Reupload Audio Fixed. This week has been another crazy one, with momentary panic during political drama that threatened to decommission the Dragon Spacecraft, another failed robotic moon lander from iSpace, a counter proposal to NASA's budget, and impressive rocket reuse tests from Chinese companies. Join us for a lively discussion about the future of spaceflight.
When the live show completes, our members can join the After Dark party here: https://www.youtube.com/live/90wn8URhfIY Not a member? As little as $1.00/mo gets you access to all the fun and chaos! You can watch older episodes while you're waiting for new content!
You literally cannot get any closer to landing.
I was panicking there for several hours and still am a little bit.
It turns out that the laws of physics apply equally in the United States of
America as they do in the People's Republic of China.
Good morning. How's everything up in the sky?
Hello, everybody. Welcome to Tomorrow.
It has been another crazy week in space flight,
and there is a lot of stuff that we need to talk about.
Been quite a bit of political drama and back and forth between
the leaders of the free world and the leader of human spaceflight right now.
And there's also quite a bit of discussion going on in the Senate about the budget for NASA.
Unfortunately, we've had another failure at the moon,
and there is so much more to talk about.
So let's just get right into it.
Joining me today, we have Ryan Caton,
who I am very much looking forward to your thoughts and opinions on this.
I've got Jared Head here. We also have Dutta here.
And we've got to talk about the drama.
For anyone who missed it, there was a bit of a fallout between Donald Trump and Elon Musk,
and started publicly talking about each other's contracts and programs.
And basically, Trump was saying that the easiest way to start saving billions of dollars with the
budget is to cancel all of the subsidies and contracts for all of Elon Musk's companies.
And what concerns us the most is the contracts for SpaceX.
And in response to that, Elon said that he would begin decommissioning
the Dragon spacecraft immediately.
And then not too long later, a couple hours later,
walked back on that a bit and said, OK, we won't decommission Dragon.
But still, just the thought of it has been a very scary proposition.
And it has brought up quite a few different
alternative scenarios to what might happen if such a thing were to actually occur.
And I don't know about you guys, but I'm still on the fence as to whether or not this is just
a big, massive troll, or if there's a serious risk that a lot of the contracts for SpaceX
might get canceled. So let's discuss.
You know what? Since I called you out first, Ryan, I would like to hear your thoughts about
all of this. I mean, I was panicking there for several hours and still am a little bit.
Yeah, I mean, thankfully, at least for the moment, it seems that calmer minds have prevailed
because Elon has since, you know, he replied to a reply.
So one person on X a single handedly saved US spaceflight for the foreseeable future.
Thank you to that person.
I know. But seriously, he removed the he removed the post saying that SpaceX would
begin decommissioning Dragon immediately.
The interesting point I found with this whole deal is
Dragon isn't the only contract that Tesla, SpaceX and all of other Elon Musk's companies
have with the US government, right?
Dragon is is what if we just if we just think about SpaceX, Dragon is one of many contracts
that SpaceX has with NASA.
We have science missions which are launched on Falcon 9 of Falcon Heavy.
We have defense payloads which are launched on Falcon 9 of Falcon Heavy.
But the first thing that came to Elon's mind was Dragon,
which I think is really interesting because it kind of adds to the rumors we've been hearing
for a while now that Elon doesn't really want to keep developing Dragon.
He wants to move on to Starship, a human rated Starship as quickly as possible.
And it doesn't seem like he really holds that much regard for Dragon,
at least from his comments, because, you know, as soon as as soon as President Trump
threatened to cancel his contract, the first thing that came to mind in his sort of quick
emotional response on X was, well, we'll begin decommissioning Dragon immediately,
not the defense contracts, not the science contracts.
It was it was Dragon.
So I think I am very much I'm kind of 99% sure Dragon will stick around.
I very much doubt this will actually happen.
I have a feeling maybe this was a moment similar to back in the early days of Falcon Heavy,
where Elon was like cancel everything.
And then Gwen Shopwell ran into the room at the 11th hour was like,
No, we can't cancel Falcon Heavy.
We can't cancel Falcon Heavy.
So I think this might have been a similar scenario, maybe just a little bit more emotional.
So, yeah, I think this was definitely an emotional post going significantly over the top.
But, yeah, I do think it's I do think the the underlying idea that Dragon was the first
thing that came to Elon's mind when he thought, what should we cancel?
I found that very interesting.
It's certainly not the largest contracts that SpaceX currently has with the federal government.
However, maybe it's the most visible.
You know, that's the kind of average person might still be like, Oh, what?
You're going to, you know, and actually, I loved your joke in our discord that you were
talking about of how now it's flipped from what the headlines were a year ago.
And SpaceX has stranded astronauts at the International Space Station.
If this were to play out that way.
Yeah, I don't know.
It's a crazy thought.
And a lot of really good points are being brought up about how, you know, this isn't
the only customer for the Dragon spacecraft.
I mean, in just a couple of days, we have another private Axiom mission that's launching
on Tuesday, and that is the fifth and final Dragon spacecraft that Pegsy Whitson, as the
tradition has been the commander of the first mission for it gets to choose what its name
is.
So I'm really eager to hear what name she gets to pick for it.
And I'm sure that Axiom is going to want to do many more missions with the Dragon spacecraft
in the future.
There's the whole idea of whether or not Jared Isaacman is going to continue with the Polaris
program.
I think we're all hoping that he does.
And if so, then there's more Dragon missions just from from that right there, at least
one more.
And, you know, a lot of the other private spaceflight companies have included Dragon
in their architecture for private space stations.
Vast, even Starlab, you know, is looking at that.
And, you know, so there's a lot of other business, even if they were to cancel everything
with the International Space Station, with the US government.
So it would be really, really.
I mean, it goes without saying cancelling Dragon would, you know, end human spaceflight
in the Western world.
It just would because without Dragon, we have Starliner, which is a limbo.
You know, NASA says it is going to fly again.
Boeing hasn't said anything about Starliner since it returned to since the crew flight
test returned to Earth uncrewed back in back in, you know, the September timeframe of last
year.
So that would then just leave Soyuz.
And are we going to go back to the decade long period we had of paying Russia to fly
American and European astronauts to the International Space Station?
And then what happens when the International Space Station is retired?
You know, Russia has dropped the cadence of Soyuz flights from every six months to every
nine months because they need to save money, because they cannot fund their human spaceflight
program at the same degree they were a few years ago because of all the sanctions and
the war in Ukraine and so forth.
So it would be it would be really devastating.
It would be it would be the end of human spaceflight in the Western world.
I think you're overestimating the importance of science exploration and research to this
current administration.
I don't think they would pay for Russian seats.
Yeah, I doubt they would at this at this stage either.
And if they did, they would go about it in such a weird roundabout way that it wouldn't
hit major headlines.
Despite our long cooperation with Russia on the International Space Station, I think
giving Roscosmos and anything related or touching Putin is kind of a poison pill at this moment
in politics.
Jared, what are your thoughts about all of this?
As nicely as you can.
I mean, where do I even begin with this?
Should we turn the rant light on at this point?
Well, you know, turns out even if you pay $250 million to purchase a country, you don't
really get a say in how to run it.
So I can also say, what were you expecting?
Were you expecting this executive branch to just kind of let you run around with however
you want to do your things?
Like, did past experience not show you what the present would net you?
And it's very difficult for me to seriously take the seriously.
Hold on.
I'm trying to figure out the correct way to phrase this.
It's very hard for me.
And I kind of don't really want to tiptoe around it anymore because I feel like
so I have a very much feeling a level of regret and culpability in platforming the people
and no politics in our way into these kinds of things occurring now.
So yeah, there's that.
But to kind of just stay on topic, at least for here, we could save the other really spicy
stuff for after dark if we want to.
I don't know if any of us were very particularly surprised at the implosion of a bromance of
someone who holds themselves higher than the number of dollars that they apparently have,
along with somebody who just cannot claw themselves out of the K-hole for however hard
they try.
So it's just a mess.
And what's the how's the saying go?
I like to clown, enjoy the circus or something like that.
So you're taking a gander at what happens when you put two wildly incompatible people
together who don't give each other an inch in terms of what they're going to do.
So yeah, I don't really know what to say other than having a single supplier is not a good
idea.
We've never exactly said that it's a good idea here on the show.
Redundancy has always been the way to go.
And if you lose your company that's providing your transportation services simply because
someone has an emotional spat over the fact that a friendship may end, you know, holy
smokes, what a what a bad foundation you had for your human spaceflight program.
So yee-haw.
I mean, what could who could have expected this?
I guess it's kind of what we're sitting back and saying to ourselves at this point for
many of us.
So we'll have to figure this out.
So I mean, and yeah, it's just it's such a weird situation, right?
Because usually it would be like an engineering issue that would be causing the to threaten
to collapse a program or something like that.
It's usually not a personal issue between two specific individuals in the case of Elon
Musk and President Donald Trump here.
So like, I can't really think of when a personal issue between two people coming to loggerheads
has caused something like this in spaceflight before.
But if somebody in the chat room can think of that or somebody in the comments can think
of it watching this on demand, I'm certainly all eyes and ears to have heard about that.
It's just such a such a weird, uncomfortable situation.
And I just don't like it.
And it's it's just thinking about it.
I want to have to go take a cold shower and scrub myself with concrete to try to remove
the feelings of it.
It just feels nasty.
You know, I feel genuinely uncomfortable having to talk about it.
But here we are, right?
So the closest thing I can even think of, and certainly nowhere near as public would,
but would be like Richard Sheldie bullying everybody and kind of always getting his way
when it came to NASA contracts and making sure that Huntsville, Alabama, you know, was
always getting a large share of something.
And over the past decade, that's been SLS, which, you know, at the same time that all
this drama was going on between Elon and Trump, Senator Cruz, the chairman of the Senate Armed
Forces Committee, put out a counterproposal to the current NASA budget and, you know,
also trying not to be negative about that.
He is asking for almost $10 billion to support the Moon and Mars program, the Artemis program.
But the direction that he's proposing to go with it, I'm not too happy about.
Let me just pull up some of this so that you can see what I am talking about.
Interestingly, at the same time that all this was going on, all of this drama between Elon
and Trump, Senator Cruz, the chairman of the Senate Armed Forces Committee, and the committee
that, you know, does a lot of the proposal work before it's fully voted on by Congress,
had a counterproposal to the president's proposal for what NASA's budget should be.
And wants to commit almost $10 billion in support of the Artemis program and the Moon
and Mars program.
Unfortunately, some of it seems to be a little bit misdirected.
So, just a quick summary, he wants $700 million for a Mars telecommunications orbiter, which
would support a Mars sample return mission, which all depends on whether or not that gets
canceled, but could also support future manned missions.
So, essentially a Martian, hopefully, high-power communications satellite.
Then they also are asking for $2.6 billion to fully fund the Lunar Gateway.
That is something that has been talked about being canceled, and there was only a little
bit of money in the president's budget proposal to basically end the contracts and finish
paying off the contractors who are currently building pieces of it right now, one of which
has already been delivered to Cape Canaveral and is being outfitted for a launch.
They also want $4.1 billion to continue the Space Launch System, importantly for Artemis
4 and Artemis 5.
And the problem with that is both of those missions would require the exploration upper
stage, the more powerful upper stage that they've been working on for a couple years
that is already way over budget and way beyond its initial schedule, much like the entire
Space Launch System program.
And there's a little bit of money for the Orion space capsule to ensure that they have
their fourth Orion finished that is currently being developed, and then set aside stuff
to do any sort of refurbishment for the four Orion capsules that they have.
And then $1.25 billion in support of the International Space Station to make sure that all of its
operations are going to be covered for the next five years, and kind of importantly to
make sure that they will have a smooth transition over to private commercial space stations
for the LEO destination program, and that there wouldn't be any gap in that low-Earth
orbit experiments that we do on a regular basis.
And to make the rest of the Senators happy who are part of this committee, there's a
little bit of money, a billion dollars worth, spread across several different facilities
to give them infrastructure upgrades, repairs, and so forth.
And like I said, this is probably to appease other Senators.
But interestingly...
I was going to say for the infrastructure upgrades there, that's actually something
that NASA has as a whole.
NASA has spoken to deferred maintenance on their facilities at all of their centers,
and the current total of that deferred maintenance is somewhere on the order of about $5 billion.
So that billion dollars would be very helpful towards the deferred maintenance and other
things that needs to be done that hasn't been done because there just hasn't been
money for it.
Yeah.
So, I mean, I get that.
But at the same time, you know, I can't help but think of that kind of political nature
of all the Senators involved when making sure that their district gets their cut.
So, I see that both ways.
I want my piece of the pie.
Yeah, I see that both ways.
Everyone getting their piece of the pie, and necessary upgrades.
Sorry, by the way.
Why is SLS so expensive to launch?
That doesn't make any sense to me at all.
We've been trying to figure out for years.
I think we're talking like, you know, over $2 billion per launch now.
Yeah, that's insane.
Hardware that is left over from the space shuttle program.
Yeah, I was going to say, is that technically more than a shuttle launch?
I think so.
I remember hearing when it was getting close to the billion dollar mark for a shuttle launch.
So, we're already double that.
It hasn't even gotten started, really.
It's been driving me nuts.
Driving us all nuts in the space fan community.
Yeah.
So, this is part of what bothers me about SLS.
That's not a justifiable cost.
Period.
Like, there's no way that it actually costs that.
That's, you know, contracts plus margin, plus profits, plus blah, blah, blah, blah.
It's a cost plus contract, I know.
But there's no way that that's a sustainable business model,
or a sustainable model for a program.
There's just no way.
Other than just raking in dough, why does it make any sense?
To have that as your cost per launch for that system.
Come on, Dutta.
You got to think of the shareholders here.
No, you don't.
You need to cap the shareholders,
and you need to think of the taxpayers who are giving you all that money.
In the case of, you know, I don't disagree, Dutta.
That's, like, perfect.
But these companies are not beholden to that kind of an idea.
They want to make money, and they want to make money for the people who own them.
Therefore, how much money can I bring in?
But that's a good way to not make money,
because the contract gets canceled because it's too expensive.
Well, we'll make money for at least, like, a decade.
I'm sorry, you're not going to get your profit,
because I can't afford plating your rocket in gold.
I was going to say, we can only use the foil, not solid gold.
I mean, honestly, I've just been, for the longest time now,
I think that it's all those contractors just ripping off all of a sudden.
That's why we had to get rid of cost plus contracting.
There's still a bit of that around,
but with the commercial cargo and commercial crew program,
moving over to this fixed price contract model
has been such an awesome improvement for things.
With cost plus contracting, you can get away with being super greedy and saying,
oh yeah, this is going to cost us billions of dollars and take us 10 years,
whereas one of your other competitors could probably do it
for a tenth of the price and in a quarter of the time.
I haven't been able to justify it any other way.
I can't fathom that the actual cost of that vehicle,
paying your engineers and paying for parts and hardware and materials and all that,
as well as amortizing all the research and design that you've done
over the program for the last 20 years.
I can't imagine it costs half that.
Especially for hardware that NASA already owns.
A lot of the engines, NASA already owned the engines
and then they had to repay for engines that they already owned
at a much higher price than when they originally purchased them.
Yes, there was refurbishment and work that had to be done on them to get them flight ready,
but for crying out loud, full price?
You need full price for an engine that you already own?
That's like me buying a car for $45,000 10 years ago
and taking it somewhere to get a repair
or doing some sort of thing to make it compliant
for your local emissions department or something like that.
I have to pay full price for the car again in today's dollars.
So even though I purchased it for $45,000 10 years ago,
I now have to pay $65,000, $75,000 to get the repair done to satisfy emissions.
Maybe that's a little bit too simple of a comparison, but that's what it feels like.
I don't even think it's that sensical.
It's like buying a car 10 years ago for 45 grand
and then when you say now that you want to drive it,
oh, you want it to operate.
Oh, hold on.
You need to pay another 45 grand so that our engineers can tear down your engine
and reassemble it with starting lube because reasons.
I will just bust out my line that I always bust out
when talking about the Space Launch System,
which is that it is a rocket from another era.
This was started well before Artemis.
It was started before Asteroid Redirect.
It was started before Constellation.
It's a product of its time.
And if we want to go to SLS in its current configuration,
whatever we want to determine that to be,
then we're talking about just before commercial cargo
began and the commercial cargo and commercial crew programs
were not expected to succeed.
That is very clear in the history that everyone speaks to
who worked in those programs,
which is that nobody expected those kinds of programs to succeed
because of the types of contracts that they had.
No way could you actually build a rocket and build a spacecraft
that could carry cargo and people
and do it with a fixed cost budget.
That's not how it works.
At that time, you had to have that margin
in order to build in the money or to get the profit out of it,
however you want to say that with that.
So it's a dinosaur, not just with the technology,
but also with the managerial mindset of it as well.
It is a product of a bygone era,
not just because it uses the shuttle technology,
but because it looks at building and managing a program
in such an archaic way that for most people
who have gotten interested in spaceflight recently,
it doesn't make sense because they've never seen
this archaic way of doing things,
the old ways of how it was done.
That doesn't mean that it was a good idea to do things
in the old ways in the archaic days.
We now know that maybe that wasn't the best way to do things.
But I suppose for those of us who have been around
a really long time covering this kind of stuff,
it is a contract that I would have expected to have seen signed
in 2011, right?
So because we had been, what, one Falcon 9 flight at that time?
We used this architecture for 35 years,
and even accounting for inflation since April 12, 1981,
it didn't cost this much per launch.
No, not at all.
Anyway, moving on.
No disagreement.
It's freaking expensive.
It's too expensive.
I do want to loop in because there have been
a lot of really great comments in the chat here about this.
Some of these are funny to the point of depression.
Like Massimo, SLS wasn't designed to be launched.
It was designed as work.
Launching is basically an afterthought.
Kind of feels that way.
So many profit margins and management overhead.
We got to pay for the endless studies to make sure
that they have everything the way that they say
that it's going to be.
Middle management all the way down.
No skunk works here.
Cost plus does make sense when you're doing something
completely new, but SLS is not.
It's all old hardware.
We've been studying this idea since at least 1991,
which means people already have the idea before that.
And yeah, I also agree with Joel Corley here.
Boeing has said that the cancellation of SLS will result
in the layoff of about 400 people.
That means Boeing is bringing in about $5 million
per person per launch.
That is just a crazy amount of money.
And you know that those 400 people aren't getting
a bonus like that.
That's all straight to the top.
Anyway, we're getting on an angry SLS rant.
And to kind of wrap up this section.
Let's get back to the angry politics rant.
Yeah, let's get back to the angry politics.
Something that was really interesting.
Today is a day of strong emotions.
I want to say something wasn't Pentagon,
but there was some government account on X
that basically was putting out kind of a call to arms
to SpaceX competitors of, you know,
we highly recommend that you get comparable systems
online as soon as possible.
I don't remember what the exact words,
but I just remember seeing that and the discussion
forming around of just like, holy crap,
I bet, you know, everyone is super happy.
And also like freaked out at the same time,
you know, when it comes to like United Launch Alliance
or Blue Origin, Rocket Lab, Firefly, even Stokes Space,
you know, maybe this is kind of lit a fire under them
to be like, maybe, I mean, we all want to see SpaceX succeed
with all these competitors.
Maybe they have a chance to actually get in there
and seize some of these contracts.
If that scenario does play out,
which I think at the end of the day,
we all agree that it's probably not.
This is just two, how do I say this?
Two men who are arguing and putting all of our hobbies
at and the things that we enjoy at risk for it.
But at the end of the day, it's probably just arguing.
And I think that cooler heads will prevail.
You know, we all need to say, I saw the comment earlier.
We all need to send Gwen Shotwell a fruit basket
or some sort of gift basket for all her hard work.
I'm sure she's going to swoop in and be like,
no, we're not decommissioning Dragon.
We've got contracts for the next four years.
You're not screwing us out of that over some fight Elon.
She probably says it much more nicer and diplomatically,
but you know, even within Congress,
I think cooler heads will prevail.
I'm going to speak for myself
and you can subscribe if you like.
I'm not necessarily a SpaceX fanboy.
I don't have stake in which launch provider
or which company survives.
I just want the exploration to continue.
And thus far, SpaceX has been doing a bang up job
of investing and doing the engineering
and doing the work and improving launch cadence
and literally changing what the industry is
and what the industry can do
and changing what the goalposts are
so that everybody else has to work hard.
I think there should be multiple companies
that are doing that, not just one.
I think there are multiple companies
that should be getting the government funding to do that,
not just one.
I don't have any personal investment in SpaceX's success
other than I hope Jamie has a long and prosperous career there
as well as all of the other engineers and friends
that I have that work there.
But we've got to figure out the exploration part
and that's what I'm after.
I'm after the engineering and the exploration
and the science that goes into this.
If any other company can come up and compete with SpaceX,
great, let's do that.
Let's figure that out.
Yeah, SpaceX is pretty good.
They're pretty solid.
Falcon 9 is one of the best rockets,
if not maybe the best rocket that humanity has ever made
in terms of its success and how it changed the industry
and what it's done and what it's enabled.
Its low costs have helped out science.
We've been able to add extra instruments
or other things that we wouldn't have beforehand
because $100 million extra to launch services
as opposed to saving that $100 million
and saying, okay, we'll put it into developing
this massive laboratory piece of equipment
down to something that weighs four kilograms
that we could put into orbit around something.
That's to me been the big thing
about that lowering of launch costs.
So getting true competition to make SpaceX better
than they already are would be astounding
and everyone would win from that.
It's not just one of those things where it's like,
oh great, that company wins
because they're also competing with SpaceX as well.
SpaceX gets that win too
because then they've got to get better
and they're already pretty good.
So like, what does an even better SpaceX look like?
So it looks pretty good to me.
Yeah.
Ryan, do you have any final thoughts on this?
Sorry for derailing you.
I've just been sitting back, reacting,
enjoying, observing, listening.
I am not surprised at what has happened.
I think it was inevitable, to be completely honest.
The personalities of President Trump and Egon Musk
do not fit together perfectly like a puzzle piece.
There was going to be some tension at some point
and it's just happened now at the start of June.
Actually, to be perfectly honest,
I thought it might've gotten a little bit more tense
a little bit earlier.
So I'm kind of surprised it lasted amicably this far, this long.
In terms of the proposal Ted Cruz put out,
again, I'm not entirely surprised
because this is how federal budgets work, right?
The White House says they want one thing,
Congress says they want another thing
and then we go back and forwards until October, right?
So this is part and parcel of how these things,
whether you think they should work like this or not,
that's a completely different discussion.
But for decades, this is how it has worked.
It's just a little bit more emotional this time.
I am kind of surprised to see a proposal for SLS
to be funded through to Artemis 5
because I think Artemis 3 might've been enough
because the SLS, it is a fact SLS is ridiculously over budget
and ridiculously behind schedule
and the SLS architecture back in 1990 made perfect sense
and I don't think anyone can be blamed for that.
I think considering where we were at that point
with the space shuttle program
and with commercial space not really being a thing,
SLS made perfect sense
but we're not in the 1990s anymore, we're in 2025.
Falcon 9 just celebrated its 15th anniversary.
We've been landing rockets for a decade.
We are at the beginning of the commercial space industry
picking up steam.
That ball is rolling down the hill
faster than it ever has been before.
Why do we, we are getting to the point
where SLS doesn't make sense anymore
because we are on the precipice of commercial industry
being able to do and far exceed
the capabilities of SLS and Orion.
So Artemis 3, in my opinion,
is kind of that boundary right now
of where SLS is no longer needed.
I am surprised to see Artemis 4 and Artemis 5
wanting to be funded at this position
from Ted Cruz's proposal.
Gateway as well, it all depends on your opinion.
In my opinion, I think we should be investing
in a base on the lunar surface,
not a base around the moon.
We want to live on the moon,
we don't want to live around the moon.
We have commercial LEO destinations
that are going to be coming online
over the next few years, over the next decade,
which will be able to replace
the services provided currently
by the International Space Station.
But again, these are all proposals.
White House is one thing, Congress is another thing,
and then we go back and forth until October
or even later in some instances.
So yeah, I can't change anything.
Those are just my thoughts.
We'll just have to wait and see how all of this,
everything at the moment is being thrown into a blender.
It's being run and we'll see what comes out
on the other end in a few months time.
It's like those old YouTube videos.
Will it blend?
That is the question.
Well, I'd certainly like to know
everybody else's thoughts about this.
What do you think about the scenario
of Dragon being decommissioned early?
What do you think about continuing SLS
at least into Artemis 4 and Artemis 5?
And does it make sense to even have
the Gateway Space Station if SLS
only goes up to Artemis 5?
Because the whole purpose,
and it's weird near rectilinear halo orbit,
is to make up for the lack of Delta V
that the Orion capsule and its service module has.
And it's the whole reason why it's placed there.
Personally, I don't have a problem
with having a small lunar space station,
but a little bit more of a convenient orbit
that would be able to rescue astronauts
at a moment's notice or something like that.
But I really want to know what all of you watching
think about all of this
and what should be the direction
that we should go from here.
So leave a comment,
let us know what you think about that,
and we can address that at a future time.
Ryan's just being smug
because his country's space program
isn't being run by pedantic children.
Our country, okay, okay.
That is true.
But again, I'm not going to sit here
and be like European sweep incoming,
where our launch program
is significantly behind North Korea.
I'm not going to sit here smug on a high hill
and be like,
look at us, we're so mature
and we haven't launched anything for 50 years.
I got to say the European space agency-
Slow and steady wins the race.
ESA right now has a chance
to do the funniest thing ever.
So here's your shot, Europe.
Come on, baby.
Yeah.
Also, just quickly,
before the chatroom gets the wrong idea,
I would just like to clarify my position on Gateway.
I agree with Mike.
I would support a station in lunar orbit,
but it's just the current parameters of Gateway
that just don't make like-
Gateway was developed for a specific reason
upon specific reason upon specific reason
that don't exist anymore.
Gateway was developed to serve
as an interface between the HLS
and between Orion.
Artemis 3 is going to be a direct docking
between Orion and HLS.
That removes a reason for Gateway existing.
It was designed to be in this near rectilinear halo orbit
so it would have communication line of sight
with the South Pole for the majority of its orbit.
It would always face Earth
and it would be able-
and the SLS would have enough delta V
to actually get to the orbit.
When we're going to develop solutions
such as what Blue Origin is coming up with
with that cislunar transporter,
that won't be-
that won't matter anymore.
That's another one of these reasons
that Gateway doesn't-
that the current, uh, the current-
What's the word?
I can just-
Gateway in its current-
Yeah, like the current plan,
the reason Gateway is in the position
it was intended to be in,
all of these reasons
are being knocked off the list
why Gateway should exist, right?
So I'm in favor of a lunar space station
but I'm not in favor of the current architecture
that Gateway is built around
because it keeps being dismantled
like a block is taken here
and a block is taken here
and suddenly we have this small space station
in this really awkward orbit
that exists for a reason that no longer exists.
Well, let's move right along
and talk about this a little bit.
I did just want to show a little bit
of a highlight clip
and I know that, uh,
Jamie doesn't like us to do it this way
but we're going to kind of need to anyway.
So let me just roll this for a minute
and talk about what they think, uh,
happened for, um, the lunar landing.
So we were doing a live stream
and talking about, you know,
we were watching it live
and seeing all the things that were going on
and there wasn't a whole lot of telemetry
when it finally came on.
And the telemetry that we were getting
seemed pretty spotty.
It would go in and out
and it wasn't until,
it wasn't until the last minute
that we, um, were able to get, um,
a lot closer towards, uh,
the actual numbers
that we were supposed to be seeing
and it was way higher.
Um, let me get back up just a little bit.
It was way higher than it was supposed to be.
Um, the, right before we had mission cut out,
let me, uh, jump a little bit further here.
Sorry about this.
There we go.
Right before we had, uh, cut out,
I mean, we're looking at, uh, um,
219 kilometers per second
at only 329 meters from the surface,
still going over 187 kilometers per hour
when it impacted the moon.
And yeah, we get that kind of negative, uh,
altitude there for a split second.
And they're still not 100% sure
what completely went wrong with this.
The big thing that they were talking about
was the laser interferometer,
which, you know, is,
might be related to a similar problem
that they were having last time,
where they, um, their computer
basically misjudged its altitude
and wasn't able to have, you know,
the proper maneuver that it needed.
But last time it hovered
and hovered at, you know,
basically canceled out its momentum
thinking that it was almost at the surface.
So it hovered there for a minute
until all of its fuel was expired
and it still had like three kilometers
to grow, to go before its drop.
And, you know, obviously broke apart
in a couple of pieces
when it finally hit the surface.
This time around,
it seems like it was an opposite problem
where they thought that they were
maybe much higher than they actually were.
And so it wasn't starting
its programmed maneuvers to slow down,
to do its breaking burn
and slow down and get into that nice orientation
to have a nice soft landing on the moon.
So that's just a theory at this point.
We've only been getting a handful
of updates from them.
Hopefully we'll be able to get more.
But certainly the sentiment that I'm seeing
is that they're getting a lot of support
from the space industry,
a lot of support from the space band community
and are going to continue forward
and keep pressing forward.
They have lots of different operations
in motion right now.
They've got a Luxembourg office
that is building more rovers
and more small satellites
to help establish lunar communications
for future missions.
They've got their US space office,
which is where they're going to be moving over
all of the construction
of their next lunar landers.
And because of that US office,
they've also been able to get CLPS contracts,
Commercial Lunar Payload Services contracts.
So despite another failure
of their Hakuto mission,
they're not stopping
and they're going to keep going
as far as they possibly can.
And of course are eagerly awaiting
the results of whatever the budgets results
come about for the moon exploration program.
But in the meantime,
they're going to keep on doing
and keep doing their plan
of having as many investors
and sponsorships as possible
to make sure that our next mission is happening.
So a bit of sad news,
but Josh Simpson brings up
and I don't know,
Josh Simpson brings up
and I don't know what the architecture is,
but it's with it being so cold,
do they use LIDAR
and would that change the sensitivity?
Oh my gosh.
Good point, Josh Simpson.
I hadn't even thought about that.
Maybe that could be a reason
why that was on the fritz for them.
Huh.
I'm going to have to look into that a little bit
because I know that they were using,
they had a laser interferometer
and they also had an altimeter
and we're talking about radar.
So I wouldn't be surprised
if they are using LIDAR on this
since they kind of have the systems
to make that happen.
Man, I hadn't even considered
the temperature causing that
to be on the fritz for them.
I wonder, I really wonder if that's it.
Within 30 feet of the lunar surface
has entirely different condition
than the higher altitude.
So maybe dealing with a dynamic landing condition.
30 feet though seems incredibly low
considering what we do with the data
that we saw on the live stream.
Like we were still, you know,
several hundred meters above the lunar surface
traveling way too quickly.
So, you know, if it's,
if that's something that's within 30,
like I'm not discrediting the theory whatsoever
because I'm not knowledgeable
in LIDAR to that degree.
But, you know, if this is only something
that could change within the last 30 feet,
I doubt that could have an impact
considering we saw this lander
going way too quickly,
several hundred meters above the surface.
But that is according to the telemetry,
which, you know, went into negative numbers,
which I'm not 100% sure how you manage that.
But either way.
It means he went underground.
They crashed so hard.
They went inside.
No, I'm just, I'm telling you,
JPL was onto something
with their little triangle pyramid
balloon thing for mirror rovers.
We should start doing those balloon bounces
for lunar landings.
I mean, if landing is what your,
what your difficulty is,
like that problem's already been solved.
Hopefully the third time around
is somewhere in the middle, though,
because, you know, the first mission,
it landed too high up.
They were, you know,
they were hovering five kilometers
above the surface.
This one, they clearly weren't
slowing down in time.
So they crashed into the moon
at a high speed.
Maybe this time around,
it'll be somewhere in the middle
and they'll actually get a soft,
soft touchdown because, you know,
the ice base, they're good at getting,
they're good at getting nearly there.
Like two times in a row,
they've nearly got there.
You know, this isn't like
the recent Russian lunar probe,
which, you know, went kaput,
you know, in high earth orbit
and couldn't actually conduct
any sort of maneuvers around the moon
and just smashed into the moon.
They've, you know,
they've nearly gotten there
twice in a row.
So, you know, fingers crossed
they get it stuck on the third time
because they have gotten,
you literally cannot get
any closer to landing
than they have already gotten.
They've gotten so close
just without the soft landing part,
like so, so close.
So the next one will be just right.
That's the hope.
100%.
So yeah, I hope they carry on.
Yeah, me too.
I hope that they carry on.
I'm really excited that they have
some really great people
that are working with them.
Their original Google Lunar XPRIZE team
and the people that they've assembled
for the American office.
I think they're awesome.
A big fan of Ron Garan,
former astronaut.
So I'm really looking forward
to what they do
and hope that things continue.
And that everyone who has
these types of ambitions
are able to continue
and succeed with their programs.
Hopefully Intuit's machines
will get more stable
once in the future.
But anyway, not to get sidetracked.
I think we should go ahead
and move right along.
Well, to kind of close things up,
we've been yapping for quite a while,
but did you guys see the latest test
from one of the Chinese companies?
Space Epoch is their name.
I don't know if any of you
had a chance to see this,
I was very impressed by the...
I'm not sure whether this was
intended recoverability,
but we can discuss.
Right, exactly.
Yeah, here, let me blow this up
so that we can actually see this
and see what I'm talking about.
Don't blow up the rocket.
Yeah, don't blow up the rocket.
So super interesting test.
This is a smaller rocket.
It's all stainless steel
and kind of looks like Starship,
but it's actually much closer
to like the size of Falcon 9
or possibly the upper stage of a Falcon 9,
because as you can see from the video,
it only has one engine.
So pretty interesting test,
but they were able to do
this hop and hover test.
And as you'll see in just a moment,
they relight their engine
and do a splashdown of this rocket.
And the crazy thing to me,
as Ryan alluded to,
is that they were able
to just go out there with fishing boats
and recover this thing.
No explosion, even though it kind of looks
like there's some explosions right there.
This test actually survived.
And it's just mind-blowing to me
that they were able to recover this thing.
Let me, sorry, I should have been
a little bit better prepared,
but let me get the hold up
of the person that recovered this thing,
that this thing was able to survive.
And it looks like they also ripped off
a handful of things from, here we go.
They ripped off a handful of things
from more like Blue Origin systems.
You can kind of see the flaps
that they have here.
And it looks like it's multiple bars of steel,
but the way that it comes out
is really similar to the New Shepard system,
which I find to be really interesting.
And yeah, they were just able
to tow this thing into port
and was completely fine
and didn't have any problems with it.
And they should be able to reuse it pretty quickly.
So I find that really crazy and really admirable.
Here's some pictures of that recovery.
You know, that they were able to do this
and looking forward to what they can do
with the next, you know,
assuming that this was probably an upper stage
and that they're full stage for it
because they plan to catch this thing with chopsticks.
Assuming that the first stage booster
will be tested at another time.
But a lot of interesting things
that they are kind of ripping off
and following the way from the American companies
that are doing this.
And they're not far behind.
It seems like to me that they are going to have,
you know, they are going to have
their own reusable rockets very, very soon.
So, you know, we just keep getting surprised
with all these different tests
from these random assortment of Chinese companies.
Just imagine what kind of rocket you could make
if you had everybody else's design.
Well, you'd make a rocket that works for you.
I bought a Starship booster on Wish
and this is what came.
I feel like we've been talking about,
you know, Chinese vehicles
getting to the point of being reusable for so long now.
And it's going to be really exciting
to finally see an organization
that isn't SpaceX be able to pull this off
because don't get me wrong, I love SpaceX.
SpaceX does incredible things
and they've been propping up the launch industry
for well over a decade at this point, essentially.
But, you know, other people have to catch up.
And if no companies in the US
are going to be close to it,
you know, personally, I think,
depending on how well the next flight of New Glenn goes,
it's going to be between Blue Origin
and one of these Chinese companies
for the next organization,
which is going to be able to have a vehicle
which is propulsively recoverable, right?
Because, you know, ULA is nowhere to be seen
in the space.
All of the other companies, you know,
Firefly, Rugativity, Stoke,
they're still in the development phases of their vehicles
and they're currently building the initial hardware
for those things.
But, you know, China's already,
you know, multiple Chinese organizations
have thrown these hop tests now.
We have Space Epoch, we have Space Pioneer,
we have Landspace.
There's so many more, I've forgotten them.
They've gone off the top of my head.
Surely it's only a matter of time now
until SpaceX has some Chinese competition, right?
Surely it's only a matter of time
and it's going to be really exciting
to finally see something we've been talking about
for years at this point come to fruition.
Well, this is the all ships part
of the rise of the tide.
Like, you've proved that it can be done
and if there's a market behind it that can support it,
whether it's backed by government or not,
like, they're going to find the configuration
that works best to do the thing
and it's going to be copy, copy pasta.
Like, I know that there were spies
in the government, the Russian government
or USSR when they designed Buran,
but they came to similar conclusions
about a lot of things that they didn't have spy data for.
And the similar thing, like, who is it?
Josh Simpson says it's more of a lot of physics
that dictates that most of the common design
and similar approaches more than different style
or ego of country pride.
Like, it turns out that math knows
how to solve that problem.
And if you are giving it the same inputs,
you're going to get a very similar result.
But this is awesome to have another entity
be able to do the same thing.
They're developing their own software.
They're not getting software from SpaceX.
Like, they're figuring out their own solutions
to the same problem.
It just happens to look very similar.
Yeah.
It turns out that the laws of physics apply equally
in the United States of America
as they do in the People's Republic of China.
But everything's upside down in Australia.
No, just kidding.
Well, anyway, I want to be...
Australia gets it easy
because the rockets just fall off, you know.
Oh, all they got to do is just release the launch claps
and just let it fall.
Really, really efficient propulsion.
Returning them to the base is harder.
Yeah.
Oh, okay.
Got it now.
Now it makes sense.
Well, big thank you to Dave Avery
for your gift of five Tomorrow memberships
to folks in the chat room.
So thank you very much for that.
And also a big thank you to everyone else
who has been supporting this show
and making this happen.
We would not be able to do this without you.
So big support, big thank you
to our ground support members.
You can join the ground support level
for as little as a dollar a month
if you haven't been gifted one already.
And it's because of you guys
that we are able to continue doing this show
and have the type of content
that we're trying to produce.
We're going to have a lot more space pods
for you guys soon.
We're going to have a bit more members only content
for you guys talking about plans
and things that we should be doing
on the rest of the show.
But in the meantime, again,
thank you so much to everyone
who is helping to contribute.
And right after this,
we're going to be discussing a little bit more
and sharing some more of our thoughts
and opinions about the news for this week
in our After Dark,
which will be coming on live
not long after this.
So for those of you who are a member
or for those that were just gifted a membership,
you should receive that notification very shortly.
And with that, again,
thank you very much, everyone.
And we will see you guys again next time.
Take care.