Mike bought a Ford Explorer that was priced way too high, and the dealer didn't disclose the laundry list of problems it had. Later, in a surprise twist, the car dealer surrendered the title TO THE CUSTOMER WITHOUT TRANSFERING IT FIRST. Kevin Hunter The Homework Guy is joined by one our his clients who used our Legal Violation Checkup – THG Edition $179.99 https://thehomeworkguy.com/product/legal-violation-checkup-thg-edition/
Dive into this car dealer scam and see how Kevin Hunter The Homework Guy helps the average guy get a better deal and DEFEATED the dealer who break the law!
Hello everyone, Kevin Hunter here, the Homework Guy.
I have a special guest in studio with me today.
Somebody who's actually from our hometown here in Williston
and out of the 16 years that I've been doing this, Mike,
working with car buyers all around the country,
this is the first time I've seen a deal like yours.
And Mike nicely brought along a whole folder full
of information that we had in communications
back and forth with this dealership.
So, get started a little bit explaining
what went through your process of making a connection
with this dealer and purchasing this vehicle.
Well, back in early April, my son was helping me
kind of look for a SUV and he spotted it on Marketplace
and talked with the dealership and put me in connection
with the dealership and on my way back from Nebraska
on vacation in April, I stopped at the dealership
in South Dakota and looked at it.
And...
Decided to pull the trigger on it.
Yeah, I did.
Yeah, a lot of people get their car buying journey
started by somebody else, in Mike's case,
his son who found a vehicle and that sort of thing.
So one of the first things that I noticed about this vehicle
is that the dealer sold it to you for $30,000?
Correct.
And Liz and I booked it out here with Black Book
and we were appalled when we saw the actual book value
of the vehicle, 19,500.
Overspent 10,500 bucks on the vehicle.
So when you first contacted me, you started talking
about all the various problems this car was having.
What kind of issues did you experience?
You couldn't even get home without putting a new set
of tires on this vehicle, right?
No, that's correct.
Yeah, I had to put a whole new set on.
And what exactly was the problem with the tires?
Were they like the metal cord showing through?
Yeah, the rear tires, the cords were showing through
and on an all-wheel drive, you have to change all four.
You can't just do the rear two.
You need a whole set of tires when you need new tires.
Yeah, so the dealer had this vehicle sitting on their lot
with the metal cords showing out of the tires.
And then you get home and you discover
that there's all kinds of rust
on the frame of the vehicle underneath.
Yep, that is correct.
And a number of other issues.
So part of the reason that you miss these details
when you first looked at the vehicle
is your eyesight isn't super great.
Correct, yeah, and plus it had stormed the night before
and that particular morning when I was looking
at the vehicle, it was sunny and bright
and the vehicle was dirty.
So I did not pick up on any of that.
I did not pick up on the tires.
Yeah, well, some people wouldn't
and because they're kind of hidden inside the wheel well
a little bit, you know, and in the shadow
in a bright sunny day, you know,
it could definitely be missed.
So you drove the vehicle home
and then you also discovered some other problems
with the wheel bearings are bad in the back of the vehicle.
Correct, yeah, the wheel bearings are rusted.
So they're failing.
And then the air conditioner line had been cut and plugged.
So there was no air conditioning to the rear of the vehicle
and the exhaust system was rusting out, starting to leak.
You could see all the moisture around.
Yeah, once it was up on the lift.
So Mike shared all these details with me
of all the things that were wrong with this car.
And all of a sudden the silver bullet jumped out at me
after we started talking about the deal.
And you mentioned to me that the dealer had mailed you
the title signed on the back side.
In 16 years, Mike, that's the first time I've ever seen that
never ever seen a dealer not transfer a title
and just send it to you and say, that was your job.
Well, this vehicle was purchased
in the state of South Dakota
and South Dakota codified law makes it really clear
that dealership has responsibility
of transferring the title within 45 days
or the customer can rescind the car deal.
So if you remember in the beginning,
I said Mike paid more than $10,000 too much
for this vehicle.
And so obviously if you could rescind it,
that's exactly what you wanted to do.
Correct.
Yeah, so I have a letter here
and we'll block out the personal information
but we'll show it on the back screen here.
We had a letter that we wrote for Mike to this dealership
and made all kinds of specific demands in there
including payment for a lot of expenses,
expenses of the tires, stuff like that.
And then quoted the various law that was violated
by this transaction by this dealer.
And you had kind of a funny experience with,
so a title clerk called you at some point
and told you it was your job to transfer the title, right?
Correct.
Yeah, I wanted to know why I hadn't done it yet.
Plus prior to that,
when they were getting ready to send it,
I took a picture of the DMV business card here in town
so that they could send it directly there.
They chose not to and they sent it to me
which I'm glad they did that.
Yes, yes, so here dealers in violation
of South Dakota state law
and Mike's holding onto the title.
And when I first discovered that he had the title
in his hand, I was like, you keep that sucker
because as of right now,
you're the one who controls the timeframe.
So we waited until 45 days exactly
so that the dealer was clearly out of compliance
with the state law and then sent them this letter
and informed the dealer that Mike was going to rescind
the car deal.
And the cool thing about this deal, Mike,
was that from beginning to end, with our help of course,
in writing these letters for you to this dealership,
you were in control of what the outcome of this deal
and getting it rescinded.
You were in control of that the entire process.
Yes, and they just said, well, you signed the paperwork,
it's yours and they weren't willing to do nothing
except for assist with the tires.
Yeah, so the dealer did everything they could
to squirm out of this.
Initially until they got the letter
and then when the letter clearly spelled out the law
and their violation of the law,
I think the dealer had a clue at that point.
Somebody else was involved in Mike's corner
and that was us.
Part of the reason I want to share this story
with people in our viewing audience
is that when a dealer violates,
whether a state law or federal law
in the course of your car deal,
and especially if it's a bad car deal
and you want to get out of it,
we have Mike besides yours.
We've had three other car deals
that we have helped customers get rescinded.
And in every time, court wasn't involved
and we didn't have to get a dealer involved.
And I guess it kind of helps, you know,
that I have this big announcer kind of voice.
But when I had conversation
with one of these dealers directly,
it was really, really clear
that he was totally intimidated by the conversation.
And after the customer left the dealership,
he calls me up and goes, Kevin, you the man.
He goes, you had them shaking in their boots.
And I think Mike was some of these letters
that you sent off to this dealership.
Part of the reason that they complied,
they actually sent a transport up
to come get the vehicle from you.
Yes.
And then they didn't send Mike a copy of the check
before they claimed they were gonna pay this off
with the dealership, or with the credit union rather.
He had reason to suspect that maybe
they weren't following through and doing their part.
But you did have a phone conversation
with the credit union out of Colorado
and found out that the car was, in fact, paid off.
Correct.
So the dealer paid off your car loan,
the bloated car loan,
and then because you had traded in a vehicle at the time,
and they had bid this vehicle at $8,000,
which I shared with you was more money
than the car was actually worth,
but they wrote Mike a check for eight grand
or just over eight grand and settled the deal.
Yep.
So what are some of your takeaways here, Mike,
that you'd like to share with our viewing audience?
Well, I guess the biggest learning lesson for me
is I need to do a better inspection,
and if I can't see it,
I need to ask somebody else to look at it.
And that's, I guess, where I failed
because I put my trust to the salesman
thinking that he would do right by me,
and I guess, you know, I know now that that's not the case.
Yes.
All right, so you have gotten a full refund of your vehicle.
It's paid off at the bank, and you got $8,000.
So that was most of what you had put into this vehicle.
And then the other thing that happened
after the dealership paid off that credit union,
you had mailed them a second car payment,
and the credit union,
have they returned that payment as of now?
Yes, I just received that today, so.
Awesome, awesome.
So you got his car payment back, too, so beautiful.
Well, there was a happy ending in this story,
but it easily could have been very bad.
It was a good thing that the dealer slipped up
and violated a significant South Dakota state law,
and that state law was the undoing of this car deal.
And in any car deal that you guys have out there
in our viewing audience,
potentially there's a state law or a federal law
that the dealer violated
in the course of doing business with you two,
and those things can definitely rescind a car deal.
We've done four out of four car deals just like that
in the recent month.
Mike, first of all, thank you very much
for joining us here on the broadcast
and kind of sharing a little bit of your car story.
And it was a pleasure to work with you
through this whole process.
Thank you for your assistance.
It was a pleasure to work with you also.
Awesome.
All right, everyone, Kevin Hunter here, the Homework Guy,
signing off on behalf of our auto expert, Alex Stevens,
and the amazing Elizabeth,
who joins me regularly here on the show.
But being that Mike was sitting in with me here today,
she stepped out and Mike stepped in,
so that's how that kind of happened.
All right, everybody, until next time,
take care, you guys rock.
Thanks for watching.