New fully reusable rocket innovations

TMRO Space News
221 followers
57 Video Views·Feb 19, 2025
On the Feb 16th, 2025 live show we discussed two upcoming and very real fully reusable rockets being developed. Not just first stage reusability. Full reusability. Well, kinda.
In this TMRO SpacePod we take a look at the Rocket Lab Neutron rocket as well as the Stoke Space Nova rocket. Which is your favorite, and why?
And remember you can always help out the shows of TMRO by becoming a member here: https://www.youtube.com/user/TMRO/join
Continue the conversation by joining TMRO on Discord: https://discord.gg/htEJMHyFBE
the interesting thing this week is both
of these Rockets got a update from their
respective companies I'll start off with
Neutron the key uh items uh that they
released were the numbers to
geostationary transfer orbit which we
hadn't seen before so how much mass
Neutron will be able to take to GTO
interestingly next to rtls there is an
n/ a not applicable so according to this
PDF Neutron will not be able to return
to thech site if they are launching a
payload to GTO and then for the
downrange recovery on a drone ship
because Marine asset suck uh that's
1,800 kilos to a 40° GTO and then an
Expendable Neutron would be 2,800 kilos
to a GTO comparing that to Leo low earth
orbit is a quick refresher for Neutron
with rtls that's 8500 downrange Landing
is 13,000 and Expendable is 15,000
that's to low earth orbit so the Leo
numbers at least a kind of 50ish per of
what Falcon 9 can do right now it's a
bit hazy because you know different
inclinations and where you know like
there are so many things that go into
how how much stuff you can actually lift
into space but that's the that's the
general numbers right now uh rocket lab
is uh released for Neutron which is
pretty cool and then the first stage is
going to be split into two stages for
the purposes of integration so instead
of having the entire first stage
vertical in a hanger or the entire first
stage horizontal in a hanger to allow
the payload to be M into that upper
portion there on top of the second stage
which is within the first stage they're
going to be able to split the booster in
half so you'll have the lower module
which will be stacked on the pad and
then you'll have the upper module which
will be able to be hung horizontally in
a hanger have the second stage in the
payload integrated horizontally in the
hanger it will then be rotated put on a
truck rolled out to the launch site and
stacked on top Neutron is kind of like a
Russian doll as it as in you'll have the
second stage within the first stage and
then the first stage will be able to be
split in half so you can then stack both
sides of your first stage on the pad to
create a whole rocket and then that
entire first stage will come back with
the recovery with the fairings attached
once the second stage has gone on it
it's a little bit confusing it's not
very traditional but you know rocket lab
obviously thinks it would work if not
they wouldn't have designed it uh and so
yeah it's going to be pretty pretty
exciting to see how Neutron ends up
working they're basically sticking the
second stage inside the first stage and
then slinging that out think of the
upper part as a really really long inter
stage with a reusable fairing on top
that's going to stay on the vehicle so
that that interstage and the fairing can
still come back with the first stage
booster what that allows them to do then
is they're effectively building the
first so you've got your first stage and
you got a really long inter stage the
the whole of the second stage fits in
the in the interstage but now that
second stage doesn't need all of the
normal protections that you would have
to have on a traditional second stage so
while their first stage will actually be
quite a bit heavier because there's a
lot more weight that it's carrying the
second stage can be lighter and less
complex and cheaper to build because
they're not going to recover their
second stage okay so that's Neutron but
Nova is fully reusable like what's no
for you but what is Nova's reusability
Stoke space has really been going down
this path of a really unique design with
their second stage as in as I mentioned
earlier they've got it's one engine but
the engine is also the heat shield so
embedded within the heat shield around
the outside they've got all of the these
little nozzles uh which then all of the
plumes from all of those nozzles
interact with the geometry of the heat
shield in order to create what is
effectively an Aeros Spike engine which
means it's super efficient uh sea level
or a little ways up from sea at stage
separation within the atmosphere it's
super efficient there and then as they
get higher into and eventually out of
the atmosphere it remains super
efficient uh with that second stage
engine there which means that they can
go all the way into orbit and then
eventually bring that second stage back
down for landing meaning that the entire
vehicle will be fully reusable and
because that second stage engine and
second stage heat shield is embedded to
essentially be the the same thing that
means much quicker reusable turnarounds
uh with that second stage uh because
it's all one thing it's built in you
don't have to worry about having your
engines exposed because your engine is
your heat shield and your heat shield is
your engine right so we've seen on
Starship maybe a little bit of tile burn
through isn't a great thing why do we
need to mess around with thousands of
tiles when we can just have one heat
shield that comes straight in heat
shield in the engine the same thing you
don't have to worry about burn throughs
you don't have to worry about engine
damage you don't have to worry about all
of these different things it's one one
entire structure it's the same thing
which is really I personally I think
this is really quite an Innovative
system that Stoke is coming up with here
and on the newest renders Stoke has put
out they have basically designed so you
can see that second stage it tapers out
like this right it's it's a conical
shape and those nozzles are going to be
around the outside of that conical shape
the first stage is going to be slightly
thinner than the widest part of that
conical shape which means Stoke will be
able to do staging without the need for
an inter stage think starship's hot
staging right we have the hot staging
ring which is a big shield on top of the
booster the inner Raptor engines fire
down and then that plume goes out there
right by having the engines physically
outside of the bounds of the booster
that means you don't have to mess around
with any interstage any pushes any
deflectors any heat shields any of that
nonsense right the engines will just
simply fire outside of the bounds of the
booster boost booster and and uh the
second stage will then separate because
your engines are firing you don't need
any other technology in order to do that
booster can then flip round come back
and do an an rtls drone ship whatever
Stoke ends up doing a style Landing with
its three Landing legs which kind of
look they're a bit stubbier and a bit
thicker they kind of look a bit like
cartoonish Falcon 9 Landing legs in the
current renders um but that's what stok
has kinding to do with their first stage
I thought Aeros Spike didn't make sense
did so that begs the question the the
reason it didn't make sense is because
the weight necessary to build out that
Aeros Spike engine like nled out all of
the benefits it's kind of like a
hydrolox engine right hydrogen liquid
oxygen on paper those engines are going
to be their ISP is going to be crazy but
the amount of weight that you need to
put into containing that liquid hydrogen
is so insane like in all it's so
complicated and hard to contain that
liquid hydrogen you lose most if not all
of the benefits of that hydrolock engine
and and Aeros spec seem to have a
similar issue so I guess my question to
the group is is Stoke spaces because
it's like one engine with a Ser it's one
engine with a series of like nozzles did
they overcome this weight problem or did
they just build the weight problem H how
are they able to be successful in
aerospike when no one else has before
personally I think it's the integration
with the heat shield because it's not
necessarily like they've gone out to
build an Aeros Spike engine they've
built an engine that surrounds a heat
shield that happens to create the Aeros
Spike effect that's essentially what has
happened with this engine yeah so it's
not like they've gone we need to build
an Aeros Spike for upper stage they've
gone well if we put these nozzles around
the heat shield it happens to make an
Aeros Spike effect that could be useful
what I'm hearing you guys say is it's
not actually an aerospike engine it's
like aerospike adjacent it's an
accidental Aeros Spike engine right it
creates the effect but it's not an AOS
Spike not really it doesn't actually
look like an Aeros Spike engine I think
there are two ways to do it but the one
you normally see kind of has this there
is there is no Spike right with a
traditional Aeros Spike engine you have
a literal spike in it right and that's
where the exhaust is pushing against and
that's how you end up getting your
efficiency because no matter what
altitude you're at or whatever pressure
ambient pressure is around you it's
pushing on the spike it's not pushing on
the Bell or atmosphere around you in
order to do it what this seems like
they're doing is that they basically
have everything they have the nozzles
aimed in a specific way that the
geometry of the exhaust coming off of it
maybe recirculation or something in that
exhaust ends up generating that Spike
but in a physical sense all right so
this all makes sense this is actually
all really kind of exciting I guess the
next question next question is how real
are these things I feel like and maybe
this is just me being biased I feel like
rocket lab is going to deliver they've
delivered before in the past they have a
history of delivering so I feel like
Neutron is going to be a thing rocket
lab seems to be a company that uh it
seems like they'll be able to do it as
as well and I think Stoke probably going
to be all right okay uh all right in the
first going into the future uh short
term they seem like they're going to be
okay uh they just recently announced
they concluded another funding round you
know they've got a few hundred million
uh that's come into the company over the
last few years uh they're developing
this that picture we were showing
earlier of Andromeda which is the name
of that heat shielding engine uh for
Stokes upper stage that's a real engine
that's on their test stand right now in
Washington that's going through testing
that's real Hardware they've built they
they've built a real uh subscale uh
version uh of their of their vehicles
first and second stages uh they they've
built actual Hardware they've tested
actual Hardware they're working on
actual Hardware you know this isn't some
render that a small group has put out
you know Stoke space are full of founded
by an former blue origin engineer right
who worked on the be4 program you know
Stoke is full of people who know what
they're doing I'm really encouraged by
the tests that stok space has been doing
I've watched a couple of interviews with
their CEO and elapa and uh I think that
they've you know got the right mentality
and are you know have that kind of
SpaceX scrappiness of can we eliminate
things and figure out the best way to do
this you said that they have SpaceX
scrappiness do they have SpaceX sense of
urgency as well I do think that there is
a sense of urgency only because in some
of those uh interviews with Andy lapsa
talking about how you know if if like he
brought up lots of examples about kypers
space in one web um and even echostar of
like if they don't get going on their
constellations now they're going to
completely miss out on satellite
internet business
so the vibe that they're giving off is
that they do have a sense of urgency is
there a market for it like we look at
Falcon 9 Falcon 9 is not a medium lifter
right Falcon 9 is technically a heavy
lift vehicle a heavy lifter it started
off as a medium lifter but it's
technically a heavy lifter now the
medium lifter isn't the thing the the
version that was a medium lifter isn't
the thing that changed Aerospace it's
the heavy lifter that changed Aerospace
it's the heavy lifter that does the
transporter missions it's the heavy
lifter that does the Starship missions
it's Falcon Le Falcon 9 heavy lifter
that is dominating the Aerospace
industry today dominating it is there
room in the market for a medium lift
launcher or are these guys thinking too
small I think that there is a market for
both of these Rockets here simply
because of the fact that one there there
are groups that want dedicated flights
there are people that do not want to fly
with anyone else whether that be for
operational purposes or the orbits that
they're going to or things like that
there are people who want to fly solo
and then secondly these Rockets
especially something like Neutron
they're being purpose built there's a
specific reason and it's it is the
future of what we're seeing in space
flight right now and they're very much
hitting right for the gap of where you
want that ball to go and let's see what
happens if NASA continues with the Leo
destination program to create another
space station in low earth orbit to
continue the type of national lab
experiments that we do there in
collaboration with our International
partners then we're going to need cargo
delivery and we're going to need crew
delivery for quite some time and it it
seems to me I could be wrong about this
but it seems to me like SpaceX wants to
phase out the Falcon 9 rocket and Falcon
heavy and kind of move everything over
toward Starship and if we do have
another crude space station in low earth
orbit they're going to need crew and
cargo uh deliveries for quite some time
and it would be a real shame if you know
SpaceX does retire Falcon 9 or even
their crude dragons and that would kind
of open up the door for even more
competition to uh get into the crude
delivery business as well but even if
they don't manufacture their own
capsules there's going to be a need for
those types of of Rocket classes to
deliver that amount of payload I think
that there's going to be a need for that
for quite some time at least looking 10
to 15 years out I am going to agree with
Jared and Mike I think there is a market
for these especially you see we've got
relativity coming in but we don't
exactly know how far along they are they
haven't really shown off any hardware
except for Hardware which isn't theirs
anyways talking about Neutron and Nova I
think Neutron uh I how should I word
this I think Neutron definitely has the
uh opportunity just because it is at
least in theory capable of lifting more
mass in into space I think it is going
to be more successful of the two in
terms of up Mass however with Stoke this
is stoke's first rocket right and SpaceX
started small rocket lab started small
relativity started everyone starts small
then scales upright this is stoke's
first rocket this is going to be a
smaller rocket let's not disregard what
they could do in the future imagine a
NOA Style Rocket at a huge scale right
this could be kind of crazy if you think
of it the group seems to be most excited
about Stoke and Nova is that a fairly
safe assumption like is everyone just
not not that nutron is not exciting but
like everyone it feels like Stoke is
doing things that no one's done before
and that just kind of excites as space
nerds is that that fair I'm super
excited to see a fully reusable rocket
full reuse is the Holy Grail of rocketry
and to see anyone willingly pursuing
that is great
