The Harrowing And Sinister Case Of Beautiful Mary Paye

Interesting Stories
393 followers
76 Video Views·May 1, 2025
The Calculating Case of Mary Paye: A Case That Caused Much Scandal in 1880s New York and Is Still Discussed Today
Today we are looking at a case from the second part of the 19th century so sit
back as we go to the USA. Fishkill Landing in the early 1880s was a bustling
riverfront location along the Hudson River in Dutchess County New York. It was
an important transportation industrial hub with a strong economy driven by
brick manufacturing, boat building and commerce. The village had a working-class
population which included boatmen, laborers and factory workers, many of
whom were employed in the brickyards and on the docks. The Hudson River was
central to daily life with numerous schooners and steamboats transporting
goods and passengers to New York and other destinations. The area had a mix of
modest homes, boarding houses and small businesses with many residents connected
to the maritime industry. Although the village had a great sense of community
there was sometimes what was described as a rough atmosphere as disputes and
tensions often played out in public. One of the better-known families of boatmen
was the Pays. Mr. William Pay had been a river captain but he had died in 1875
and his sons David, John and Childs all took to the river early and became
captains of their own vessels. They were rugged men all who had a reputation of
being wild in their younger years but by 1882 they had put their unruly ways
behind them and had all become members of the Methodist Church. David Pay was
particularly well-known. His wife had died in 1870 leaving him a widow with
the responsibility of raising their daughter Grace alone. They lived in a
house on Division Street but when Grace was old enough she left the house to
work in New York. In 1878 David married again. His second wife named Mary was a
daughter of John Ferguson, a brickyard labourer from Bryantsville. Her life
growing up had not been easy. She had suffered from hardship and instability
which had made her a resilient and determined woman. Everyone described her
as a very attractive young lady. She was slender, had light brown hair and
beautiful eyes. She was also 22 years younger than her husband. At first the
marriage seemed happy and in 1880 Mary gave birth to a baby girl. However as
time passed tension grew between the couple and some believed that this was a
real reason that Captain David Pay had decided to leave his position as captain
of the schooner VW Brill in early December 1882, a vessel that he owned
with his brother John. His final voyage was to sail with a cargo of brick from a
yard in Fishkill Landing to New York City. At 44 years old his health had been
deteriorating. He suffered from rheumatism and had only recently
recovered from malaria. He told people that he had come to the conclusion that
life aboard a ship was taking its toll on his body. So with this in mind he had
made plans to leave the sea and open a market stall in the nearby village of
Matanwan instead. When he returned from his voyage his rheumatism was
particularly bad. So he sent for the family physician Dr. A.R. Teel and asked
him to be treated for both rheumatism and malaria. However despite this
treatment Captain Pay's condition continued to worsen. He began to
experience a burning sensation in his throat, intense stomach pain and an
unquenchable thirst. As his symptoms grew more severe Dr. Teel enlisted the help of
Dr. Henry Wilson and Dr. William Jones who were both from Newborough to assist
in diagnosing the captain's mysterious illness. Tests were conducted on his
vomits which revealed the presence of arsenic. Both surprised and concerned the
doctors decided to send the sample to Dr. J.D. Seitz. In order to get a second
opinion Dr. Seitz tests confirmed their fears. Captain David Pay was indeed
suffering from arsenic poisoning. By now he was in excruciating pain and his
health was declining rapidly. The doctors held very little hope for his recovery.
So reluctantly informed him of the grim prognosis. Despite his worsening
condition Captain Pay was fully aware of the situation and understanding what lay
ahead. He made arrangements to put his affairs in order. He authorized his
brother John to withdraw the money he had in the bank. By now he was too frail
to even lift a pen but he was able to find enough strength to touch it lightly.
While John carefully wrote his name on his behalf. It was as if this was his
final act. Even if his strength continued to fade. Dr. Teal spoke to the
coroner Dr. J.B. Schenick informing him that he believed that Captain Pay had
been poisoned and would not survive much longer. On Sunday the 24th of December
Dr. Schenick went to the house on Division Street to try and take an
anti-mortem statement from the dying man. However when he arrived Captain Pay was
too weak and was unable to make one. His condition continued to deteriorate and
on the morning of the 26th of December 1882 he died. Upon learning of the death
the coroner summoned a jury to conduct an inquest and led them to the house to
view the deceased. As they entered they found Captain Pay's widow Mrs. Mary Pay
seated solemnly beside her late husband maintaining a silent vigil. Her face was
marked with sorrow and she wept openly yet whispers of doubt rippled amongst
those present. Some wondered whether her grief was genuine or merely a
performance. A suspicion about her true emotions hung over the somber scene. The
same day Drs. Henry Slack, A.R. Teal, J.E. Mori and H.C. Wilson made a post-mortem
examination. The traces of arsenic were strong enough to convince them that the
man's death had been caused by poison. Parts of the lungs, stomach, liver and
intestines were then all transported to New York to be analysed by Dr. Edward G.
Love. As news of the death of Captain Pay spread the community was quick to
speculate on the sudden demise of a man who only recently had recovered from
malaria and who had always seemed to be strong and healthy. Rumours began to
circulate about the troubled nature of his marriage to his young wife and it was
suggested that at the end of November she had left the marital home only
returning after both parties had agreed to sign an agreement in the presence of
a justice of the peace. It was said that one of the conditions on this document
was that Captain Pay would not make trouble for his wife regarding an alleged
forgery of his name to withdraw money from his bank. Despite this her brief
abandonment of her husband had stirred much gossip especially regarding her
behaviour since their marriage. One story surfaced that Captain Pay had confided in
a doctor that he had poisoned himself only to later retract the statement
claiming instead that he had suspected his wife of poisoning him. When the
captain passed away his brothers and sisters were by his side and vowed that
everything would be done to uncover the truth behind his death. Some in the
village believed that this meant they suspected Mrs. Mary Pay of poisoning him.
Although Mrs. Pay's conduct since the death of her husband had raised no
suspicion and she had acted every bit the grieving widow, the coroner ordered
that she be kept under close surveillance. It was noted that when Captain
Pay had first become ill his wife had been the one to administer his medicine
but after that day he had refused to take anything from her. When questioned
by the physicians about what she had given him she firmly denied providing him
with anything beyond what he had been prescribed. However whispers of darker
suspicions continued to spread. One rumour claimed that on the Monday nights
as Captain Pay lay gasping for breath a member of the household woke Mrs. Pay
to tell her that her husband was dying. It was said that her response was
chillingly indifferent and all she could say was, well what of that? These rumours
only fuelled the suspicions surrounding her. In the wake of the alleged remark a
search of the premises was conducted. Gossipers then claimed that
investigators had recovered some ashes from a refuse heap and a piece of pie
still wrapped in paper that would be tested for traces of arsenic. However when
Dr. Teal was asked if this was so he remained tight-lipped, neither confirming
or denying the rumours that now gripped the village. The funeral of Captain David
Pay was held on the afternoon of Thursday the 28th of December at the
Methodist Church in Matiawan. The community gathered to bid farewell to a
man who had spent his entire life in Fishkill Landing. His widow, Mary,
appeared visibly grief-stricken as she sat among the mourners. Many people
attended both the church service and the burial, their presence a testament to
the impact of his life and the questions surrounding his death. At half-past four
after the last mourners had departed the day took a dramatic turn. Mrs. Pay was
placed under arrest and brought before Justice W.O. Harris. She was accused of
ministering arsenic to her husband which caused his death. Despite this she
was not immediately jailed. Instead she was informed that she would be permitted
to return home for the night though under the strict watch of an officer.
The inquest began the following morning with Mr. H.H. Bantis appointed to
represent Mrs. Pay and Mr. John F. Schollester appearing for the district
attorney J.E. Morai. The doctor who had assisted Dr. Slack in the post-mortem
examination was the first witness. He stated that none of the deceased organs
appeared abnormal except for the stomach which was very congested. He added that
this condition could have been caused by an irritant poison. This finding was
later confirmed by Dr. Slack who agreed that the condition of the stomach
strongly suggested the presence of an irritant poison. The next witness was
William Pay, the nephew of the deceased man. He stated that while searching his
uncle's property he was instructed to check the well. Here he said that he
found a stick with a rag tied at each end forming a small makeshift bag. He
then told the inquest that the contents of this bag had never been tested. The
deep-seated troubles within the Pay marriage were laid bare for all to see
as the testimony of witnesses painted a picture of discord, betrayal and
unresolved tension that had plagued the couple in the months leading up to
Captain Pay's death. Mr. Alan Horton who lived near the residence of Mr. and
Mrs. Pay testified that Captain Pay had paid him for five days board for Mrs.
Pay at his house in early December. He said that he did this because Mrs. Pay
had abruptly left the marital home but added that after five days she went back
to live with her husband. Mr. Amos A. Luther was another witness. He informed
the inquest that Captain Pay had come to him a few weeks before his death to seek
his advice and assistance regarding his marital troubles. Mr. Luther said that
following this he went to speak to Mrs. Pay and asked her to meet with her
husband to try and reconcile their differences and restore their formal
life together. Then with a sigh he said that his efforts were unsuccessful. When
asked if Captain Pay had told him anything else Mr. Luther said that he had.
Then looking at the jury he explained that he had shown areas of the house
where Mrs. Pay had removed furniture and bedding and apparently taken the items
to the Hortons. William Dingy who lived across the street from the Pays testified
that he had visited Captain Pay every day during the last five days of his
illness. He said that Captain Pay had told him that he believed that he had
been poisoned though he did not accuse anyone directly or express distrust
towards his wife. However Mr. Dingy said that Captain Pay had suspected that a
wife of a man named Charlie Roth who lived in New York had tried to turn
Mrs. Pay against him. He explained that Mrs. Roth had written letters to her
alleging that Captain Pay had frequently visited disreputable places in the city
associated with questionable women and squandered his money. Mr. Dingy added
that Captain Pay denied these claims and he believed that he had always been an
honorable man. Before leaving the stand Mr. Dingy recalled that Mrs. Pay once
mentioned that Mr. and Mrs. Roth had given her bed bug poison but she claimed
that she had thrown it away. When Mr. Dingy was asked why he believed Mr. and
Mrs. Pay had experienced a troubled marriage he replied that in his opinion
the couple's troubles stemmed from Mrs. Pay's relationship with a man named
William Crawford who rented a room at the home of Mr. and Mrs. Horton. He said
that Mr. Crawford visited the Pays house whenever Captain Pay was away always
staying late into the nights but never when Captain Pay was home. Mr. J.D.
Talladay was the next witness. He stated that the Pays marriage was marked by
serious marital discord which was mostly caused by Mrs. Pay. He explained that
Captain Pay had forbidden his wife from allowing the Hortons or Mr. Crawford
into their home yet despite this she persisted in visiting them. He said that
on one occasion when Captain Pay had unexpectedly gone to the Hortons house
in search of his wife he was shocked to see William Crawford lying with his head
on Mrs. Mary Pay's lap. Mr. Talladay looked at the judge and explained that
some of the words used following this encounter were in his opinion too
inappropriate to be shared publicly. However he did say that Mrs. Pay was
angered by her husband coming to find her and told him that he was not the
father of her child. When asked what type of man Captain Pay was Mr. Talladay
replied that he was a kind-hearted man who adored his wife and often ignored
her threats and cruel statements for that reason. Mrs. Pay was present
throughout the proceedings but showed little interest. Instead she sat quietly
reading a newspaper. Mr. William Crawford took the stand. When questioned he was
asked if he had helped Mrs. Pay forge a check in her husband's name. He replied
that he had not. He also denied reports that he had been seen with his head in
Mrs. Pay's lap. He stated that he had known Captain Pay during his lifetime
and often visited the Pay household. He said that on some occasions Captain Pay
was home and sometimes he was not. But Mr. Crawford stressed that he never stayed
very late, usually no later than 11 p.m. and added that he was never alone in the
house with Mrs. Pay. Someone else was always present when he visited. However
when questioned on this he admitted often the only person present was Mr.
and Mrs. Pay's young child who was always asleep by 7 p.m.
Following this Mr. Crawford was asked if he had visited the house during Captain
Pay's illness to which he replied that he did not. He said that Captain Pay had
forbidden him from going there. Dr. Teal testified that he had asked Mrs. Pay if
she had given her husband anything to make him sick and she tearfully denied
it. However he added that Captain Pay had told him that he suspected he had been
poisoned through water from the well or from a pie made by his wife. When Mrs.
Pay took the stand she was questioned about her troubled marriage and her
relationship with Mr. William Crawford, a man who had been frequently seen at her
home while her husband was away. She forcefully denied ever engaging in any
kind of improper liaison with him, stating that any accusations of
unfaithfulness were nothing more than malicious gossip. When asked about the
insisted that she had eaten the entire pie herself and that there had been no
cause for concern. She denied ever poisoning her husband or having any part
in his illness. However despite these adamant denials a witness contradicted
her, recalling that Captain Pay had actually eaten most of the pie while
Mrs. Pay had barely touched it. The witness further stated that it was Mrs.
Pay who handled the food and medicine and had also fed her husband potatoes, so
any poisoning could only have been administered by her. When the inquest
ended the jury returned a verdict stating that in their opinion Captain
Pay had died from the effects of a corrosive poison, most likely arsenic.
They also pointed to Mrs. Mary Pay, his widow, as the primary suspect. Mrs. Pay
remained under arrest. However on Friday the 5th of January she was discharged.
Justice Harris explained that while it was confirmed that Captain Pay had died
from poisoning, there was insufficient legal evidence to charge Mrs. Pay with
murder. This did not convince everyone in the community, many of who believed that
the case had been mishandled, saying that it could have been conducted with far
less expense and with greater discretion. Others speculated that the high cost of
further chemical analysis, which was estimated to be between $500 and $1,000,
had deterred officials from pursuing the trial, which would be based solely on
circumstantial evidence. Following her release, Mrs. Pay was appointed
administrator of her late husband's modest estate. Public sentiment remained
sharply divided. Some were convinced that she had evaded justice due to lack of
direct proof, while others questioned whether the authorities had done enough
to uncover the truth. Regardless, the mysterious death of Captain David W. Pay
became an enduring part of Fishkill Landing history, one that to many carried
the lingering suspicion that Mary Pay had got away with murder.
Hello everyone, and thank you so much for listening. As usual, please leave any
comments or feedback you may have, and I hope to see you all again in the next
Brief Case.
