Milton Friedman Speaks: Myths That Conceal Reality
It gives me the great pleasure to present to you today Professor Milton Friedman.
I want to talk today about the contrast between myths that are widely believed by the public
at large and what I regard as the reality which typically contradicts those myths.
As you are all aware, there has been a drastic shift in public attitudes and public opinions
in the past 50 years or so with respect to the role of the individual on the one hand
and the role of government and collective institutions on the other. There has been
a shift in the philosophy and attitudes of the public from a belief in individual responsibility,
from a belief in a society in which the role of government was as an umpire, to a belief
in a society in which the emphasis is on social responsibility and the role of government
as big brother and protector of the individual. As always when such shifts arise in public
opinion, they are largely produced and reinforced by the development of myths about prior experience.
Someone once wrote, and I'm not sure who it was, that a myth is like an air mattress.
There's nothing in it, but it's wonderfully comfortable, and deflation causes an uncomfortable
jolt. Well, my purpose today is to give you that jolt. When myths get established and
are adopted, they tend to be so strongly held, they tend to become so much a part of you,
that when anyone comes along and differs with them and contradicts them, he risks automatically
being dismissed as a crackpot. But I shall nonetheless take the risk of being dismissed
as a crackpot because it seems to me so urgent that we deflate these myths, recognize what
the reality is, in order to be able to provide a basis for a change in our philosophy, a
reversal of the direction of our thought. In my opinion, if we do not do so, if we continue
on the road we have been going, if we continue to rely more and more on government and less
and less on the individual, we are condemned to a future of tyranny and misery. And therefore,
it seems to me essential for the future of this country that we recognize these myths
for what they are and adjust our thinking to a correct perception of our present and
our past.
I am encouraged in this venture by another quotation, one which comes from a nineteenth
century American humorist by the name of Josh Billings, who wrote somewhere,
It ain't what people know that causes trouble, it's what they know that ain't so.
And that's what I'm going to devote this talk to, to trying to tell you about some
things you know that ain't so. I am going to try to cover five myths that are part of
your thinking, and if they are not part of your thinking they will tend to become so
after you take your first course in American history.
The first of those myths is a robber baron myth, the myth that somehow or other in the
nineteenth century there was an era of rugged, unrestrained individualism in which heartless
monopoly capitalists exploited the poor unmercifully and ground them beneath their heels.
The second myth I'm going to talk about is a Great Depression myth, the myth that the
Great Depression from 1929 until the late thirties was produced by a failure of private
enterprise.
The third myth I want to talk about is the demand for government service myth, the myth
that government has had to step in because of a failure of the private market and a great
widespread demand for government services.
The fourth myth I'm going to talk about was suggested by Mr. Eccles in his introduction.
It's a free lunch myth, the myth that there is such a thing as a free lunch.
And the final myth I want to talk about is the Robin Hood myth, the myth that somehow
or other government operates by taking money from the rich and giving it to the poor.
Let me start with the first of those myths, the robber baron myth, the myth that in the
nineteenth century was a period in which the rich became richer and the poor poorer, that
it was a century in which you had a conflict between Wall Street and the working man, that
it was a period in which particularly the farmers of the Middle West were being ground
beneath the rapacious activities of the Wall Street financiers, in which there was widespread
farm distress and misery.
Now this myth had its origins in the nineteenth century. It produced the widespread greenback
movement that you will learn about in your history books, a party which at one time reached
significant size, a party devoted to the idea that all of the problems of the time
could be solved if only the government would print enough of those nice pieces of paper
which are colored green on the back and which are called greenbacks.
It was a period that also gave rise to the free silver movement. To Williams Jennings
Bryan, the silver-tongued orator from North Platte, if I remember rightly, from these
areas, who gave his famous speech on the cross of gold in 1896 in Chicago at the Democratic
Convention in which he asked whether mankind shall be crucified on a cross of gold, a speech
which got him the presidential nomination of the Democratic Party, and he subsequently
was a nominee of the Democratic Party for several subsequent elections. Fortunately,
he never elected it.
That was a myth. What was the reality? The reality is that there is almost no period
in human history which saw as rapid and widespread an increase in the well-being of the ordinary
man as the nineteenth century. That was a period when millions of people from all over
the world streamed to these shores. They came here with empty hands in the hope and
the belief that they could make a better life for themselves and their children, and they
succeeded. I suspect that most of the people in this room who are American residents and
citizens today are descendants of the people who came to these shores in that period. I
know to take the immediate local case, the Eccles family derives from a Scotsman who
came to this country in the middle of the nineteenth century. My parents came here in
the 1890s from a part of Europe which is today part of the Soviet Union, although at that
time it was part of Hungary, and I suspect most of the people in this room have similar
backgrounds. Do you suppose those people kept coming to these shores in order to be exploited?
Do you think they came here to be ground under the heels of rapacious monopoly capitalists?
Not a bit of it. A few people might have been led here under misapprehension. You conceivably
could have had an initial inflow of people who thought they were going to improve their
lot and ended up being worse off, but you would not have had a continuing inflow. They
would not have sent back to the old country for their relatives and friends. You would
not have had a flow of millions upon millions, year after year. And of course they were not
exploited, they were not ground under the heel. They got jobs, they spread out west
to the Middle West, to the Far West, to where we are now, and they made of what was a desolate
country a country that was prosperous and green and productive, and improved their own
lot. With respect to agriculture in particular, that was a period when the number of farmers
increased. It was a period when the price of farmland rose. Now of course, then as now,
every farmer would have liked it better if he had done still better. What happened then,
of course, was that the spread of farms, increasing productivity, the development of machinery,
the bringing under the plow of productive land, led to a great increase in production
which led to a decline in the prices of farm products. So it's true, the prices of farm
products went down, but that was a sign of success. It was not a sign of failure. And
the evidence that it was a sign of success was a rise in the price of farmland. After
all, if this decline in the price of products had been a sign of failure, if it had been
an indication that the farmer was being ground under the heel of Wall Street, why would people
have been willing to pay higher and higher prices for the land from which those crops
were produced? So the actual story is one of a great growth of productivity in agriculture,
a great development of agriculture in this country.
If we turn to the charge that that was a period of heartlessness, a period in which the rich
were willing to say, let the public be damned, as one man was quoted incorrectly as saying,
if we turn to that charge, let me call to your attention that the nineteenth century,
the period when we came the closest we've ever come to pure, unrestrained individualism,
a period when government spending, the spending of the federal government in Washington, amounted
to less than three percent of the national income, when essentially you had no restrictions
on immigration and few restrictions on economic activity. Let me point out that that was also
the period of the greatest flowering of charitable activity in the United States. That was a
period when you had the establishment of so many independent private schools and colleges
around the country. It was a period when the private, non-profit, alimosinary hospitals
grew and sprouted in every city in the land. It was a period of the Carnegie Libraries.
It was a period of the founding of the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals.
You name it and you will find that the charitable alimosinary activities date back to the period
of the nineteenth century. So the robber baron myth is a myth, one that should be deflated.
It gets its appeal from a common fallacy, from the fallacy that one man's gain must
be another man's loss. Of course it is true that many men became wealthy during that period.
There were robber barons, there always are robber barons. People are people. Some are
good, some are bad, some are in between. And of course, some people did try to mistreat
other people. That is part of the course of history, unfortunately. But the main part
of the story is that the process whereby some people became wealthy was also the process
which opened up the country and provided opportunities for millions of other people to have a modest
competence to be able to improve their own lot. It was the robber barons who were instrumental
in building the railroads that joined the country together, who were instrumental in
developing the industries of this country, and in thereby providing the opportunities
for the ordinary man to improve his lot on life. Everybody can benefit. You can have
some people become wealthy not at the expense of other people, but by enabling other people
to become wealthy. We had robber barons then and we have robber barons today. But there
is a big difference between the robber barons then and the robber barons today. The robber
barons then primarily could get their money only if people freely gave it to them. They
got their money by selling a service and nobody had to buy it, and if people bought it it
was because it was a better service than it was before. The robber barons today are in
large part able to get their money by sending a policeman to take the money out of your
pocket. Now that's a figurative expression, not a literal expression, but how do you become
wealthy today? By getting government assistance. To mention only one very famous example, by
getting government to assign you some TV licenses, or by getting any one of a large variety of
other sources of government support. If you look at where modern wealth comes from, it
almost always comes from political influence which enables you to get benefits at the expense
of the public at large. Now that is a zero-sum game. When the money is transferred from some
to others through force and coercion in the taxpayer, then it need not be that the one
man's benefit is also the other man's benefit. Then it can and often is that the party who
gains, gains at the expense of the party who pays. So robber barons will always be with
us. The crucial question is whether we have a form of economic organization in which one
robber baron keeps the other robber baron in check, or whether we have a form of economic
and political organization in which one robber baron can help the other robber baron at the
expense of the public.
I want to turn to the second of these myths, the Great Depression myth. There is hardly
any view that is more widespread than the view that somehow or other the Great Depression
was produced by a failure of private business. That view is held not only by those who are
in favor of greater role of government, it is held by almost everybody. I venture to
suggest that if you go to any bankers, the people who are here today at this banking
conference, and if you talk to them, I venture to say nine out of ten of them, if they hadn't
heard what I'm going to say, that nine out of ten of them would say, well, of course
the Great Depression was a failure of private business. It was due to an overextension,
over-speculation in the 1920s, or it was due to an excessive concentration of wealth in
the hands of the wealthy at the expense of the poor in the 1920s, or it was due to speculative
investment abroad, or whatnot. But it was a failure of private business, and government
had to step in in order to rescue private business from its own failure. Nothing could
be farther from the truth. The Great Depression was produced, in my opinion, and I may say
this is not a random opinion. I will be glad to refer you to a several hundred-page book
in which it is documented. I won't tell you who the author is. Mr. Eccles did that.
It was produced, the Great Depression was produced, by a failure of government, by a
failure of monetary policy. It was produced by a failure of the Federal Reserve System
to act in accordance with the intentions of those who established it. It was produced
by a failure of the Federal Reserve System despite the presence of knowledge on the part
of many of the people in the system about the right course of action. It's interesting
to speculate for a moment about why this myth is so widespread. The answer is really very
simple in this case. Private enterprise has no press agents. The free market has no press
agents. The government has a great many press agents. The Federal Reserve has a great many
press agents. And the Federal Reserve, of course, would never admit, never proclaim,
that it produced the Great Depression. On the contrary. And again, I don't mean to be
criticizing individuals. We are talking about the way institutions operate. You and I are
the same as all the rest of us. We are all the same. The hardest thing in the world is
for anybody to admit that he made a mistake. If any one of us makes a mistake, we can always
find somebody else to blame. And if you read, as I have for my sins had to read, the annual
reports of the Federal Reserve System over a 50-year period, there is only one element
of humor that lightens that test, and that is the cyclical fluctuation in the powers
of the Federal Reserve. In a good year, when things are good, when the economy is booming,
you will read that the Federal Reserve, by its wise policy, by its efficacious management
of money, has produced this fine situation. However, let things get bad, and all of a
sudden the tone of the annual report is different. Then you discover that despite the best efforts
of the Federal Reserve, outside forces combine to produce difficulties. Even at the depth
of the Depression in 1933, when in the spring of that year the Federal Reserve began to
close, which had been established in order to prevent banking panics and keep banks from
closing, when the Federal Reserve System itself closed its doors and you had a banking holiday
for seven days, and when over the previous three years a third of the banks of this country
closed their doors and went broke because, in my opinion, of the poor policy followed
by the Federal Reserve System. Even in 1933, if you read the annual report, you will discover
how much worse things would have been if the Federal Reserve hadn't behaved so well.
Now as I say, I don't blame the members of the Federal Reserve for that. Any one of us
would do the same thing. We have to find somebody to blame. But as an objective scholar, I can
tell you what the facts are. The facts were that from 1929 to 1933, the total number of
money in the United States, the amount of currency, the amount of bank deposits, what
Mr. Eccles referred to as M2, that total amount of money declined by one-third. The total
number of banks went down by one-third. And why did the quantity of money decline? It
declined because the Federal Reserve System failed to prevent the decline. The Federal
Reserve System could have prevented the decline at all times. There never was a moment during
that period when the Federal Reserve did not have the power to prevent the decline in the
quantity of money. If it had prevented the decline in the quantity of money, you might
still have had a recession, but it would have been a garden-variety recession. It would
have been over in the middle of 1930 or early in 1931 at the latest. It would not have been
a major catastrophe, not only for this country but throughout the rest of the world. Moreover,
this is not only hindsight. At all times the people at the Federal Reserve Bank of New
York and at a number of other banks were pleading with the Federal Reserve Board in Washington
to do the right thing. At all times there were people in Congress who were arguing that
the Federal Reserve System should take a different course. At all times there were
outside commentators. One of the Canadian banks was particularly pressured, but there
were other commentators who were pointing out the disastrous effects on the American
economy of the restrictive policies that the Federal Reserve System was following and which
was permitting and facilitating a whole series of bank runs. So the Great Depression was
not produced by a failure of business. On the contrary, it was produced by a failure
of government and a failure of government in an area in which responsibility had been
assigned to government since the founding of this country, the Constitution of the United
States. It gives Congress the power to coin money and set the value thereof, and it was
in the management of this fundamental function of government that government failed and produced
the Great Depression. We have learned from that failure. The Federal Reserve will not
fail in the same way again. This time it will fail in a different way. This time it has
been failing not by producing a Great Depression, but by producing an inflation, because just
as you will hear the story that it was business that was responsible for the Depression, so
you will today hear the story that it is labor and management that are responsible
for inflation. It is the same kind of a myth. Inflation is made in one place and one place
only, Washington, D.C., and in Washington, D.C., the chief source, immediate source of
inflation, is a Greek temple on Constitution Avenue which houses the Federal Reserve Board.
An accomplice, and a major accomplice of course, sits in the halls of Congress in Washington.
They are a major accomplice because you tell them to be. The American people have been
telling Congress for many years, spend more money on us please, but they have been telling
us don't raise our taxes. Congress has been listening. It has been spending more money
on you. But on the other hand, it has been very unwilling to raise taxes. As a result,
it has imposed inflation as a tax. That's one tax that you don't have to vote for, but
you have to pay.
Let me turn to the third of the myths I want to cover. This is a myth closely related to
the Great Depression myth. It is a myth that somehow or other the private market has failed
to provide certain important services, and the government has had to step in in response
to an overwhelming public demand in order to provide those services. The reality is
very different. The reality is that if you look at every program that the government
has adopted in the direction of extending its scope, it took an enormous propaganda
campaign by special propaganda groups to get those measures passed. There was no underlying
public demand for those measures. On the contrary, the demand had to be created, it had to be
developed, it had to be produced, and it was created, it was developed, it was produced
by people who sincerely- I'm not questioning their sincerity- who sincerely wanted to see
an expansion in the scope of government.
Let me take some of the most prominent examples. Let me take the example which today is the
greatest sacred cow of them all, Social Security. Was there an overwhelming demand for Social
Security in the 1930s when the law was adopted? Far from it. There was no public demand for
it. It had to be sold. How was it sold? By the slickest devices of Madison Avenue, by
imaginative packaging and deceptive labeling. Social Security was sold as an insurance scheme.
It is not an insurance scheme. There is very little relationship to the amount of money
any one individual pays and the amount of money he is entitled to receive. Social Security
is a combination of a bad tax system with a bad way of distributing welfare. It's got
two components and I have never known anybody, whatever his political or other persuasion,
who would defend either component separately. If you look at the tax system, who can defend
a wage tax? A tax on wages up to a maximum, a tax on work, a tax which discourages employers
from hiring people and discourages people from going to work, and a tax which is borne
by the lowest wage groups. It's a regressive tax. In millions of Sundays you could never
have gotten such a tax passed as a tax. Look at the benefit arrangements. Here you have
an arrangement under which the amount of money a person receives does not depend on his poverty
or his indigence. It depends on the accident of what industry he worked in. If he happened
to work in a covered industry, he gets a benefit. If he happens to work in a non-covered industry,
he doesn't. If he has only worked a certain number of quarters and not more, no matter
how indigent he is, he doesn't get anything. If he is 65 and he decides to continue to
work, earning more than a modest amount per year, not only doesn't he get a benefit, but
to add insult to injury he has to pay taxes on the wages he is receiving in order to finance
the benefit he is not receiving. If a man who is 65 years old has a million dollars
in income from property and doesn't work, he gets his full Social Security benefit tax-free.
If the same man goes to work and earns $20,000 a year, he is in the position I just described.
He doesn't get any benefit. Is there anybody who would justify that system of distributing
benefits? And I could go on to all the difficulties with it. I have only touched the surface.
Note the misleading language. The Social Security system consistently refers to the taxes you
pay as a contribution. Now tell me, do you regard taxes as contributions? The word contribution
denotes voluntary arrangements. If you buy an insurance program, you are contributing
freely. If you contribute to the United Way freely, you are contributing freely. But if
you pay taxes on your wages as a condition of being employed, that's a tax, it's not
a contribution. Again, it always refers to the payments people get as benefits. They
are not benefits, they are subsidies. What you have is a system of subsidizing people
on the one hand and of taxing them. What about the claim that it's insurance, that there
is a relationship between the two? Well, there is a minor relationship. It is true that on
the whole those people who pay more will receive more, other things the same, but every student
of the subject has pointed out that the relationship is very small, that most payments are independent
of most receipts. Moreover, what you really have is not a system under which people are
providing for their own security as the Social Security system will say it, as they describe
it in their pamphlets. They describe it as a way in which 90 percent of American workers
are providing for their own future. That's nonsense. What people today are doing is paying
taxes today to pay the subsidies to the people who are receiving benefits today. What you
have is a system of taxing the young at any point in time to subsidize the old. Now there
may be nothing wrong with that. For the moment I'm not discussing that issue. I'm discussing
whether Social Security was a response to a broad-scale public demand, or whether it
had to be sold to the people by the worst devices of Madison Avenue. And the answer
is it clearly was the latter. What you have is a system under which people today are being
taxed to pay benefits today to the people who are receiving them. So far, those people
who have been receiving payments have received much more than the actuarial value of what
they paid. That's because you've had a growing working force, you've had higher wages being
paid, wage tax has gone up very sharply. But the number of recipients is growing relative
to the number of people paying, and that's why Social Security is currently in so much
financial trouble. That's why the so-called reserve, which is not a reserve at all, has
been getting smaller and smaller, and that's why you have all the agitation for Congress
to do something to make Social Security again financially responsible. Again, for the moment
I'm not discussing whether Social Security or the separate parts are good or bad, but
only whether it can be regarded as a program adopted in response to a great public demand.
Let me take another more recent movement. Consider the imposition on you and me and
on our automobiles of all sorts of so-called safety equipment, nothing to prevent us individually
from buying it. But now we are required to buy it by government. Why? Was there a great
public demand? Not at all. There was a man named Ralph Nader. Now maybe he arose in response
to a public demand, but if so, it was a public demand for entertainment, not for safety.
But Ralph Nader launched a major propaganda campaign, and as a result of this propaganda
campaign, as a result of a great selling effort, also characterized by misrepresentation. Also,
as you know, his original weapon was a book, Unsafe at Any Price, which damned the Corvair
as being an unsafe and knowingly unsafe car. Later studies have demonstrated that his claim
was not justified, but that did not prevent it from having its effect. It did not prevent
it from adopting it. But the extent to which this did not result from a great public clamor
can be shown by what has happened whenever the agency that was established to administer
auto safety regulations has overstepped its bounds. You will recall that a few years ago
it tried to impose the requirement of an interlock that no car could be started unless the seat
belts were fastened, and that produced such a great public outcry that Congress stepped
in and it had to be rescinded. You are now having a similar kind of a controversy about
the airbag. Or again, let me take a very different example, one which has not yet emerged fortunately,
the drive for national health insurance. Is there a widespread drive for national health
insurance? Not so you can notice it. Indeed, the proponents of it have been trying to get
it passed year after year, and so far they haven't gotten it passed. As I say, fortunately,
because if so-called national health insurance were passed, it would bear as little relationship
to insurance as Social Security does. It's not a program for national health insurance
at all. It's a program for socialized medicine. It's a program for making physicians government
employees. It's a program for creating long waiting lines and inferior medical service.
But that isn't the way it's labeled. But the pressure for it is having to be created and
built up by propaganda. Or again, let me take another modern version. Has the FDA's ban
on saccharin been in response to a great public outcry for it?
Let me turn to the fourth of my myths, the free lunch myth, the belief that somehow or
other government can spend money at nobody's expense. I don't know how many of you have
ever heard of a wonderful description of government that was made by a French economist
by the name of Frédéric Bastiat about 150 years ago. He said, government is that fiction
whereby everybody believes that he can live at the expense of everybody else. And that
is the free lunch myth, the myth that somehow or other government can provide goods and
expense.
Now the particular form which that myth takes is very specific. It has two parts. One part
is the belief that somehow or other you can tax business without consumers or workers
or individuals paying for it. Somehow business is a big cornucopia out there that can be
taxed at no cost. And the other form the myth takes is that you can create money at no cost,
that if you turn the printing press, if you produce those greenbacks, that will enable
people to become richer with nobody becoming poorer.
Well let me look at the first problem. Can you tax business? What's business? There's
no business to be taxed. There are people. Only people can pay taxes. Can I tax this
floor? Can I tax the building? The building can't pay taxes. Only people can pay taxes.
So when you talk about a tax on business, it has to be paid by somebody. Either it's
paid by the stockholder, or it's paid by the customer, or it's paid by the worker.
There's no other way it can come from. There's no Santa Claus, no Tooth Fairy, there's
no one that's going to provide a source by which the government can spend money that
doesn't come from somebody. Somebody has to pay. And yet, over and over again you hear
the claim, oh we must not increase taxes on individuals, we'll increase taxes on business,
in connection with the current discussion of Social Security. This fiction arises. There
is a fiction that the Social Security tax is half on the individual and half on the
employer, that the individual only pays 5.75 percent, the employer pays an equal amount.
That's nonsense. That's bookkeeping. That's not economics. That's not reality. The part
that the employer pays is part of his wage cost. If an employer considers whether it's
worth his while to hire an additional worker, he has to consider as part of his cost not
only what he pays to the worker, but also the extra taxes he will have to pay to the
government. It makes no difference to the employer at all if he pays the worker a bigger
check and the worker pays a larger part of that directly to the government, or he pays
the worker a smaller check but in addition has to send a check to Washington. What matters
to him is the total number of dollars it costs him to hire an additional person. So
the fact is, the logic is, the reason is, that the so-called tax on the employer is
paid by the employee. Now this has always been clear from economic reasoning, general
economic reasoning, but it has also been subjected to empirical tests. In a book even from that
temple of belief in greater and bigger government, the Brookings Institution in Washington, published
a couple of years ago, demonstrated empirically that the tax on the employer was really paid
by the employee, that it was shifted to the employee, and it can't be any other way as
you will see if you think about it. So business doesn't pay that tax. And yet, despite this,
you have the great move in Congress right now in remedying the problem of Social Security
to impose a larger fraction of the tax on business on the alleged grounds that somehow
or other that spares the worker. It doesn't have any such effect. It reduces the incentive
to hire people and thus is imposed on the worker. But again, if you look at the tax
on corporate profits, the distinction you have to draw is between who writes the check
and who fundamentally bears the cost. It may well be that an official of a corporation
writes the check for the tax on profits, so-called profits. He writes the check, but who pays
it? He doesn't pay it. Here is a poor fellow who may be earning a modest competence. He
may be writing a check for $10 million. That isn't coming out of his hide. Where is that
$10 million coming from? It has to come from the proceeds of the goods and services which
the enterprise sells, and that $10 million is $10 million less available either for cutting
prices or for paying out dividends or for paying wages and salaries. The tax is borne
by people, and for this reason I must say I have always myself been strongly in favor
of eliminating altogether the tax on corporations. So it's open and above board that you are
taxing people and that you do not conceal that fact by appearing to tax corporations.
Well again, with respect to money, can you print money at no cost? It's very cheap to
turn out those pieces of paper, but does that get society something for nothing? Not
at all. It's simply a different form of taxation. If you print money, people have more money
to spend. If they spend more money on the same amount of goods, prices go up, and in
effect everybody is paying a tax through inflation. Once again, it's only a form of taxation.
Let me turn to my final myth, because it is in some ways the most pervasive, the most
dangerous, and the most deep-seated. That is the Robin Hood myth, the myth that government
has benefited the poor at the expense of the rich. That's the myth. Those are the terms
on which many a governmental program is sold. What is the reality? The reality has been
described in an article in the Journal of Law and Economics by my colleague George Stigler
under the title of Director's Law. Director is the name of Aaron Director, who was a professor
at the University of Chicago Law School, and I might also say my brother-in-law. Director's
law is that almost invariably government programs benefit the middle-income class at the expense
of the very poor and the very rich. Now that may seem to you strange, but let me first
explain why it makes logical sense, and second, give you some empirical evidence starting
right here at home with higher education and the state financing of higher education.
On the logical level, you have a political system under which laws are passed by 51 percent
of the people voting one way against 49 percent of the people. Now the way to get a law passed,
therefore, is to form a coalition covering 51 percent of the people. You might think
that you would take the bottom 51 percent versus the top 49 percent, but the more you
think about it, the more you realize that that's not a very effective way to form a
coalition. Why? Because those people who are at the bottom tend to be much less skillful
in political activity for the very reasons that leave them at the bottom in the economic
scale. They are at the bottom in the economic scale because they have low skills or low
abilities or low entrepreneurial capacities or have been unfortunate to have been born
handicapped or in groups that are discriminated against. But those same features make them
relatively less effective in political activity. Who are the most effective people in political
activity? Those of us in the middle classes. Where are the people who are literate? Where
are the people who write for the newspapers? Where are the people who mount the hustings?
Where are the people who provide the candidates? Well, you might say, why doesn't the coalition
come from the top all the way down 51 percent? Well, the answer is that, gee, those people
at the top, that's a place we can get a lot of money from, and it's worth sacrificing
a few votes to get a large fraction of a tax base. And therefore, the logically most reasonable
coalition is sort of 51 percent of the people running from the lower middle class through
the upper middle class and leaving out the very rich at the top and the very poor at
the bottom. Now it doesn't always work that way. Sometimes the very rich are able to use
their money to get an effective coalition, but most of the time that's the way it works.
Now let me illustrate it in reality, in the real world. One of my favorite examples is
state finance of higher education. This is always sold on the ground of providing opportunities
to everybody in the society to get an education, but what are the facts? I doubt that there
is any program financed by government in the United States which is as regressive in its
impact and its financial impact as the financing of higher schooling. Who are the people who
go to school? Who are the people who are attending this university? Mostly people who come from
upper middle or lower middle income class families. If there are a few among you who
come from lower income families, you are going to be among the middle and upper income classes.
You are the richer among the poor. They are the people who go to school. They are the
people who get the benefit from it. Your training here will enable you to get higher incomes
than you otherwise could. Who pays for it? Well, you pay for it, and your family and
friends pay for it, not through tuition. I am told your tuition covers about 15 percent
of the cost of your schooling. The taxpayers pay for it, including the people who don't
go to school. Some years ago there was a study made for the state of California which showed
that 50 percent of the students at state-supported institutions of higher education came from
the top 25 percent of the income class, and 5 percent came from the bottom 25 percent
of the income class. This is a program. When I talk in California and want to be demagogic,
I say it's a program to impose taxes on the people in Watts to send the children from
Beverly Hills to college. Now you here in Utah know better what the local equivalents
of that are. Now I'm not blaming you as individuals again. I couldn't do that because I myself
am a beneficiary of state-supported higher education. I went through a school that has
since become a state university, Rutgers University in the state of New Jersey, on a state scholarship.
Now I think I benefited from going to the university, and I think even maybe the country
at large did, although I know there are many people who disagree with that. But there's
no reason why I shouldn't have paid for it. What did the poor citizens in New Jersey get?
The day I graduated from college I left New Jersey and I've hardly ever been back since.
There's a strong case to be made that everybody who wants to go to university should have
an opportunity to do so, provided he's willing to pay for it. Not necessarily right now.
It's highly desirable to have arrangements under which he can borrow now to pay it back
later out of a higher income that his education will make possible. But there is no justification
for imposing taxes on lower-income people to finance the schooling of people who are
or will be in the higher-income groups. And yet, how much political movement is there
to impose full-cost tuition on colleges? There is nobody who would have a ghost of a chance
of being elected to a legislature or to the State House on that program. It's the hardest
thing in the world legislatively to get higher tuitions imposed. Why? Because the middle
class looks after itself, because of director's law. Now what's true for higher education
is true in every other area. Consider Social Security. Now Social Security is also sold
as a program to benefit the poor. What are the facts? Social Security is a program which
imposes unduly heavy taxes on the lower-income groups in the society to provide higher benefits
to upper-income groups in the society. How does it work? It's not because of the regressive
nature of the wage tax. It's not because of the structure of benefits. It's because of
a very simple phenomenon. At what age do younger men from the lower classes go to work? Sixteen,
seventeen, eighteen, nineteen. That's when they start to pay Social Security taxes. At
what age are you people going to go to work and start paying Social Security taxes? Some
of you may in part-time jobs have been doing so, but you will be a full-time Social Security
payer only when you reach your middle twenties. So they will pay taxes for more years than
you will pay taxes. Next, which one is going to receive benefits for longer? Every demographic
study has shown that the average expected length of life of middle and upper-income
classes is longer than the average length of life of people from the lower-income classes.
So those poor suckers are going to pay taxes for more years and receive payments for fewer
years than you and I will. Now some of us, by virtue of continuing to work between 65
and 72, will not be in that favored class, but already the fraction of people who work
between 65 and 72 has been cut to a small part of what it used to be because of the
incentive offered by Social Security. And overall there is little doubt, therefore,
that Social Security is a program which transfers income from low-income classes to high-income
classes. The same thing is true of almost every other social program you can mention.
I have often challenged people to find a single governmental program in which the people who
pay taxes have higher incomes than those who get the benefits. I know only one, and that's
direct relief, public assistance, the aid to families of dependent children. It's not
a good program. It's a terrible program. It's a welfare mess. But so far as I can
find out, it's the only program that demonstrably transfers income from higher-income classes
to lower-income classes, and that's why it's such an unpopular program. Director's law
shows up in the unpopularity of the welfare mess as well as in the popularity of Social
Security, housing programs, and the like. I could go down a great many others, but time
will not permit.
I come to my conclusion that if we are going to look forward to the future, to an end of
this reduction in our freedom and the growth in centralized government, I think we must
begin to dismantle these myths which are so widely accepted by people, which have become
an unthinking part of their philosophy and of their beliefs. And I hope that in the course
of this hour I have deflated your air mattress and given you an uncomfortable jolt. Thank
you.

