Using a CARFAX report effectively can help you uncover used cars and vehicle history, ensuring you make an informed decision when buying a used car. Hi, I'm Kevin Hunter, known online for the last 15 years as The Homework Guy. Our Auto expert Alex Stephens is back today to discuss a very important topic for all of you used car buyers out there. How to effectively use a Carfax report from the viewpoint of an Automotive Expert! Here's a step-by-step guide on how to review and interpret a CARFAX report before buying a used car.
1. Verify the Vehicle Information Match the Details: Ensure the VIN (Vehicle Identification Number), make, model, year, and trim level on the CARFAX report match the car you’re considering. Check for Discrepancies: If details like the odometer reading or year don’t align, it’s a red flag and worth investigating further. 2. Look for Title Issues Clean Title Status: Confirm the vehicle has a clean title, meaning it hasn’t been reported as salvage, rebuilt, or junked. Warning Signs: If the car has been branded as flood-damaged, totaled, or has a lien on it, proceed with caution or walk away. 3. Review the Ownership History Number of Owners: Fewer owners can indicate consistent care, but multiple owners over a short period could signal issues. Geographic Location: Vehicles from regions prone to flooding, snow, or salt use (like coastal or snowy areas) may have hidden damage or corrosion. Personal vs. Fleet/Commercial Use: A personal vehicle is often better maintained than a fleet or rental car, which might have higher wear and tear. 4. Analyze the Mileage Odometer Consistency: Check that the mileage increases logically over time. Any sudden drops or resets may indicate odometer tampering. High vs. Low Mileage: Compare the mileage to the car's age. High mileage isn’t always bad, but it could mean more wear. Extremely low mileage could also indicate the car was underused, which might lead to mechanical issues. 5. Look for Accident History Accident Reports: Review any reported accidents. Pay attention to the severity, location of the damage, and whether it was repaired. Multiple Accidents: A car with repeated accidents might not be worth the risk, even if repairs were made. 6. Check Service and Maintenance Records Regular Maintenance: Look for consistent oil changes, tire rotations, and inspections. A well-maintained car is less likely to have future problems. Gaps in Maintenance: Long periods without service could indicate neglect. Major Repairs. 7. Inspect for Recalls Unresolved Recalls: Check if the vehicle has any open recalls. This can affect safety and may require immediate attention. Resolution of Recalls: Ensure previous recalls were addressed by the manufacturer or dealer. 8. Look for Flood or Structural Damage Flood Damage: Watch for mentions of water or flood damage, as these can lead to long-term electrical or structural issues. Structural Repairs. 9. Confirm Emissions and Inspection Status State Inspections: Ensure the vehicle has passed emissions or safety inspections required in its previous state(s). Recurrent Failures: Repeated inspection failures might indicate mechanical or emissions issues. 10. Check for Use as a Rental or Taxi Usage Type: If the car was used as a rental, taxi, or fleet vehicle, it may have been driven hard, even if it appears clean. 11. Review Additional Disclosures Lemon Law Buyback: Look for mentions of “Lemon Law Buyback,” which means the car was returned to the manufacturer for unresolved defects. Insurance Loss Records: Verify whether the car was written off by an insurance company. 12. Compare with an Independent Inspection CARFAX Isn’t Everything: Not all accidents or issues are reported to CARFAX. Always combine the report with a physical inspection by a trusted mechanic. Verify Claims: If the CARFAX shows major repairs, confirm them by examining the vehicle or asking the seller for supporting documentation. Request the CARFAX early in the buying process to save time and avoid surprises. Use It as Leverage.
using a Carfax report effectively can
help you uncover a vehicle's history
ensuring you make an informed decision
when buying a used car hi I'm Kevin
Hunter known online for the last 15
years as the homework guy our Auto
expert Alex Stevens is back today to
discuss a very important topic for all
of you used car buyers out there how to
effectively use a Carfax report from the
Viewpoint of an automotive expert all
right Alex let's go through a
step-by-step guide on how to review and
interpret a Carfax report where do we
say
yeah you know the first thing you would
definitely want to look at Mr Kevin is
um does the VIN number match the vehicle
that you're purchasing make model you
know uh year Etc does all those things
actually uh are those accurate on the on
the
Carfax um and then the next thing is uh
I always like to check you know hey is
the odometer correct you know um you
know if it says it has 50,000 mies but
then you get in the truck and it has
60,000 Mi or the vehicle right so that's
another or if it's the other way around
it's posted as having 30,000 miles in a
Carfax shows that has 50,000 miles
correct right those are some questions
to ask you know and um I would always
say too if you ask for a Carfax or you
know something like this right and
there's a hesitancy to give it to you or
like a delay or like oh it'll take me a
little bit to get that for you right
that's a red flag M okay that for me
okay cuz it should just be part of it
you know it should be either on the
website or talking to dealer she to
produce it for you fairly uh easily and
you can look it up yourself there's a
fee for that but um and I've seen
private sellers that you hey uh I went
ahead and bought the Carfax for the
vehicle for you I'm want to sell it so
if the you know you can see the history
right I didn't own it since it was new
maybe I thought it used right but it
should be something you should have
pretty quickly I always tell people if
the dealer willingly surrenders the
Carfax and very willingly allows you to
get a pre- purchase inspection down in
the vehicle that's probably going to
come out good on both ends because they
got nothing to hide oh yeah 100% so um
yeah and then obviously you want to as
you're reading through the Carfax you
know the CARFAX is not going to be like
your golden ticket to Wily Wonka show
it'll be like a a crumb or a little bit
of a lead to something right so hey was
this car ever wrecked did they mention
that no actually this car has got a good
you know it's a good clean car oh is
that she was wrecked so it's not a good
clean car May has a history right those
are some things you know was this car
ever in a flood you know has it had you
know been total right been repaired you
know was it a salvage title at one point
they're showing a good title but now it
has a salvage title Etc right and for
our viewing audience you have to be
aware that vehicles that are titled in
given States like let's say a vehicle
was owned in the State of Florida and
then interestingly enough it got titled
in the state of Texas that's a red flag
to me because Texas allows scrubbing of
the title believe it or not so those are
things you want to obviously look at you
know hey is if I walk around this
vehicle it's saying it was a perfectly
clean car it looked clean but then the
title tells me it has a wreck on it and
they'll it'll grade you know is it a
actually will say uh minor moderate
severe heavy you know it'll have a great
deployment yeah it'll show you how
serious like if it's had like a basic
little hey they bumped a a garage door
and they put a little dent on the fender
okay you know it had to have a new
Fender replace and paint so that might
be a moderate or a minor or a little
scuff on the bumper it went in and got
repaired right and what about ownership
history for sure uh I actually just
purchased a new vehicle um and uh at
first I didn't want to buy a brand new I
was looking for used and I was kind of
very particular and I was actually
talking to you about this I was looking
through the car fats at this particular
vehicle I wanted to purchase and it had
8,300 mil on it and it had had three
owners in 8,000 miles in 8,000 miles and
I'm like wow that's a that's a red flag
for me mhm where are these owners so I'm
L and actually looked I looked at it
when it left the factory it went to the
first dealership and then I saw that it
was purchased and then it was like tra
in like a month and a half later and
then oh what's this again oh it was
actually another dealership that
purchased it and I'm like okay you know
I'm looking through and then I lo and
behold as I went down further I could
see the maintenance records and I can
start to see the truck had been in for a
couple recalls it actually had some
parts replaced you know it showed what
was replaced and serviced and then I was
able to say oh these owners based off
the number of owners this truck might be
a Limon this truck might be a poor you
know not a very good specimen of vehicle
um and but I could see that by the
number of owners because I could track
based off the mileage and so forth and
rate and obviously hey if you're looking
at a car that has 100,000 miles and it's
had six owners okay that's not terrible
I mean it's not great I mean that that
might be a bit of a concern right but if
you look at a car say has 100,000 miles
on it and it's had two owners then
that's a little bit nicer like oh hey
it's been owned 50,000 Mi by this guy
and say 50,000 Mi for this other guy and
you maybe have good maintenance you're
like hey this has been a good solid car
it's not had a ton of issues um and I
think too with the ownership you want to
look if there's a massive Gap in
maintenance or Gap let's say owner had
it for 4 years and there's no
maintenance that means maybe this car
wasn't maintained at a ASC Certified
shop or maybe it wasn't maintained at a
dealership right let's say it's pass
that 36,000 miles so like you know the
bumper bumper coverage is gone and maybe
they opted to start take it to their
local guy they've always taken it to and
they do their own oil changes that
doesn't scare me it's just that should
prompt some more questions so besides
number of owners there's also where the
car was owned 100% some states will use
a ton of salt and stuff like that on the
road you can have a lot of corrosion and
stuff like that that can be happening to
a vehicle because it's in a salt zone so
to speak yeah that's a that's a great
thing to point too is if I'm looking at
it from a ownership and maintenance like
I my brain immediately goes to hey I
like this vehicle let me see the
maintenance on that Carfax I want to
know but if that vehicle spent its first
say 10 15 20,000 miles in a salt belt
state right and then now it's down south
yeah I'm probably going to pass my
vehicle because yes it may not be a ton
of salt life but it's a significant
amount and you may have earlier problems
because it was exposed to higher
corrosion right so that's a great thing
to note like pay attention to that you
know if it was snowy salty area out near
the coast a lot of sand like those are
all things that take in consideration so
then uh Beyond like where it was owned
who actually owned it so talking about
either Fleet or commercial use right
because if the vehicle is owned by a
private person likely that it's seen
pretty decent uh maintenance or more
likely if it was a fleet vehicle that
might not be the case for sure so like
uh let's talk about rental cars right uh
I've seen like a lot of rental cars I'm
sure a lot of our viewers have rented
cars
um I know people who when they get in
the rental car it's like the gloves
comes comes off they're like this ain't
my car and I'm going to I'm going to
drive it like I stole it or whatever so
like um but rental fleets you know
rental car manufacturers do they do have
a maintenance schedule they have a
pretty strict one so they make sure gets
in for oil changes and services right so
that vehicle has maybe potentially been
driven really really hard really really
pushed you know on its level of care but
it's been maintained but if I see rental
you know not always not not every single
car not every single time but if I
usually see a rental Fleet or a fleet
vehicle on the Carfax I'm like this
vehicle's definitely had a higher rate
of wear or potential you know lack of
Maintenance or or a higher rate of uh of
uh harsh abuse right sure so something
to note there that's a great Point Kevin
I mean think interesting thing about uh
rental cars you and I were talking about
Scott Madden earlier and I know Scott
well I know he wouldn't have any problem
with us using his name here on this show
might even actually like the shout out
for a matter of fact but good job Scott
anyway uh Scott has been renting
vehicles from Enterprise a local car
rental place near him while he's waiting
for us to find a car and we ended up
finding him a vehicle that another buyer
one of our hassle-free car buying
clients wanted to trade in and instead
of trading it into a dealer he's getting
better value out of it by selling it to
Scott Scott's getting a buy by buying
that vehicle but Scott told me I'm
getting Enterprise rather calling me
nonstop wanting me to buy a car from
them and he goes Kevin I'm on my fourth
rental car from these guys yeah cuz
every car I rent from them breaks down
or has some kind of mechanical problem I
was just like you know every
organization around the country can run
through some financial hardship and the
unfortunate truth is is that if you're
own a rental car company and you run out
of money what stops the maintenance
right I like so you got all these broken
down cars and they want you to buy their
vehicle no dice 100% also say you know
we talked about a rental side of of of
uh Fleet or commercial the next thing
will actually to be you know businesses
right so like if you're you know a
construction company right and you
decide to go through the fleet or the
rental car model and you know rent your
vehicles into a fleet you know think
about some of those trucks or vehicles
that are used on a commercial basis not
necessar rental car but commercial use
from a fleet those trucks could just be
really abused or those Vehicles Not Just
Trucks but those cars could be really
abused so a lot of people are worried
about mileage on vehicles how many miles
are actually on the car uh high mileage
isn't necessarily a bad thing because it
could simply mean the vehicle is used a
lot on the highway or whatever the case
is um but what most people don't know is
extremely low mileage for a given
vehicle could also present some possible
mechanical issues couldn't it yes sir
100% you know uh I think oh lower the
mileage uh it's been less driven less
but less used you know one thing I would
say with that is hey uh oil has a life
mhm both from a mileage standpoint and a
Time standpoint before the molecular
structure starts to break down and the
additives and everything start to
separate it settles in the bottom of the
pan right so just because the car hasn't
been going down the road doesn't mean
the oil is still good 100% yeah and it
needs to be served but that goes to your
your tires it goes to the transmission
fluid the brake fluid the tire steing
fluid right um you know tire rubber has
has a life the belts have a life you
know there's the cooling system has a
life not just from a mileage standpoint
but also from a Time standpoint um and
if obviously if you know you have
moisture so if let's say you're in a
cold environment it's a not a not a
heated garage that truck that vehicle
that car gets a lot of temperature in it
cold temperatures or hot temperatures
that affects that engine and if it's not
regularly being lubricated or or cooking
off some of that condensation you can
develop issues so that is something to
note pay attention to that like just
because it's low mileage you still want
to have it inspected you still want to
treat it as if it was you know a high
mileage car to some degree you know low
mileage a couple years old still take
can have the fluid service go and have
it you know inspected and looked at so
another thing you can find on the CARFAX
is any accident history and we're
talking about this a little bit earlier
that there are severity of accidents and
also I would say the number of accidents
so the vehicle has says you know minor
accident four times you're like holy cow
what's been going on with this vehicle
that it's been in that many potential
fender benders even if it's something
mild you know how many times do this
vehicle hit a grocery cart or you know
bump somebody you know who's in a
rightand turn lane or whatever but uh
yeah so accident history the severity of
the accident and the number of accidents
100% yep and I would say too um looking
at the state we talked about this
earlier like where in what region of the
United States is that vehicle in it
let's say if it is a salt belt car and
it's had a number of accidents like
you're going to you know the metal from
the corrosion is going to start to break
down the gaps will start to open up you
know there's a lot more variables to
that too not just hey it's had a lot of
accidents but where were these accidents
what states were these in in what region
yeah it's been bent and crunched enough
times that it's probably having some
metal break down yep 100% yeah so I know
one of the things that you love to look
at a Carfax for is the good old service
records and maintenance records on the
vehicle yeah I like to ask a lot of
questions I spent time you know how
often was oil change
you know what were the tire rotations
when it went into the dealer is it on a
maintenance plan with that dealer right
some dealers now are offering that we're
like hey buy from us we're going to give
you the next two years free oil changes
and whatever right so those are things I
love to love to look at um and then
depending on some dealers and where it
was serviced at they'll tell you hey
this had the BCM replaced at 14,000 Mi
right you know you can start to see if
it's had some issues it'll tell you if
it's had recall work done that's another
thing to look at so um I love to dig
into that I look for gaps in it like we
talked about I look for um how
frequently it was serviced right and
then you know we talked about German
cars way way early in our time um
European they have a service interval a
service B service and that's based off
of mileage usually and hey has it had
its you know 60,000 M service done and
then if you look at um I had a friend
last year looking to buyer Mercedes he
used Mercedes I believe it was like a 18
or 19 and he say hey would you mind
looking at the car fats for me seems to
me the car fact I'm looking through it
I'm like oh yep it's had low mileage as
you just described it was in Florida it
was a you know a snowbird car where they
only came down so much a year it set in
the garage a lot and he's like it's
super low mileage but it's had like you
know it's already had like it's 50,000 M
service 60,000 M service and I said oh I
know why because the car sits and I was
able to look and tell him oh yeah it's
already had the tires the belts it's had
all this lubricated I said I would have
no reservation about buying that car cuz
it's already been looked at as if it is
a long-term car right so yeah those are
things to look at and if you see major
repairs on that that should be a I don't
think it should be a red flag it should
be a caution I should now ask more
questions all right let's talk a little
bit about recalls because whether it's
new or used but anytime you're looking
to buy a vehicle out there you should
always look up to see if there's any
history of recalls and if there's
recalls that are unresolved on a US
vehicle that you're looking for yeah
100% yeah recalls are a big one
especially if you're buying it from a
private seller I would actually like to
point out that is that private seller if
it's a newer car look at the recall even
say a few 10 year old car you still want
to look at the recalls and uh and then
get a hold of your dealer you know there
are some shops that can perform the
recall work there's very few but there
are a few non dealer shops but get a
hold of that dealer and say hey I have
this vehicle I want to do a recall is
this is the mileage are you guys still
accepting this recall at this mileage
right or can you here's the VIN number
can you tell me if this vehicle has had
its recall work they can look through
the database and like much you know um
so that's a huge thing and then the
Carfax should tell you hey yep came in
for recall work this is what recall was
or Google the current recalls for that
vehicle and then ask a buyer hey have
you had these work done yet all right
well with all the Hurricanes we had in
Florida something everybody has to be
aware of with used car always is the
potential for flood and water damage all
right uh let's talk about structural
repairs yeah if you see something on a
Carfax like said we talked about major
Collision right they may not always tell
you yeah frame rail cut out and bent and
replaced or whatever but if you see the
word major major Collision or you know a
large uh higher Collision you very well
could have structural airbag deployment
yep stuff like that you if you're going
to purchase that car if you like hey I'm
I want to get this I recommend taking it
to a reptical body shop or Automotive
you know repair shop and have it
inspected MH hey is the fame rail bent
is this vehicle safe to drive right just
because it was fixed that doesn't mean
it was fixed correctly I cannot tell you
these are many personal stories of some
good friends that have found a really
good deal on a car and purchased a car
drove it home it drove weird really
weird asked me to come over and look at
it looked at the car facts with them and
like hey man this had a major repair
they told me it was fixed and more than
just airbag deployment I'm talking about
major frame damage horrible stuff so
just because it was fixed it doesn't
mean it was fixed right right you want
to spend some time researching so so we
were just helping a car buyer out of the
city of
Chicago uh who is looking at a
Lamborghini great car very high-end
vehicle and uh we scheduled lemon Squad
out to look at it and lemon Squad sends
us back report and says the hood and the
driver side fender panels don't line up
and then they use they don't they
couldn't put the vehicle on a hoist but
they have a scope to put underneath the
vehicle and they inspected the frame and
this says it's also got some frame
repairs done to it oh yeah might want to
pass on this vehicle cuz you don't know
to what extent damage has been done to
the vehicle very common and it had a it
had a fairly attractive price but I
think that had a lot to do with the
Damage Done to the vehicle yeah really
really common right now is that stuff
buying wrecked cars from Copart or
places like that and fixing them and
selling them you know doing the basics
to get a car roadworthy inspect have a
pre- purchase inspection done have the
vehicle left over if it's used and I
would say that you know a lot of people
ask me this question that how do you
know your dealing with a trusted
mechanic when you bring it to a shop
that's out of state out of town and you
don't have a relationship with them let
me just share with you uh some of my
learning experiences cuz we've had to
help people do this several times over
the years and sometimes it doesn't work
out to get lemon squad or Pal car out to
look at the vehicle we just went through
this with a vehicle over in the state of
California and I looked up the
gentleman's address where he lived found
a shop nearby him called the shop talked
to them about a pre- purchase inspection
they said oh yeah we do these they goes
but you're going to need to drop the car
off cuz we're going to need it for about
2 and 1 half hours I was like that is
enough time to really thoroughly look
this car over 100% so I mean if the guy
says you know 15 minutes we're done not
not such a great deal but no I could
tell by his uh explanation and then the
fact that they get the vehicle up on a
hoist and you know inspect the frame and
you know they sent back a really nice
report on that vehicle too so well done
but people have to be aware of the fact
that the Carfax isn't the car Bible that
there going to be plenty of things that
don't show up on a Carfax report that
only an inspection is going to help
uncover
100% so you've done plenty of vehicle
inspections yourself what kind of
vehicle inspection are you most
comfortable with what what does that
basically look like yeah for me you know
I like this I personally like to start
the car up um you know listen for noises
listen for sounds I like a full-fledged
vehicle put it on a lift if you don't
have a lift put it on jack stands lift
the car up look at the bottom you know
take it for a road test check the fluids
you know do it use a use a a a quality
scan scan tool and actually look at this
look at the codes see if there's any we
were talking about this earlier before
the show is um are there any permanent
codes inside this right those are all
things um you know look at the um the
chassis the suspension you want to check
the bushing there's I like a
full-fledged deep inspection the 2 and
1/ half hour one is about ride on par
when I was doing you know pre-
purchasing inspections or you know
vehicle inspections stuff like that it
would take us 2 and a half maybe three
depending on what it is it could be even
4 hours right if it's a luxury car like
when we're doing Mercedes and BMWs
Volkswagen those cars are a little bit
more involved there's a lot more
potential you know higher cost repairs
so those are a little bit more involved
sometimes Lamborghini for example would
be Ferrari I sure would all be higher
inspections so yeah I think the deeper
inspection is a lot better as always a
very informative show for those of you
in viewing audience uh some final tipss
here make sure you get the report
beforehand request the Carfax early in
the buying process to save time and
avoid surprises and as Alex pointed out
if the dealer hesitant to give you the
Carfax walk away yeah just just leave it
you can always use a Carfax as leverage
in your negotiation process use findings
like accidents uh high mileage or lack
of Maintenance to negotiate a lower
price or just walk away as I said
earlier you can always trust but verify
a car so a clean Carfax doesn't
guarantee that the car is Flawless
without any problems use it simply as a
guide not as a sole discretion maker if
you found this video to be helpful to
you remember to give us that great big
thumbs up and share it with your friends
and leave a comment down below I hope
you enjoyed this factual conversation
about a Carfax and how to properly use
it please let us know about your car
buying experiences we love hearing your
stories and great comments always help
the homework guide Community also if
you'd like help from one of our car
buying coaches when buying a car please
let us know at 71441 3399 to all of you
long-term subscribers out there you guys
rock God bless you all I'm Kevin Hunter
the homework guy signing off on behalf
of Alex Stevens The Amazing Elizabeth
and the entire hasslefree homework guide
team thanks for listening