Milton Friedman on Money ⧸ Monetary Policy (Federal Reserve) Part 1
It's seldom that you can date
precisely when there's a major
change in a human institution,
let alone in a monetary
institution. But you know, it's
an interesting fact that you can
date precisely a really drastic
change in the character of the
monetary system around the world
and you can date it on August
15th, 1971. That's the date on
which Richard Nixon finally
ended the supposed agreement by
the U.S. government to sell gold
for $35 an ounce to foreign
governments. And that was the
final nail in the coffin of the
kind of monetary system that had
prevailed from the beginning of
time so far as you can see. All
monetary systems before that were
commodity systems based on a
commodity, whether it was silver
or gold or other things. From
August 15th, 1971, no national
currency in the world is any
longer based on a commodity. You
know, when people talk about
money, they think it means
something. But what in the world
is the money that people use
today? But even then, the money
that we use was not in any
meaningful way connected to gold.
I mean, it was just paper as it
is today. It was a long time, you
know. Literal commodities were
used as money for centuries, for
millennia. When you go back,
whether you go back to Greece or
Rome, they used silver coins or
gold coins. Earlier than that, the
first recorded kind of money was a
mixture of gold and silver. It
wasn't a deliberate mixture. It
was a mixture that came out of the
earth in the form of- what was it
they called it? It was a king
somewhere in Arabia who
discovered this amalgam, and
that's what they used as money.
He was the first one who put a
stamp on it and said, this is
money. This is to be taken as
having a certain value. And as
late as the 19th century, I guess
most monetary transactions were
actually made with coins. Well,
by the 1850s, the most actual
transactions were either written
with checks, like they are today,
or with bills that came from
banks. But at least if you're
using bills, they act as if it was
a commodity because there was this
underlying relationship between a
piece of paper and some number of
ounces of gold someplace, or some
number of weight of commodities
someplace. I think what's happened
then, since 1971, is we've had a
pure fiat standard where it's just
the whim of a government as to what
our money's going to be worth. We
were pretty close to that even
before. Well, a dollar, you know,
it used to be, if you took out a
dollar bill, it would used to say
on that dollar bill, the United
States of government promises to
pay one dollar. It used to say.
Now it doesn't say that. It hasn't
said that for a long time. Oh, it's
not so long. You're young. In my
lifetime, it's not so long. I was
a kid when it changed. I'm not sure
you were. I think it only changed
in about 1960. When they went off
silver certificates? I think so. I
think when they finally ended, for
a long time the government had a
policy of a fixed price for silver.
And they didn't go off that until
something like the 1950s or 60s, a
purchasing program. But now it just
says the United States of America,
one dollar. Now what really gives
it some meaning, it says this note
is legal tender for all debts,
public and private. Now what does
that mean? Well, that's the way the
government defines what it is. That
means that when I have a debt with
someone, I could present that bill,
and if they don't receive it, well,
they fail to fulfill their portion
of the contract. No, but that's only
true if the debt is in dollars. That's
right. The only thing it's really
good for is government funding. Well,
no, wait, wait, wait. If a contract
is written in dollars, the question
of the court has to decide what does
the word dollar mean. Okay, and then
the Article I of the Constitution
gives Congress the power to decide
what the word dollar means. It's just
like Article I also says that Congress
has to decide how long the yard is or
how big the gallon is. And one of the
things the government does is it
decides units of weight, measure, and
value. And the dollar is the unit of
value, and it's given meaning to that
by saying this piece of paper is what
we mean by the dollar. Now, what's
amazing is that people accept that.
You know, this meaningless scrap of
paper is taken to have value. One of
the things I find in the course of
years of talking about money to lots
of people, the hardest thing people
have to find it, the thing they find
it hardest to understand is that
literally there are 19 people sitting
around a table in Washington who
have the power to have twice as many
dollars or half as many dollars
or ten times as many dollars. You
know, people think that the number
of dollars in existence is somehow
determined by some physical or
technical or some other rule. The
idea that they're just this, who are
these 19 people? Seven governors of
the Federal Reserve System plus 12
presidents of Federal Reserve Banks.
Not all of them have a vote. Only
five of them have a vote. But, you
know, seven governors plus the five
bank presidents can vote what to do
about the amount of money. And
there's absolutely no other control
except the indirect control that the
Congress could pass a law changing
their powers. Yeah, but the amazing
thing about that group is that they
regularly contemplate changing the
unit of measure. It's as if...
Remember, there's one other person
that we never talk about which is
the director of the National Bureau
of Standards who determines how long
the yard is. We never think about
changing the length of the yard, but
regularly the people you're talking
about shrink. The dollar gets
smaller, a little bit smaller every
year. It's as if we had a shrinking
yardstick. Not in terms of the
definition. It's still the legal
tender for debt. No, but the
purchasing power of it. Back to the
original point, we also have an
indirect way if our president acts
in such a way that we have higher
rates of inflation, we tend to vote
them out, which is probably the
leading reason Jimmy Carter was
thrown out and also labor government
was and Margaret Thatcher came in.
So there is some kind of a very
tenuous check on their acting...
Oh, I think it's better than that.
One of the interesting things is not
only does the U.S. have this system,
but Japan, Germany and many other
countries have the system and it
delivers really a remarkably stable
currency in spite of the fact that
all the elements of instability are
there and yet the performance of the
system, especially in the last ten
years in the United States, for
example, has really not been bad.
But the interesting thing is you
see that until August 15th, 1971
there was at least the pretense
that it was not being determined by
twelve people, that it was really
being determined somehow or other
by the link which it had to go.
It was a pretense though. You go
really way back. You correctly
called it a pretense. Oh, it was a
pretense. It wasn't a pretense to
begin with if you go back to what
happened when gold was discovered
in California in 1848. It was very
far from a pretense that the
quantity of money was being
determined by how much gold there
was. Well, it's not the quantity
that doesn't matter. It's the value
of the money. The value of the
money declined when gold became
more plentiful. It declined because
there was more of it. The quantity
of the value of the money is not
unrelated to the quantity of money.
Just argue in favor a little bit of
this fiat standard. One of the
things that's good about it is
society is not really forced to go
and take gold out of the ground or
silver out of the ground and put it
someplace in order to create a
money system. So if the government
is doing its job correctly, that is
having a non-inflationary growth
rate of the money supply, then we
could have this fiat money, this
pieces of paper, instead of the
gigantic expenditure of resources
necessary to pull gold out of the
ground, being our money stock, and
save a lot of resources that we can
use elsewhere. That's an argument I
often make, I used to make, and I'm
not so confident about it anymore. I
used to say it's just simply absurd
to dig gold out of the ground in
South Africa in order to bury it
under the ground in New York in the
vaults of the Federal Reserve. But
since I've observed the operation of
this fiat money standard, it isn't
costless either. It isn't costless
because it introduces so much
uncertainty into the world about
what's going to happen. You're
right. The point is in the best of
all worlds, savings of resources, if
governments do the correct thing
from the beginning, it would be the
best of all worlds. When have you
known governments to behave as if
it's the best of all worlds? I've
looked at them in my shorter lifetime
and they always do things wrong. But
the U.S. government in the last ten
years has delivered a more stable
purchasing power of money than we
had under the gold standard. Now I
admit that's only a ten-year period.
That depends on what period it was.
I can name other ten-year periods
in which that was true. It's not
impossible. You can take a ten-year
period, for example, from 1896 to
really a seventeen-year period, from
about 1898, let's say, to 1914, in
which you had a very regular
uptick in the value of the gold
thing, but it was very stable.
Stable inflation. Yeah, that period
was very similar to what we've had
in the last ten years. Yeah, and
you can take a period from about
1922 to 1929 when it was very
stable horizontally, seven years.
Right. Some governments do a good
job, however, with their monetary
policy and I think something that's
interesting is why is the United
States, which is where we invented
monetarism, where you invented
monetarism, why have we done such a
bad job and why have the Japanese
done such a good job and why have
the British not even admitted that
monetarism is a sensible view? But
hold on for a moment. You take the
Japanese again, you're very time
bound. Until 1973, they did a very
lousy job. Until 1973, they were up
and down all the time. Yeah, that's
right. There was more price
instability in Japan. Well, since
Greenspan has taken over the Fed and
my business, which is the money
management field, we've talked about
the Japanization of U.S. monetary
policy where you have the sensation
that Alan Greenspan is actually
trying to follow the monetary policy
that the Japanese have followed in
their good period and he's trying to
reverse the monetary policy that the
United States followed before he
came into office. But if you take
Japan, go back. Okay. In 1973, they
changed because inflation had zoomed
up to 25%. There was a feeling
something had to be done about it
and they did, from then on, have a
very good monetary policy until
about 1988 and then they went off
again. When the U.S. government...
And it was our fault. The U.S.
government, Jim Baker and his gang
went to the Louvre Accord and said
Japan, you've got to help us do your
thing. So we want the yen to go to
be devalued. No, we want the dollar.
We want the dollar. The dollar is
too strong. The dollar is too strong
so help us do that. And they have
since bought the Japanese growth
rates. At the plaza, no, at the
Louvre Agreement, they wanted to
support the dollar. Support the
dollar. They wanted to stop the
decline of the dollar. And that's
what caused the Japanese to print
so much money. They went from 8.8
to higher rates of growth rates in
their M2 plus CDs, which is what
they tend to look at. But now
Japanese growth rates of money are
down to about 2% and this is part
of the problem that's causing Japan
and Japan right now. Well,
similarly, if you take Germany...
Germany has done a relatively good
job. Now, one of the interesting
phenomenon to me is how long
people's memory is. There's no
doubt the reason Germany has done
such a good job is in considerable
part because from 1918 to 1922,
23, 24, they suffered a tremendous
inflation, hyperinflation. You know
people don't realize what
hyperinflation is. People in the
United States complain about prices
rising. But in Germany at that time
they paid wages three times as much
three times a day after breakfast,
lunch, and dinner so people could
go out and spend the money before
it lost its value. Well, it was a
good idea to buy two beers at once
because the price of the second
beer went up faster than the beer
went flat. And there are pictures
in my textbook where people would
walk around with wheelbarrows of
money to make their pays. That's
very extreme. John Maynard Keynes
made that crack once. He said when
he was in Russia during this period
and he saw a man rushing with a
wheelbarrow of money, he said for
the first time he knew what
velocity of circulation really
meant. One of the interesting
things right now going on is just
watching some of the things that
are happening in Russia where I was
recently there and experienced 40
percent, 50 percent a month
inflation. And this is to people
who have known price stability in
their mind for years and years and
years and you go from fixed prices
where everything was fixed by the
Soviet government to this crazy
system where prices are moving at
50 percent a month. It's left them
breathless. They're dumbfounded.
They just don't even know how to
make any sense out of it. And it's
interesting watching these poor
countries of Eastern Europe and the
ex-Soviet Union undergo these
dramatic changes right now. Once
again, it's because their money
doesn't mean anything there. It's
just pieces of paper. Well, if you
come back to the United States for
a moment and come back to general
attitudes about money, I suppose
one of the real difficulties about
people understanding money is
distinguishing- going back to
something you were saying, Bob-
distinguishing between the number
of pieces of paper, the number of
units, and what that number of
units will buy. What economists
call the nominal amount of money
versus the real amount of money.
And to an ordinary person, it
seems kind of curious. Let's
suppose these 19 people sitting
around a table suddenly decided
that the quantity of money should
be increased and everybody got
more money somehow. Let's not ask
about the process. Each individual
separately would think he was
better off. And yet the economy of
the whole might be very much worse
off. And that's why I think when
you ask the question, why is it
that countries have inflation? To
do something that almost everybody
agrees after the event was a bad
thing. I don't believe there's
anybody in Argentina who thinks it
was a good thing that they had
inflation rates of 100, 200 percent
a year. I don't think there's any-
there are very few people in the
United States who think it was a
good thing that during the 1970s,
inflation was allowed to go up
until in 1980 it was in the
neighborhood of 20 percent. And
yet we do it. And that's really a
puzzle, isn't it? Why is it? But
it speaks to the more general
problem of the failure of
government. Governments fail very
characteristically in the same
direction. They promise too much.
They generate too little revenue.
And it often- the hyperinflations
we've talked about are generally
related to that phenomenon of the
government printing money in
desperation to try to honor its
spending promises. I think it's
also- in the case of the U.S. in
the 70s, it was probably- I think
you've even mentioned this- it's
the first round. They didn't know
how strong this tiger was that
they had unleashed when they got
rid of gold back in the early 70s.
And that was the first round. Now
politicians now know that if you
let inflation go up to 20 percent
in the United States, your party's
out of power for 15 years. And this
is now the case that those 19
people might say, well, I'm going
to give in to the pressure. But the
person who's the president says,
well, if you give in to the
pressure, we're out of power for
20 years. And he's going to be
very upset about that. Is he? Is
he? I've just been observing that
over the last year, Mr. Bush has
been trying to urge the Federal
Reserve to print more money to
ease conditions. But the rate of
inflation has declined during that
period. The rate of inflation has
declined, but it's still- The
president has been saying let's
keep inflation at the 45 percent
level where it was before, and
now it's dropped to 3 percent. I
agree that was the wrong thing
for him to do. I also agree that
the political calculus that he
went through in order to allow
for an increase in marginal tax
rates was an incorrect one, and I
don't understand what he gained
by doing that either. So if you're
saying we have an irrational
person who's not maximizing his
political support, well, I'll
accept some of that. But suppose
we were thinking of the public at
large here now, everybody in the
United States. Money is- you're
right that it's a special example
of a more general problem,
government failing to achieve what
it seeks to do. But it's a
particularly important problem.
There's nothing else which, if it
goes wrong, does so much harm.
And the interesting thing is that
you very seldom have seen any
structural suggestions,
suggestions for really changing
the system in a way which would
make money a better servant and a
less cruel master. Well, you and I
both put a lot of persuasive effort
into that. We've just been
unsuccessful, is that what you're
saying? Yes, we have been
unsuccessful, absolutely. We
haven't been able to persuade the
public at large. We haven't
persuaded- been able to persuade
the powers that be. Well, in some
sense it hasn't been that bad.
Yeah, I think that's right. It's
not like our school systems or
something like that, but it is.
Inflation is not at the top of the
list of- It isn't at the moment.
No, no. By the time you bring it
down to three or four percent a
year, which it is now, and of
course it's not too easy to
measure. What is three or four
percent a year in what? Some
prices are going up, some are
going down. As a computer user, I
know that there's been big
deflation. Automobiles are more
expensive in dollars, but they're
much cheaper in terms of the
number of months you have to work
to get one than they ever were.
And moreover, the quality of them
has improved enormously. So it
isn't all one way. And yet, it
seems to me that for not only in
the United States, but elsewhere,
that it's fascinating that
there's been so little attention
to money and what it can do and
how much harm it can do when it
goes wrong. And the thing we
haven't done is build in any
protection against repetition of
the disasters of the 1970s or even
worse, which could happen. The
federal government is drifting in
the direction of a true fiscal
emergency sometime in the next
five, ten, fifteen years, and that
could be accompanied by the kind
of a severe inflation emergency
that we've not had for a long
time. I think the time to act
would be now in terms of
structural reform. Of course, so
far as the public at large is
concerned, inflation to them
means higher prices. And to them,
they look at higher prices as
being set by business enterprises.
And the most popular explanations
of inflation are not those we've
been talking about. That's right.

