JJ Thomson and the discovery of the electron
And welcome to High School Physics Explained and today I'm going to do a video
on J.J. Thomson and his discovery of the electron.
And as I go through it I will touch on a little bit of the history of the cathode ray tube
and the controversy that it initially created.
I'll touch also on the behaviour of charges in both an electric field and a magnetic field
and how all of these things contributed to the discovery of the electron.
So let's get started.
So in 1855 Geisler, who was a glass blower by trade, developed the vacuum tube.
So he was able to produce a tube made out of glass and remove a significant portion
of gas within that tube and he embedded within that tube two terminals.
So he was able to connect it to an electrical supply or battery and allow a current to pass
through it and he noted that it actually glowed when he placed a voltage across it.
A couple of years later, in 1858, Pluker was able to produce the same effect in what
was known at the time as the Geisler tubes and he was able to vary the pressure within
the tubes, in other words vary the amount of gas within the tube and he noticed that
it emitted different amounts of light.
But he also noted that the light could actually be deflected by a magnet.
So he supposed that whatever was in the tube was electrically charged because it was unknown
at the time that an electrical charge could be deviated by the presence of a magnetic
field.
In 1875, an English scientist by the name of Crookes believed that these particles that
were within this Geisler tube, which is now known as a cathode ray tube, were negatively
charged particles and he noted that if you change the anode and the cathode it wouldn't
affect the actual light that was emitted and he surmised that there was some sort of negatively
charged particle emitted out from the cathode and travelled in straight lines to the anode.
And he did a number of experiments that helped him predict that it would be a charged particle
of some sort.
And two types of tubes that he developed, one was the Maltese cross and so what we have
here is a cathode emitting these cathode rays and they would strike this Maltese cross
and the fluorescent end would glow where these cathode rays would hit, just as what Pluka
had seen, but the Maltese cross created a shadow on the end and what Crookes surmised
is that these particles travelled in straight lines.
The fact is that these particles were blocked by this Maltese cross and hence produced a
shadow.
Another thing that he was able to produce is he was able to produce this paddlewheel
setup.
Now ensuring that this setup was completely level, he noted that when he applied a supply
to it, an electrical supply, he'd get his cathode rays being emitted and as they were
being emitted the paddlewheel would start to move.
So now all of a sudden this paddlewheel was moving due to some sort of a collision with
these negatively charged particles that Crookes believed.
So Crookes was a strong proponent that these particles were negatively charged particles
with mass.
Now there is no conclusive evidence at this stage to suggest that he was correct and so
in the 1880s other scientists, interestingly enough on the other side of the English Channel,
did similar experiments on the cathode rays but came to different conclusions.
So Heinrich Hertz tested the cathode rays.
He surmised that well if they are negatively charged particles then they should be deflected
by an electric field but he failed to deflect them.
He did not see any deflection and so he concluded that they were a form of light and so he
concluded that they are some sort of electromagnetic radiation.
At the time also an area of research after Maxwell's predictions of electromagnetic
radiation.
Philip Lennard, a Frenchman, also looked at these cathode rays and he filed them at gold
foil.
Now in this case the cathode rays passed straight through them so again he was of the opinion
that these cathode rays were not forms of matter but were some sort of electromagnetic
radiation.
So here you can see there is a little bit of discussion in Europe as to the nature of
cathode rays.
Were they particles as Crookes believed or were they forms of electromagnetic radiation
which Hertz and Lennard suggested.
So none of this was conclusively decided upon until 1897.
In 1897 a British scientist named J.J.
Thompson set up an experiment to help determine the nature of these cathode ray tubes and
so here is J.J.
Thompson at his work and here is a picture of the tube that he looked at.
You'll notice that it has a number of features.
It has a cathode and that cathode emits the cathode rays.
Then over here you'll notice I have a series of anodes and these anodes being positively
charged caused whatever these rays were to accelerate.
Because they are positively charged and the view was that they were negatively charged
they accelerated through these anodes and if you look very carefully you can see there
is a slit here.
So what happens is what J.J.
Thompson was able to produce was a very narrow beam of cathode rays.
Then over here you see another set of plates and in this case J.J.
Thompson was setting up an electric field.
So by setting up an electric field he was hoping to deflect this particular beam either
up or down depending on the polarity of this electric field.
So here is a diagram of his setup and as you can see what we have here is my cathode over
here, my anode over here and the anode having a hole through the actual terminals meant
that our beam is collimated.
In other words we've got this narrow beam of cathode rays and you notice that they started
to curve upwards and they do curve upwards because of course there is an electric field
at play here and so their charged particles are accelerating in the vertical direction
due to a force that they applied which I'll discuss in a moment.
And the fact that they deflected towards the positive plate suggested straight away that
whatever the cathode rays were they were certainly negatively charged.
Now I only a moment ago mentioned that Heinrich Hertz was unable to deflect them through electric
field but it was only a few years that took place that allowed J.J.
Thompson to develop a much better and more accurate way of measuring the deflection of
electric field and so because of improvements in technology he was able to deflect these
cathode rays through the use of an electric field.
So let's discuss the nature of the movement of this negatively charged particle through
our electric field and as you can see I've set up here an electric field
as shown as the lines go from a positive plate to a negative plate.
Now how did he actually set this up?
Now a quick revision we should already know that an electric field
is determined by the amount of force per unit charge.
That is how we define an electric field it's the force per unit
charge and as you can see the unit is usually written as Newtons per Coulomb.
But of course how does he actually set this up?
J.J. Thompson sets this up by setting up a potential difference across this
and so we have a certain voltage.
Now what is voltage?
Now voltage is equal to the amount of work done per unit charge.
That's a definition if you remember your work from maybe earlier studies is that the definition
of voltage or potential is the work done per unit charge which is the same way as saying
the amount of potential energy per charge or energy per charge.
But what is work?
Now work is when you apply a force on an object over a certain displacement or distance.
In this case the distance is the separation here between these gaps.
So this is my distance over here and of course the voltage is this work done per unit charge.
So now all of a sudden if you look very carefully
I have F over Q here and F over Q is equal to the electric field.
So the electric field multiplied by the distance between the plates
gives me my potential difference or better way of saying it is that the electric field
can also be determined by the amount of voltage you apply over the distance
or the distance between the plates.
And so our units for electric field can not only be Newtons per Coulomb
but they can also be volts per meter.
And so very simply what JJ Thompson did was apply a voltage which he was able to regulate
and ensure that these plates were close enough so that the electric field was strong enough
to deflect this negatively charged particle.
And of course this negatively charged particle is experiencing a force
in this case in the upward direction.
Now it's moving also of course horizontally at a constant rate
and you should know that if an object has horizontal motion
and then it has an accelerated motion that is perpendicular to its constant motion
what you basically get here is projectile motion.
And in essence that is what happens to my charge.
They actually undergo projectile motion and that's because we have a net force acting
in the vertical while the object is moving horizontally.
And of course it doesn't.
In reality of course my projectile motion for this case would be actually much lighter
and in the case of JJ Thompson this would cause this to bend
and therefore as a result if we just go back to the diagram here
it would deflect and reach up here.
And the amount that would actually be moving up here
is determined by of course the force that's applied here.
And so he could measure that distance and notice that changing the voltage
would change the amount that the deflection occurred.
Before we go on about what JJ Thompson did
that was so different to the work of previous scientists
we need to quickly touch on the nature of the motion of a charge in a magnetic field.
So in this case we already know that we have a magnetic field like so
and we also of course have our moving charge which we know already is negatively charged.
If we have a moving negative charge then the conventional current
is actually in the opposite direction.
And so using your right hand slap rule you should know that the force that is going to be applied
will be applied in this direction.
But that of course will cause my charge here to change direction
and now head downward like so.
But the force will again in this case be perpendicular to the motion
and so will go in this direction.
And so what you in essence get in this case
is that my particle will actually follow a circular motion
because of the force always being perpendicular to the motion of my negatively charged particle.
And so in essence what you get is a force that is due to a charge
and that formula that determines the force that is experiencing is equal to Q, V and B
where Q is the charge, V is the velocity of my particle
and B is the strength of the magnetic field.
The larger this magnetic field is the tighter this is going to turn
and so what we end up getting is we have circular motion
and I'll touch on that in a moment in terms of the significance of that.
What JJ Thompson did was so different was he said well okay we know that an charged particle
our cathode ray can be deflected by an electric field
and it can be deflected by a magnetic field.
What he did was he did both.
So he was able to apply a magnetic field and an electric field
in the same region of his cathode ray tube.
And so as a result he was able to apply a electric field
that caused the charge to experience a force in the upward direction
but at the same time he was able to apply a force due to the magnetic field
that was in the opposite direction
and because he was able to determine the electric field by just changing the voltage
and the distance between the plates
and because he was able to determine the magnetic field
by changing the strength of the magnets
he was able to apply those fields so the forces that these charges experience
are equal but in opposite direction
and as a result my charged particle my cathode ray would remain undeflected
as it passed through both fields.
So let's have a look at that mathematically.
So first of all we know that we have the force due to the electric field
and the magnetic field being equal.
Now we know that the force due to the magnetic field is equal to Q V B.
We also know that the force due to the electric field
which we've already established is simply equal to E Q.
Now of course what he can do now because the two are now equal
because the forces are equal he was able to discount
or remove the value of the charge in this situation.
V of course is the velocity of the cathode ray
and you can now see that is simply equal to the electric field strength
divided by the magnetic field strength.
As I've said JJ Thompson already knew the electric field
he already knew the strength of the magnetic field
so now he was in a position to work out the velocity of this cathode ray
and he did work out the velocity
and he got a value of approximately 1 by 10 to the power of 7 meters per second.
So that's pretty good but can you see the significance of this?
The most important thing here is not what the value is but what it isn't.
It isn't C. It isn't the speed of light
and because Maxwell had already confirmed that the speed of light
or the speed of electromagnetic radiation is a constant value
namely 3 by 10 to the power of 8 meters per second
the fact that this velocity is not that value automatically settled the debate.
Whatever the cathode rays were they were not a form of electromagnetic radiation
because they were not traveling at this particular speed
they were traveling at another speed.
So that is the first part of JJ Thompson's significant contribution
but he goes further.
So now JJ Thompson already has established the velocity of his charged particles
and what he does is now just remove the electric field
and measures the amount of deflection in a different tube
where he was able to measure the amount of turning within a magnetic field
and so the first thing he does he understands that this is going under circular motion
so he understands that there is a centripetal force at play
and of course the centripetal force is equal to mv squared over r
but we know that the force that is occurring here
is the force due to the magnetic field
and we already know that is equal to q v b
but the thing is the two are exactly the same
the force on a charge in a magnetic field
is actually the centripetal force of that charge in the magnetic field
so what you now have is you have q v b equaling mv squared over r
so these two values are exactly the same
we can now rearrange this and clean this up
the first thing you need to see is that the v's cancel
the second thing is we can now rearrange this
and this is what j.j thompson did
because what he was interested in was the ratio of the charge to mass ratio
why?
because it was an actual value an empirical value
that was determined for a number of substances
so the charge to mass ratio was known for hydrogen for example
which we now know is simply a proton
and many other particular atoms as well
so they weren't able to work out necessarily a charge
but they were able to work out in a number of experiments
at least the mathematical ratio between the charge and the mass
of whatever object that they were studying
so if we clean this up you can see that the charge to mass ratio
ends up equaling v over br
now remember v was already determined by j.j thompson
by equating the force due to the electric field
and the force due to the magnetic field
we already have the magnetic field
but by measuring the amount of curvature
and remember what the charges do is that they cause a glass screen to fluoresce
he was able to determine the actual radius of the curvature
of this particular cathode ray
so he was able to determine v as well
and as a result he was able to work what we call the charge to mass ratio
it's equal to v over br
and what he discovered was this
j.j thompson was now able to calculate the charge to mass ratio
of this unknown cathode ray particle
it was already known for the hydrogen atom
which at that time was the smallest known atom around
which we of course we already know that
because it is made up of only one proton
and what he discovered was this
he discovered that the charge to mass ratio of this cathode ray
was 1800 times bigger than the charge to mass ratio of a hydrogen
1800 times
so that basically means that either
a the charge on my cathode ray is 1800 times bigger
than my charge the charge for my hydrogen
now that is one option
the other option is that the mass of my cathode ray
is 1800 times smaller than the mass of the hydrogen
now clearly the fact that the cathode ray could not be deflected by electric fields
suggests clearly that the charge is not 1800 times larger
than the charge of the hydrogen atom
so the only possible solution is that the mass is 1800 times smaller
now that in itself is pretty significant
so here we have the hydrogen atom
which at that time was to be known the smallest form of matter
here we have a cathode ray which we know to be a particle
and is 1800 times smaller than the hydrogen atom
so J.J. Thompson correctly surmised that we have here a new particle
and this new particle is 1800 times smaller than the proton
now the proton was discovered or at least understood in the early 1920s
but at the time of course we know this as to be hydrogen
secondly whatever this particle is it is also negatively charged
it has the same size as our hydrogen ion
and so what J.J. Thompson said well we have a new particle
and i'm going to give it a new name
and the new name is based on the greek word for amber
as we know amber is a petrified tree sap
and the name for amber in greek is electros
and hence we have the electron
so here is the discovery of the electron
by J.J. Thompson's work of cathode rays
by being able to deflect it with electric fields and magnetic fields accurately
and thus measuring also the radius of curvature of our cathode ray in a magnetic field
he was able to show conclusively that this particle that the cathode ray is made up
is the electron
interestingly enough we now know the actual ratio of the
mass between the hydrogen nucleus and the electron
and that value is 1836
so if you get the rest mass of a proton
and divide that by the rest mass of our electron
you're going to get 1836
that's pretty close to what J.J. Thompson worked out in the late 1800s
well i hope that's helped you understand the discovery of the electron
and a little bit of the physics behind it
please like this video if this has helped you
and by all means please share with your peers if you think this video is useful for them
if you want to see more of my videos please subscribe and share as well
thanks for watching
bye for now

