all the greats,
just really stuck with me. And it kind of set me on this path to choosing to do classics university,
choosing to pursue my master's degrees, and it's taken me all the way up now to applying for PhD
places. So it's been quite a journey, sort of started off by accident. So thank you to the
lovely admin team at the school who put me on this path. So the life of Alexander the Great, or more
specifically his campaigns against the Persian Empire, is arguably one of the most documented
events in the ancient world and subject to countless biographies and writings from authors
both ancient and modern. But almost nothing composed within Alexander's lifetime survives, and
we have to rely on the secondhand retellings of memoirs and biographies that have been since lost
to the passage of time. How was the legend of Alexander being crafted both during and immediately
following his reign? What sort of work do we have to do when trying to sort between fact and fiction
of what authors like Plutarch and Arrian tells us, or is the legend all we really have?
I find the historiography of Alexander the Great, so even not so much the events that happened,
more so the way that these events are recorded and written, to me that's really one of the most
interesting things about Alexander, because as you say, nothing that we really have that is dated to,
contemporaneous to his lifetime, survives. I think the earliest sources we have are for Roman things
that are written perhaps 300 years after his death. That's quite a long gap, and a lot happened
in those 300 years in terms of Alexander's legacy, his life, the way that his image was changed,
and the way that he became known and spoken about in the Greek world and then in the Roman era and
the Roman Empire. So these sources present to us really an image of Alexander, but it's really
an image of, I guess, the Roman Alexander in a sense. It's not necessarily Alexander as he acted,
behaved, and was thought of during his lifetime. It's almost a snapshot of Alexander as he was
recorded and believed to have been some 300 years later. So the source tradition is, it's very
complex. So we have a number of historians whose work survived mostly intact. You've got a nice
biography by Plutarch. Plutarch also talks about Alexander in a couple of his other essays and work.
We have Arrian, whose Anabasis is one of the longest and most complete accounts of Alexander's
work. And then we have other historians like Diodorus, who wrote on Alexander as part of a
wider history. You have Curtius, who wrote his own version of Alexander. And then you have things like
Justin, who again was writing on Alexander as part of a wider history and various bits and pieces
and fragments of history that survives. So on the surface, it seems as though we have quite a wealth
of information to do with Alexander. We have multiple authors that survived in fairly good
conditions and some fragmentary evidence. But when you kind of start to read and delve into it a
bit more, some of these histories are contradictory in part. They're very complex. They make up
different things. They attribute different names and different actions, different motivations to
things that he does. So it almost, you can imagine there's like a massive chalkboard and you're
putting in different pieces like, oh, well, Arrian said this, but Plutarch said this. And when you
try and compare them all like that, you kind of ended up with a bit of a tangled mess, this kind
of literary legacy of Alexander the Great. But I still think there's something quite interesting
in there that is worth talking about and worth researching. It tells us a lot about how Alexander
was perceived. It tells us a lot about how history writing at that time was evolving and becoming a
more complex genre than what we consider history today. So something that I looked at for my
undergraduate dissertation was the artifice in these literary portraits. So when you read
the account by Arrian, for example, Arrian quite explicitly in the beginning of his work says,
I wish to be the Homer to Alexander's Achilles. So he's not just wanting to write a book that is
something that is factual. He also wants to write something that is entertaining, something that
will be preserved by posterity as a work of great literary merit, as well as something that is
informative. We tend to say that Arrian is the best of the sources. He tends to be the one who
cites where he got his information from. So even though we don't have these original works,
we know that there were a number of works, a wealth of works written about Alexander by people
who knew him in his lifetime. So supposedly there's the work of Callisthenes, who was one
of the court historians. And we know that Ptolemy, King Ptolemy I, Pharaoh of Egypt,
also wrote a history based on his own experience being on campaign with Alexander. And we know
these existed at one point because we have various authors such as Arrian, and I think perhaps
Curtius also mentions the existence of these, and they cite these as being the sources or
inspiration for their own work. So we know that grains of truth and aspects of truth are being
preserved through these ancient sources. So they do have some merit, but it's always worth keeping
in mind when you read them that what you're looking at is as much a literary portrait as it
is a true history. So especially with Plutarch and Curtius, they're writing not just about Alexander
as a historical figure, but they're also trying to tell a sort of a morality tale at the same time.
So Plutarch is, you know, he's renowned for being a biographer, not a historian. He's very much
concerned with character as much as he is concerned about writing down what really happened. So when
he's telling us about Alexander and some of the things that happened later in his life, in his
reign, and particularly his murder of his friend, Cleitus the Black, Plutarch describes to us how
he kind of is overcome with this madness, or he's kind of overcome with this horror, and he kind of
calls out and blames Dionysus for this terrible event. It's not just that he's, you know, you
imagine the real life Alexander was blaming the gods for his actions, but Plutarch is sort of
sowing this seed and creating this idea of Alexander as almost a motif of what can happen
if you indulge too much in drink, if you kind of get too drunk and lose control of your actions.
It's almost a morality tale in a sense. So the histories are a little bit complicated when you
first approach them because you're not quite sure how to, what to make of them really, because on the
one hand you think, well these are ancient sources, it's the best we have, are they being 100%
factual? And then you can kind of ping the other way and go, well no, we're looking at things that
were written centuries afterwards, there's all these set pieces, all these kind of outlandish
anecdotes that I really don't think happen. Especially for some of the sources in
Curtius, he writes about quite a few of the more salacious details I suppose, you would imagine
that that's probably the equivalent of the tabloid coverage maybe. So it's quite easy to ping the
other way and say, well actually they're not that useful at all, we don't really know what the real
Alexander is like, how could we possibly when what we're looking at has been so finely constructed
and it's based in so many things, it's based in 300 years of changing literary traditions and
historical perceptions. But I think the answer as always really lies somewhere in between the two.
So perhaps we can never reconstruct an accurate image of Alexander the Great based on these
histories because these histories are constructing a character of Alexander almost, it's not taken
from eyewitness accounts, it's kind of eyewitness accounts plus a little bit of literary flourish.
So perhaps that's a detriment if you're looking to kind of know the real man, but if you want to
know a bit about Alexander as much as you can know in terms of the things that he was recorded as
having done, the way he did them, and the way people thought about him in the ancient world,
I think that our source tradition is very useful for that, but there's always just a little bit
of care, a little bit of a grain of salt that needs to be taken when you read some of the more
outlandish and exciting stories. I think that certainly with any sort of source, I mean you're
supposed to take a critical eye towards whatever you're reading when you're applying to history,
but I think with Alexander's case, which is so interesting, is that each one you read,
like you mentioned, is sort of a thought exercise where Quintus Curtius feels more like
Suetonius in the time of Tiberius and the court politics of Tiberius, rather. And meanwhile,
Plutarch is this person, which I always like this quote, I'm stealing from another historian,
if it isn't true, it ought to be, where it fits to the idea of, well, Alexander probably would
have said something like this, but it is really astonishing when you try to go through these
sources and you're like, each one is telling this own tale, even though they may have not had a
direct connection where they're trying to lionize or to fit the character of Alexander to their own
needs, even the sources that they built on, like Ptolemy or Hieronymus of Cardia has some writings
on Alexander, and Callisthenes in this case, they all had their own niches that they were filling
at the time, where Ptolemy is deriving his entire legitimacy from the Met legacy of Alexander,
Callisthenes was a court historian, so something of a sycophant in some extent, and other ones could
be intensely hostile to them. So I think that part of my favorite stuff with Alexander is just trying
to dissect each work and seeing what is each source's version of Alexander and how we try to
composite 10 different Alexanders into one universal being, but then inevitably enough,
each interpretation of those interpretations has created an ever-spiraling mess and web of
visuals, like from Tarn's Brotherhood of Mankind to Greene's more sarcastic take on Alexander,
or even Bosworth's more negative conquering tyrant sort of figure, so it's always a fun
treat to kind of just talk about Aryan and Plutarch and see how they compare to the rest of them.
Yeah, definitely. I think that that's the beauty and the frustration of studying Alexander is you
have to kind of wrangle with all these different versions, because as you picked up, you know,
Tarn's Brotherhood of Mankind, this kind of very gentle, sensitive, almost scholarly Alexander,
is, you know, so far apart from, you know, some of the rebuttals to that, you know, Ernst Badian's
Alexander is somewhat of a dictator, a terrible, you know, bloodthirsty tyrant, and it's hard to
kind of read these two different portraits of Alexander and think, wow, are they really coming
from the same place? They've almost veered off in totally opposite directions, but ultimately,
they are reconcilable with the ancient treatment of Alexander, because even that was so
fragmented and different. So I think that there's a really good quote that I've read in a paper that
I cannot remember the name of, unfortunately, but I think the general gist of it was that
the reason why Alexander has been the subject of perennial fascination is because nobody can quite
work out whether he's the good guy or the bad guy. You know, we all like to kind of look at
figures from history and think, okay, how do we relate to this person? How do we place them into
how we understand the world? And there's something quite elusive about Alexander,
where all these different versions of him, where he is the hero, but he's also the villain,
they all exist at the same time, in the same framework, sort of almost complementary to
each other, as much as they are contrasting, and I think that's one of the most interesting
things about studying him as a figure and as a cultural phenomena. Speaking of heroes,
after his death, and even within his own lifetime, Alexander Wunder went into apotheosis and
essentially became a demigod in the same mold as his ancestral idols, like Heracles and Achilles,
in the eyes of his Macedonian subjects and peers. Was the perception of Alexander as a heroic
archetype universal throughout the Hellenistic and Roman world? I think it very much depends on
who you would be asking. I mean, Alexander as the Macedonian conqueror was quite deeply unpopular
in certain places within the Greek world. So Demosthenes, who was the famous Athenian orator,
was famously against the Macedonians and their conquering of Greek territories and kind of
them establishing themselves as the head honchos in the Greek world. So I think if you would have
asked the Athenians how they would have felt about Alexander's legacy as kind of being almost
the best of the Greeks, the epitome of Greek culture, you know, the founder of this great
Hellenistic age, I think they probably would have been horrified. I think I know they would
have been horrified. Similarly, if you've asked, I suppose, the people of Thebes,
the ones that were left, they probably would have found him to be horrific. So I think when we think
of Alexander, I think a lot of our modern understanding is that we think, oh, well,
he must have been the hero of the classical world. He's the one who, you know, brought Greek
civilization to all these different places. He achieved all these fantastic things under the
name. You know, they must have adored him, which I think is very, very much not the case if you
were to have asked certain people in certain places in the Greek world. But certainly in terms
of his perception during the Hellenistic age, I think it was very useful to successors to create
him this persona of him being a, you know, a demigod, somebody who achieved godhood status
through his actions and deeds, because it was through their association with Alexander,
it was them aligning themselves with Alexander that gave them their own claim to legitimacy and
their own power boosts, in a sense, because Alexander died without a viable heir. You know,
his son Alexander IV was born posthumously, but was killed as a boy, so he could never really
have this official claim to Alexander's lineage. But somebody had to lay claim to it, right? So
that's where you have all the different successors kind of using Alexander's image in certain ways.
I'm sure we'll get to discuss some of the brilliant coin portraits that he crops up on from
the Hellenistic age, but then you have, you know, you have examples of Ptolemy literally hijacking
Alexander's body. So there's no greater claim to kinship and lineage than being in physical
possession of that body, right? So as a symbol and as a status symbol and almost as a bargaining chip
to try and fill this power vacuum, it really does benefit the successors and those who are
trying to piggyback off his, you know, his image and the acquisition of power to make him as
grandiose as possible. If you can elevate him to a godhood status, it's almost not that strange
that you're then claiming a descent from him. It may not be a literal genealogy descent,
but it's a descent in ideology, perhaps. You know, you're carrying on his legacy, you're carrying on
his thoughts of empire, and that is what makes you worthy to succeed him and worthy of possessing
these territories. And certainly by the time we get to the Roman world, so by the time of the
late Republic, certainly when the Romans have kind of reconciled their position in the world
with this new Greek background, as they come into new contact with the Greek world, you know,
Alexander as a paradigm and as an exemplar would never have existed in the Roman imagination before
they engaged in their own conquest of the Hellenistic world. So by the time we get to
the late Republic, he's definitely an exemplar of heroism and perhaps not as a king because the
Romans had a very complex relationship with kingship and with, you know, aligning themselves
with kings, but certainly as a general and as somebody who is the exemplar of military might
and power, he's someone that prominent Roman people were aiming to emulate. There's, you know,
the famous anecdote of Julius Caesar who sees a statue of Alexander and begins to weep because,
oh my goodness, he had accumulated and done so much in his lifetime and he's dead and I'm, you
know, that age now and I've done very little. So, you know, there is definitely the idea that Romans
were trying to establish a connection between themselves and Alexander as an example of military
might, especially with Pompey, Pompey Magnus, which again, Magnus is the great, which I think
was a moniker that Alexander originally got in the Roman world. So the Greeks didn't call him
Alexander the Great, that was a Roman moniker, Alexander Magnus and so Pompey is, you know,
taking this nickname, which was allegedly a bit of a joke with people teasing him, saying, oh,
he thinks he's so wonderful, he thinks he's Pompey the Great and he kind of said, oh, you know what,
I like the sound of that and he, you know, took that on for himself and you've seen in some of
their images as well, there's a fantastic head of Pompey, it's not quite a bust, it's a sculpted
head and you see he's kind of got a typical Roman face, which is, you know, quite lined,
quite austere looking, like a typical elder Roman man that is sort of commanding power in a very
Roman way, but then when you look at his hair, he's kind of got this rather foppish, boyish hair
with this cowlick and at first you think, well, that's a bit of a, looks like he's just rolled
out of bed, but it's quite a deliberate allusion to some of Alexander's most famous portraits,
where Alexander's hair is one of his defining characteristics. So the Romans are taking on
not only kind of him in name, but also him in vision, because that's the visual language of
power and good generalship. So certainly for the Hellenistic and Roman world, he does exist as this
paradigm of good generalship as a hero who you can emulate if those are aspects that you want to
bring into your own persona, aspects that benefit you in your own, you know, military ambitions.
Now connecting to the previous question, how was Alexander seen in cultures outside of the
Greco-Roman tradition? There is, of course, the famous Romance of Alexander that was extremely
popular throughout both medieval Europe and the Middle East, but did each culture place an
emphasis on different virtues and vices for Alexander? Yeah, definitely. One of the most
exciting things about Alexander is this change he sort of undergoes and how he becomes an example of
many different sectors that you previously wouldn't have associated with him. So just to pick up on
on the medieval Europe thing to start with, I'm not a medievalist, so I haven't researched this
extensively, but I have looked into it a bit, and there are some absolutely fantastic medieval
images of Alexander, and it's of Alexander as the great explorer. He becomes the ultimate explorer
in a sense. There's some brilliant pictures of him in these beautiful medieval, I think they're
paintings or perhaps they're images from larger books or scrolls, and he's kind of accompanied by
all this great banter, all these great people, and he's doing marvellous things. There's examples of
him battling dragons. My personal favourite motif is Alexander as this underwater explorer. He's
kind of in what looks like a rudimentary form of a submarine. It looks a bit like a glass
jar with rope on either side, and he's being kind of put down into the seabed, and it's fantastic.
You look within this little glass jar, and there's a little fellow with a crown that we
believe is Alexander. So in the medieval imagination, he's not just really a conqueror,
he's not just a king. He becomes this great explorer. He also becomes associated with
medicine and healing because he's gone to all of these different places, and he's picked up
all of this knowledge. A lot of that kind of comes from Alexander in the biblical tradition.
So Alexander's kind of mentioned a little bit in the Bible, but there's the idea that he was kind
of searching for the water of life, for eternal life, and that's why you see him in these little
submarine-like things searching. So the medieval Alexander is really a fascinating character
because he's evolved so far past his Hellenistic and Roman origins. I think they would never have
conceived of putting him in a glass jar and putting him under the water, but every era
kind of casts Alexander in what is most pertinent to them. So definitely medieval era exploration,
discovery, science and knowledge acquisition is something that's quite important.
And so that's something that they pick up on and they attribute to Alexander.
Alexander in the Middle East and in Persian culture is something that's also very interesting.
There's kind of two traditions that preserve the story of Alexander in the Middle Eastern culture.
You've got on the one side is their version of the Alexander romance. So that came into
Persian tradition through the Greek via the Syriac translations, and that preserves quite
a positive spin and quite a positive outlook on Alexander. So in this version, they've almost
concocted a new lineage for Alexander. So in the Persian version of this Alexander romance,
he is allegedly the illegitimate son of King Darius II. He's the son of King Darius II and
a daughter of Philip of Macedon, I believe, who was not accepted by the Persian king,
sent back to live in Macedon, and then eventually comes back to almost, in this story, reconquer
his own birthright in a sense. In this version, that would make him sort of a half-brother to
Romulus III. So almost Alexander's conquering of the Persian world, if you follow this tradition,
is sort of a justified almost reclaiming of a birthright. They don't want to view Alexander
as a conquering outsider, more as almost like a returning one of their own almost,
which is quite a difficult thing to kind of reconcile when you think about it. When you
think that, well, I mean, he came and he conquered Persia, he destroyed a lot of their great cultural
icons, caused irrevocable damage to a lot of the Persian statehood, and yet here they are
reconstructing him as almost being one of their own. But I think when you put that against the
background of what Alexander did and what his character was becoming, it's very difficult to
cast him as a villain and as a bad guy because he was so successful. People like to think that
good people succeed and that evil people ultimately have their comeuppance. Although Alexander died
young in somewhat mysterious circumstances, I don't think you can really view that as a
comeuppance. So perhaps that's why they're trying to recast the story a little bit.
But the other tradition, it comes through the Zoroastrian tradition, so the ancient kind of
religious texts of Persia, and they preserve him as being an out-and-out bad guy. He comes to Persia,
he destroys the Temple of Persepolis, which was an important part of Persian culture,
especially Zoroastrian religion. So he's the death bringer, he's the destructor,
and that's a very negative spin. But you have both of these traditions existing at the same
time, just through different origins. So one is brought into the Persian mainstream through the
Greek and the Syriac translations of the original romance, and the other is this preservation of
this more religious understanding of Alexander. But you do see poets later on in and around Persia
who are writing about Alexander with a positive spin. He's Ixander, he's an important figure
for them also, and they've changed and reconstructed him to something that has more
relevance for them. But it's definitely interesting how these two strands, these two
polar opposite depictions of him are preserved and brought into the Persian imagination through
different sources. Moving away from the literary presentation of Alexander, it is harder to think
of a historical figure that has been represented in sculptures, mosaics, and coinage more than
Alexander himself. But how can we identify Alexander as Alexander? Are there any particular
motifs or themes that are shared between his depictions, or some unusual cases that stand
out to you? He's definitely got a very noticeable face and very noticeable symbols and attributes.
When you look at the sculptures of Alexander, one of the things that is most unusual about him,
one of the innovations which he's responsible for, is how he changed up the visual language
of kingship. Prior to Alexander in the Greek imagination, a king was certainly somebody who
was a mature individual, a king was certainly somebody who was bearded. If not in real life,
hopefully you'd be able to grow a beard. If not in real life, you would at least be depicted with
a beard. When you look at figures who are related to kingship, kingship and fatherhood go hand in
hand almost. If you're not the father of your own children, you're at least the father of that city
state. They'll be all the head of state. So depictions of Zeus, for example, who's supposed
to be king of the gods, as well as being the premier god, he's always depicted bearded. So
are many of the other kind of premier godly and kingly figures. To be bearded was one of the main
things that denoted masculine power. But when it comes to Alexander, this prototype, this archetype,
it just isn't useful for him. He comes to power at the age of 20. He's only 20 years old when he
becomes king. And he's really not even out of this youthhood yet. So the Greeks have their
understanding of this youthfulness is almost a different life stage. You're a child, you're a
youth, and then you're finally a man. And at 20 years old, he really is not a man by any stretch
of the imagination for what they would consider to be the best guy to be their king, their man.
So he has to rethink and rejig what makes the visual language of kingship. For him,
the beardfulness is not going to work. So he deliberately makes this adjustment where he
starts to adopt looks that are more suited to athletes or divine beings. So younger divinities
in the Greek pantheon, such as Apollo, such as Dionysus, would have gone without beards. They
would have been clean shaven. And this is the image that Alexander chooses to adopt. Rather
than going for a mature look, he chooses throughout his lifetime to maintain quite a
youthful image. And you see this in all of his portraits. You see this in him in coins. You see
this in him for mosaics. You see this for statues and sculpture and presumably for paintings,
even though we don't have any existing paintings. And it's a very deliberate choice because he's
making allusions to divinity with this eternal youthfulness. And you see this also in his hair.
So again, when you think of the king, you don't think of long hair necessarily. You think of,
you know, a standard kind of not quite cropped military hair, but certainly something that
was a lot more sensible to an extent. When it comes to Alexander, he starts to depict himself
having this longer hair, you know, down to the back of his neck, quite full, quite voluminous
with a, what is called like an anastole, so a bit like a cowlick. It's this kind of hair
lifted up from the forehead. And so his hair is always quite big, quite textured. And that's
really one of the calling cards of Alexander is, does he have this anastole, this bit of
hair? And again, the long hair and the beardlessness, these are all traits that,
you know, previously in classical Greek iconography is reserved for, you know, younger
gods. So Apollo, Dionysus, Hermes sometimes is reserved for athletes. And it can also sometimes
have negative connotations. So if you're an old, so if you're a man, an aging man out of the
youthhood bracket, and you're still maintaining long hair and clean shaveness, that could be
interpreted as being passive homosexuality, which is at the time, not a good thing if you're trying
to be a king. But with Alexander, he takes these images and they become the visual language of
kingship. And this persists for long after Alexander, you know, the days of the beard is
a symbol of masculine power and kingship are now gone. So even his successors, who I mean,
Ptolemy got to a grand old age, even when you look at his coins, although his hair isn't quite as long,
and it doesn't quite have the same mobility with the anastole, he's still depicting himself clean
shaven. And the same for all the other successors who put themselves on their coins. There are
always some differences in these coin portraits where you can see individualized features. So
the coins of Demetrius Poliorchitis, who's sort of a successor of the next generation,
he maintains this beardlessness and this hair, not quite as long, but that has really become
the new normal, the new standard for kings. And really that persists all the way through
the Roman era, you know, you very rarely see Roman statesmen with beards, Roman emperors as well. And
when we get to Augustus, also Augustus really picks up on this eternal youthfulness as the
ultimate symbol of power. Augustus would never be called himself a king, but he's certainly the
premier person in Rome. And his, you know, his statue program for his entire life depicts him
as a youth. And this is something that he really is kind of picking up from this exemplar of
Alexander. And a good example of this that I like to think of is the Alexander mosaic. So this is the
very large, quite famous mosaic that was found in Pompeii. And it depicts Alexander on one side in
the middle of battle with Darius III on the other side. And in it, you can see quite a detailed
portrait of Alexander in profile. And you can see he's kind of got this dark hair kind of behind him,
there's a lot of motion, it's a battle scene, so it's quite dynamic, fixed picture. But when you
sort of look closely and examine his face, you can see that he's completely bare cheeked and bare
chinned, he's clean shaven. But then when you see his profile, you can see he's got quite prominent
sideburns. So it there's a lot to unpack there, because what it suggests to us what the artist is
trying to create here, this image, which is supposedly the mosaic is dated from around I
think it's first century, whereas it was based on a much earlier painting, which no longer survives,
but it's based on an earlier tradition of artwork to do with Alexander the Great, it's a Roman copy.
And what the artist is getting across here is that Alexander is is purposely clean shaven,
it's not that he's too young, it's not that he's too inexperienced, it's not that he's not a mature
man who cannot grow facial hair, he's making this a deliberate choice, because he has these prominent
sideburns, suggesting to us that he is a fully grown man, he's a masculine man, he could grow
a beard if he wanted to. But this allusion to divinity, this change has been a deliberate choice
that he's kind of taken control of. So the beardlessness, the very textured, very mobile
hair with this anastole are all sort of calling cards of Alexander's portrait in, you know,
the Hellenistic age and onwards. These are things, these are part of his image that have been
maintained. Other things that you see a lot in his portrait, you see kind of this slightly parted lips
in a lot of his sculpture, and often his head is kind of tilted to the side or slightly slightly
bent neck. And in Plutarch, I believe Plutarch gives us a detailed description of what Alexander
looks like. There are some literary descriptions of what Alexander looked like, but again these
kind of need to be taken with a grain of salt. I think there's a description in Alien that describes
what he looks like, but at the same time it also says that he had fang-like teeth, and Plutarch
also said that he had a natural sweet smell, because he was descended from divinity. So all
of these portraits and the literary descriptions, you can kind of take hand in hand, but they're
worth again taking with a pinch of salt, because these descriptions of his physicality may not be
a hundred percent to the mark. Plutarch does tell us that he kept his hair long, and that he
potentially had a turn in his neck, a kind of twist in his neck, which, you know, some modern scholars
have tried to diagnose him with various medical conditions based on the twist of this neck,
whether he had torticollis or something like that. That is one suggestion. I think that's kind of
unlikely, because he was very, he was meant to be very prominent in battle, and when you read a bit
more about torticollis, it causes all sorts of, you know, mobility issues, and he never kind of
seems to have those issues in fighting. But there's another interpretation that, you know,
this twist of the head, this slightly bent neck, is more to do with him sort of, his gaze being
outwards, but always looked off slightly to the side. It's sort of a physical manifestation of his
desire for travel and for conquest. He's always kind of slightly looking out into the horizon for
where is he going to do next, what is he going to do next. So if you see a portrait, and it's got
all of these aspects, you know, the clean shaven, this mobile hair with the anastole, you know,
head slightly bent, mouth slightly parted, you're generally, hopefully looking at what is supposed
to be an image of Alexander the Great. Those are his most kind of defining visual features.
I think one of my favorite undercurrents of the Alexandrian image is how even people at the time
were kind of self-aware when it was being presented to them as such, where I believe is, I think it's
a quote from The Life of Demetrius from Plutarch, where they make mention how these old men,
referring to the Diadohoi, are like, something we'll talk about in a little bit, where, you know,
they're in their 50s, 60s, 70s, and they're getting a little flabby, but they're still
maintaining that youthful, vigorous look of the upturned head, and even, at least from Plutarch's
perspective, people are kind of mocking it to some extent, because they know how absurd it looks,
given the nature of Alexander and that eternal youthfulness, but then even men in there who
probably missing quite a few of their teeth and quite a little bit bald are still trying to cast
that image. And even with cases of non-Greeks, or I guess of Hellenized non-Greeks, you have
Mithridates, who has, I think is one of his best coinages, like, his hair is not only long,
it's just, it's like blowing in the wind, it's going, it's like, swept back. And I think it's
interesting how they consciously know these decisions, they make them anyways, just because
of that nature that is connected to Alexander. And I think there was actually an interesting,
one of my listeners reached out to me and asked specifically for information for an article they
were working on, on the apopotropaic usage of Alexander's image. And I think even in late
antiquity, there's a reference from, I believe, I'm not sure if you actually provided this to me,
was John Chrysostom, or if I believe that's the author's name, how he referenced how people in
the third century, fourth century AD were taking images of Alexander, whether in coinage, and using
as magical talismans. So it's amazing to see how this image just transcends even like, it
transcends the normalcy of life and kind of turns into this divine status, like a talisman, or like
a symbolic representation of power. I don't find that surprising. I mean, it's the apotropaic
nature of certain images is quite powerful. And it almost doesn't matter what the original
intention was, it's how people choose to construe it later down the line. Again, going back to the
Alexander mosaic, if you look closely on his breastplate, Alexander himself is wearing an
apotropaic image of Medusa on his on his armor looking outwards. So I'm not surprised that he
himself becomes this apotropaic image of kind of warding off, you know, badness, because, you know,
who better do you want on your side than Alexander the Great, I suppose, if you need a symbol of
power and protection, he seemed to do quite well for himself right up until he didn't, I suppose.
So I guess to kind of focus on one example, one of the most famous pieces of ancient art with
Alexander as its focus is the Alexander sarcophagus, which is currently housed in the
Istanbul Archaeology Museum and shows the Macedonian king atop of his loyal Mount
Bucephalus battling against the Persians. Could you speak about your work on the sarcophagus and
maybe how it informs us of the perception of Alexander the Great within his own time?
Yeah, I mean, the the Alexander sarcophagus, I mean, it should really be the so called Alexander
sarcophagus. It's definitely not the sarcophagus of Alexander, which is an interesting thing,
because when you first see it, you think, wow, this, you know, it's so amazing. I wonder who
could possibly be here. But, you know, in my research, I kind of, I go for the theory that
it doesn't belong to Alexander. It belongs to this guy, Abdelhamid of Sidon, who was the final king
of Sidon, which is on the Phoenician coast, almost near Tyre. And he was installed by
Alexander as a client king of that area. So he owed a lot of his success, he owed his position
to Alexander in a sense. And that may be why Alexander features so prominently on this
sarcophagus that doesn't actually belong to Alexander himself, it belongs to this Phoenician
king. But the Alexander sarcophagus is one of my favourite artefacts from the whole of antiquity,
I think. It is such an interesting example of royal iconography, and particularly how royal
iconography changed during this neocolonial landscape of Alexander's conquest. Because on
the one hand, you have this area of Phoenicia that has been, you know, under conquest of the Persians
for a very long time. And then rather than being liberated, I think that's something that a lot of
people say about Alexander, that he liberated these places, which is, you know, quite a difficult
statement to make and quite a difficult statement to reconcile, because, you know, any form of
conquering isn't really a liberation. But, you know, this area has been under conquest by one
great empire, and then all of a sudden, there's quite a bloody battle, quite a bloody war,
and they're suddenly under conquest by another very different empire that has very different,
you know, cultural markers for kingship, very different norms of royal iconography. And so
how do you, as a king in this place, a king who has, you know, Persian background, potentially
Persian ancestry, but now you owe your position to this, you know, Greek Macedonian king? How do
you now establish yourself? How do you create your own royal iconography in a way that kind of
very delicately treads the balance of this new colonial landscape, you know, this new world?
And it's from that, that this Alexander sarcophagus emerges. It's an absolutely stunning,
spectacular piece of craftsmanship. It's likely coming from a Rhodian workshop, from Greek
artisans who were commissioned to create this beautiful thing. Generally, it's believed to
have been commissioned when Alexander was still alive, so we're looking perhaps in the 20s BCE.
It's not known when Absalomon died, there's some speculation he died around 306, but we know that
he was definitely alive to see out Alexander's reign, and that this sarcophagus was likely
commissioned and designed while he was still, you know, a friend to Alexander, while he was still in
Alexander's circle. And it's very interesting that a lot of people focus on this image of
Alexander. I think that's potentially testament to the Alexander bias that exists in a lot of
scholarship pertaining to the time period and place, which is almost a naturally arising problem,
is that he's kind of almost this personality vacuum, where anybody else who tends to try and
around him just gets sucked in. You know, think about how people have much less regard for the
prominent generals around him while he was still alive, and it's only when he disappears that they
kind of have a chance at the limelight, when in any other circumstance, you know, these successes
would be worthy of a million biopics and studies in their own right. But this beautiful Alexander
sarcophagus is so-called the Alexander sarcophagus, because on one panel there is a figure who people
very strongly identify with Alexander, and this is on the basis of what appears to be a helmet of
Heracles. So Heracles, the great Greek hero, was an important figure in Alexander's life,
and in the life of Macedonian rulers previous to him. So a lot of the Macedonian Argeid line,
which is Alexander's line, Philip II's line, trace their ancestry back to a son of Heracles,
and because of that Heracles and his iconography featured quite prominently in Argeid royal
iconography. So in their coinage, for example, you may see the club of Heracles, or you may see
the portrait of Heracles wearing this helmet. But on the Alexander sarcophagus, we have Alexander
the individual, we know it's likely to be him, it's not an image of the Heracles, and yet he's
dressed up in the guise of Heracles. And this is a very interesting thing, because prior to this,
you don't really get kings outwardly masquerading themselves in the guise of heroes. But we have
some literary evidence in the form of fragments from Athenaeus, who writes and tells us that
towards the end of Alexander's life, he did start masquerading as great Greek heroes,
such as Heracles, and that he wore this imitation lion's cap. There's other fragments that suggest
that he would dress up as Dionysus during drinking parties while out in India, some that suggest that
he would dress up as Artemis to go hunting on chariots, which there's some suggestion that this
is maybe a misconstruction of the original, and that he may not have been dressing up as Artemis,
he may have just been imitating Persian kingly garb, which to a Greek audience may look slightly
like a feminized robe, and that's maybe where this conflation happens. But there's sort of
fragmentary evidence to suggest that he does start dressing in the guise of heroes. And then this
image on the Alexander sarcophagus just kind of cements that and nails that down, that he may have
been known to have been dressed as Heracles, especially during hunts and during kind of these
moments where he would be socializing with his, not his peers, but the people that he had
surrounded himself with, whether this was his generals, whether this was client kings with which
he was building a positive relationship. So in order to identify Alexander on his sarcophagus,
Abdelhamid is choosing this image of Alexander as Heracles, which is so interesting to look at and
consider that that is how this Macedonian king is being identified, as he's being identified
by virtue of Heracles. If he did not have this lion's hat on, how would we know it was Alexander?
You know, we could go with the hairstyle or something like that. There's another panel as
well where people think that this may be Alexander depicted again, only this time in battle, and that
this time he's not wearing the cap that he is in part of this battle scene. There's four
friezes of it, there's two long sides and two short sides, if you imagine sort of a rectangular
sarcophagus, and they follow two themes. So you have the hunting theme, of which there is a long
side and a short side each, and then you have this theme of battle, of which there's a long side and
a short side. A lot of talk about the Alexander sarcophagus is focused on how it is
such a beautiful example of artwork. It's absolutely exquisite to look at, the craftsmanship is beautiful,
the figures are so beautifully carved, they're in relief, but it's so highly detailed
and fine relief, it's almost as if they look like freestanding sculptures because they protrude so
far out. Some of the colouring, the original paint is still visible on it, it's a beautifully well
preserved thing, but a lot of it kind of doesn't really go too much into investigating what this
visual program really means. When I was researching the Alexander sarcophagus, a lot of prominent
authors who mention it, it gets mentioned a lot in sort of these handbooks of great Hellenistic
artwork, but there's not so much an exploration of what its themes mean. There's this line that
says, you know, well it's a bit of a complex artifact because it's quite contradictory, you
know, on the one side you have Greeks and Persians battling each other, and they're identified as
Greeks and Persians by virtue of their clothing, you know, the Greeks are in these wonderful
pieces of armour, the Persians are in wonderful cloth dressing, you can look at the cloth and you can
see the beautiful texture of it to sort of know what it would look like, and you can identify them
as being Persians through that, and whereas on the other side in the hunting scenes,
you have Greeks and Persians working together, but they are still maintaining their same cultural
signifiers, so the Greeks are still dressed up as if they were, you know, Greeks, the Persians
still look like Persians, so we're definitely meant to see these two types of people as being the same,
just in one side of the frieze, one long and short side, they're backing each other, and on the other
they're working in collaboration, and it definitely gives you an interesting insight into perhaps what
you know, Abdelonimous as this client king in Phoenicia, he's kind of treading the line and
trying to juggle these two cultural backgrounds, on the one hand you have the existing Persian
culture which has been dominant for a long time, and now you have this new incoming Greek culture
which has been dominant for a long time, and how you reconcile these two ways together in a visual
programme that is pleasing and understandable to both your Greek and your Persian audience,
you know, the incoming Greeks are not going to eradicate the Persians overnight, so you still
have to have a way of appealing to both sides of the population, you know, the population of Sidon
at this time, you would have had Phoenicians, you would have had Greeks, and you would have had
Persians, and as a king what this sarcophagus suggests is that Abdelonimous is trying to blend
these cultures and these traditions together and present a unified programme, he's meant to kind of
put himself into this great historic tradition because there is an image of what looks like a
Persian, but again there's some debate over whether the clothing should be interpreted as being
strictly Persian or simply representing an other. Something interesting about the Alexander
sarcophagus is how people have tended to try and read it as a historicising monument, so try to
read it as depicting a moment with historical, you know, accuracy, but when you kind of look at it
again it's very difficult to read it through those terms because some of the figures are nude, some
of the figures are clothed, and there seems to be a blending not only of cultural traditions with the
Greek and the Persian costume, but it's also a blending of the, you know, the real, the reality,
with this kind of pseudo-mythologised landscape, so we've got figures who are nude who are probably
heroic, and yet we also have figures who are mortal, and they're all kind of working together,
so it's a mixed bag of these ideas of these different motifs, but it has kind of one
connecting line, which is that they went from a period of conflict, so you've got the Greco-Sidonians
and the Persians or Eastern troops fighting against each other, so we have conflict, but then
it comes around to reconciliation through this hunting scene, and, you know, hunting and battle
are symbolically linked, you know, the hunt and the battle, and all the way back to kind of Homeric
motifs, a lot of the battles will feature hunting similes with prey animals and predator animals,
so the idea of the hunt being symbolically and thematically linked to battle is well established
in Greek tradition, Greek culture, so it's following on with that motif, but it's showing
how we've gone from combative to collaborative, you know, for what purpose could this possibly
be, you know, what is he trying to present, well, if you think that you are a client king of this
period, of this particular place, which is quite a tumultuous place, if you think about what happened
to Tyre, which is quite near to Sidon, and what happened when they went against Alexander, they
were very brutally attacked and, you know, suffered quite a terrible fate at the hands of
Alexander for their lack of compliance, so you imagine this King Abdelonimus, he's thinking,
well, I have to show some degree of compliance to this new, you know, this new Greek king,
who is now in charge, but I can't completely negate and get rid of, you know, the Persian
Eastern influence of where I come from, of where I live, so it's how to marry those two themes
together, and that's what the Alexander Sarcophagus does so successfully, so we're used
to seeing, you know, Greek successors using Alexander's image to try and promote their own
reign, promote their own story about how they fit into this part of history, and we're not so used
to seeing examples of Eastern people and how they use Alexander's image to promote themselves,
to establish their own standing in the world, and when I look at the Alexander Sarcophagus through
my research and through my interpretation, it's a very interesting artifact, because to me what
it represents is, you know, an Eastern king, a Phoenician king, who is using Alexander's image,
because Alexander features quite prominently on this, to try and establish himself. He's using
it to try and show these connections to Alexander, these positive connections, how he has been part
of this tumultuous area of history. He's seen the war, he's seen the combat as evidenced by the
battle scenes, but, you know, through his interaction with Alexander, you know, proof of his
reign, he's brought us from combat to a collaboration, you know, he's got a semblance of
peace now has been established, so much so that Abelonomus can go hunting with the very Alexander
the Great, because beside Alexander in his wonderful Heracles helmet, we have a figure
who's established to be Abelonomus. So to me, it's an interesting and a wonderful artifact,
because it shows us how Alexander is perceived with regards to how he's using his own kind of
cultural mythology to, you know, evidence himself as king, but it's also evidence of an Eastern king,
rather than a classical Greek king, which is what we're so used to, who is almost appropriating
Alexander's image to create his own narrative, and I find that very fascinating about this object.
Now, it is said that during the wars of the Diadohoi, many of the successors and warlords and
various dynasts of the crumbling empire would attempt to use Alexander's image as part of their
political propaganda and aspirations of legitimacy. Do you think that this assessment still holds up,
or is this more of a retroactive creation from later authors than from us today?
I think as a general statement, the fact that the successors used Alexander's image as part of
political propaganda still holds up. An area that I've researched about this is through
coin portraits. So a lot of our, some of our most brilliant and beautiful images of Alexander really
come from coin portraits, but what is interesting is that Alexander was the first mortal person to
have his face put on coinage, but he didn't do it himself. His face was put onto his coins
by his successors. I think of the beautiful coin portraits, for example, by Lysimachus,
the one that really, you know, hones this image of Alexander with the ram's horns, which is an
allusion to Zeus Amon in Egypt, and the diadem, which is this allusion to, you know, Hellenistic
kingship. So they're really using Alexander's image almost the way that previous kings used
image of Heracles, of, you know, Athena and Athena. He's almost become their little deity
that is important to them and a way to establish their own lineage. But then after kind of Alexander
sets the precedent of mortal faces on ancient coins, then the successors kind of have this
leeway to start putting themselves on ancient coins. And that's when you start to see coins of
Ptolemy with Ptolemy depicting his own face. Again, this portrait that is slightly Alexander-like
in it being, you know, clean shaven, sort of youthful, but you can see that there's a little
bit more aging in the portraits of Ptolemy than there were before. But you definitely see the
successors using, I guess, Alexander's precedent of being immortal on coinage, and that's the
stepping stone that they need in order to put themselves on coins. The way that they depict
Alexander also really depends on what is most important to them. So Lysimachus, again, is using
this ram's horn depiction. But then when you look at the coins by Seleucus, for example, Seleucus is
depicting Alexander with sort of allusions to, I believe, it's like panther skins. And the panther
skin is something that is associated with Dionysus, which is associated with India. And Seleucus,
during his, you know, his time with Alexander was particularly important during the campaigns in
India. And so it makes more sense for Seleucus to create his royal imagery using something that is
related to something that he had a more personal hand in, this being the campaigns in and around
India. And they're all kind of, there's so much iconography to do with Alexander because he went
so many places and did so many things that you can kind of cast into whatever is most useful.
An interesting thing that we see that is kind of a slight
departure from Alexander is when we get to the coins of Demetrius Poliorchitis. So Demetrius
Poliorchitis, as I kind of briefly mentioned earlier, was a successor of almost the next
generation. So he didn't actually go on campaign with Alexander. His father was the one who was
campaigning with Alexander. So, but it was really during the wars, you know, the diadocs that he
was getting involved in all this. And when he became, came when he chose to put on his portrait,
he, you know, presented this Alexander-like persona. He used Alexander's own image in his
earlier coins, but then as time goes on, he kind of starts to adapt his own image. So we get a
sense that Alexander started off as, you know, the premier image to use for the successors because of
their relationship with him. But then as we move into the next generation of successors, Alexander
becomes less important as an individual and it's more about what symbols and what icons can you
take from Alexander to then input into yourself. So it's kind of this next generation of successors
where Alexander's image as Alexander as a person becomes slightly less important and it becomes
more about just using him as a symbol than as an individual. So I think it definitely
holds true that he was part of their political propaganda, but I think as an individual king
and as an individual person, he became less important. It became more about this mythologized
symbol of Alexander and his attributes that then could then be taken off and applied to different
people of different places at will, depending on what was most suitable. So true to an extent,
but I definitely think that as time goes on, as an individual, he became less important.
I feel as though that like those living in the Hellenistic period, I can never seem to escape
Alexander's shadow and I still find myself constantly returning to talk about him nearly
40 episodes and almost three years after starting my show. So I think we should stop our discussion
here in the meantime, but I'd like to say thank you so much for joining me to talk about one of
my favorite subjects, Ether. Is there anything you would wish to plug, like social media or
any upcoming projects you're currently working on? I mainly try and make summary threads,
talk about my research online. So I do that via my Twitter account, which you can find me
at agameganon, which is quite a good pun that I'm very proud of. Other than that, I'm just kind of
an independent researcher at the moment. I'm trying to put forth some of my own articles,
trying to get out there and get some of my research out there. So nothing, no huge projects to plug at
the moment, but you can follow me online and I'm trying to get some of my articles, some of my
short blog posts kind of polished up, published. So that's kind of a work in progress. I'm hoping
to get more work out there in 2021. That's kind of the goal this year. Well, I'll make sure to
include those links in the podcast description and in my episode notes, along with a representation
for the Alexander Sarcophagus for you all listeners to see at your own leisure and kind of
follow along with our discussion. But in the meanwhile, thank you once again for coming onto
the show and for the rest of you, you've been listening to The Hellenistic Age Podcast.
