10th president John Tyler was the first man to take the office by default, stepping up from the position of Vice President when his running mate, William Henry Harrison, died after a month in office. Since the Constitution provided no procedure for how to fill the presidential seat if it were left empty, Tyler set the precedent for all future presidential deaths by assuming the role of president immediately, although he faced constant criticism and disrespect from both parties throughout his term. His first wife died during his presidency, and he remarried while still in office, making him the only president to have two wives in the White House; he also holds the record as the president who fathered the most children, sixteen.
Welcome to American Legends. My name is Tiffany Brannan.
Each culture has its legends, and that could be myths or different stories,
but here in America, our greatest legends are the wonderful heroes who are right from our history
pages. Now, some of these heroes are very famous and some are obscure, but each person deserves to
be discovered because each man or woman stands as a great example of how we can be better Americans
In the days of old, over in Europe or in the far reaches of Africa or Asia,
there were many different legends. Stories about knights and kings, gods and goddesses,
prophets and wise men. Here in the United States, our history is much shorter,
but we have our own legends. Our legends are about generals and politicians, brave patriots,
people who went against their friends and allies and then banded together again to make a great
nation. These people fought their way through the wilderness first of the new nation and then
through the wilderness of the new political structure to make the United States the country
and the civilization it is today. Today, we're going to talk about the 10th president of the
and the fascinating role he played in a very unpopular position. From the very beginning
of the United States, the vice president was a strange position. The first man to hold this
position was John Adams, who would eventually become the second president of the United States,
and he said that it was the most unimportant role ever conceived by the mind of man. It sounds like
it has great importance, second in command, yet the vice president had no clearly defined roles
in the original constitution, besides that he would preside over the Senate.
Throughout the years, the vice president took on different jobs and eventually he began actually
running alongside the presidential candidate, which was not the case originally. In the earliest days
of the first elections, the vice president was simply the runner-up, the person who got the
second most votes for president, and so he would get to be the vice president.
Now, when we think of vice president, I think that the main position which comes to mind is the fact
that he really is the understudy for the president. If anything happens to the commander-in-chief,
the vice president takes over in that role, but that role was not defined in the constitution.
In fact, for the first many decades, no one really thought about what would happen
if the president were to die. All of a sudden, everyone had to think about that in the year 1841,
when the ninth president of the United States, William Henry Harrison, died in office after only
one month as president. There wasn't much time to think about what to do though, because his vice
president, John Taylor, immediately took the oath of office. There wasn't a lot of discussion,
there weren't a lot of debates, no one voted, he just said, well, I'm the vice president,
automatically, I should take over as the president. And by doing so, he accomplished two
things. Firstly, he set the precedent for what happens when the president dies or becomes
incapacitated in some way. The vice president immediately takes the oath of office, that
position must not be empty, and because of that, that has happened every time since.
But he achieved another thing when he did that. He alienated himself from both political parties,
ultimately, and would gain a lot of opposition. Now, it wasn't just because he took that action,
it was because of what he did after taking that action. But that was just the first step in his
being bold and really unconcerned with what people around him thought. He was dubbed his
accident-cy. Now, at this time, there were two major political parties, the Democratic Party
and the Whig Party, which you could say is more closely aligned to, in the earliest days,
the Federalist Party, which favored a stronger central government, and perhaps in modern times,
you could say the Republican Party, but the Democratic Party now is very different than it
was then. The Democratic Party was the descendant of the Democratic-Republican Party, which sprung
up as early as Thomas Jefferson's time when he was the third president, and it advocated for strong
rights of the individual states. Now, who was John Tyler? He, of course, was the running mate of
William Henry Harrison. Their campaign slogan was Tippecanoe and Tyler too, because William Henry
Harrison was dubbed Old Tippecanoe due to the fact that the valiant war hero's most famed battle
victory was in the Battle of Tippecanoe. There's been a lot of debate over when, why, and how Tyler
ended up getting the nomination as vice president. Most people agree it's just because there wasn't
another person who seemed like a good choice at the Whig Party. The Whig Party had just started
at this point. The Federalist Party was gone, the Democratic-Republican Party had split into
the National Republican Party and the Democratic Party, but the Republican was fading away at this
point, so it was basically just the Democrats and whoever opposed them, and many different parties
sprung up to oppose the Jacksonian Democrats under Andrew Jackson. A lot of people disagreed
with what he did, and so that sort of became a whole political cause, being against Andrew Jackson,
and the Whigs were one party which sprung up in that time period, but again, they didn't have
a lot of organization or a very strong campaign platform besides that they were against the
Democrats, and in this somewhat confusing time, William Henry Harrison came to the forefront as
a man of the people, as opposed to Martin Van Buren, the eighth president of the United States,
who was seen as too aristocratic, and an important thing was to get people from all different sides
of the country. Since Harrison was a northerner, the Whig Party was concerned about getting
southerners involved too, because even though this was a couple of decades before the Civil War,
the tension that would lead to it was already pulling the North and South apart, as they had
very different needs, and by this point, the North was basically free of slaves, whereas the South
still relied heavily on slave labor, so that was a very hot issue for decades before the Civil War.
John Tyler came from Virginia, and being a southerner was something which defined his
political career just as much as being an American. He came from a family which was a plantation owner,
he was well educated, following the tradition of the men in his family, going to
the William and Mary College in Williamsburg, and there he was educated to go in the law profession.
He ended up being admitted to the bar at the age of 19, which was actually too young at that time
according to the law, but he got in simply because the judge didn't ask him how old he was.
He had a private law practice before going into politics himself. He became very involved in the
Virginia government, and this meant that he was following in the footsteps of many of the
presidents who had come before him. The majority of U.S. presidents up to this point were from the
state of Virginia, including George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, and many others. As a matter of
fact, there were so many presidents from Virginia in these early days that they were called the
Virginia dynasty. Because of this, he had many of the sentiments which were associated with the
believing in that slave labor was wrong in theory but sort of a necessary evil, and he battled with
this just like his predecessors like Jefferson and Washington did. They used slaves while admitting
that it was actually wrong, but they didn't agree with completely abolishing it from a government
standpoint. From his earliest days in politics, whether he was a governor serving in the state
legislature or in Congress, there were two political points to which he always stuck.
Firstly, he believed in the rights of the individual states to make their own decisions,
and secondly, he believed that a national bank was a bad idea. Now, both these ideas, particularly the
thing about states, would make you think he'd be a democrat, and he was originally a democrat,
but the reason he stopped being a democrat was because he began to disagree with Andrew Jackson
as he got closer to that whole political scenario, mainly over the Nullification Act.
Now, that was regarding tariffs and, again, the rights of individual states.
Many of the southerners felt that it was not fair to them, particularly the state of South
Carolina, that these tariffs were specifically designed to attack them and that they didn't
suit their needs, and this led to his own vice president, John C Calhoun, becoming so upset that
he broke off from him, resigned, and became his fiercest political opponent. Meanwhile,
John Tyler aligned himself with Calhoun and disagreed with the Nullification Act,
and this became a very contentious point for him because he was a democrat at the time in
the government, and many people in his party thought that he was completely going against
policy to be publicly criticizing the president, who was his own party at the time, but again, he
didn't really care what anybody said about things like that. He suffered from ill health throughout
his life and sometimes used us as an excuse to withdraw from certain political offices,
but although his health was weak, his temperament and his nature was always very strong. He eventually
became part of the Whig Party, mainly because it was opposing the Democratic Party, but he would
have some problems with them too, mainly because he was so in favor of the rights of individual
states. As an example, how do roads get repaired or built in the first place? Well, different roads
are built different ways at this point in history, but at that point, back in the earlier to mid-19th
century, they were still figuring out how to continue building and developing the country.
He felt that it was completely unacceptable for Congress or any other federal government
organization to send the money to the individual states to work on their infrastructure. He thought
that was the right of the individual state and that they should raise the funds through taxes or
tariffs or whatever sort of infrastructure they used to create that money they needed, and he
saw it as insulting when Congress wanted to give money to his own state of Virginia. They didn't
need that kind of a handout. He saw it as an unfavorable form of charity. One of the reasons
why he was so opposed to the idea of a national bank was that he was involved with auditing the
second national bank, and he found a lot of corruption in there, and he just said it's not a
good idea. We shouldn't have one central government. He felt that even more important than the
Constitution, although he supported the Constitution greatly, was the power and the rights of the
individual states. Interestingly, this was something that more Southerners seemed to believe
than Northerners, mainly because they thought the Northerners were all about their commerce and
industry, whereas the Southerners had more individual needs, and if anything was allowed
to just be from the federal government, well, the South thought they always were going to get the
short end of the stick, and that kind of hard feelings and prejudice and feeling like someone
is against you is just the sort of thing that can lead to a civil war, and did. One way that some of
the presidents who preceded Tyler kept balance between the North and South was by keeping an
equal amount of slave and free states, such as with the Missouri Compromise, when it was decided that
Missouri would be admitted as a slave state while Maine would be admitted as a free state.
Tyler thought that this was a horrible idea, and instead he thought that there shouldn't be such
strict limits placed on the expansion of slavery. He thought it should be allowed to expand westward
because maybe that would mean that the slave owners and slaves would move west out of the more
civilized areas like Virginia, and eventually there would be so few slave owners and slaves
that they simply would abolish slavery in those states because not many people wanted to practice
it, as he'd seen happen in the North. This was a good idea in theory, I suppose, because again, he
thought that it was wrong morally, but it was being used for practical reasons, but it was
too contentious to be solved that easily. Throughout his presidency, many of the Whigs insisted on
calling him the acting president, or the president in interim. They refused to acknowledge that he
was actually the president, but that didn't stop him. Even as most of his cabinet resigned,
and he had no vice president because there was no formula for electing a vice president.
As a matter of fact, there was no process for replacing the vice president until 1967,
and there had to be a new amendment to the constitution to come up with how we would do that.
So he didn't need a vice president, he just went ahead and did what he wanted to do,
and he didn't care who opposed him because he believed that he was fighting for the right thing,
and he did a few things which were noteworthy. Florida was admitted to the union during his time.
He was able to work out a peaceful border between Maine and Canada, which is one of his most lasting
contributions and was a very positive thing that happened. He also supported the annexation of
Texas. Although Texas was not admitted to the union until a few months after he left office,
he set that in motion. He didn't run for re-election because he had just faced so much
opposition. In fact, he no longer was aligned with any political party by the time he left office.
Within a few months of his becoming president, the Whig party expelled him because of his strong
stances against the bank, which they were very much supporting, and his views on the state's
rights. So he was the president without a party, and he stuck to his guns, and he tried to do what
he thought was best in a very difficult situation. After that, he retired to a more peaceful life,
but that wouldn't be the end of his time in public office or in the political scene.
In 1861, by which point he was quite an old man, he became involved with, well, what was a big deal
for Virginia at that point, the beginning of the Civil War. He supported some of the ideas of the
new confederacy springing up, although he didn't want a complete break. He was in support of the
peace conference, which would create some kind of an amicable, peaceful solution between the North
and South. When that didn't work out, though, he became a strong supporter of the confederacy,
and was actually elected to the Confederate Congress, making him the only U.S. president
to serve or be elected to the government of two separate countries. He did, however, die before
actually taking this position. Looking back on John Tyler, I think people look at the fact that
he was eventually anti-American, and that he was pro-confederacy, but I think when you see it,
you can see that it wasn't that he disagreed with the whole idea of the United States.
He very much supported it. He disagreed with some of the views which were taking hold in the North
at that time, and he was a very loyal Virginian and Southerner. What he did believe, though,
was that the rights of the individual, whether that's the individual state or the individual
citizen, especially to cherish and follow your own religious views, are the most important.
Many of his quotes he talked about that we shouldn't have to answer to anyone by our own
conscience and God for what we believe. He believed that that kind of individual freedom
is what made the United States strong and would keep it alive. For instance, he's quoted as saying,
I contend that the strongest of all governments is that which is most free. He also said, I can
never consent to being dictated to, and that is why he basically destroyed his own political career
in the pursuit of doing what he thought was right. But despite all these things,
his most lasting contribution was making that bold stance to step up to be the president
in that time of conflict when he found out that Harrison had died. And he's quoted as having said
on that matter, if the tide of defamation and abuse shall turn and my administration come to
be praised, future vice presidents who may succeed to the presidency may feel some slight encouragement
to pursue an independent course. The tide of defamation never really did turn,
yet he did set that precedent nonetheless. And he must be commended for being unafraid to be his
own man. Whether you agree or disagree with his actual political views or the things he did,
it's admirable that he wanted to do what he thought was right as a president, not just be a
copycat of William Henry Harrison or a stooge of the Whig party, just a slave to political ideas.
He didn't bow to anyone. He did what he thought was right, and that's something which all
politicians could use more to their advantage. Thank you for spending this time with me talking
about the 10th president of the United States, unaffectionately dubbed his accidency, John Tyler.
His legacy as the first vice president to become president because of the president's death
is a complicated one, but it's an important step in the history of the United States and its
government. I hope you'll join me next time to talk about more presidents and first ladies
and their roles. Thank you for spending this time with me in American Legends. Goodbye.