📈 Are you on track with the Baby Steps? Get a Free Personalized Plan. https://ter.li/5h1r0i
Next Steps: • 💵 Start eliminating debt for free with EveryDollar - https://ter.li/11slv5 • 🏘️ Find a Ramsey Trusted Real Estate Agent - https://ter.li/ni98m5 • 📞 Have a question for the show? Call 888-825-5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET or send us an email.
[Music]
brought to you by the Every Dollar app.
Start budgeting for free today.
>> I've been out of college for many years.
I've paid off about $15,000, which was
the entire uh loan that I was aware of.
Um, and recently
my parents just informed me that they
had taken out a loan to assist me going
to college for about $13,000 and they
are now asking for uh for me to be
responsible of it.
>> So, it's a parent plus loan,
>> correct?
>> In their name.
>> Okay. When they took it out, was there
any discussion back in the day when you
were in college?
>> No, I literally I didn't know it exists
then. Um, you know, I thought because
they were very honest with me, uh, you
know, about college, you know, I got,
um, FASA assistance. I got, uh, a lot of
grants. I only went to a four-year
school for about, uh, two years. I went
to a, um, county college the first two
years. So, uh, I I really thought that
that was sort of it. I I didn't really
realize that they had uh, taken out. So,
they took out a loan and didn't tell you
anything about it at all.
>> And yet, they want you to be responsible
for it.
>> Yeah. You know, they're asking for
responsibility or or at least help or
assistance with it. Yeah.
>> How many years ago was this?
>> Uh I graduated about nine years ago.
>> So, for a decade, they've they've been
making just minimum payments on it.
Well, there's so on top of the 13,000
there's $4,000 acred in interest. Um, so
it's a it's totaling out to around 17.
>> So they took out a loan and they didn't
pay on it for a decade.
>> Well, there was a good portion of time
with COVID forgiveness. I believe that
that had
>> Sure. But the balance has grown. They
did not pay on it for a decade.
>> Yeah. Yeah. No, absolutely. Mhm.
>> And now they don't like this payment in
their life. They're probably having
their own financial problems and going,
"Well, it's really his debt, so we
should go after him for it." Except it's
not because it's in their name, not
yours. So legally is their
responsibility.
>> Oh, there's no question about the legal
part. Um,
>> you're talking is this a moral,
ethically, what should I do as the son?
>> Yeah, I think that's definitely more
what I'm coming from. My wife and I, um,
>> Yeah. What do you guys make a year?
Oh, we make um roughly about 305 a year.
>> Okay. And you have a Do you have money
stacked up somewhere?
>> Uh no, we don't have I mean, we have an
emergency fund. We have 30,000 emergency
fund. The only debts we have are a car
payment um that we're going to have paid
off next April.
>> Can I ask a stupid question, James? Why
is a couple making $35,000
having trouble paying for a car in cash,
let alone paying off the loan?
>> Um, we we
could have paid it in cash, but we
didn't want to dip into our emergency
fund.
>> Where's the $300,000 going? Because in
my head, you can clean this debt up and
savor the relationship with your parents
or you can let it, you know, crush the
relationship because people are petty.
Yeah, that's sort of where that's so
that's what I'm I'm getting to. Um,
>> okay. What George is saying is you suck
at handling 305,000. We can't figure out
what you're doing with it.
>> Yeah, this is a sidebar, but it's it's
connected to the first problem cuz you
could clean this up in two months and
pay them and say, "Hey, listen. This
really isn't mine legally to pay, but I
love you guys. I appreciate what you've
done for me. This didn't go down how we
thought it would. Here's your money. Pay
it off." Or even better yet, apply it
directly to the loan. We have received
uh you know recent promotions within the
last year um with our family.
>> Okay. So here here's what here's what I
want. Here's what I would do the entire
time.
>> Here's what I would do. Okay. I would
commit to getting control of my money so
that my home does not look like your
father's home. You want to work this
hard and make this kind of money and you
want to have something to show for it.
That includes paying off your car
immediately. And I probably given the
disparity in income, the fact that you
guys make this much money, I'm probably
going to reach over there and just pay
that other loan off.
>> Um, but I I do think it is completely
fair for you to not do that as well if
you choose not to. Okay?
>> Because um it's not fair that you come
up to someone a decade later, tell them
something that they didn't even know
existed, that they did not agree to, and
ask them to pay something from a decade
earlier. That's ridiculous. If I had
done that, I would have too much honor
and pride to tell my kid they had to pay
it.
>> I would have gone and delivered pizzas
to pay it
>> rather than ask you to pay it. There's
this is not morally right
>> what your parents are asking you to do.
It's maddening and it's frustrating. The
only good news is it's a tiny amount of
money.
>> Sure.
>> That's the only good news in the story.
If it was 130,000,
I'm probably just telling them, "Sorry
guys, you signed up for this crap and
you didn't tell anybody." If you had if
you had promised them when you were 19
years old and going to school, "Yeah,
mom, y'all take out this loan. When I
get out, I'll pay it back. It's in their
name. You're not legally responsible,
but you handshake. You'd be morally
responsible. I'd be telling you to write
a check and shut up. You're whining."
But they didn't tell you a stinking
thing about it. And that is morally
wrong. They should not have done that.
You have a right to be angry about that
and so does your wife because she's
getting drugged into this too. And then
on top of that, you guys make so
stinking much money now. Maybe they're
recent raises, but I really want y'all
to get control of your money so that
it's not an issue either way. So if I'm
you, I'm paying this loan off and in in
one just write a check today just to get
rid of it. And if you want to have a
little sit down with your dad and go,
"Dad, this is not cool. And if you come
at me again with another one of these,
I'm gonna give you a big fat nope. And
you can chew on my big fat nope because
I'm not going to do it. Nope. This is
wrong. You shouldn't have surprised me.
You shouldn't have done this afterwards.
It's wrong. But I'm going to pay it
because I can. And uh I'm going to get
rid of it. I'm with you, George, on that
because it's just such a stinking small
amount of money.
>> They make that much in a month. So it's
not a big part of their life.
>> And then I'm going to pay off the car
and then I'm going to rebuild my
emergency fund and no more borrowing
money.
Okay. Period.
Period. Get away from this. It's not
None of this discussion has brought you
a blessing. Nothing in this was like,
"Oh, this was so wonderful." No. None of
this is wonderful.
>> And these parent plus loans, Dave, it's
it's a cancer on relationships.
>> They're horrible. Absolutely horrible.
That's just They're just And we see
this, we get this call once a month,
maybe.
>> Yeah.
>> Where the parents didn't even tell the
kid. And what's happening is the kid
can't qualify, which is pretty wild
because student loan lenders, they'll
just give anybody loans. So they go,
"Hey parent, you're going to take it on
at a higher interest rate than a normal
loan for the pleasure of your kid going
to college."
>> Yeah.
>> And then they struggle to pay it off a
decade later. This is the story we hear
time and time again.
>> They haven't paid anything on in a
decade. There's no struggle. They
haven't done anything.
>> They just it's by the wayside. Yeah.
>> We'll let him worry about that a decade
later.
>> They sat on it and then they looked up
and went, "Oh, somebody needs to pay
this."
>> Oh my goodness.
>> Yeah. So, moms and dads, this is the
problem. When everyone goes, "Student
loans don't have a," oh, student loan is
the ultimate emotionally kicking the can
down the road. I don't have to worry
about it. I'll worry about tomorrow.
Worry about tomorrow. Worry about
tomorrow. They'll get they'll get out.
They'll get a degree. They'll get a big
job. They'll be making a lot of money.
We'll worry about tomorrow. We'll worry
about it tomorrow. We'll worry about
tomorrow. It doesn't matter. All
education's worth it. We'll worry about
it tomorrow. All these lies you people
tell yourself and your kids over and
over and over. So they go get a degree
that's absolutely freaking worthless and
then they've got debt around it. And
worse than that, some of you didn't even
bother to tell anybody. H it's
unbelievable. Create your free every
dollar budget today. The simplest way to
budget for your