Traditional Archery: Heavy Arrow Vs Light Arrow

LEARN ARCHERY
7 followers
May 18, 2025
Comparison Shooting a heavyweight vs lightweight arrow and overall performance and impact out of a 40lb Centaur Supercurve.
Man, what is going on y'all. So it's been a few days since I got out here and I wanted to talk
about something that kind of you know I've been I've been worried about for a little while and
you know I love I guess you know I love a fast boat. I just built a set of arrows for these
Gold Tip Velocity Pro arrows right here. They're a 6.5 GPI arrow. They're a Gold Tip 600 with
and I'm running a 125 point. They're 354 grams total and that is a super super light arrow
for a traditional bow setup. Super fast. It's a good 3D arrow. It has a you know really fast
flight flat. It's a flat flying arrow and fun to shoot but y'all listen to this. So I started
shooting that arrow at my targets. You know it's getting good penetration out of where I thought it
was and then you know I was talking to a guy he was like I was like what do you shoot for hunting
you know what what is your what is your weight for hunting there you know 500 plus grains for
a hunting arrow is a you know a good starting point especially for this lightweight of a bow.
It's not sending the arrow super quick but from this weight and on you know further up you're
the faster I can shoot a heavier arrow you know the better my chances are as far as getting better
penetration which in reality it's pretty much right you know. So I went back to my roots
and I have set up an arrow for this bow. It's a Deep Impact 500. It's working for me.
I have a 100 grain focus system up front plus 225 grain centaur big game broadhead. This one's
kind of dirty but this is the arrow set up the broadhead set up I'm going to be shooting out
of both of my bows this season. I have a this centaur super curve and I have a 46 pound centaur
super curve that I just purchased and that bow is going to be quite a bit faster than this one
and this bow already will bury these arrows pretty good into the target so let's uh let's get out
here and take some shots with both my um my target arrow and the hunting arrow the heavier we're
going to shoot some shots at a 20 yard distance. I'm going to set up a smaller target and I may
have to move my um not going up and down to accommodate but uh let's see what happens and
see um see how my accuracy is with both of these arrow setups. All right Charles so we're going to
start off the video shooting a heavy arrow um this shot right here is about 20 yards we'll be
shooting at the block target just to get um get loosened up and uh we'll um get loosened up get
our shot down and uh start putting arrows in the middle. Um right now I'm shooting a 120 a 200 grain
field point up front on this arrow I don't have a 225 so that's what we're using for the um for
the heavier arrow setup. The wind is blowing like crazy I'm going to try to take some shots but uh
if I can't we'll go ahead and set up a target just to see um you know kind of check out how
this heavy arrow flies in the wind also versus a light arrow so let's take a shot at the middle
of that block target. All right so the wind caught that arrow bad it was that um that arrow was right
in the middle of the target and the wind uh kicked it out and I went to the left but uh it was a slow
I don't know if y'all saw it it was pretty slow arrow so now I'm going to shoot this gold tip
velocity um this arrow is oh it's 200 grains less than the arrow that I just shot it's a 354
grain arrow versus a 575 and um the wind just blew my camera over that's how windy it is it's not
really a good day to shoot but I'm gonna go ahead and uh I'm gonna go ahead and shoot this video
you know shoot this arrow so let's do it this is this arrow is going to be a lot quicker
so that arrow um that arrow sliced through that wind like I thought it would do it's
right in the middle of the target 20 yard shot super fast arrow and um as far as a 3d arrow
that's what that's what I'm gonna pick is that I'm gonna use those light arrows for my 3d arrows
and I'm gonna use these heavy arrows for hunting let's shoot another one of these um dp impact
575 grain arrows and see if it'll even get down to the middle of the target in this wind
all right so that that actually flew pretty good it wasn't didn't have too much play with the wind
um those arrows are showing a hair weak with that 200 so we may have to chop them down a little bit
but I'm gonna um I'm gonna shoot them right now just to see how they do all right so let's shoot
the deep impact again man I'm telling you with this heavy heavy weight up front at that short
distance I'm going to be hunting that if I could get this arrow to work for me and fly somewhat
straight it's going to be a powerhouse as far as getting maximum penetration on an animal
let's shoot with the deer target all right double long on the deer target good shot
so that arrow you know was it was moving a little bit in the wind but not not terrible
it wasn't as bad as I thought it was going to be let's shoot another one the same arrow
um heavy deep impact and put another one in the long
all right that wind knocked my camera over but like I was saying let's put a
another one of those arrows
another one of those arrows in the bottles of the deer target
that was a good flying arrow right there that was that heavy arrow
oh quiet and the bow down a little bit and it flew super smooth out to the target I actually
held a little higher because I thought it was going to drop off but it didn't drop off
near as bad as I thought it was gonna so here's the lightweight arrow let's uh take a shot with
I'm gonna have to hold low with this thing because I know it's going high on this shot
man this wind's about to knock my camera over again hold on y'all y'all give me a second
boom right there man right there in the heart so I'll be honest with you that fast arrow is fun
to shoot it's flat flying but it's not that much faster than the um this heavy arrow I mean
I'm telling you this heavy arrow is probably shooting low high 160s low 170s on the chronograph
that light arrow is hitting 195 with this bow averaging about 195 but it's not really a concern
to me my concern is getting this arrow through that animal this arrow right here is gonna do it
it's got enough punch I'm telling you it's got enough punch with this serious heavy broadhead
setup y'all gotta see this shot right in the middle of the target this is 20 yards with the
325 grain total point weight 225 grain centaur broadhead y'all check this out 20 yard shot
centaur broadhead right in the middle of the target with my little super curve
now this this bow right here is fast enough at 40 pounds to get it done that's super accurate
this arrow fight was awesome big broadhead I mean it's it's tearing my target up that's a big ass
broadhead right there and it is gonna be a killer setup this season and this is what I'm sticking
with not changing my mind I'm hunting with this arrow and um this is what I'm gonna be using I'm
gonna get some pass through on whatever animal I get a chance to shoot at whether it be a deer or
hog or maybe a rabbit who knows y'all I changed this shot angle up a little bit I'm I'm this
camera is working out for me but I'm thinking about getting me a little bit better camera here
soon this one shoots in 4k the video quality is fine on it but um I think I could get a little
bit better quality with another camera but anyway enough of that let's uh let's shoot some arrows
let's shoot these heavy arrows at the uh if I can't shoot my deer targets I will shoot the block
I'm gonna move this camera over a little bit this will work let's shoot the block and uh
we're gonna shoot the white block um I'm gonna shoot the white block and then I'm gonna shoot
the rod hard block with the broadhead cool with that shot I don't know so when I when I
I missed my shot high to the right and I don't know if you can see on the video I started letting
down and that every time you do that you're gonna miss you'll miss every time you let down like that
you're gonna miss to the right why I'm a right-handed shooter and when I'm when I uh that bow arm lets
down what that's gonna do is um it's gonna stiffen it's gonna stiffen that arrow up which
a flesh arrow a flesh stiff arrow is gonna fly to the right where a weak your weak
arrows are gonna it's gonna go to the left and then correct itself so
I'm pretty sure that's how it works out um but uh let's shoot another let's shoot another
heavy arrow 550 grain arrow and I try to hit this target all right that was that arrow I didn't hold
high enough on that one it dropped off but it was right in the center it's a good shot but
wasn't perfect let's shoot this light arrow do the same thing and I'm gonna show y'all
it's gonna hit right in the center right in the center actually it was a little bit to the left
but we'll pretend it was right in the center let's shoot the broadhead with the rod heart
this one's gonna hit the center caught some wind it was fishtailing like hell out of there
all right y'all so those those three shots right there are horrible I'm gonna shoot these again
let's start out with the light arrow this time so that light arrow shot a little bit low
caught some wind um but it was still in the middle they uh it really zips through the
wind a little better than these heavy ones but um these heavy ones are hitting with a lot more force
right there in the middle with that heavy arrow and it uh rocked the target
I gotta get my shots together I keep uh messing my shots up pulling off my face or whatever
let me put this uh we'll put this oh I gotta go retie that too let me put this uh arrow in the
middle of the target broadhead arrow boom good shot little fishtailing right there in the middle
we need to tune I need to tune that 225 broadhead to those arrows I think we're gonna have to cut
them down a little bit they're still getting a lot of flex from being uh too weak so we'll get
that set up before uh here soon definitely before hunting season all right y'all there's my shots I
was shooting at the uh over there by the fence that's another angle but um shooting um that was
my last shot with a broadhead it hit a little bit to the right which I said that you know it's it's
catching it was fishtailing a little bit um my first deep impact arrow was uh in the middle right
there and then the second one was a little bit to the right same thing happened I let down
and when I let down it goes to the right but I want to um I'm going to do one more
I'm going to shoot a shot with the um heavier arrow at the at my block rod heart target
and we're going to see the penetration difference from about 15 yards on the heavy versus the
lightweight arrow all right y'all so these three shots with the different arrows were um
I could definitely tell that the heavier arrows hit this target with a lot more force
let's uh let's look at the penetration from the heavier arrow real quick
got that much into the target super heavy arrow uh slow but hits like a tank that much into the
target super light arrow slow hits like a tank I think this will be a different story with the
broadhead on the end of it another super heavy arrow um I don't know watch the video but I'm
pretty sure these heavy arrows are moving this target a lot more with a lot more force than the
the lighter weight arrow all right y'all sorry about the noise um my pool was on and I'm just
I'm gonna leave it running for right now um we're gonna take a we're gonna take a long shot now with
the lightweight arrow and then one of my heavyweight arrows just to see you know how slow
the heavier arrow gets to the target versus the light arrow but let me remind y'all this heavy
arrow has way more force behind it and uh penetration wasn't a ton different but
it uh when it hits vitals of an animal it's going to be different
I'm telling you so let's see how this let's see how this light arrow does
we got about a 27 yard shot from here all right so it's in the lungs made it to the deer target
find there wasn't a uh there wasn't a much drop with that air even in this wind it didn't affect
it too much so let's see what this heavy arrow does so the heavy arrow let me let me shoot that
again but I don't know if y'all saw the deer target out there when that heavy air hit that
deer target from this distance it rocked it talking about the whole deer target shook it's
a lot of force from this 575 grand error all right that dropped off a little low but uh plenty
accurate I don't uh I'm not uh too worried about that now let's shoot the centaur broadhead this
is a way long shot to be shooting this but uh I'm gonna shoot it at the bottom Rhinehart hard
to see if I can hit in the middle all right it was in the middle kind of fishtail but it was low
I definitely want to tune those arrows to that big broadhead all right Joe I'm I've been talking about
you know the two errors I have that I'm shooting with um one's that one's a 575 grand error with
the centaur broadhead and with the 200 the 200 grand tip I'm shooting off of it is coming it
should be coming in around 550 grand so let's check we're going to start with the light arrow I have
so showing 23.1 so when you're if you if you have a green scale you'll be uh taking 23.1
so we have 23.1 times 15.432 that is showing 356 grains for this lightweight
uh gold tip velocity pro arrow so with that being said 356
356 grains for that centaur I mean for that gold tip velocity pro with the 125 point
so the heavy arrow I'm gonna weigh the 200 grain field point and see what it comes out to
all right so
make sure I have it in the right spot
35.7 on this so let's see what that is 35.7 times 15.432
550 grains on the dot with the 200 grain field point 550 grains for that arrow so this is a
considerably heavier arrow compared to the gold tip let's weigh it with the centaur broadhead now
this is a 225 grain broadhead
let's see
we're getting a 37.4 let's see what that is 37.4 times 15.432
so 577 grain arrow right there with the centaur big game broadhead heavy here
for that little uh 40 pound bow that I'm shooting
all right for the end of this video I just I set up a bottle down on my coke uh set up
set up a coke bottle down upon the target we're just going to take a couple shots with
the lightweight arrow and the heavy arrow just to you know test accuracy and see which one's
flying better the wind died down a hair but still got a good bit of wind um for today but let's
shoot this the lightweight uh air first I have it tuned to this bow so um hopefully we'll hit
it right off the bat all right we got a little bit to the right that arrow will fly super straight
out of this bow see what the heavier arrow will do now all right I'm accurate with the heavier
arrow it was moving around a little bit but I did hit the coke bottle from here this is uh
about a 17 yard shot so that's plenty for um it's plenty good for hunting I'm not going to be
um I'm not going to be shooting at animals too much further than that
