Rebecca Newberger Goldstein is a MacArthur Genius Award recipient, philosopher, novelist, and author of The Mattering Instinct. Her verdict on why human beings are driven to matter — and what threatens that drive — might change how you think about your own life. Check out her recent appearance on Mindscape here.
In this conversation, we discuss why every human being is haunted by the need to matter, the four types of people and how each one tries to satisfy that longing, why Ludwig Boltzmann's tragic death is a thermodynamic story, how depression maps onto entropy, whether AI can ever have a mattering instinct, and why heroic strivers are the most threatened by artificial intelligence. We also get into what Freud got wrong about what women want, the physics of matter versus the philosophy of mattering, and why the second law of thermodynamics may be the most personal law in all of science.
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein is a philosopher, novelist, and MacArthur Genius Award recipient. She is the author of multiple books including Plato at the Googleplex and 36 Arguments for the Existence of God. Her newest book, The Mattering Instinct, is one of Apple's most anticipated books of the year.
Key Takeaways: 00:00 Why every human being needs to matter — and what happens when they can't 04:25 The second law of thermodynamics and what it has to do with your life 08:00 The 4 types of people: Transcenders, Socializers, Heroic Strivers, and Competitors 17:30 Why fame-seeking millennials will give up everything — including relationships 22:00 Zero-sum mattering: the competitor who was happy for 15 minutes after winning a Nobel Prize 24:15 Ludwig Boltzmann solved one of physics' greatest paradoxes — then despaired 34:50 All tragedies are thermodynamic — and so is depression 40:00 Life as resistance to entropy: what flourishing actually means 54:00 Can AI have a mattering instinct? What that would mean for human rights 57:50 If AI becomes a heroic striver, what's left for us?
📚 Get my books: Think Like a Nobel Prize Winner, with productivity tips from 9 Nobel Prize winners: https://a.co/d/03ezQFu
Focus Like a Nobel Prize Winner, with life-changing interviews with 9 Nobel Prizewinners: https://a.co/d/hi50U9U My tell-all cosmic memoir Losing the Nobel Prize: http://amzn.to/2sa5UpA
The first-ever audiobook from Galileo: Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems: Ptolemaic and Copernican https://a.co/d/iZPi9Un
There's a law of physics that governs everything. Your happiness, your depression,
and even whether your life has meaning. And guess what? It can't be broken.
Life is a local violation of the law of entropy. It is a counter-entropic resistance.
The thing that the suicidally depressed people feel is that they don't matter,
others do, they don't, nothing they can do will ever make them matter.
This is how I judge people. Are you increasing entropy or are you decreasing it?
If these agents begin to have a longing to matter, if they do this, then what we have are
non-carbon based humans. She's a MacArthur genius,
a philosopher who's trained in physics. And she just used the second law of thermodynamics to
explain why your life feels like it's always falling apart. What Rebecca did next is what
no physicist has ever done before. She took the second law of thermodynamics and built an entire
theory of human meaning on top of it. What took you from MacArthur genius,
your many, many works of philosophy and your great contributions to literature from the
genius grants, et cetera, to write a book that's basically a stealth physics book?
When I studied physics as an undergraduate, and then I had gone, when I went into philosophy,
it was into philosophy of physics, you know, so I've always been interested in physics.
When I first learned about the second law of thermodynamics, I couldn't quite conceptualize
it. I couldn't completely wrap my head around it, but it seemed to have implications for us,
right? I mean, we are physical systems. We are subject to the second law of thermodynamics.
There's a tragic dimension to this law and that we live in resistance to it. All living things
live in resistance. In fact, when I was a graduate student, that occurred to me,
oh my gosh, biological systems are really just organized to resist the second law of thermodynamics.
This is so exciting. Has anybody discovered this? And then I read Schrodinger's,
What is Life? Other people had, in fact, Boltzmann himself had realized this at the
laws of biology, or in some sense, biology's response to this supreme law that tells us that
in closed systems, entropy never decreases, and if there's any way for it to increase, it will.
And what that entropy is, is the measure of the disorder of the system. The disorder is,
the more disorder, the higher the entropy, the less efficient work you can get out of the system.
And eventually, the system will go to thermal equilibrium. You'll be able to get no more
energy out of it. It's somewhat the end of the system. And in fact, Rudolf Clausius,
the 19th century physicist who formulated a concept of entropy, which means literally
transformation from within. There's poignancy in that. It's a transformation from within is going
to the end of the system. And he had said, you know, that the universe itself will go to thermal
equilibrium to what we call the heat death. And so, there'll be no more energy to be gotten out
of it. This sounds like, I mean, a joke from Woody Allen. His mother brings him to a shrink
because he's discovered that eventually the sun is going to go out. He said, you know,
how can I live? What's there to live for? You know, the sun is going to go out. And the mother
says to the shrink, you know, I don't know why Althea is so worried about it. It's not going
out over Brooklyn.
It's in Annie Hall, right?
Annie Hall, yes, that's right.
He goes, yeah, what do you care? Brooklyn's not expanding, right?
Yeah, that's what it was. It was expanding, right. That's right.
Classic.
You studied physics as an undergraduate, and right in the book, you've been haunted
since your early days as an undergrad by the second law of thermodynamics. So, let's start
with that story that you tell first about Ludwig Boltzmann, who solved one of the great paradoxes
of physics, the irreversibility paradox. Talk about that, and then why did, in your mind,
was he so traumatized, perhaps, or full of dread of his equation that he took his own life? So,
talk about that.
Yeah, and this is really good because it really ties back to your previous question, you know,
about the types of scientists, the different types of, you know, scientists, types in terms
of their personality. And to me, the formative feature of personality is how you minister
to this longing to matter, you know? So, there was this great paradox, which is probably most
of the processes that we observe are irreversible. If you film them, like, let's say I crack open an
egg, and I stir it up, and then I fry it. And somebody filmed this, and then they reversed the
film. Anybody who sees the reversal of that film is going to know it was reversed. That cannot
happen in nature. That egg is going to uncook itself, unscramble, the yolk is going to separate
from the albumen, and then jump into the shell and seal up. Impossible, right? So, almost, you know,
everything that we see is irreversible. What's going on there is a matter of what's going on
in the molecules that constitute this process. And if you filmed all of the motions of the molecules,
and then filmed it, and then reversed the film, perfectly, perfectly normal, you know,
not contrary to nature at all. So, how can that be? That the macroscopic state is just
constituted by the microscopic state. On the microscopic state, we find complete reversibility,
and on the macroscopic state, irreversibility. It boggled the mind, and it was called a paradox.
And Boltzmann solved this problem. He really has only two premises here. That matter has
constituents, and that order is much less probable than disorder. Those constituents can only be
in a certain configuration. You can switch them around a little bit when you have the egg cracked
open with the yolk and the albumen surrounding it. Once you scramble it up, you can change,
you can shuffle those parts every which way, and it's still going to look the same. The features of
the system are going to stay the same. Instead of order going to disorder, you could talk about
shufflability. One of my physics professors had described it in terms of shufflability.
The more entropy there is, the more shufflability, you know, you can change around the parts and
you're still going to end up with the same system. There are just so many more, by orders
of magnitude, so many more ways of getting disorder than order in terms of the constituent
states. This is the amazing thing. So here was this real paradox, a real mind-boggling paradox.
All you need is the matter is made of constituent parts, and the laws of probability, you know,
it's the laws of large numbers applied to microstates, and that's why it's the supreme
law of a physicist. I think it was Eddington who at first called it that, but it's repeated by
Einstein and by Stephen Hawking and by really all physicists. That is, we know it is never going to
be falsified. All laws of nature are open to falsification. That's what makes them scientific
laws, you're right?
They're provisional.
Well, it's always provisional. We're going to get more evidence, we're going to have to go back to
the drawing boards. But this, and Einstein puts it very, very beautifully, and as does Eddington,
if something doesn't agree with the second law of thermodynamics, too bad for your theory,
give up. You are not going to get that Nobel Prize. You are going to give it up.
In that sense, it's the supreme law of physics, Ludwig Boltzmann, and he solved this amazing
problem, and get this, none of his peers accepted it because of bad philosophy. They were all,
in that day, you know, it was Ernst Mach, was like a leading Austrian, and he's a great,
great, great physicist, you know, but he was a positivist. He did not believe in molecules and
atoms. If you couldn't observe it, it didn't exist. I would call positivism bad philosophy.
That philosophy was sinking an amazing piece of scientific work that has proved so fruitful.
The ramifications of this are all over, including, I want to make them even, you know,
I want to draw even more consequences out of the law of second thermodynamics.
You write beautifully, you say, all tragedies are thermodynamic. You mention it in the context
of his daughter, Elsa, finding her father's dead body, and it wasn't like he showed any sign,
and we can't go into the minds of someone who dies by suicide, right? But at the same time,
you think that this would be a more common thing, and I guess my question to you is,
why do some scientists kind of fall victim to even bad philosophy, whereas others,
so I'm thinking of Ignaz Semmelweis, who you write about, and we had Matt Kaplan on from
The Economist, who wrote a book basically about Semmelweis not being accepted, called I Told You
So, an event, he didn't commit suicide, but he did kind of die tragically young, and of illnesses
probably precipitated by some of his melancholia. He was in an asylum when he was, yes, they tricked
him into an asylum, yes. My friend Patty Carrico invented mRNA COVID vaccine. She thrived despite
even worse circumstances than people not believing her, and they certainly didn't believe,
they wanted to deport her, a post-doc advisor threatened to deport her if she got another job,
and yet she came back resilient as ever and won the Nobel Prize. So why do some scientists fall
victim to, I mean, physicists love to make fun of philosophers, you know that, I'm sure.
I love to make fun of philosophers.
Tell me, why do some, you know, have, we sort of have arrogance, you know, and then
other times seem to fall prey to their predations. Why is that?
Temperament plays such a large role in this. I was not a person who was raised to think big ideas.
I wasn't raised to think at all. I was really raised to be a good Orthodox Jewish wife and
mother, and my temperament didn't go that way. I could just feel this sort of something, you know,
the restlessness, the intellectual restlessness and whatever. Altman, he knew he had solved
something incredibly important. He said, you know, it must be wonderful to be a general leading
great armies into the battle and great victories, but as for him, the only thing he wants to do is
sit in a little room and solve big problems that will contribute to knowledge. Now to contribute
to knowledge means that other scientists must accept it. He wanted to happen what exactly did
happen to him only post-death, post-mortem, which is that he would make science grow. He has made
science grow amazingly, but he despaired that that would ever happen. And he had a temperament,
he might have been bipolar, you know, but so it hurt him so much and towards the end of his life,
I mean, he was really desperate and he committed such a sad, sad thing and as you say, I mean,
you know, that his teenage daughter found him is just, it's such a tragedy. It was the day before
he was supposed to return to teaching and he was a beloved teacher. He had been a very funny teacher
and very engaging, but he got more and more depressed. You're creatures of matter who long
to matter. You can only say that in English, but I'm so glad you could say that in English because
it's again, incredibly poignant. You know, we're creatures of matter who are subject to the laws
of physics, including the second law of thermodynamics, but we long to matter. And so
much of the book is trying to explain how that transformation from within us, within our species
happens. You know, that's a normative transformation, an ethical transformation and
it's really what distinguishes us. That we, in some sense, want to justify the fact that we
matter so much to ourselves, that we pay so much attention to ourselves and that we actually can
pinpoint the place in human history where this emerged during the period when all the religions
emerged that are still extant, which is so interesting, and also Western philosophy emerged
during the period of history that's called the Axial Age. And that's when we became these creatures
who long to matter and who are searching for the right values to help us justify ourselves,
first and foremost. So, I've been thinking about this forever, actually.
Yeah, you say it's the hardest book, it was the longest book, you know? Which is surprising with
all your other, you know, just enormous contributions to literature. It's a beautifully
printed and bound book. Prominent throughout it is this concept that you came up with,
which is the maps of mattering. Talk us through the maps of mattering. What are they and where
do scientists like my audience members maybe, where do they find themselves?
I've noticed that there are four general strategies, and that's what I sketched out.
This is like the four continents of the mattering. And I asked AI to help me with how big to make
them, how the proportions of humanity are, how they split up, and AI was very, very helpful in
this. They're first of all, they'll start with transcenders, what I call transcenders. And
transcenders, which we, humanity has been for a long part of our history, up until I guess
we would say the Enlightenment, we all sought our mattering religiously. We had a metaphysical
premise that there is a transcendent presence in the universe, whether we call him God or
something vaguer, and that this God made the universe, created something out of nothing,
created the laws of nature and the moral order within, and he created each one of us. You know,
the fact that we are here is the proof that we have a role to play in the narrative of eternity.
This is a very grand story. I get goosebumps when I even just, you know, say it. Very grand
way of conceptualizing our mattering. It's a kind of cosmic mattering that the God who created
everything created us and we are here to try to figure out how he wants us to behave. These are
the people I call transcenders. Then most of the people I talk to, even if they go to church or
mosque or synagogue, they're not transcenders in this way, you know, in that their life would
not be worth living if they didn't have this metaphysical belief. Most of the people I've
spoken to are what I call socializers. They understand this question, do you matter, that I
ask them. They understand it as do I matter to others? And very often the others to whom they
need to matter are the people who are already in their lives. We all need people in our lives.
Transcenders, heroic strivers, competitors, these are the four branches of four continents that I
delineate. We all need people in our life. We're gregarious creatures, evolved from gregarious
creatures. But for a socializer, there is no mattering other than mattering either to their
people who are already in their lives, their children or their romantic partners or their
community, colleagues, neighbors, people in their lives. But there are other socializers, and I found
this particularly with millennials, who it's not so much people in their lives, it can be perfect
strangers. Many millennials want to be famous. That is how they want to appease the longing to
matter. They want to be influencers. They really want to be famous, and they're willing to give up,
I read a lot of psychological literature on this, they're willing to give up having children,
having romantic partners, having any connection with their family for fame, which is to be,
to matter to a bunch of strangers, which is an odd thing, really.
Completely unique in human history. There's a trillion-dollar industry predicated on the
need to matter to get affirmation from strangers. In fact, a lot of people you don't like. I always
feel like you go to a comedy club, and it's almost impossible for the comedian to really
like the audience or whatever, but they want to be famous. But the most terrifying thing you quote
in the book, in that chapter on fame seekers, had to do with the fact that they don't care
what they're famous for. That's terrifying.
I understand a little bit the rationale because of the way I understand this longing to matter
is really trying to convince ourselves, which I find endearing about our species,
that we have to convince ourselves. But the evidence that a lot of people are paying attention
to us seems to be overwhelming evidence that we ourselves matter, that we deserve this attention.
So, I understand it in some sense. But in fact, most of the people I've spoken to who are famous,
it's very, very insecure that they're not particularly happy people. The public is
very fickle. Then heroic strivers. And heroic strivers, mattering doesn't mean
mattering to God, it doesn't mean mattering to others. It means having certain standards of
excellence that you are committed to, if not realizing, at least psychotically approaching,
getting closer and closer to it. And it could be intellectual, it could be artistic, it could be
athletic, military, entrepreneurial, ethical. All of these types are profiled in the book.
Their mattering project, whether it's intellectual or ethical or artistic, is what keeps them going
and failures in that are existential failures. Those setbacks are existential. I don't feel
like my life is worth anything. That sort of thing is what you hear.
And the last group are competitors. That's the one group where when I talk about,
to them about mattering, they get a little uneasy. I can always tell by the reactions at this point,
you know, like where you are, sometimes I'm wrong, and sometimes it's very, very tricky.
But competitors really see mattering as zero-sum. The more others matter, the less
they matter. Just not enough mattering to go around. And it can be against individuals.
It could also be group against group. And one of the people I profile,
I really wanted to talk to a neo-Nazi. That's somebody, you know, it's a group against group,
zero-sum mattering. And look, he's done great work. I'm glad for his work. It's seminal work.
And so I would say for all of these types, socializers, transcenders, competitors,
heroic strivers, it can be good. It can be bad. And I try to define what are the good ways? How
do we judge the good ways of trying to appease this longing we have? What are the creative ways?
What are the destructive ways? And once again, entropy comes to the rescue.
You do write that once the disintegration from within has sufficiently progressed,
it takes that much more energy to reverse it. A law that holds for our psyches as for all else.
And so is depression sort of a, you know, they used to think miasmas and things in the air,
you write about that. But is depression at heart an entropic collapsing process?
I have spoken to a lot of people who suffer from clinical depression. And I want to say,
first of all, that the US hotline for suicide prevention is www.youmatter.gov. The thing that
the suicidally depressed people feel is that they don't matter, others do, they don't,
nothing they can do will ever make them matter. It's terrible, terrible. And what this means is
they cannot abide their own presence. I mean, I really think it shows how strong this
mattering instinct is in us. You know, if you can't somehow appease it, you can't abide your own
presence. The people I've spoken to, and one is a very, very good philosopher who has suffered
from depression, told me is that phenomenologically, this is exactly what it feels like.
It feels like psychic disintegration. It just feels like an unraveling. And it's a kind of
death within death, you know, you don't have the counterentropic drive to push on against
entropy into your life. You lack energy, you lack that innervation, positive and negative.
And, you know, when I read, sometimes I get asked is, I'm sure, you know, what's the meaning of
life? I usually say something like this, Rebecca, I usually say, and it relates to your theory and
what you posit in the book, which is it relates to entropy in the following way. If I said to
Rebecca, could I double your happiness right now? Well, you have grandkids, right? Like,
pretty hard, like maybe you have two grandkids, you know, and then you go to four. But eventually,
it's going to start to decrease, right? Like, as wonderful as they are, you know, I know somebody
with like 72, I mean, he's a Chabad rabbi, his grandfather has 72, you know, grandchildren. I'm
like, does he know all their birthdays? Whatever. It's probably like every day of the year. If I
gave you a billion dollars, yeah, you'd be a lot happier. But would you be, you know, like,
could you be 10 times happier? But I say to somebody, and this really only kind of works
for people that have very tight, you know, either children or relationships in their life that are
like children if they don't have biological children. And that's that I could make your
life infinitely worse. Like, I don't even like to say it, right? I'm not even going to vocalize
what it is. But you and I know as being parents, how our life could get infinitely worse, right?
So the converse of that to me is you should do those things that which if they were taken away
through an entropic destroying process, you would be devastated. Okay, maybe not. But like,
the more of those things you have, I think the happier or at least you can progress towards
happiness. You speak about happiness, not as a state of being, but as a almost like a journey.
Does that comport with this entropic, you know, overarching, I would say, architecture that you
speak about? We're not closed systems. Being a closed system is not compatible with being alive.
We take in energy in the form of food and sunlight and certain chemicals,
and it's taken in through the work of metabolism. Keeping up the order that life needs, you know,
life is a highly ordered system. So ordered, it's scary to think because the more order,
the more ways it can go wrong. And all of this order is maintained, you know, in the
face and in resistance to entropy. That's what life, you know, viva la resistance,
this is what life is. That's what it is, resistance to entropy. While we're, of course,
exporting high entropic waste, you know, heat and other waste into the environment, life is a
local violation of the law of entropy. But the life with the environment, that system
is obeying the law of entropy. There are no violations to the law of entropy.
This is what life is. This is what flourishing is. It is a counterentropic resistance, defiance,
and happiness, you know, happiness is a very ordered state. And I would say, I would go even
further. Everything worth living for is an ordered state. Knowledge is better than ignorance.
Clarity is better than confusion. Flourishing is better than suffering.
Love is better than hatred. Beauty is better than ugliness. These are truisms,
you know, that we all accept. And if you look at the thing that's better, it's an ordered state.
It's negation is a disordered state. So, I think I would argue this is a very kind of
hypnosis argument, trying to get out of the laws of nature some ethical enlightenment,
some ethical guidance, because that's what we want. We want ethical guidance. You know,
we know we want to matter, we know we do all sorts of things to matter. Some people do very
bad things in order to matter. Some of the people I've spoken to, they want power over others. They
want dominance. They want to make other people's life miserable, you know. These are bad things,
right? They cause an increase in entropy. This is how I judge people. Are you increasing entropy
or are you decreasing it? Well, one of my favorite lines in a book that caused me to laugh out loud
while I was playing golf with one of my kids and listening to the audiobook, which everyone should
get all versions of it. At one point you say, and I'm like about to hit, you know, my 16th shot on
the whole, and you say that we burn 320 calories per day just by thinking. So, if this book is
you to step up your thinking, even only to disagree, then you're burning extra calories. So,
Brian, you're welcome. And so, I read the book twice, Rebecca, so I could have that extra croissant.
But it raises a real question. If people or situations are anti-entropic, you just said,
like you judge people. I'm going to ask you a very provocative question, which is, can people
who don't have children, and children could mean biological, but it could also mean ideological
children. It could mean mentees. It could mean protégés. It could mean people that you sponsor,
your big brother, big sister. Do they matter less? I know it's provocative, but can we say
something about that? Any mattering project that depends on making others feel like they matter
less is wrong. I think I have a good proof. I didn't put it in this book because my editors,
they wanted the book to sell. There couldn't be too much philosophy. But I think a very good proof
for why we all morally matter, and I think I've actually even broached it here. There's something
ennobling about wanting to matter and devoting so much of our energy to these mattering projects.
We devote so much. It's hard enough to live, right? But no, we devote so much of our energy
to these mattering projects. Writing books, studying, bringing up our children, fighting
for justice, so many different ways. What are the bad ways? Well, anything that depends on making
others feel like they matter less, either those in your life or ideologically or whatever.
But I would also say that some mattering projects can be bad because they're not actually working
for you. I mean, sometimes as a professor, you know, you have students and they want to study
a certain thing and you don't know really why they want to study it. They don't love it,
they're not doing well in it, but somehow their mattering seems to depend on this.
It's kind of a responsibility to say, look, you're very smart, you have many talents.
I don't think this is the best use of your talent. So, to answer your question,
here's what I would say, because I want to be extremely pluralistic and I know people who I
think live wonderful lives who don't have people that they're particularly caring for in their
lives. They're just not caretakers. And I'm going to go back to Hillel the Elder, the great rabbinic
sage of the first century. He said, you know, if I'm not for myself, then who will be for me?
We can translate that into entropic language. I have to be for myself. I have to be constantly
fighting entropy and trying just to survive and to thrive. And because of that, you know,
I pay a lot of attention to myself. It's not that we're self-centered, but we have to feel
ourselves deserving of our own attention. I mean, our whole planning, our whole sense of
engagement with life demands this. And so, of course, I have to be for myself,
but if I'm only for myself, then what am I? So, the way I would translate that is,
if your mannering project is only working for you, and it is not helping in any way
to enforce the counterentropic process, which is life and flourishing, then you're selfish,
you know? You're selfish. But that there are so many ways of doing that, you know? I mean,
even, you know, plant a garden in a park, you know, so others can enjoy it. There's so many
ways that you can, in some way, be a force or save the animals, you know? They're suffering too,
right? This book, we have to do what you're not supposed to do, which is judge a book by its
cover. Take us through the book, the title, the subtitle, and this map of meaning or this
braided thread, it says it in Mercurial, I love the title, the cover, and the subtitle.
So, take us through it, Rebecca, please.
Yeah, the mannering instinct, the subtitle, how our deepest longing drives us and divides us.
And this divides us was very, very important to me, and that was sort of,
after germinating these ideas for decades, what finally got me to write is what seems to be a
mattering that we're going through and that is, you know, so dividing us to the point that it's
hard to have a civil union. I did want to offer this book as a way of perhaps being able to see
the deep humanity in all of us and where we diverge. A lot of the divergence is in good faith,
you know, to be able to see each other as generously as possible. That was really the
motivation because frankly, you know, I'm trained in analytic philosophy, analytic philosophers
like very little problems. Puzzles, we like puzzles. Puzzles and language are the best,
right? I'm suspicious of big theories, but somehow this theory kept growing in my mind from physics
to biology to psychology to philosophy to ethics, you know, and I was suspicious, I would say maybe
afraid even to put it out as like who the hell am I to put forth a broad theory. But I think it was
really the sense of it helps me when I get very angry when I'm reading the newspaper and it's
like what's wrong with my species? It helps me to go through the ideas that I work out here and to
just to grow the generosity toward one another. So, it's in that spirit. And that's how I understand
this braid. We're together, we're together, we're so together, we are all, you know, the whole
scientific story of how we come to have this longing to matter and to justify ourselves,
it's a common story, we share it. But then the way we appease this longing to matter,
this mattering instinct, find a way of living with this self-justificatory longing that requires us
to have values, which is a leap. The values don't follow from all of this. If there's free will
anywhere, it's here where we branch off and we become undivided and go off in our, that's what I
understood by this. I had turned down a whole bunch of covers because it's a very abstract
idea and a lot of the covers they gave me looked like introduction to differential geometry. It
just looked like a math book. Fear that a lot of people have nowadays is about artificial
intelligence, kind of replacing, you know, what we do that we have a sense of mattering from,
what we derive our matter, you know, and you quote Freud in the book, Freud said, you know,
all of life is work and love, and if AI can replace the work of knowledge workers like you and me,
and it can replace the love because of things like character AI and all these artificial
relationships that, you know, don't require me to go out and ask a woman on a date or, you know,
nowadays for men. So I want to ask you the question, can AI have a mattering instinct,
or is it encoded in this wet supercomputer that we carry on our shoulders? You know,
is it possible, you're right that AI is making everyone feel that redundancy is threatening to
us, but will the AI rob ourselves of our mattering? You know, two different questions there, you know,
one which is really, I think, you know, gonna be upon us, maybe already is, you know, that some of
the most creative ways of appeasing our mattering instinct will be superseded by what AI can do,
prove math theorems faster, make discoveries in science, write novels, write music, paint pictures
that have led to flourishing and led to great achievements that we can all take pride in.
I take great pride in our species producing, you know, Bach and Shakespeare and Michael Jordan,
I'm a big basketball fan. Here's one thing I would say, you know, heroic strivers,
what I call heroic strivers, it's really gonna threaten them. I don't think that the socializers
are going to look to, I mean, to some extent, maybe for romantic partners, but mothers are
not going to have little babies, AI agents that are acting like their babies. I don't think that
this is going to happen, but I think heroic strivers, what I call heroic strivers, are going
to be severely threatened. One of the ways to be a heroic striver is ethically, and that will still
remain to us. AI will not be able to do that. They could write our novels or our poetry or our music
or prove our math theorems, but they're not going to be able to do that for us. And so,
wouldn't that be a wonderful turn of events if somehow there was a change, an incredible ethical
change, and that's how we got our status, you know, from how much good we're actually
doing in the world, how much counter-entropic good we're doing in the world. You know,
this is a big thing that's upon us, is all I can say. I can't think of anything else,
not the Industrial Revolution, not the Enlightenment, nothing that has the possibility
of so changing what we are and what we see our lives as being about.
Even the very name of our species, you know, homo habilis meant, you know, tool maker or handyman.
Yeah.
Homo sapien means man who knows, right?
Exactly, exactly.
We're not the only things that know.
And your other question, if, you know, God forbid, if these agents begin to have a longing
to matter, want to justify their own, you know, it would take self-reflection, you know, of the
sort that we have, you know, being able to step outside themselves and say, oh my God, I pay so
much attention to myself. Am I worth it? Do I deserve this? If they do this, then what we have
are non-carbon based humans. These will be humans, and that means we're going to have to
think about their rights. We're going to have a whole different way of having to think about
epics because we will have created, and we've always been creating humans, but we will have
created humans in a new way. You know, philosophers have been at it for over 2,000 years since the
ancient Greeks. This is the moment for philosophers because these are philosophical problems.
So, show us what you've got, philosophers, right? You've been thinking about this for 2,000 years.
Show us what you've got.
Nathan Rebecca, this has been such a wonderful
conversation. This book is incredible. It reminds me of a famous quote by John Archibald Wheeler,
the man who coined the term black holes. He said matter-
Rebecca I had him at Princeton.
Nathan You did? Oh, you're so lucky. Your career
is legendary. I mean, I just love your writing and your books. But Wheeler said, maybe you heard
him say it. Maybe not. He said matter tells space-time how to curve, and space-time tells
matter how to move. And this book, The Mattery Instinct, was one of the most moving books to me.
And hopefully, we'll have many more. You'll write many more books, or we'll talk about your
other books, too, that have been so important to me and my colleagues and the intellectual circle
that I move in. But the movement of this book, it was surprising to me just how deep it is,
how accurate it is, and how precise it is. It's a wonderful book. It's one of Apple's
most anticipated books of the year. It's got hundreds of incredible reviews already.
And I just thank you so much for sharing your time and just your ideas and your brain,
your giant brain with the Into the Impossible audience. Thank you so much, Rebecca.
Oh, thank you so much. I knew it was going to be fun.
And I'll do it again sometime.
Rebecca Neuberger Goldstein just used the second law of thermodynamics to explain depression,
meaning, and why AI might create new species.
If that changes how you think about what matters, hit subscribe and turn on notifications.
Drop a comment. Which of the four types of person are you?
And if you want to go deeper on entropy and explore a provocative new theory
that perhaps there is a new arrow of time, click here and watch my interview with Michael Wong.
You won't be disappointed, and your life may just keep it together a bit longer.
Go ahead, click it now.