The Preservation and Restoration of a Limber Chest - 382

Jay Bates
100 followers
Jul 15, 2025
Playlist for all of my history-related videos: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLoEggaYbboJFdbghzXt49htP1ifDb2xhi
Alright, Mr. Duffy from the Starkville Civil War Arsenal is back with another chest that he just acquired.
Tell us a little bit about this chest real quick.
Well, it's remarkable. I know if you possibly saw the last video we did, we restored a chest like this about a year ago
and we thought it would never happen again, and about a month ago I got a call from a man in Vermont.
He was out deer hunting about 40 years ago, found this chest out in the woods, thought it was too good to leave in the woods,
was dragged it home and was always going to restore it, and that was 43 years ago.
And he saw Jay's video that Jay put out on the 160-year-old chest.
He saw that video and decided that we would be the people to restore it.
So he donated it to the Starkville Civil War Arsenal with the stipulation that we do restore it and preserve it.
Because it does need some help, it needs some cleaning, obviously it's really clean, so we're going to try and clean it
and then we're going to do some preservation work on it.
But the goal is to make it complete and whole again, but not to change structurally.
We're only going to put replacement parts that are missing.
Things like this plate right here that is obviously gone.
Rusted away.
It's just rusted away. This should have a 90-degree bend that should fit up underneath there.
Same way on the end, there's plates on the end.
You can see that these went underneath.
So we are going to replace those with exact reproduction, same specifications.
So we are going to replace anything that's missing, but structurally we're just trying to stabilize it
and get it ready for the future generations again.
Let me squeeze through here real quick.
You can see the inside of the lid still has some, if not all, of the stenciling.
There's some under here that...
Actually, the camera is doing a better job showing it up than it's actually showing in person.
The HDR of the camera.
So that actually doesn't show up that well in person.
So we're going to clean up all of this.
Give the whole chest a cleaning.
That's step number one.
So Duffy's checking with a magnet to see what nail heads are original
because the original ones are not magnetic.
Copper.
They're copper.
So there's a whole row that is magnetic, so they're not original.
Little stuff like that needs to be removed.
It's coming off.
So there's no...
Well, it's hinged at the top, so...
Hold on, hold on, hold on.
I think we're glued right here and I don't want this piece to break off.
Let's think about this.
Turns out this panel is nailed right there.
There's one nail through the rabbet and we've got the magnet on the other nail.
So literally in this state, it's just hanging on by those two nails.
Now if we just pull it out, we risk damaging this and this fragile piece here.
So I'm going to use an oscillating tool to cut into the wood down here and sever that nail
and then we'll pull the scab off after the fact.
We got the bottom panel off and we're doing some thinking about the joinery here.
So tongue and groove is known to be used as well as a bunch of grooves with a spline in between
and we're thinking that that's most likely the case.
So we initially thought that this was a lap joint
because just at first glance of the surviving other piece...
So this was somewhere, right? We don't know exactly where, but it was somewhere.
It's the only surviving piece and we just looked at it and thought,
well, that's a lap joint, right?
But after further inspection, you can clearly see that the top is broken off on both sides.
So that looks like a tongue groove, a tongue on both sides here.
I'm sorry, a groove on both sides for a tongue and groove joint.
A groove on both sides with the top side broken off.
Well, after looking at this, my initial thought was, well, if that's a tongue,
well, if that's a groove, then this is a tongue because it looks like it right here.
But the more we think about it, they used grooves and splines quite frequently.
And if that's the case, this could have a groove, a spline glued into the groove.
I'm getting tongue-tied here.
A spline glued in and then it was just broken off when the repair was made.
So we're leaning towards that.
And that also makes sense because as they're milling these up,
you only need one plane to make a groove joint,
where you need two planes to make a tongue and a groove.
So it would be less tooling to make just a bunch of grooves and throw a spline in there.
And that's what we think is going on.
And this was somewhere.
I believe it's right there because this is where the inlay for the corner end plate.
So we pretty much know exactly where that one was.
Left or right, but that was a centerpiece.
Yeah, it had to be a centerpiece.
That's right because it doesn't have the inlay for the strapping up here.
So that's the remaining section of the center board.
More like that.
That's interesting.
Well, we cleaned this up a little bit,
and there's a definite gunk groove right here and on the backside.
And after a little bit of wiping the stuff away,
that is without question a spline and a groove, not an interval tongue.
Moment of truth, we got all of the screws out.
Is it just stuck there?
Yeah, all the screws are out. It's just stuck there.
So let's see those dovetail joints.
Wow, that whole corner just fell off.
I think it can be put back together, though, believe it or not.
May be able to salvage that.
But that's an interesting sight.
What year do you think this is from?
Let's say range, rather.
1840s to 50s?
The white 12-pounder came about in 1857, and they stopped making them in 1865.
You can see on the top here the dovetail stops
because with the lid open you can see that this is a mitered joint.
And you're going to spritz it real quick?
For the camera.
Excuse me.
Oh, go ahead.
That's not what I expected.
There.
So we just noticed that these things were built like tanks.
So a big, massive, wide dovetail joint.
Then it is reinforced with nails through every other tail
to keep the tails in place opposite of the dovetail.
And then it's wrapped with steel for the corner.
Or iron plate for the corner.
That's what you do when you don't want something to move.
Now my question is, are the nails there to simply stop
or eliminate the step of adding glue?
Did they just dry fit this, use nails, and then...
Built a wooden box and then send it to the guys that ironed it.
Put the irons on.
So when they sent them the box, it was a very stable wooden box
to handle, turn upside down, do whatever they wanted
as they started placing all these irons on.
Most of these screws holding the irons on
had deteriorated enough that the holes needed some attention.
Whether it was the problem with the hole
or the threads deteriorating, messing up the hole,
they all needed attention.
So to eliminate any issues installing the screws,
all of the holes were plugged with dowels.
And this will provide some solid material for every new screw
to grab onto when the irons are finally installed.
Next up, we started milling white oak for the bottom panels.
And the original build specs for this, it's kind of interesting.
It states that the case, the lid, and the center divider
are all to be made from walnut.
The removable dividers, the divider liners, and the tray
were to be made from poplar.
And then the bottom panel and the bolsters
to be made from white oak.
So we milled a spline joint for the two new boards
and made a concession for the joints
between the original and the new boards.
So I was concerned with how accurate I could cut the spline
on the original bottom board with some stuff kind of in the way.
And that as well as kind of removing too much material
and making that joint brittle because that board is so old.
So here's what we did.
We opted for using biscuits to help with the alignment
and then to glue the center board to the original.
It's not 100% accurate, but we thought it was kind of
the best solution for preserving the last remaining piece
of the bottom panel.
So we glued the middle board to the original board,
inserted the spline, and then glued the outside board
into the rabbet.
And then put some weight on it to kind of let it dry
for a few days, but Duffy's going to go back
and nail along the entire perimeter
according to the specs in the original contract.
The next day of work started with the new
and the refurbished plates.
I think only one of these was a replacement.
The others were just cleaned up and then patched
as needed with a TIG welder.
These are inset into the bottom panel,
so the profile was traced and then the bulk of the waste
was removed with a router and then finished off
with chisels until all the pieces fit
like they were supposed to.
At this point, we were able to flip the chest over
to work on the top.
So the top structure, it's basically a walnut frame
and panel with a domed profile to shed the water,
which is pretty interesting.
The lid is then covered in copper,
and as you can see, this copper has definitely
seen better days.
However, the back corners are in perfect shape,
and there's some folding that went on
to get it to wrap around the corners.
It would be a shame to not let that example
of craftsmanship live on,
so the idea here was to very carefully
remove all of the copper nails,
and then the entire copper top was pulled off
so we could clean underneath it.
Duffy would later decide on what to do
with the front of that copper.
Under the copper, we found all kinds of junk.
We found some copper nails.
We found some modern steel nails,
which obviously don't belong.
We found some old cut nails,
but mostly a bunch of metal BBs.
Now, we initially thought that this was from
like a shotgun, considering how many there were,
but also, considering that we didn't find
any through holes in the copper,
just indentions,
my guess is that kids used it for target practice
with a BB gun
while it spent part of its life outside in the woods.
Next up are the removable dividers,
and the specs called for these to be made
from a solid piece of poplar.
If I recall correctly, they were about 11 inches wide,
so Duffy brought a pretty huge piece of poplar for this.
The extra that I cut off happened to be perfect
for the tray that I'll build in just a little bit.
All of these panels were milled to their final size,
and we also cut the divider liner pieces.
These will be nailed to the inside of the case,
and a pair on either side will locate the divider,
and then allow it to slide in and out of the case,
and the tips of these, they look kind of rough right now,
but they'll all be rounded over by hand.
These and the dividers were wrapped,
and then set aside for Duffy to install at his place.
While we're talking about the poplar,
I did use the offcuts to make a tray,
and I made a separate video on making this tray.
I'm not sure exactly what day it was that I made this,
or if it fits in this order of the video,
but I made a separate video on this tray,
and one of the interesting things about the tray
is there was a center hole in the bottom of the tray,
and what's kind of interesting is,
what's the reasoning behind that?
While I made the video, and while I made the tray,
at that time, I did not know the reasoning for it,
and I just guessed that it's probably due
to something like the piston fit.
If you make a box with a very, very tight-fitting tray,
and you set it on top,
it'll slowly fall down on an air cushion,
and as woodworkers, that's just a good sign
of a precise fit.
Well, you don't want that in a functional piece like this,
where, you know, you're in battle, basically,
so I think that the center hole,
or I thought that the center hole
was to prevent a piston fit,
and I did end up finding some documentation to confirm that.
45-degree bolster blocks are also needed
between the dividers to help locate the ammunition,
and we milled these to size,
just, you know, nothing major,
just a 45-degree block of white oak,
and then drilled some counterboard holes
for the installation.
Again, these were set aside
for Duffy to install at his place.
All of the poplar dividers are removable,
but there is one walnut divider
that is placed directly in the middle,
and it is not removable.
It fits into a dado in the front and back of the case,
and will later be bolted in place.
This was a pretty large board,
both in width and thickness,
and I really, really did not want to cut it too small,
so I took my time milling it down,
and I used a scrap piece of MDF
to really help determine the exact fit.
Back to the lid for some repair work on the lid frame,
and like I said, it's a frame and panel,
so you basically have a rail-in-style cabinet door, right?
In this case, the front and back pieces
are the ones that extend all the way,
so they're the ones that have the end grain exposed.
The lid also has an interior rabbet
all the way around where the stencil panel is nailed to,
and that rabbet results in kind of a high area
near the end grain where the wood can very easily chip off.
This is the second of these chests
that I've worked on with Duffy,
and both of them required this area to be repaired.
The solution is to square up the chipped area
so a block of walnut can first be glued into place,
and then trimmed flush with the rest of the lid.
Both of the front corners of the chest
needed this to be patched.
The last little bit of work in my shop
was to drill the hole for the through bolt
in the center walnut panel.
So what we have here is a 20-something-inch-long
1⁄2-inch-diameter bolt
that needs to go all the way through the chest
and through the 1-inch-thick center divider.
For this, I picked up an 18-inch-long,
9⁄16-inch auger bit.
This is a wood-owl auger bit,
which will allow us to drill halfway through
from either side.
This...this was stressful,
to say the least.
The only guides we had here
were the original holes to start the bit.
So as far as tracking left or right,
that's pretty easy for me to do.
I'm the one holding the drill,
so I can visually look at it
and tell if I need to go left or right
to maintain, you know, in alignment
with that center divider.
For the vertical alignment, I don't really know
because, you know, I can't really tell
how high I am in comparison to the top
of the center divider.
So I had Duffy stand back at a distance
so he could look at both the drill bit
as well as the top of the panel
and let me know if I needed to go
up or down a little bit to keep it tracking
parallel with the panel top.
Again, this was...this was just nerve-wracking,
but in the end, we were able to get it done.
Finally, the bolt can be installed,
and for that,
some lubrication was shot into the hole.
I forget exactly what we used,
but it sure couldn't hurt at this point.
And the half-inch bolt
was driven all the way
through the entire chest.
This is pretty interesting, the way this works.
The front of the bolt
contains the latch for the lid,
and then the back of the bolt
is secured with just a washer
and a square nut. And with that work done,
the work in my shop
was done. Everything else
was taken to Duffy's house
to be completed as time allowed.
Hallelujah!
That was stressful.
I think it's gonna be
just fine.
And here we are back at Duffy's
Museum. Before we talk about the
restoration of the rest of this video,
I want to reference this
24-pound howitzer chest
that we worked on last time. I've got a
video you can check out for that,
as well as firing
this sweet-gum mortar in both
daytime and nighttime. Pretty cool stuff.
So, this
is the completed chest.
Duffy did all the rest
of the work here in his shop. There's one
thing that I want to reference before we begin,
and that is
this sticker
or paper that was
supposed to be put on the very bottom,
I don't know if you can see that, it says
this sheet is to be glued on the inside
of the limber chest cover.
But,
you didn't want to put that on there, did you?
No, just couldn't cover up
all that beautiful old wood.
Well, let's open it up and see the inside.
So, we'll talk about the lid and all that in just a second.
But, on the inside,
we have this
stencil that
really cleaned up quite nice.
It wasn't this visible, all the little
stenciling was not this visible when we
first got it.
That's basically all you did to the inside
cover right here, right? And removed
the nails and such that weren't there.
The repair job
on both inside corners blends
really, really well, so that's pretty cool.
The tray, he's aged it a little bit
and it's very interesting.
Of course, you can't really show it too much on camera,
but when you open
that up and then put it back
in there, the center air hole,
you can feel it on your face.
Air just being rushed right back
into you.
But, anyway, that's the reasoning
for the hole. On this side,
we have the dividers
and these were called
liners, is that what those are?
Yes. These two are the original
and then everything else
has been replaced
or remade.
And this is the one
original partition.
Everything else has been replaced.
So, original, replace, replace,
and then original, liners,
and then replace, replace.
So, you can see the originals
have that kind of rounded taper
and some of them are rounded,
some of them are straight, and we try
to replicate that with these over
here.
Let's take the tray out.
Give it a little
snug fit.
And those blocks on the
bottom, those 45 degree blocks, those were the
bolster blocks
that we referenced
earlier. And all of these
dividers, these partitions, they
all slide out.
Of course, the center
walnut that we put that bolt
all the way through, that was a little bit stressful, like we
mentioned. But,
you kind of can't tell that some of these
pieces are replaced. Now,
lighting is not great,
but, the far...
You know what, Duffy?
I can't even tell which one's the original bottom panel.
Which one is it, the front or the back?
Let me think for a second.
I guess that's a good...
It's got to be this one.
This has got to be the original.
Yeah, it's that one. That's the original.
In this orientation, the right
one is the original panel,
and the middle and left are the replacement.
They're aged
a little bit, visually,
and it all looks like...
It all looks like it was supposed to.
Now, one thing that's pretty interesting
is... Let me get out of the light here.
These
bolsters are secured
to the dividers, so they come up
with it, which means
that this one, you couldn't have the
holes in the same location. Of course, you could offset them,
but the contract specified
that one of these was
secured through this side,
and the other one secured through
this side as well. So, the screws
that were used to hold this on
are hidden behind this bolster
as well.
I'm not sure if it really...
You think they did that to
reduce the amount of metal...
Oops! Metal exposed?
Possibly. Possibly.
Or it was just easier
to put them in there than to
work at that crazy 45-degree angle.
Alright, well,
let's close it, pull it away from the wall a little bit,
and we'll get around to the perimeter of it.
One thing to note here
is this board
was one of the
replacement bottom panels
when Duffy received the chest, so
this was not to
original specs, but it did spend quite a bit
of its life in the chest, so we wanted
to keep it with the chest, so
all I did was just
carve a sign out of it, and
that's one way to keep this piece
with the chest.
So we have it sitting on a crate here, we can walk around it,
and
on the front,
you may remember that there was a bunch of damage
up here, and we contemplated
leaving it completely original,
having that damage shown and all that,
or just filling it in,
and obviously Duffy went with filling it in.
This is
somewhat the same green color.
Now, what was the specs for as far as
green color? Did they have any specific green?
It was called
olive drab, but all I did was
match the inside cover.
So that's matched
to the inside lid, which is the original
paint. Yeah, so it's a little bit of
interpretation, but, you know, what do you do?
You can't match paint that's
200 years old or whatever it was.
Here's one
side over here, and again
you can see the original
craftsmanship on these corners is preserved,
so that was the original fold.
He was able to get it all put back
together, and I think the other side's a little bit
better.
Irons look nice
on this side. Did you end up filling the
slots
of the screws? Yes, I did.
Yeah, so the originals,
these
slots of the screws were filled
with white lead,
and they're filled
as they're put back in.
This is the back
side of that bolt that we put all
the way through, so I
was mistaken. I said that this was a
washer and a square
nut. The iron
here acts as a washer, and then it's just a square
nut on top of that.
And if I'm not mistaken,
this corner, this
original corner
looks really good, if I can get this to focus
here.
So that's all
original craftsmanship.
It's really
cool to be able to preserve that. Now,
my
question is, how
were you going to preserve the
top, the original
copper with so much damage to it?
So just explain here what
exactly you did to preserve
that. Well, we had a couple different options,
and we went with the simplest one.
We simply took a piece of copper,
same gauge, and slipped
it up underneath, bent the
corners to match, and then just
overlapped the original
copper over the top.
You know, we had thought
about cutting it off and then getting
a nice, clean
butt joint. We could have soldered
it and then ground it down, but
the more and more I looked at
it, and the more and more Jay and I looked
at it, you know, this was
1860s copper,
and we wanted to preserve every
bit of it. I used
about 95%
of the original nails that came out.
I sat there with a little ball-peen hammer
and a little anvil and straightened
them out. I spent about a day
straightening out over 200
copper nails, but
I just thought it was important to put
those nails back in there, so all the
nails that came out all went back in.
That's cool. And then the
copper obviously was
colorized, or I aged it
with a couple of different chemicals
just
to get rid of that brand-new look.
Well, that's
cool. It's done, and it is now
on display in your museum, so
if you guys are interested in actually
checking out the rest of this museum, there's
quite a few gems
in this place, and this is just
one small room
of many here. So if you're
interested, you can go to his website,
StarkbullCivilWarArsenal.com,
and you can
find his contact info, contact Mr. Duffy,
and maybe set up an appointment to
check all this stuff out.
That's it for this video. You guys take care, and I'll catch you
in the next one.
