What if the most successful theory in science… doesn't actually explain anything?
In this episode of Into the Impossible, I talk with physicist and author Adam Becker, who wrote What Is Real?, a stunning exploration of quantum mechanics, its messy philosophical roots, and the long-ignored questions about what the theory really says about reality.
We dig deep into a paradox at the heart of modern physics: quantum mechanics works better than any theory we’ve ever invented, yet no one agrees on what it means. Becker walks us through the forgotten history of physicists like Einstein and David Bohm, who dared to question the mainstream “shut up and calculate” mindset, and explains why that mindset might be holding science back.
We explore the eerie predictions of the Many Worlds Interpretation, the mind-bending implications of Bell’s Theorem, and how modern experiments—some Nobel Prize-winning—are forcing physicists to confront uncomfortable truths about locality, realism, and the nature of observation.
If you’ve ever wondered whether quantum physics is just math, or if it really describes the world we live in, this conversation will challenge everything you thought you knew.
—
🎯 Key Takeaways:
00:00 Intro 02:01 Interpretations of quantum mechanics 05:04 Einstein’s discontent with quantum mechanics 08:01 EPR paradox 10:16 Many-worlds interpretation and Everettian mechanics 17:37 John Bell and Bell’s theorem 23:43 Experimental tests of quantum mechanics 27:21 Quantum computing and its promises 29:17 What is real? 31:56 Outro
Einstein was very unhappy with quantum
mechanics. But there have been some
myths about what he was unhappy about.
The common myth is that Einstein was
really unhappy that quantum mechanics
had randomness fundamental stochastic
element. Belle came up with this idea of
a way to mathematically constrain
what long distance correlations were
possible in a local theory and then he
showed that quantum mechanics violates
those conditions. Everything you think
you know about Einstein and his
objections to quantum mechanics is
backwards. We've been told for decades
that the great physicist was stubborn,
that he couldn't accept the randomness
of quantum theory, that he didn't
believe God played dice. But Einstein
wasn't wrong about quantum mechanics. It
turns out he was terrifyingly right.
Einstein identified something that
should keep you awake at night. Quantum
mechanics forces us to abandon one of
the three fundamental beliefs about
reality. Either quantum mechanics is
incomplete or particles can
instantaneously affect each other across
the universe or physical objects don't
exist when we're not looking at them.
There is no fourth option. Decades
later, physicist John Bell proved
Einstein correct with mathematical
precision. Bell's theorem showed that
quantum mechanics definitively violates
locality, meaning reality either breaks
the speed of light limit or splits into
parallel universes every time a quantum
measurement occurs. Today's guest,
science writer Adam Becker, reveals how
our most accurate scientific theory
tested to unprecedented precision
simultaneously remains our least
understood model of the universe. We can
calculate quantum mechanical quantities
perfectly, but we have no idea what's
actually happening in the universe when
we're not watching it. Adam helps break
down all this and more in this special
episode of Into the Impossible. Let's
go. Today we're covering a topic that
you may think you already know, and that
is what is real. What is reality? But I
assure you, our today's guest has much
more to say about that than you would
have ever contemplated. And I like to
begin Adam by asking you in the context
of what we teach our students. We never
sit there and talk about what is the
interpretation of a pendulum in
classical mechanics Newton's balls as
shown here. We don't talk about
interpretations. We don't say in
electromagnetism how do we interpret the
magnetic field even though it's bizarre
because it involves imaginary numbers.
So why do we have to talk about
interpretations of quantum mechanics to
understand it in any depth?
Yeah. because the math of the theory
doesn't line up with reality in an
obvious way, right? That's that's sort
of the fundamental difference between
quantum mechanics and these other
theories that we're talking about,
right? In Newtonian physics, the the
role played in the theory by, you know,
a mass is very clear, right? It's it's a
little thing like this, and when you do
this, it does this, right? Sure, maybe
the the electromagnetic field is a bit
weirder, right? Uh as you said, it
involves imaginary numbers, but you
know, we know what magnets are. We know
what things with electric charge are and
the the effects that those forces have
on those things is relatively clear. In
quantum mechanics, that all kind of goes
out the window and it's not actually
clear what the relationship between the
math of the theory and the things in the
world is, except in certain very
specific scenarios. And so this leads to
questions like, oh, okay, outside of
those very specific scenarios, like, you
know, when we're looking at the results
of an observation, what's going on?
And that's where we need an
interpretation of quantum mechanics to
understand what's happening.
There are those that say that we don't
need it, we just should shut up and
calculate. How is that philosophy or
that school differed in in the sense
that we teach our undergraduates
effectively, we teach in the Copenhagen
interpretation. Yeah. in advanced
quantum mechanics. Then we go back to
the beginning and talk about the
interpretations of quantum mechanics.
Yeah, we might even get into many worlds
theory. We might talk about that today.
But the question that I have is and yet
there are very few situations where we
can actually get numbers out of the
theory that we can test against
experiment but when we do those numbers
are testable to the highest level of
precision of any of the sciences, let
alone of the physical sciences. So talk
about how useful it is to be able to do
calculations even if you don't
understand the interpretations.
Totally. Yeah. Well, look, like I say in
in the book, what is real? Quantum
mechanics works incredibly well. It's,
you know, arguably the greatest success
story in all of science. It's an
incredible theory. And so as a practical
matter, shutting up and calculating is
often a pretty good move, right? Because
if you have to shut up in order to do
those calculations, yeah, that's that's
a reasonable price to pay, right? But we
don't. And if we ever want to move
beyond quantum theory to the next
theory, whatever that is, we may need to
wrestle with these issues that were sort
of left unresolved by the founders of
the theory.
We talk about quite often that Einstein
was wrong about quantum mechanics. And
it's too bad because he could have had a
good career. You know, he could have
been famous. You know that. And if he
had accepted the presidency of Israel,
that that's all he CV really lacked.
Talk about what was he wrong about? Was
he wrong about being wrong as he was
with the cosmological consonant or or
perhaps dark energy? Well, so Einstein
was very unhappy with quantum mechanics.
But there have been some myths about
what he was unhappy about, right? So the
the common myth and I mean not just in
the public but among physicists is that
Einstein was really unhappy that quantum
mechanics had randomness fundamental
stochastic element. And and it is true
that quantum mechanics has that and it
is also true that Einstein wasn't happy
about it. But that's not the thing that
he couldn't accept. Einstein had no
problem with randomness in theories. He
was actually a big advocate of
statistical mechanics. What he had
trouble with was not even that the
randomness was fundamental, which it's
not in statistical mechanics or at least
not in the same way. That concern with
randomness came out of his real
fundamental concerns which were about
realness about reality in the theory and
about another thing locality. So that
the first one was just that the theory
seemed in in this Copenhagen
interpretation this shut up and
calculate approach championed by among
other people Neil Spore seemed to imply
that when observations weren't happening
the things governed by quantum mechanics
the the the subatomic particles didn't
exist or you know couldn't be said to
exist and this was something that
Einstein just you know said like there's
no reason to think that that's true
observation isn't like that why should
observations matter matter in this way.
And to demonstrate that problem, there
was this sort of related problem that he
was really the first to identify which
is still with us, which is that quantum
mechanics has a tension with the idea of
locality. The idea that things
influences cannot travel faster than the
speed of light. And Einstein correctly
pointed out that the theory as
formulated had that problem. And many of
his contemporaries like Boore dismissed
that and said no it doesn't. And then
what was discovered later on after both
Boore and Einstein were dead was yeah
actually there is an issue with locality
in quantum mechanics. You know it's not
a fatal flaw but there's a tension
there. there is something in the theory
that does allow for the possibility of
some sort of non-local influence or you
know the appearance of a non-local
influence there's something that
requires further work and explanation in
the theory regarding locality and
Einstein saw that actually before there
was even a fully worked out theory of
quantum mechanics his concerns about
locality and quantum theory go back as
far as 1909
in the famous EPR are, you know,
conjecture paradox. Can you explain
that? Why is that so such a rich source
of inspiration for people working on
foundations of quantum mechanics and
interpretations of it even to this day?
Yeah, so EPR that that showed up in 1935
and the the name EPR was is the initials
of the three people on the paper,
Einstein, Podolski, and Rosen. And the
idea there was that you could have a
system of quantum particles that shared
a quantum mechanical relationship even
though they were very far apart called
entanglement. And Einstein and Podilski
and Rosen came up with this to show that
there's this fundamental feature of
quantum mechanics entanglement that
implies that these particles must be
sort of connected instantaneously no
matter how far apart they are if you
accept that no fuller description of
nature than that given by quantum
mechanics is possible. And so Einstein
in his sort of reformulation of this
that he did about 15 years later
basically made it clear that that the
choice in the EPR paradox was between
either locality or the completeness of
the theory. And Einstein said, you know,
he thought clearly the correct answer
was completeness. He said, you know,
quantum theory works. Of course it
works. It's just incomplete.
And for a long time there was no real
reason to think that he was wrong about
that.
Would that have necessitated what we
call hidden variables or what they have
completeness? Could you have locality
completeness or reality or did you have
to pick like a smores board from you
know one of two of those options at most
to fill in this completeness gap that
Einstein saw you would need hidden
variables or something like that. And
so, you know, he was laying this out as
a choice of like either you have to be
comfortable with non-locality, which is
a pretty high price to pay, or you need
to say, well, we're not done yet. There
was something missing from the theory
that we can find with a deeper theory.
And and for a long time, that looked
fine until this guy came along, John
Bell.
Yeah. Yeah.
We'll get to John Bell in a minute.
Before we get to John Bell and resolve
this issue of of completeness and hidden
variables, I want to talk about a
contender that's come up lately as a
springboard to determine what will it
mean to have a theory that is complete.
What does it mean in practice and that's
called Everettian mechanics or many
world interpretation of quantum
mechanics. I like to joke that I've
discovered a parallel. You know,
Schroinger's cat is kind of the most
famous paradox of superposition and the
Copenhagen interpretation led many
people to kind of scratch their heads
for a long time. So, I've come up with
the analog of that for Everettedian
mechanics, which I want to lay upon you.
So, the Schroinger had a cat, but but
Everett has a rabbit, and it's called
Leverettian mechanics.
Oh, no.
Got it. That's a good one. Come on. I'm
a dad. I got to make dad jokes. Come on.
I got a license. So, talk about why is
it in your opinion, why is it undergoing
kind of a resurgence of popularity?
Everyone from movies to Sean Carroll and
and others that really do bolster this
this interpretation and almost accept it
as if it's true. And and not only that
they they sort of have a belief in it.
So first of all what is everian
mechanics many worlds interpretation as
it's called and what if any evidence in
the physical world would give us
credility in the fact that these things
branch at different rates and we could
measure can we actually ever settle this
question of which interpretation is
quote unquote correct?
I think we can but I'm going to come
back to how in a minute. But as for why
many worlds has sort of seen this surge
in popularity I think there's a few
reasons. One of them is sort of steeped
in the physics of it all. Right? There
has been a wider appreciation over the
last 2030 years among physicists that
hey actually maybe quantum foundations
does matter because for a long time it
just was not seen as real science and
real physics and the only people really
doing it were either like outcast
physicists or philosophers of physics
who I think correctly recognized that
there was a serious problem here. But in
the last few decades, what's happened is
quantum mechanics has been more
established as this theory that really
needs to work at all scales from the
small up to the large. And once you
accept that, you really can't shy away
from the problems that come with it like
the measurement problem. If you want to
do quantum cosmology, you need to be
comfortable in some way with talking
about quantum systems the size of the
entire universe. And if you do that, you
need to be thinking about quantum
foundations. There's no way out
that and you know the fact that things
that came out of quantum foundations,
directions of research that came out of
quantum foundations like quantum
computing has sort of seen this like
full flowering I think made it
impossible to ignore this. And then once
you stop ignoring quantum foundations
then you have to start looking at
possible solutions. And there are a lot
of things about the many worlds
interpretation that look pretty
appealing to physicists. I don't
subscribe to it personally, but I think
it's a reasonable option of the options
available like the things that make it
appealing. It doesn't it doesn't involve
modifying any of the equations that we
already have, right? It doesn't
you still have Shinger's equation.
Exactly. You still have Schroinger's
equation. You still like do everything
the same way. You just need to make this
change in what you think the theory is
saying about the nature of our world.
And the alternative is collapse of the
wave function and unitary evolution
versus non-unitary evolution collapse.
So you you avoid that because everything
evolves unitarily.
Right. Exactly. And so that looks pretty
good. I mean the the price that you have
to pay for that is oh my god there are
all of these universes but we don't see
them. Where are they? But the theory has
an answer for that as well. So, you
know, I can I can understand the appeal,
but the the other reason it has appeal
is not about the physics and it's it's
just it sounds pretty good, right? It
just sounds interesting.
It's a matter of taste.
No, no, no. I don't I don't mean it
sounds good like as a physicist. I mean
it sounds cool if you're not a
physicist. Right. Right. That's why
movies.
Yeah. Exactly. That's why it's in movies
and comic books and the Spider-Verse.
Right. Yeah. But you mentioned how could
we detect it? So, I I asked this of Sean
Carroll. Um
Yeah. How is it possible that we could
even you know detect something that
where this branchial you know function
is is occurring at the rate of you know
10 theus 32 of a second which is you
know getting close to plank time you
know it's only 10,000 or 10 billion
plank times tell me how could we
actually discern the presence of a
parallel alternate multiverse universe
ever or otherwise
right right so I'm not Shawn right Shawn
would say well you see it in the fact
that quantum mechanics is correct Right.
Many of you are watching this on a
television and I know that if you love
the cosmos as much as I do, you'll want
to subscribe now. It's a little more
tricky on TV, but it's well worth your
time. Click down below and don't forget
to leave a thumbs up. More minds, more
mysteries, more multiverse awaits you.
People say things like, "Oh, the double
slit experiment."
I've never really fully bought that, but
maybe can you make the case?
Oh, sure. Yeah. If I if I put on my
Shawn Carroll hat and pretend to be
Shawn Carroll for a second and like
really be Everett. I just saw him like a
week or two ago. Then I'd say, "Yeah,
well, look, the fact that we get an
interference pattern in the double slit
experiment is something that you can't
coherently explain without, you know,
many worlds or something like that or
you have to, you know, choose one of
these other less palatable options. And
so out of the available options for
explaining how quantum mechanics works,
this is the best one." Right? And I I
don't know that that's exactly what Sean
would say, but that's the kind of thing
that you get from Mad Verdians. And I
understand why they say that. And again,
I think this is reasonable. I'm just not
convinced that they're correct. I don't
think that we currently have a way to
detect this or figure out which
interpretation is correct. But I think
that someday we will because what's
going to happen is one of the few things
that I think everybody agrees on within
physics about quantum mechanics and
quantum physics is that it's not the
final theory. Right? We know we're not
done. At the very least, we need a
theory of quantum gravity.
And that means we need to move beyond
this theory at some point. Historically,
it is when we move beyond a certain
theory that we get a new light onto what
that theory was saying in the first
place. Right? When we moved past
Newtonian physics, we learned new things
about what Newtonian physics had been
saying all along. We had a new way of
looking at it. And the interpretation of
quantum mechanics that we choose may end
up influencing, you know, in what
direction we make a discovery that lets
us move past it to the next theory. And
so it may be that the next theory comes
with a way of looking at the world
that's really best compatible with one
or a certain way of interpreting quantum
physics and may even come with a way of
experimentally distinguishing between
different interpretations of quantum
mechanics.
Is there any other example of a theory
that works but nobody understands how it
works?
Yeah, that's a great question. Honestly,
I mean there are there are theories that
people commonly misunderstand,
but it is hard to think of a theory that
people take as seriously as quantum
physics that is as poorly understood at
the fundamental level as quantum physics
is. And and I think that's really
striking and one of the reasons it's a
problem.
And let's talk about John Bell. How does
John Bell kind of come to either the
rescue or perhaps final humiliation of
EPR of Einstein and and his and his
colleagues? What was his role? And and
first explain if you would what are
hidden variables and and why did this
pose such a contentious problem for many
decades?
Absolutely. So hidden variables the idea
there is realizing in a way Einstein's
dream right saying yeah you know what
quantum mechanics works really well but
it's incomplete and there is some hidden
thing that takes this fundamentally
probabilistic theory and actually makes
it deterministic something that actually
determines these outcomes that we are
seeing that we can only ascribe
probabilities to and again the
probabilistic stuff isn't what Einstein
was really concerned with fundamentally,
but finding a way to solve that problem
would, you know, get rid of the problems
or or seemed like it would get rid of
the problems that Einstein had. And this
brings us to Bell, right? Because Bell,
it's actually it's very interesting.
Some people have said, "Yes, Belle's the
man who proved Einstein wrong." And
other people have said, "No, Belle's the
man who proved Einstein right." And I
understand why they both said that. I'm
more inclined to say that he proved
Einstein right in that Einstein was
concerned about locality in quantum
physics. And Bell showed that he was
right to be concerned about that because
it's a problem. What Bell did was he
looked at the only hidden variable
theory that existed at the time that he
came up with, you know, that that he was
thinking about this. Bel was thinking
about this originally in the early 1950s
and then he put it down for a little
while. Came back to it in the mid 1960s
and he was looking at the only hidden
variable theory that existed at the time
was a thing called bowan mechanics which
does you know assign this sort of
deterministic hidden variable picture to
what's going on like under the hood of
quantum physics but at the price of
introducing non-locality.
And so Belle looked at that and said
does it have to do that? Is that a
general feature of quantum mechanics or
is there a way around it? And so what
Bell did and and I want to emphasize he
did this without quantum mechanics. He
just did this starting from the
assumption of locality and not from the
assumption of hidden variables or
anything else like that. Just locality.
Belle came up with this idea of a way to
you know mathematically constrain
what long distance correlations were
possible in a local theory and then he
showed that quantum mechanics violates
those conditions. So you know Einstein
with EPR he had shown that with quantum
mechanics there was a choice between its
locality and its completeness and what
Bell showed was it's worse than that
either nature is non-local or quantum
mechanics is incorrect in certain
situations
or there's some weird third way out that
involves something like many worlds or
or something else. there's you know
there are ways to wrigle out of Bell's
you know theorem but there it's a very
narrow door
I view this as sort of an very
instructive the sociology of science
even the great Einstein was sort of
shunned and certainly you make the case
in the book the bone was really kind of
you know traumatized by by his outcast
what is the role of consensus in science
I mean going beyond the headlines and
97% of scientists agree I mean whatever
that means is there a place for
consensus and what was the damage done
and what opportunities came out of that
for people like Zillinger Clauser and
others that we'll get into a minute from
the shunning people like this figure
that Bow and ultimately is portrayed as
in the book.
Yeah. Yeah. No, I mean David Bow, you
know, he was shunned by his fellow
physicists for, you know, saying the
things that he said about quantum
physics and then he got, you know, run
out of the country for being a communist
and couldn't find work. And even though
he had recommendation letters from
Einstein and Oppenheimer, just about the
best recommendation letters you could
ask for, he ended up going to Brazil.
And then even though he ultimately
decided that communism was wrong and
that he he was no longer a communist, he
didn't feel comfortable coming back to
the US after the experience that he'd
had. And I think understandably so. But
yeah, I mean I I think that there is a
place for consensus in science, right?
And I think even David Bow would agree
with that. For example, bone was part of
a scientific consensus that quantum
mechanics is correct, right? And Naomi
Areskis, author of Merchants of Doubt,
she talks about consensus as sort of one
of the products that science produces is
scientific consensus. And it is
absolutely true that there's a
scientific consensus that quantum
mechanics works. It is also true that
sometimes scientific consensus is wrong.
But usually when science is functioning
properly
that you know the cases where scientific
consensus is wrong are usually more like
questions around quantum interpretation
than they are around questions around
you know does quantum mechanics work at
all. The key point there is that you
know it goes back to the question you
were asking about can we know if there
are these other universes. One of the
reasons quantum foundations is hard is
because quantum foundations with rare
exceptions like Bell's theorem doesn't
make contact with empirical, you know,
experimental science.
And so it was only when Bell found a way
to have quantum foundations make that
contact that a new opportunity for
consensus arose. And and I think that
part of what we're seeing now with the
the increased interest in quantum
foundations is essentially a delayed
reaction to that to say, "Oh, yeah, I
guess actually this does matter." I
think there is an important role for
consensus in science. When science is is
functioning properly, we need scientific
consensus. We just need to be careful
about it.
Since you wrote the book, at least two
scientists have won the Nobel Prize for
quantum foundations, Anton Dylinger and
John Clauser. Talk about and that was
obviously due to your book. I mean, you
put them on the map, Adam. Let's be
honest here.
Talk about the experimental approach to
interpretations of quantum mechanics,
the work by Clauser, by Zylinger and
their colleagues. How does that fold in
and why does that still matter today?
Haven't we proven, you know, shut the
door completely on this, you know,
Sophie's choice between completeness and
locality and reality?
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So Bell showed that
there was this choice, right, between
the accuracy of quantum mechanics, its
its correctness and locality. And so
that meant that you had to test quantum
mechanics in these specific scenarios
that as it turned out, no one had tested
it in. Some people had come close, but
no one had actually done the test. And
so what Clauser and then later Aspay and
Zylinger did was they actually performed
that test. So John Clauser led the
charge to do the first experimental test
and he did this up at Berkeley in 1972
with Stuart Freriedman to actually do
the first experimental test of Bell's
theorem to to test quantum mechanics in
these conditions. And Bell thought that
quantum mechanics would you know come
out on top. He thought that it would
work. Clauser wasn't so sure. Clauser
was was hoping that it wouldn't, which
is, you know, understandable, right? In
in his first letter to Clauser, Belell
said, you know, you you you got to think
that quantum mechanics is going to work,
but there is the small chance that it
won't. And in that case, that would
shake the world, right? Clauser wanted
to shake the world. And I think it's a
testament to his skill as an
experimentter. Both that he was able to
do the experiment and that even though
he was hoping it would turn out one way,
it turned out the other way. And he
published that result. And then when
another team I think over at Harvard did
a similar experiment and found that no
actually quantum mechanics was wrong,
Clauser went back and did his experiment
again at a higher precision and in you
know a way I think more closely
resembling the Harvard team and found no
his initial result was correct
even though it's not what he wanted
which is a good thing. I mean that's a
good sign of a scientist is not
dominated by confirmation.
Exactly. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It's how
science is theoretically supposed to
work. Aspay came in and saw this debate
going on between Clauser and the others
and said, "Oh, by the time I get an
experiment up and running, it's going to
be too late. That'll be resolved. But
maybe I can find a different twist.
Maybe I can get the experiment done.
There's a thing that has to be done in
these experiments where you switch
detector settings at different ends of
the experiment." and he said, "Maybe I
can find a way to make that happen
really, really fast, which would close
certain loopholes around, you know,
slower than light connections between
the two ends of the experiment." And he
did find a way to do that and published
that result. And he also, you know,
Clauser had a lot of trouble finding a
job. Asp went and talked to Belle before
he engaged in this. And Belle said, "Do
you have a permanent position because
otherwise you shouldn't do this?" And
Aspay did. And after he did it, he went
and gave a lot of talks about it and was
very sort of persuasive that this is
interesting science. And that had a
really big effect just on the culture of
the field. And then Zylinger came in and
closed another one of these loopholes
around detector efficiency at at both
ends of of these Bell experiments. And
you know, this third generation of Bell
experiments is is sort of, you know, led
us into this modern era of quantum
information science. They're all really
spectacular and I think beautiful
experiments. So two final questions.
One, can you explain quantum
computation? Why does it have so much
promise? Is it hype? Do we really expect
to learn more about the physical
universe than just learning about how to
solve a Hamiltonian or a protein?
Quantum computers are very good at
describing how quantum computers work as
Fineman pointed out in the in the 50s
and 60s. What else can they do? Can they
really do anything superior? And can we
connect them to your new book? Are they
also going to be part of an AI dystopian
future?
I mean, quantum computers, it's not just
hype. If we can get quantum computing to
work, we can use it to, you know, as
Fineman and many others said, it's not
just him, we could use it to learn a lot
about, you know, material science,
quantum mechanics. There are certain
algorithms that we have not been able to
find classical computing algorithms for,
but quantum computing algorithms that
can go really fast for like factoring
numbers. It's really it it could be very
interesting. We don't know for sure that
we're going to be able to get it to work
at the scale that we'd need it to for it
to actually be practical. And even if
and and by we, I just mean humanity
here. And even if it turns out there is
a way to do that, that doesn't mean that
it's going to replace the kinds of
computers that we have now. I don't
think it's ever going to do that. Both
because Chrome computers are not better
than existing computers at many other
tasks. They're just as good or worse.
And also it seems unlikely that we'd be
able to get quantum computers to work,
you know, that would not be sort of very
delicate because the level of control is
literally quantum needed to make them
work. So it's not hype, but it's also,
you know, still technology that we're
figuring out. We're trying to see if we
can prove it. You know, the the answer
to the question is it going to be part
of this, you know, AI future? It really
depends on the question of well, how
well does it work out? Silicon Valley
would like it to work out very well and
you know perform all kinds of magic
tricks for us. Silicon Valley wants a
lot of things.
Okay. So, Adam, what is real?
Okay. So, my favorite Amazon review of
either of my books or maybe it's Good
Readads. Yeah, I think it is. It's a
good readads review of What is Real? And
it's art. Like, I should print it out
and frame it. I love it so much. It just
says, you know, what is real? the
author's answer, I don't know.
And it's like, buddy, there's a question
mark there at the end of the title and
the subtitle has the word unfinished
right there in it. Like, did you if
somebody could explain to you in just
300 pages, what the answer to the
question, what is real? Would you
believe them? Like I, you know, I don't
I don't know. But I do know that
whatever it is, it is something that
makes
quantum mechanics true, right? Or at
least approximately true, right? Because
like quantum physics, quantum mechanics,
quantum field theory, these are the most
accurate theories that we've ever
devised, especially quantum field
theory. There's got to be something in
the world that those theories are about
that makes them approximately true. We
hear a lot about all sorts of
mislications of quantum theory as well
as things like quantum healing, quantum
spirituality, even things that are
supposed to entangle us and how those
relate to souls and the afterlife and so
forth. What would Einstein make of this?
Would he call it nonsense? What do you
make of it?
I can't speak for Einstein, but I don't,
you know, I I do think he would have
thought it was nonsense. I I can't, you
know, imitate his his voice well enough
to say what he would say, but he
certainly would not have thought that
any of that was good. I think he would
have just rolled his eyes and said,
"Yeah, that's what humans do." Right? I
think it's nonsense. There's certainly
no connection to quantum mechanics with
any of that stuff. And I also think that
these sort of misunderstandings around
what quantum mechanics means and the the
sort of hole in our understanding of it
that's left by not investigating quantum
mechanics for or the quantum foundations
rather for a very long time left an
opening for that stuff made it easier to
to sort of sell that kind of snake oil
to say that yeah you know quantum
mechanics proves that there's this
fundamental role for the observer and
stuff like that but I will also say that
is also just stuff that humans Humans
are always going to find ways to
misapply, you know, truths and and try
to try to do this kind of thing. And,
you know, if you're if you're feeling
pessimistic, you can say we're always
going to con each other. If you're
feeling optimistic, you can say we're
always going to look for hope, even
where, you know, we shouldn't. But
either way, this sort of misinformation
and disinformation is out there, and you
got to be careful.
Adam Becker, thank you so much for your
time on both of these wonderful books.
We'll have links to everything down
below and so much more. The implications
of quantum mechanics stretch far beyond
the laboratory. And if you enjoyed
exploring how our most successful theory
might be fundamentally incomplete, you
should definitely check out my episode
with cosmologist Shan Carroll, where we
dive deep into the many worlds
interpretation and whether every quantum
measurement literally splits reality
into two parallel universes. Click here.
And don't forget to subscribe.