JJ Thomson Cathode Ray Tube Experiment: the Discovery of the Electron
A man named J.J. Thompson discovered the electron in 1897 and there are tons of videos about it,
but most of them ignore what Thompson himself said was the motivating factor. A debate about
how cathode rays move. Want to know not only how but why electrons were discovered? Let's go!
First, a little background about Joseph John Thompson, J.J. on publications to friends and
even to his own son. Thompson was born in Lancashire, England to a middle-class
bookseller. When Thompson was 14, he signed up to be an apprentice to a locomotive engineer.
However, they had a long waiting list and to fill the time he applied to and was accepted
as a freshman at Owens College. Thompson later recalled that quote,
the authorities at Owens College thought my admission was such a scandal. I expect they
feared that students would soon be coming in strollers, that they passed regulations
raising the minimum age for admission so that such a catastrophe should not happen again.
While in school, Thompson's father died and they didn't have enough money for him to get
the apprenticeship. Instead, he relied on scholarships at university, ironically leading
him to greater fame. In 1884, at the tender age of 28, Thompson applied to be the head of the
Cavendish Research Institute. He mostly applied as a lark and was surprised as anyone to get
the position. He said quote, I feel like a fisherman who has cast a line in an unlikely spot
and hooked a fish much too heavy for him to land. Suddenly Thompson had a lot of resources,
stability, and ability to research whatever he wanted. He ended up having an uncanny ability
to find new material to research. In fact, a full eight of his research assistants and his son
eventually earned Nobel prizes. But of course, like Thompson's own Nobel prize, that was in
the future. Why did J.J. Thompson discover the electron in 1897? Well, according to his
autobiography, quote, the discovery of the electron began with an attempt to explain the
discrepancy between the behavior of cathode rays under magnetic and electric forces. What did he
mean by that? Well, a cathode ray or a ray in a vacuum tube that emanates from the negative electrode
can be easily moved with a magnet. This fact gave a charismatic English chemist named William Crookes
the crazy idea that the cathode ray was made of charged particles in 1879. However, five years
later, a young German scientist named Heinrich Hertz found that he could not get the beam to
move with parallel plates or with an electric field. Hertz decided that Crookes was wrong.
If the cathode ray was a beam of charged particles, then it should be attracted to a positive plate
and repelled from the negative plate. And Hertz decided it was some kind of new electromagnetic
wave, like a new kind of ultraviolet light. Further in 1892, Hertz accidentally discovered
the cathode rays could tunnel through thin pieces of metal, which seemed like further proof that
Crookes was so very wrong. Then in December 1895, a French physicist named Jean Perrin used a magnet
to direct the cathode ray into and out of an electroscope called a Faraday cylinder and
measured its charge. Perrin wrote, quote, the Faraday cylinder became negatively charged when
cathode rays are thus charged with negative electricity. This is why J.J. Thompson was so
confused. He felt that Perrin had, quote, conclusive evidence that the rays carried a charge of negative
electricity, except that, quote, Hertz had found that when they were exposed to an electric force,
they were not deflected at all. What was going on? Thompson wondered if there might have been
something wrong with Hertz's experiment with the tube plate. Thompson knew that the cathode ray
tubes that they had only work if there's a little bit of air in the tube. And Thompson wondered if
the air affected the results. Through a trial in air, Thompson found he could get a stronger beam
by shooting it through a positive anode with a hole in it. With this system, he could evacuate
the tube to a much higher degree. And if the vacuum was good enough, the cathode ray was moved
by electrically charged plates, just as negatively electrified particles would be. If you're wondering
why the little bit of air affected it, it's because the air became ionized in the higher electric
field and became conductive. The conductive air then acted like a Faraday cage, shielding the
beam from the electric field. As stated before, Heinrich Hertz also found that the cathode ray
could move through thin metals. How could a particle do that? Well, Thompson thought maybe
particles could do that if they're moving really, really fast. But how to find how fast the cathode
beam was moving? He used the fact that he could move it both with an electric field and a magnetic
field to make an electromagnetic gauntlet. First, Thompson put a magnet near the ray to deflect the
ray one way, and then he added charge to the plates so that the forces were balanced and the ray went
in a straight line. Thompson knew that the force from the magnet depended on the charge of the
particle, its speed, and the magnetic field, given the letter B. He also knew that the electric force
from the plates only depended on the charge of the particle and the electric field. Since these forces
were balanced, Thompson could determine the speed of the particle from the ratio of the two fields.
Thompson found speeds up to 60,000 miles per hour, or up to a third of the speed of light.
Thompson recalled, quote, in all cases where the cathode rays are produced, their velocity is much
greater than the velocity of any other moving body which we are acquainted. Thompson then did something
even more ingenious. He removed the magnetic field. Now he had a beam of particles moving at a known
speed with a single force on them. They would fall, as Thompson said, quote, like a bullet projected
horizontally with velocity V. Note that the gravitational force is much, much smaller than
the electric force on such light objects and therefore can be ignored. By measuring the distance
the cathode ray went, he could determine the time they were in the tube, and by the distance they
fell, Thompson could determine their acceleration. Using F equals ma, Thompson determined the ratio
of the charge on the particle to the mass, or E over m. He found some very interesting results.
First, no matter what he changed about the experiment, the value of E over m remained
constant. Quote, we may use any kind of substance we please for the electrodes and fill the tube
with gas of any kind, and yet the value of E over m will remain the same. This was revolutionary.
Thompson concluded that everything was filled with these tiny little things that he called
corpsicles, but we now call electrons, and that the corpsicles in one item are exactly the same
as the corpsicles in another. So for example, an oxygen molecule contains the same kind of electrons
as a piece of gold. Atoms are the building blocks of matter, but inside the atoms there are these
tiny electrons that are the same for everything. The other crazy result he found was the value of
E over m was enormous, about 1700 times bigger than that for a charged hydrogen atom, which had
the biggest value of E over m for anything they had found before, which meant that either these
corpsicles were very very highly charged, or they were tiny. A student of Thompson's named C.T.R.
Wilson had experimented with slowly falling water droplets and found that the charge on the
corpsicles were, to the accuracy of the experiment, the same as the charge on a charged hydrogen atom.
Thompson therefore came to some really interesting conclusions. One, electrons are in everything and
are well over a thousand times smaller than even the smallest atom. Two, Benjamin Franklin thought
positive objects had too much electrical fire and negative had too little. Really, positive objects
have too few electrons and negative have too many. Oops! Three, although since Franklin people thought
current flowed from positive to negative, really the electrons are flowing the other way. When a
person talks about the current that flows from positive to negative, they're talking about
something that is not real. True electrical current flows from negative to positive and that's the way
the electrons move. However, by the time people believed J.J. Thompson, it was too late to change
our electronics, so people just decided to stick with, quote, conventional current going the wrong way.
Sorry! Four, since electrons are tiny and in everything, but most things have a neutral charge
and because solid objects are solid, the electrons must be swimming in a sea or soup of mildly
positive material, like raisins in a raisin cookie. The first three conclusions are still considered
correct over a hundred years later. The fourth theory is called the plum pudding model. It is
named after a truly English dessert that they tortured people with during Christmas. It was
proposed by Thompson in 1904. In 1909, a former student of Thompson's named Ernest Rutherford
was experimenting with radiation and inadvertently demolished the plum pudding model in the process.
However, before I can get to Thompson's gold foil experiment, I first want to talk about what was
happening in France concurrent to Thompson's experiments. This is the story of how a new mother,
working mostly in a converted shed, discovered and named the radium and radiation that Rutherford
was experimenting with. That woman's name was Marie Goldowska Curie, otherwise known as Madam Curie,
and her story is next time on the Lightning Tamers. If you're watching my video, please remember to subscribe,
please remember to give it a thumbs up. Also, if you're confused about the history of the cathode ray,
I have videos about that. If you're interested in more about Heinrich Hertz, I have videos about that.
I have a lot of videos. Why don't you subscribe, and then you can spend all day watching my videos.
Okay, have a nice day. Please remember to put a comment. It always makes me happy,
unless your comment is, I didn't like your video. And please remember to give it a thumbs up,
unless you're planning on giving it a thumbs down, in which case, skip it.

