Heisenberg, Bohr: the Friendship behind the Copenhagen Interpretation of Quantum Theory

Werner Heisenberg (1901 - 1976)
3 followers
In 1930, 28-year-old Werner Heisenberg
wrote an introduction to a book
where he boldly stated that the Copenhagen spirit
of quantum theory has directed the entire development
of modern atomic physics.
Soon, Heisenberg's term Copenhagen spirit
was reframed as the Copenhagen interpretation.
And according to Wikipedia,
the Copenhagen interpretation is, quote,
one of the oldest interpretations in quantum mechanics
and remains one of the most commonly taught.
But what was the Copenhagen spirit
and where did it come from?
Aside from Copenhagen, Denmark, of course.
This is mostly the story of the friendship
between Werner Heisenberg and Niels Bohr.
Ready?
Let's go.
♪ Electricity, electricity, electricity, electricity ♪
When 20-year-old Werner Heisenberg
met 36-year-old Niels Bohr for the first time
on June 14th, 1922, he was so excited he wrote his parents,
Bohr is the first scientist
who also makes an impression as a human being.
He's not just a physicist, but much more.
With me, he's always especially nice
and he has invited me to see him once again next week.
Heisenberg then quickly finished his PhD in Munich
and then got a job as an assistant
to the physicist Max Born in Göttingen.
Sorry, Born and Bohr sound so similar.
At the time, Born was working to try to, quote,
find the weak points and contradictions
in Bohr's semi-classical theory of atoms.
By the end of 1923, Heisenberg had formed a new theory
and sent it to his friend Wolfgang Pauli
to send it to Niels Bohr.
Bohr immediately responded with an invitation to Heisenberg
to spend spring break with him in Copenhagen.
Wolfgang Pauli was particularly pleased to hear this
because he found Heisenberg's theory ugly
and without deep connections.
And Pauli wrote Bohr, I was therefore very pleased
that you had invited him to Copenhagen.
Hopefully then Heisenberg will return home
with a philosophical orientation to his thinking.
In Copenhagen, Heisenberg and Bohr
got along like gangbusters,
discussing philosophy and physics till midnight every night.
Soon, Bohr worked out a deal
so that Heisenberg could complete his grant
with Max Born in pieces.
And then Heisenberg spent many months
of 1924, 1925 in Copenhagen.
When Heisenberg returned to Germany,
he used some of the ideas born in his conversations
in Copenhagen to come up with a new mathematical model
for quantum mechanics,
which he gave to his advisor, Max Born.
Born then realized this was a math concept called a matrix.
And for six months, Heisenberg, Born
and Born's new student, Pasquale Jordan,
created a series of papers that are widely considered
the beginning of modern quantum mechanics.
Although the mathematics were terribly difficult.
Bohr was as excited as anyone.
Although according to Heisenberg,
he wasn't very good at math.
Bohr was not a mathematically minded man.
He was, I would say, a Faraday, but not a Maxwell.
As a historian, I like that analogy.
Then in January, 1926, Erwin Schrodinger
published a wave theory of quantum mechanics.
And soon there was a fierce debate between the two methods,
which everyone assumed were incompatible.
However, by May, both Schrodinger and Wolfgang Pauli
proved that they were mathematically equivalent.
This gave the advantage to Schrodinger
as his math was much easier.
And more importantly, people, including Schrodinger himself,
held the philosophy that using Schrodinger's theories,
quantum mechanics could be made
into a branch of classical mechanics.
In July, Heisenberg went to a talk by Schrodinger
and was told to be quiet as, quote,
"'We are now finished with all that nonsense
"'about quantum jumps.'
Depressed, Heisenberg wrote Bohr that very night,
and Bohr then invited Schrodinger to Denmark
to debate the issue.
Once in Copenhagen, even Heisenberg was surprised
by the ferocity of Bohr's feelings on the issue.
Bohr now appeared to me almost as an unrelenting fanatic
who was not prepared to make a single concession.
It will hardly be possible to convey the intensity
of passion with which the discussions
were conducted on both sides.
It got so intense that when Schrodinger fell ill,
Niels Bohr's wife, Margaretha, nursed him
while Niels Bohr continued the discussions bedside."
Interestingly, Schrodinger had a far different view
of the encounter, and a few weeks later, he wrote a friend,
quote, "'In spite of all our theoretical points of dispute,
"'the relationship with Bohr, and especially Heisenberg,
"'was totally, cloudlessly amiable and cordial.'"
Schrodinger was also quite surprised
and a little bit disappointed
to find that someone of Bohr's fame,
he described Bohr as being honored almost like a demigod,
would be so shy and timid.
Quote, "'Bohr talks often for minutes,
"'almost in a dreamlike, visionary,
"'and really quite unclear manner,
"'partially because he is so full of consideration
"'and constantly hesitates,
"'fearing that the other might take a statement
"'of his point of view
"'as an insufficient appreciation of the other.'"
Despite all the talk, Schrodinger remained unconvinced.
Then in October, 1926, Wolfgang Pauli wrote Heisenberg
about a strange phenomena.
If he used Heisenberg matrices,
then the more he studied the position of an electron,
then noted with the letter Q, but now used the letter X,
then the harder it was to describe the object's momentum
or mass times speed,
then and now denoted with the letter P.
Wolfgang Pauli wrote Heisenberg,
"'One can look at the world with a P-eye
"'and one can look at it with a Q-eye,
"'but when one would like to open both eyes,
"'then one gets dizzy.'"
In the beginning of 1927,
while Bohr was on a ski trip to Norway,
Heisenberg realized that he could derive this relationship,
which he called the imprecision relation.
By mid-March, Bohr returned to Copenhagen
and immediately noted problems with some of the concepts,
which left Heisenberg in tears.
After 10 days that were described as very disagreeable,
Heisenberg edited the paper to Bohr's satisfaction
and published it on March 22nd, 1927.
Bohr happily then sent copies of the paper to Einstein
with a comment that he felt that it, quote,
"'represents the most significant,
"'exceptionally brilliant contribution
"'to the discussion of general problems of quantum theory.'"
Einstein was not impressed.
In fact, he hated it with a passion
and Einstein debated it with Bohr for the rest of his life.
Meanwhile, in about April, 1927,
Heisenberg and Bohr were having conflicting arguments
about quantum mechanics.
Heisenberg recalled, quote,
"'We are unable to find the same language
"'for the interpretation of the theory.'
"'Part of it was a question of mathematics.'
"'Heisenberg felt that we must realize
"'that our words don't fit.
"'They don't really get a hold in the physical reality
"'and therefore a new mathematical scheme
"'is just as good as anything.'
Whereas Bohr was determined to make it work
outside of mathematical.
His biographer wrote that Bohr believed that, quote,
"'Our words have to fit.
"'We have nothing else.'"
Bohr's assistant recalled that these disagreements
about Heisenberg's work became a source of inspiration
and Bohr decided that quantum mechanics
needed new words to describe physics
that didn't originate in classical theories.
According to Bohr's assistant,
Bohr dictated and the next day,
all that he had dictated was discarded and we began anew.
And so it went all summer.
By July 1927, Bohr published an article
originally titled,
The Philosophical Foundations of Quantum Theory.
Ironically, Bohr's devotion to the science
of how to communicate quantum mechanics without math
was incredibly difficult to follow,
especially in the beginning.
So I'm gonna give you his biographer's paraphrasing of it.
"'The question of whether an electron is a particle
"'or a wave is a sensible question in the classical context,
"'where the relation between object of study
"'and detector needs no specification.
"'In quantum mechanics,
"'that question is meaningless, however.
"'There, one should rather ask,
"'does the electron or any other object
"'behave like a particle or like a wave?
"'That question is answerable,
"'but only if one specifies the experimental arrangement
"'by means of which one looks at the electron.'"
Bohr called this complementarity,
pairs of complementary properties
which cannot all be observed or measured simultaneously,
like position and momentum
or wave versus particle properties.
The debates about the uncertainty principle
and Bohr's philosophies got so intense
that the Solvay Congress decided
they could no longer continue
their embargo of German scientists
and dedicated their entire meeting to the debate.
At the conference, Einstein would wake up every morning
to give Bohr a new thought experiment
that was supposed to disprove uncertainty
and Bohr would find a solution by dinnertime.
Meanwhile, by June 1927, 25-year-old Heisenberg
was offered a position as a full professor in Leipzig,
making him the youngest full professor in Germany.
Heisenberg became dedicated
to starting a world-class physics program in Leipzig
with deep connections to Bohr in Copenhagen
and Born in Göttingen.
And for a few years,
every physicist worth his or her salt learned German
and went to Leipzig, Copenhagen, or Göttingen,
and usually all three.
By 1928, any disagreements between Bohr and Heisenberg
were completely passed.
Heisenberg wrote Bohr apologizing
for his ungrateful behavior and Bohr replied,
"'Rarely have I felt myself in more sincere harmony
with any other human being.'"
In February 1932, the English scientist James Chadwick
discovered the neutron,
which is a heavy, chargeless material found in the nucleus.
When Bohr found out about it,
he immediately wrote Heisenberg.
Here we have become very interested in the neutron problem,
whereupon Heisenberg also wrote his own paper on the neutron
to, quote, apply quantum mechanics to the nucleus.
Bohr's liquid drop model ended up having major implications
for the development of quantum mechanics
and the development of the nuclear bomb.
Heisenberg's theory from this time, as far as I can tell,
was discounted pretty quickly,
as he assumed the neutron was just an electron and proton
sort of smushed together,
which violated Heisenberg's own uncertainty principle.
In January 1933, Heisenberg and Bohr's relationship
got much more challenging because Hitler came to power.
Heisenberg was convinced he was a flash in the pan
and tried to convince all the scientists he could find
to stay in Germany, or if they were forced to flee,
that it was only a temporary thing
and maybe they should just take a leave of absence.
Bohr had no such ideas, was very concerned about Hitler,
and formed committees,
which eventually helped over 300 scientists.
Years later, Bohr's wife, Margaretha, recalled,
Oh, the 30s were such terrible years.
There we nearly collapsed.
I remember when we went to America in 33,
we had such a long list of people
for whom we should try to find places.
In addition, despite the fact
that Bohr wasn't at all religious,
he had something personal to fear from the Nazis
because his mother was Jewish.
Despite their differences on politics,
Bohr and Heisenberg continued to be very close
and visit often.
Meanwhile, Heisenberg formed a very, very close relationship
with his student, Karl Friedrich von Weizsäcker.
And according to Heisenberg, quote,
I saw Weizsäcker almost daily during the years 1931 to 1935.
For example, in October, 1934, Heisenberg wrote his mother
that the only way he could understand the rise of Hitler
was with the friendship of Karl Friedrich,
who struggles in his own serious way
with the world around us.
Heisenberg's relationship with Weizsäcker
got a little bit more complicated in 1936
when 34-year-old Heisenberg fell in love
with Weizsäcker's 19-year-old sister Adelaide
and her parents rejected the suit.
A few months later, Weizsäcker ended his assistantship
with Heisenberg and started an internship
with Lisa Meitner in Berlin.
Their friendship remained a little distant
until 1939 at the start of the war
when Weizsäcker invited Heisenberg
to join the Uranium Club
to study the military aspects of nuclear fission.
Back in 1936, Heisenberg felt very lonely
without the young Weizsäckers.
But then in January 1937, he met a young woman
named Elizabeth Lee Schumacher.
And two weeks later, they were engaged.
Heisenberg wrote Bohr that he would be worried
about being a successful scientist and family man
if it weren't for the great example of his idol, Bohr.
After their quick marriage,
Heisenberg brought his new bride to Copenhagen to meet Bohr.
In Copenhagen, Margaretha Bohr was a bit disturbed
by the politics of her husband's protege and his wife.
Margaretha took Lee on a private walk
away from prying eyes
where there was no fear of being overheard
and said, quote,
"'Wouldn't it be nice for you
"'to get rid of this terrible government
"'and get some decent people?'
To which Lee replied,
"'Oh, but what would we do without a Fuhrer?'
Margaretha recalled,
"'That was the attitude of nice young Germans.'
"'So I gave up.'"
As far as I can tell,
Niels Bohr and Werner Heisenberg
did not see each other for over four years.
But the drought ended in September 1941
when Werner Heisenberg went back to Copenhagen
and Heisenberg wrote his wife, quote,
"'I'm once again in the city
"'where a part of my heart has stayed stuck.'"
But much had changed.
Germany had been at war for two years by this time.
And although Denmark had tried to stay neutral,
they had been occupied by the Germans 16 months earlier.
So Heisenberg wasn't just a visitor.
He was a representative of a repressive regime
that was oppressing their country.
This time, Heisenberg's pro-Nazi comments
were too prevalent to be ignored by Niels Bohr.
And even stranger, Heisenberg told Bohr outright
that he was working on nuclear bombs for Hitler,
which brings up the question, why?
And that mystery is solved
next time on The Lightning Tamers.
Thanks for watching my video.
Please remember to give it a thumbs up
and share it on social media.
And if you really wanna be nice,
you can become one of my patrons.
Thank you, patrons.
There's a link down below.
Okay, remember to stay safe and be nice to each other.
Have a good day.
Which would turn to...
Oppressed them about 16 months before as well.
Let me do it again.
That's good.
