Archery in Melee | The "Sudden" Attack Scenario

LEARN ARCHERY
7 followers
39 Video ViewsยทJul 24, 2025
Comments are disabled for this video.
Hey guys, this is NUSensei. Today we have yet another archery melee topic.
Now, we've already established that bows are pretty bad in melee, and people keep on saying,
but what if, what if? I'm not going to do any more demonstrations with using a bow in melee,
because it's all pretty silly, but this is more to address a particular argument,
or a particular line of thinking, which makes absolutely no sense to me.
So this is a logic discussion rather than a practical discussion.
The argument I often hear is that using a bow will give the archer time to take out their sidearm.
Now this, at surface level, makes some sense. It does take time to switch weapons.
And by the way, all archers had a secondary weapon.
Look, they're soldiers. They have to carry weapons, and archers in armies would have no shortage of weapons
like swords, or clubs, or maces, or axes, or picks.
Even a poacher, who's not a career soldier, would have some kind of long knife,
because that's what they need to poach with.
So the idea where an archer is completely defenseless with no weapon is such an incredible and unlikely scenario
that you might as well say, look, you can't use another weapon.
That's an unfair argument.
But going back to the main topic of the idea that you need time to draw a sidearm.
Now, I don't have a historically accurate analogue. Let's just say I've got a blade here.
Look, I don't understand the argument of buying time to draw a weapon,
because how long does it take to draw a sidearm?
With the bow?
I'm not exactly a master of Jiu-Jitsu.
This literally is not exactly a hard thing to do, or a slow thing to do.
You would have your weapon on hand. It's just right next to you.
That's why it's called a sidearm.
So I don't understand what situation you might be thinking of that would prevent me from accessing my weapon.
So a lot of people are saying, well, what if you were suddenly attacked?
What does that mean?
In what situation would a soldier be suddenly attacked in a way that leaves it impossible for them to have any action?
Firstly, how far away is this sudden attack?
If you're charging at me, and you're more than 10 paces away, this is what I can do.
So if you're at a range where you are running at me, I can shoot you, and if I don't already disable you,
then I can freely draw my weapon at my own leisure.
I don't even need to worry about a full draw.
If I'm under stress and I need to shoot something, I can snap shoot, do a half draw,
and that will still give a projectile advantage and give me time to get to my sidearm.
But you might say, what if I don't have an arrow ready?
This close?
Oh look, now your weapon can reach me.
I'm this close to you, and you're already attacking me?
I mean, seriously, any person with a brain, any sane archer, who by the way is a soldier first,
will know how to react in the appropriate way.
If you know somebody is about to engage you at this distance in melee combat,
and you can't flee for whatever reason, you switch to your sidearm.
There is no way an archer is going to let you come this close,
and then decide, oh, I should switch to my weapon now, I've got to use my bow first.
That doesn't make any logical sense.
Note, by the way, I didn't even have to drop my bow.
I could if I wanted to, so if I have to discard this,
it's nearly a timeless action.
This isn't a turn-based RPG where it takes me two action points to change weapons.
I can literally do both things at once if I had to.
Maybe you're thinking of a situation where, you know, there's a bush or something,
and they're on the other side, so I'm walking past, and suddenly, oh crap!
This is exactly why archers carry sidearms.
Because they have a much better tool to fall back on with minimal effort.
And look, archers weren't averse to fighting in melee combat.
They weren't weaklings.
Now, talk about soldiers here, talk about poachers, that may be a little different,
but all archers were soldiers first.
If you were a professional archer in the English army,
then you definitely had the strength and the training to use swords.
If you were a Mongol archer, then you were the all-around warrior.
You were expected to be good with spears, and bows, and swords,
and whatever else you had to use.
Barehanded wrestling.
So it wasn't like archers were like, oh no, please don't hurt me!
They were more than capable of fighting in melee combat,
and that's why they carried more weapons.
And because of that, an archer would not need to wait to the very last second
to engage in melee.
At some point they're going to think, yes, now's the right time.
Or if you're in a formation, then perhaps the captain or the master archer
will give the command to draw swords.
So it's not like in Mountain Blade or Total War,
where you have to touch the archer for them to suddenly switch to their daggers.
So given that an archer would have plenty of time to react to any threat,
and then present their own threat,
there doesn't seem to be a need to hypothesise this sudden attack scenario
where I literally am right in front of your face,
and I have to use my bow.
But could I? Of course, I could knock your blow aside, draw my weapon.
But I can do that without engaging my bow in combat.
I can always just step back and draw my weapon.
Because, again, this is a zero-time action.
This isn't me trying to open my pack and then find the right weapon,
and then pull it out.
I can do so in one movement and engage in combat.
It's not a movie thing. This is literally what can be done in real life.
And this is why I can't understand the logic behind using your bow to buy time.
This takes zero time.
So if I make any offensive action with my bow, I am wasting time.
The sooner I go from this to this, the more likely I am to survive.
If I have to make you flinch, if that's a thing,
and by the way, as I've said already, this is a terrible weapon.
I can't even swing towards the camera.
If I flip it around, sure, it's a bit easier.
But if I were to swing at you to make you flinch,
notice how I've committed two hands to my attack,
so I can't draw my weapon.
I have to do this, finish my attack, drop the weapon, and then pull it out.
But that's longer than just drawing it in the first place.
Not to mention that by committing to an attack,
I leave myself open to counterattack.
So you can therefore block or parry this blow,
and then counter in your own time.
I have no way to recover from my committed strike.
I have to do this and hope that you flinch or you block the attack.
If you do that, that means you now have the initiative.
If you can attack me back, I can't defend now,
because I've got this really crappy melee weapon.
Again, it doesn't make any logical sense to me
to have to use this when I can already draw my weapon very freely.
The only situation where this would be appropriate for any melee usage
is if you didn't have any secondary weapon at all,
in which case, yes, you would probably have to improvise with this weapon
to defend yourself, but never to attack.
You cannot do enough damage with a bow full stop.
You might simply be defending until you get a better opportunity
to find another weapon or to run away.
You would not engage in an offensive fight with this tool.
It's here to save your life only,
so you would probably be just backing it up, making space,
dodging attacks, using this to parry where possible,
but at the very last moment, if you had to attack someone,
it might be parry and then grapple.
Otherwise, there is no need to use this in melee in any way.
Not offensively, not defensively.
The argument where you need to give yourself time to draw your weapon
has no logic behind it, because drawing a weapon is zero time.
It doesn't take time to take out another weapon,
even if you still have your bow in your hand.
You don't need to block and then draw, or strike someone,
make them flinch and then draw.
This takes longer, and it's a risk which doesn't make any sense.
You would switch to your most effective weapon as soon as you can,
not try to fence with this and then stab someone with a knife.
That's why I think this argument is way illogical,
and some people are really trying to stretch the argument.
So, that's it. No more bows in melee.
That's my final opinion.
It doesn't need to be done, it wasn't done,
and any argument that tries to put in a situation where it must be used is so extreme,
it is nearly impossible.
Because, again, when you have this ready, you do not need this.
As far as modifying the bow goes, my favourite rebuttal is this.
Simply, if you think about adding metal guards and plates,
and even a blade on the bow,
and make it detachable so it doesn't interfere with the bow,
then why don't you also add a crossguard and a hilt and a pommel,
and call it a sword.
So, that's it. That's why bows were not used in melee.
This is NUSensei. Thank you for watching, and I'll see you next time.
