China and the U.S. just signed a temporary trade deal—but don’t let the headlines fool you. While Chinese state media declared a triumphant “win,” the reality is far more one-sided. In this talk, I’ll break down what the agreement really says, the four major concessions Beijing quietly made, and why Xi Jinping had no choice but to fold. We’ll also look at China’s bizarre movie schedule changes—and what they reveal about the Party’s true mindset. From tariffs to propaganda, here’s the truth behind the deal that gave Xi a lifeline… for just 47 days.
Hello everyone, welcome to Lei's Real Talk.
Lei has a new internet connection, so hopefully this will work better.
Let's see.
All right, after two intense days of negotiations,
China and the US have reached a temporary agreement for a trade truce.
It's the most significant breakthrough since the trade war began back in 2018.
It created a so-called win-win moment that brought short-term relief to global markets.
But beneath the surface, deep structural differences
underscoring long-term frictions in US-China relations.
As soon as the joint statement was released,
China and state media kicked off a full-blown propaganda campaign, declaring victory.
Some online nationalists even linked the outcome to China's military strength,
claiming a strong military naturally settles trade disputes.
Other patriotic Chinese pointed to China's diplomatic confidence.
After all, China sent only a vice premier to talks in Switzerland,
rather than dispatching a top leader to Washington.
Former Global Times editor Hu Xijin was quick to weigh in, calling it a triumph of courage over
hegemonic pressure. He said China had once again won big.
Surprisingly, some American media echoed Hu's narrative.
MSNBC claimed the US just blinked. Really?
CNN said Trump's biggest win wasn't the deal, but his distortion of reality.
And Washington Post ran, China celebrates hard-line stance after trade deal with the US.
So today, let's cut through the noise and take a closer look.
What's actually in this agreement? And who blinked? And who really came out on top?
And what hidden concessions did China make? In my opinion, they made four major concessions.
And despite all the narratives, how does Beijing truly feel about this deal?
So first things first, what's in the agreement? I'm going to give you a very brief summary.
Based on the joint statement, here's what the US-China
agreed. First, the United States will maintain a 50% total tariff on Chinese goods. This includes
20% from Section 301 tariffs, which came from Trump's original trade war number one,
20% fentanyl-related punitive tariffs imposed in February and March, 10% reciprocal tariffs
from the April 2nd global tariff hike. Now China, in return, will impose only a 10%
tariff on US goods and will drop all other retaliatory measures, including the rare earth
export ban. So it's a US 50% and China 10%. Many media outlets used 30% versus 10%.
They failed to mention that the 20% in existing tariffs remained untouched. So let's break it
down and compare the US-China tariff trajectory chronologically. Section 301 tariffs began in
2018, covering nearly all Chinese exports to the US, with a weighted average of about 10% at the
time. Under Biden, these tariffs weren't rolled back. In fact, some were expanded. By the time
Trump returned to office in 2025, the average US tariff on Chinese goods
ranged from 5% to 25%, settling at about 20% on average. Meanwhile, China's baseline tariff on US
goods was about 7%. This is according to a financial analyst based in Hong Kong.
So here are the numbers. So why 7% or why only 7%? Well, according to the analyst,
this is China's nominal tariff rate. It looks low on paper, but Beijing uses non-tariff barriers
like VAT, consumption taxes, and strict certification rules to block imports.
These measures have long frustrated American exporters.
Then Trump came back to power in January 2025, and the pressure on Beijing escalated quickly.
So in February and March, citing CCP's lack of action on fentanyl smuggling, the United States
imposed two rounds of 10% punitive tariffs, adding another 20% tariff across all Chinese
exports. In response, China announced countermeasures targeting US agriculture,
energy, and machinery. But in practice, none were enforced. Why? Well, because China operates under
a strict import licensing system. Only state-owned enterprises or SOEs are allowed to import such
goods. These SOEs avoid the tariffs by simply submitting a statement called
Supplying Chain Irreplaceability. This document cites Article 57 of China's customs law,
and they get exemptions. China's customs never challenged them, never challenged the SOEs.
So the only ones that got hurt are the few small private companies importing low-volume
niche products that they can't get anywhere else. So by March 2025, China's real tariff rate on US
goods was about 15%, a moderate or a modest 8% increase. Meanwhile, US tariffs on China
had climbed from 20% to 40%. So here's this comparison. That's March.
That's before April 2nd. Then came April 2nd, the liberation day for Trump's trade strategy.
On that day, the United States launched a full-scale tariff war, imposing reciprocal
tariffs globally. Only China retaliated. Other regions, like the EU and Canada,
talked tough but didn't act. During this phase, US tariffs on China escalated to 165%,
combining the new 125% reciprocal tariffs plus the existing 40% baseline. China too
raised its tariffs, at least on paper, to 125% as retaliation. Then came May 2025,
the dramatic climbdown in Switzerland. At the Geneva talks, China essentially folded.
Its delegation dropped tariffs on US goods from 125% to just 10%, and canceled all other
countermeasures, including rare earth bans. This means all 2025 retaliatory measures are gone.
Also, China has fully accepted US punitive tariffs. Let's put it this way. Only a fool
in Washington would say no to this offer. So why China can't really retaliate? Well,
it's because China's imports of US goods, especially in agriculture, energy, and critical
machinery, are non-substitutable, if there's a word. Is there a word called non-substitutable?
Yes? Okay. All right. Tariffs on these would only hurt China's economy, so that's why Beijing's
hands are tied. So that's what I say. The Geneva framework states that US tariffs on China is 50%,
and China's tariffs on US goods are 50%. So that brings the US tariffs level back to Trump's
original April 2nd proposal. At the time, China rejected those terms, but now they quietly
accepted them. The other point is both sides have agreed to continue negotiation over a 90-day
period, but this 90-day period started retroactively on April 2nd. That means the deadline
is July 1st, and it's only 47 days away. The two countries have only six weeks left to conclude
negotiations. If no agreement is reached, the US will impose another 24%, pushing the overall
tariff to 78%. There's more. The US has kept the punitive tariffs on strategic sectors,
including automobiles, semiconductors, steel and aluminum, and pharmaceuticals.
And these tariffs range from 50% to 100%. But since China exports little in these sectors,
comparatively speaking, they only nudge the average tariff up by 4% to 5% on a weighted scale.
So that puts the real average US tariff on China at about 54%. My proof? Well, Trump just signed an
executive order yesterday setting... Is it today or yesterday? I'm blind. I lost track. Maybe today.
He adjusted the tariffs on small Chinese parcels. He lowered the tariff on the small parcels from
120% to 54%. So it was 120% or $200, whichever is higher. Now he lowered it to 54% or $100.
So I think this 54% that he used is really the real average US tariff on Chinese goods.
If you put everything in, if you weigh everything together. But if you look at
the bottom line is US tariffs on China, 54%. That's up from 40% in March. That's a 14 points
uptick. And China's tariffs on US is 10%. That's down five points. So let me just show you this
slide. So this is a chronological order of China's tariffs or the US-China tariffs.
So it's pretty clear who won and who lost. So to summarize, Beijing made four major concessions.
First, China effectively accepted all pre-April 2nd US tariffs. 20% from Section 301,
from Trade War 1.0, 20% for fentanyl, plus a new 10% base tariff, totaling 50%. In contrast,
China is only imposing 10% on US goods. That's a 40 point gap. And this was China's first major
concession. Second, China agreed to suspend all non-tariff countermeasures, including,
since April 22nd, including the rare earth bans, soybean restrictions, and investigations into US
firms like DuPont. However, the United States made no reciprocal move. For example, the ban
on Nvidia's H20 chip remains firmly in place. Third, China reportedly agreed to specific US
demands related to fentanyl, which has caused America's opiate crisis. Meanwhile, the 20%
US fentanyl tariffs still hold, along with 25% sectional tariffs on steel, aluminum, bottles,
and meats. Fourth, while not formally detailed, reports have suggested that China quietly pledged
to increase imports of American agricultural and energy products.
So that's obviously a move aimed at narrowing the trade gap and placating Washington.
So this agreement is a temporary reprieve for Xi Jinping. It gave Xi Jinping and the CCP
a desperately needed break, a moment to catch their breath before the ship sinks. To put it
bluntly, the mood inside the CCP leadership right now can be described as, it's like being granted
a royal pardon. And it is not just people like me who took notice. I'm not making this up. The
Chinese public have also noticed the mood change. And how do we know that? Well, sometimes you just
need to watch what they want you to watch. A recent curious programming change on CCTV's
movie channel became a public interest in China. Monday morning, there's an official
government news outlet called Changjiang Cloud News. It's a state media outlet. It posted a
screenshot of CCTV's movie schedule on Weibo. The post announced that following substantial progress
in US-China economic and trade talks, CCTV would air two parts of a movie called New York, I Love
You on Monday night at 10.24 p.m. and 11.00 p.m. And then after that, the post tagged CCTV
channel schedule's New York, I Love You quickly went viral and shot to the top of Weibo's trending
and Chinese public smelled something. Well, here I have a poster of the movie
New York, I Love You. This was a 2008 American romantic comedy. It was a sequel to a 2006
French film called Paris, I Love You. But this movie change was a red flag because it felt
oh so familiar. Back in 2018 and 2019, when the US-China trade war 1.0 was heating up,
CCTV responded with a stream of anti-American Korean War movies like Battle on Shanganling.
And also there's a movie called In Xiong Er Nu or Heroic Sons and Daughters. These are very
patriotic propaganda movies. But right after a call took place between Xi Jinping and Trump,
the same movie channel pivoted dramatically and aired the movie called Brief Over the Yellow
River. It's a love story between a Chinese revolutionary soldier and American Flying
Tigers pilot. I don't know how that can be possible, but apparently there's a movie made
about it. This time in trade war 2.0, the declaration of love to America was even more
overt and embarrassing because Chinese netizens took notice and brainwashed Chinese nationalists
to find it hard to take. And soon the CCTV replaced the movie, not once but twice.
First, they replaced New York, I Love You with a 1936 old movie. They replaced it with this movie,
Camille, right? It's an old movie. There's an opera, Verdi wrote an opera called La Traviata
based on this story. And in Chinese, we say Cha Huan Yu. It's a famous tragic love story.
Okay, then realizing they made another mistake, the CCTV movie channel replaced Camille with
a feel-good Italian comedy called Welcome to the South. I spent time trying to find these movie
posters. So why do these movies matter? Well, don't assume these changes were random. They reflect
Beijing's internal mood better than any press release. New York, I Love You and the movie
The Grief Over the Yellow River share the same message. China knows it cannot survive without
the Americans and does not want to be separate from America. Both movies are about finding true
love and needing each other. And Camille, or La Traviata, was likely pulled after internal pushback.
Why? Well, because it's a tragic love story. For a regime that compares US-China relations to a
couple and itself to the female lead, that's a bad omen. The female lead in La Traviata or in Camille
died tragically. So in the end, CCTV settled on the movie called Welcome to the South. It's a
light-hearted, feel-good 2010 Italian comedy, which is about cultural misunderstandings.
It's a sign that Beijing needed to lighten the mood and save face. So who really blinked and
if you're still wondering who won the trade talks, just look at the trail of these Chinese movies.
They spoke volume about Beijing's true mindset. All right, let's talk about what's ahead.
I have not seen any of these movies. I watched the opera. I saw the opera, La Traviata,
because it's such a famous opera. My family members are fans of classical music.
My mother is a big fan of Italian opera. Anyways, the opera is what I have seen.
So what's ahead? Despite the temporary truce, there are two major issues remaining, in my
opinion, that are fundamentally unresolvable in the next 47 days. First is fentanyl.
Fentanyl isn't just a drug. It isn't a drug issue. It's a weapon. It's been widely reported
that Xi Jinping's fentanyl policy was a strategic operation to weaken America from within. It was
his, quote-unquote, new opium war against the United States. And the project was even given
a code name. It's called Project Zero. As long as Xi Jinping remains in power,
no meaningful agreement on fentanyl is ever going to be possible between the two countries.
The only scenario for the resolution, a post-Xi Jinping leadership transition or a post-CCP
scenario. And the second issue is free market access. President Trump has made it crystal
clear. He wants China to open its market. He said so on his Air Force One. He mentioned it again,
I think, in the last day or so. But here's the reality. Any sector that still remains closed in
China now, after 30 years of opening up, is never going to open, at least not under CCP's rule.
And this includes media, the media sector, financial services, telecommunications,
digital services or platforms, education, and maybe even more. These are the
major sectors that came to my mind. These industries will remain off-limits to foreign
competition so long as the CCP controls China. If Beijing opens them for foreign competition,
they will lose control of the country. That's the end of the regime, or that equates to the
end of the regime, or that equates to ending the regime. So as long as the CCP and Xi Jinping
remain in power, there is no chance for the United States to reach any agreement on fentanyl
and free market access. Anything the CCP promises on those two issues,
in my opinion, is deception. That means there won't be a truly comprehensive US-China trade
agreement in the next 47 days before July 1. So the current 54% tariff rate will likely
rise to 78%. I should say the current 50% because the 54% is weighted. So I should say the current
50% tariff will likely rise to 74% on July 1, unless there's a leadership change and a regime
change within the next 47 days. Although that's not entirely impossible, the chances are not great.
But the damage is real. Think about it this way. The original 20%
tariff from Section 301 in 2018 had already forced many Chinese exporters to relocate to
Southeast Asia and Latin America. The analysts in Hong Kong said that half of China's remaining
exports to the US became disguised transshipments through third countries.
Now, with average tariff at 54%, most exporters are unable to stay afloat unless the Chinese
government steps in to help them. But unless it's a strategically important industry,
that's highly unlikely. And if the tariffs rise to 74% in July, I think to a lot of people,
it won't even matter because many businesses will go out of business before they even get to that
point. Beijing might have bought itself 47 days, but time is running out. Unless we see immediate
political reforms or leadership regime changes, I think this trade truce will be remembered as the
day that Beijing blinked, and it will be the beginning of a long, painful unraveling.
So that's what I have for you. I hope it's helpful.
Okay. All right. That's all. I hope you enjoy the movie parts.
There has to be some entertainment value in talking about the CCP.
Otherwise, it's utterly gruesome to talk about this every week.
All right. Let's see what people have for me. Okay. Oh, here's one. Miles David.
Do you think China will actually become more powerful militarily and economically over the US?
If so, is there anything the US can do to stop it? I do not think China will become
more powerful militarily or economically under the CCP. Not under the CCP, never. However,
China will continue to pose as the biggest threat to the United States, not because it's powerful
militarily or economically, but because the CCP is willing to play very dirty with the United States.
That's what's scary and threatening. And it's willing to play dirty. It's willing to cause
pain and suffering to its people. It's willing to sacrifice the well-being and happiness.
There isn't even happiness at this point. It's just well-being or the safety of its people.
And that's why it's scary. No other governments would do this, but they are totally capable of
doing it. The CCP is threatening, not because it's powerful or it's strong. It's not strong at all,
but it's bad. It can do terrible things that other people are not capable of doing. So that's the
idea. Okay. All right. Good question. Very good question. Okay. I'm just picking some random
questions if I see some. No questions. No questions for me. Oh, here's a question forwarded by Chris.
The audio isn't clear. What happened? The audio isn't clear.
Oh, terrible. Wrong microphone selected. Is this better? Thank you, Chris.
All right. I'm sorry that the microphone was the wrong one. All right. I feel awful for these
technical mishaps. What about Trump airplane from Qatar? Is that a bribe? I have not followed
that. I'm not quite sure if I can answer that question because that doesn't involve China.
Next swing. Thank you, Lei. It's going to take time to unfold the current relationship.
I think President Trump knows China's moves and will take measures to control them. Well,
thank you. Let's hope so. Let's hope he's not being fooled by China's promise to open its market
because it will not. It will not. Okay. All right. Okay. So the audio is now good.
John John S. Lei, what else can we expect between China, Japan, Korea, Taiwan?
What else can we expect between these four countries? I think the similarity, I mean,
what I'm really concerned about, I think the first thing we need to answer, the first question we
need to answer is what's upcoming in the South Korean election, right? I mean, that's the first,
depending on who wins the presidency. I think that's the first question I have. And then for
Taiwan, Taiwan has a similar challenge. The parliament, the Taiwan legislative
is controlled by the opposition. And there's a massive recall movement going on,
calling to remove the pro-Beijing legislators. So if that movement is successful, then I think
is in a better position to issue policies that will better protect Taiwan.
Because if that movement fails, then Taiwan's situation could become very similar
to that of South Korea. These are really the top issues that concern me right now when it comes to
South Korea and Taiwan. I don't see there's any commonality that could tie these four countries
together, other than that Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan should be on one side and China is
on the other side. I don't see any commonality that connects all four countries. That's my answer.
Okay. All right. Brendan G. The PRC constantly violates all agreements. Shouldn't the PRC be
suspended from WTO, all these conventions and favor nations until generally complied with
agreements? Absolutely. Why it's not? I mean, any agreements that other organizations or governments
reach with the PRC is... I mean, has the PRC kept its promise on any agreement, has honored any
agreements it signed with these organizations in your question? I don't think so. I mean,
it partially complied with the agreements they signed, but they never fully complied with
the agreements it signed. So, question. Do you think Trump is blindly optimistic about
China's capabilities to play dirty? I don't think he's blindly optimistic about China's... I think
he's fully aware of China's capabilities to play dirty. I think on that note, he is aware,
but I think he could be a little too optimistic about his ability to force the CCP into some kind
of agreement. I think on that note, he's a little bit too optimistic. But all leaders, all strong
leaders have that tendency. So, it's not just unique to him. I think he's a little too optimistic
about forcing China to open up. The only way China will open up is after the CCP disintegrates.
All right. Chinese children are being taught to hate Americans. Do you think that the parents
and children will grow and hate Americans? It's very hard. I was going to say that if they have a
chance to visit the US and really know what the United States is all about, then they may not. But
then I changed my mind because take a look at our colleges. There are so many Chinese students here,
but they still follow the directives of the CCP. This is because their parents are probably
high-ranking government officials, and it's in their best interest to work against the United
States because of who their parents are. But then the average Chinese at this point probably
won't be given a chance to come to the US to learn what America is all about.
So, it's only the privileged ones that can come, and then they are not going to change because it's
in their best interest to continue the official narratives because that's the guarantee of their
privilege. These students grew up with privilege, and they don't want to lose that. So, what's the
point of sending them here? It's not to our advantage. So, I don't know. I think it's a very
sad reality. A lot of Chinese children and parents will continue to hate America without knowing
that they were being deceived. All right.
Chickapees. Lei is the best channel for truth. I'm so happy to hear that. Well, thank you.
Will Lei be my adopted sister for James, California? Okay. Am I up for adoption?
All right. I'm glad that people want to adopt me. Okay. So, I know that I always have a home.
Okay, good. Well, thank you. Brendan G. Well, thank you, Brendan. Okay. All right.
That seems to be all. Now, seek the truth. Do you think the recent
push by the CIA fishing expedition to get CCP officials to cooperate yield any results? Oh,
I made a program on that. I think it will. The reason they made the videos was because
it had yielded results. Because last year, they released the video. It was an instructional video
just to tell the Chinese how to contact them. There were no narratives, but it was working.
So, they followed up with two more videos. So, yeah, I think it's working. I think it will work.
Someone asked me, Galia, why Xi Jinping was not accompanied by his wife in Moscow?
That's a good question because his wife has missed two of his recent diplomatic
missions. He was in Southeast Asia and then Moscow. His wife missed the trips.
There were two explanations. One explanation was that his wife was not allowed to go with him.
She was held back as a hostage in Beijing. That was one explanation. The other explanation was
that his wife is probably also under investigation because she holds the title. She was a commission
member. She was a member of this commission in the military that vets the promotion of all officers.
So, I shouldn't say overseas. She's part of a function that reviews the promotions of all
military officers. Because of the large number of purges that has been going on in the PLA,
she could be in trouble. People could hold her accountable. If you're part of this group that
reviews all promotions, then how come you didn't know that all these people have loyalty issues?
So, that's another explanation. She is being held responsible and possibly is being investigated.
I do not know the answer. I do not know the answer. But typically, Xi Jinping is known for
always taking his wife on the trip because he knows he's not as charismatic as his wife. His
wife is a singer and is popular in China. The woman is likable. So, that is a question that
many people ask. Kiran Patel. Well, thank you. His Chinese economy is only at $8 trillion.
It's only at $8 trillion. What? GDP? What is the $8 trillion? Okay. All right. I think that's all.
Here's a question forwarded by Chris from Jim K. Do you think China will resort to military
action attempts after July 1? It depends on how bad China's economy will become. It also
depends on how much power Xi Jinping has left. It depends on who has full control of the regime at
that time. So, it's hard to tell at this point. Okay. I will end it here. Thank you for joining
me. And I'll see you on Thursday. Thank you. Bye-bye.