Darksword-Armory Ranger Sword Review

Ancient Edge 1
3 followers
1 Video View·Apr 24, 2025
Rather than just show what they can chop, I decided to make some more hands-on sword reviews to answer a lot of the questions I had about the swords when I was considering purchasing them. Enjoy and please let me know what questions you have or what swords you want to see reviewed!
Hello, I'm here to review a new sword with you guys. This is the Ranger Sword by Dark Sword
Armory. They're a company out of Canada, if you don't know. Pretty great company. But I'm trying
to give you a bit of a no-frills review on this sword and a lot of other swords. A lot of reviews
out there, a lot of people chopping stuff up and giving reviews, but they don't really give me the
information I need. I decided, so I wanted to, I'm setting out to make some some good reviews here.
Starting with this sword and I'll do any swords I have eventually and any swords you guys want
that I can see if I get a hold of. So first sword, Ranger Sword by Dark Sword Armory. I've had this
one for a few years. They've had at least two renditions of this sword as far as I'm aware.
This one is a little further from the Lord of the Rings movie version than I would like, than
the previous edition as well, but it's still a great sword. So overall stats on this guy. This
guy is 46 and a half inches overall. So 46 and a half overall. Gives it a 36 inch blade. 46 overall,
36 inch blade. The hilt got about nine and a half inches here and importantly the blade is
just over two inches wide. It's about two and a eighth, two and a quarter wide compared to the
United Cutlery official version is just under two inches wide. So this guy's a little
little wider. Length is almost exactly the same as the United Cutlery version, so that's kind of cool.
All right, overall weight on this guy is four pounds 11 ounces. So that's a hefty sword. I
believe Dark Sword said it's one of their absolute biggest and heaviest swords they make, which is
an interesting stat for this guy. Anyway, they use a 5160 high carbon steel for this guy,
so pretty good steel. It's a good spring steel, so it does and can take a good bend to it
and return to its initial original straight state there. So that's pretty cool.
They call it a dual tempered blade, which means they did go through the work of making the blade
itself harder than the rest of the steel used on the sword, which is great. If you don't know,
they do that so you can have a sword that has that ability to bend well but still can retain
a good edge after cutting. So if it's not dual tempered, you just have a overall too soft of a
sword, then the edge will dull really quickly and if you harden the whole sword too much,
then it might break when you're actually cutting people down. So the dual tempering
is a good solution for that when companies can actually make it happen. A good forger
will be able to do that. So that's a good thing that Dark Sword is doing with these.
They say it's a Rockwell hardness of 60 on the edge and like 48 to 50 in the middle,
something like that. Just some numbers for you. Okay, some general impressions of this guy.
It's a good sword overall. So general impression, good sword, even great sword. I love it. It's got
that spring steel, fantastic. It's a little bigger and heavier than I like. I try to carry it around,
whether it's just Renaissance festivals, that kind of thing, Halloween. It's a hefty sword.
It's almost too big for me to carry. I'm 5'11", 210 pounds and it's a hefty sword. I don't like
carrying it around on my belt at all. It's too big, too heavy. So we'll get into more of that
later. Everything's tight on it. There's nothing loose. It's a well-constructed sword. They make
the handle and the hilt parts really, really well. Let's see, everything else. Hilt construction,
yeah, decent. Tolerances, if you can see in there, pretty small gaps. Not bad, not bad.
Pretty good overall. They put a good finish on their swords, on their hilts and all the parts.
Pretty good overall. It's got a nice fuller running the full length, almost the full length
anyway. Nice deep fuller. Good gradual taper to the sword. So yeah, overall great set handle
construction. Great, great leather they use. It's durable. It's good. I love it. All right,
let's see. See if I want to get into issues here. Yeah, the Edge. Everyone's going to ask
about the Edge. Why am I not chopping stuff? I'm not going to be really chopping stuff with these
reviews. I might get into it later, but what I'm trying to do with these reviews is just handle
the sword right in front of you and really show it to you well. Edge, the ones I buy from them,
I buy them all sharpened. It's a $25 fee for them to sharpen it. Well, it's not much of an Edge.
We'll get on that later. I already discussed the fuller and the scabbard. The scabbards they give
you are pretty good. It's a good leather overall. You can get it with this integrated belt design.
That's pretty good. Nice steel tip to it on this guy. So yeah, they're good overall. It's a wood
core covered in leather. So a standard good design, but there's a good quality. It's a good quality
leather. They're solid and I'll get into an issue on that later though. So that's all the general
impressions of the sword. I said pretty good overall. So if we get into some issues, I already
touched on it. It's too heavy. This sword is too heavy, big and heavy. It's over four pounds. I would
love to see a 42 inch, three pound version of this. So if you knock me four inches off this sucker
and knock a pound off of it, I think it would be a much better sword. It's just, it's too hefty.
Yes, it's supposed to be a two-handed sword, but this thing is beefy and that is due to greatly
in fact, this huge pommel on it adds a lot of that weight. It seems to balance out the weight of
the blade though is what's going on there. Yeah, so I think it's too heavy for what it is.
We know Aragorn had a big heavy sword, but did it need to be this big and heavy? I don't
know about that. It's a little too unwieldy, I would say. So it's actually too
heavy for the belt they give you, honestly. If you put this thing on, it sags funny. It just
doesn't quite work. So if they are going to make the sword so heavy, well then they need a beefier
belt to go with it. I noted that. That's one thing interesting. So I think if I did it again
when I get the belt with the scabbard, I think I would still, but you'd also consider just having
your own belt for this one or any of their swords that are this heavy for that matter.
On that other issue, it's pretty close to the United Cutlery dimensions and why is that
important to me? I would like to be able to get the United Cutlery scabbard for this as well as
their other Lord of the Rings swords that they make. I think that's a cool thing to be able to
have a functional version of the sword that fits in the movie accurate scabbard because of course
United Cutlery doesn't make many of their swords into a functional battle ready version, but their
scabbards are really nice real leather and they look great. So yeah, I'd love this to fit in the
United Cutlery scabbard. This one is actually really close. It may or may not fit as I touched
on earlier. I'm actually going to buy a United Cutlery scabbard and see if it fits and see if I
can modify it to fit, but I don't have one yet. Contrary to their Anduril, Darksword Armory's
Anduril, that's nowhere near fitting. The after the United Cutlery one is actually significantly
longer. It's at least four or five inches longer than Darksword Armory's and it's also
Darksword Armory is much wider, so unfortunately there's no way you can make a Darksword Anduril
fit into a United Cutlery scabbard. You'd have to cut the blade way down to make it work, so
not really possible. So next issue, the sharpness of the blade. I touched on that before and I'll
get into that more now. I said it costs $25 for Darksword to sharpen the blade for you.
Pretty good price. That's not bad at all, but for what you get from that, to me
it's not an edge you can do anything with. It's still what I would consider a fairly blunt edge,
so they say it's very sharp is how it's worded by Darksword when they ship it with the edge that
you pay for and I would... it's not. It's a mediocre sharpness I would say at best.
I've tried to cut stuff with this from with the edge that they provide and it will not cut much,
so you can do some chopping with it because it's a good wide bevel that they put on it, but you
cannot chop very... cut very much with this, unfortunately. Try to cut bottles and you're
most likely not going to cut them. You're going to hit them like a club with it, unfortunately. So
the edge has some considerable work needed. That's not a big deal for me. I have a decent grinder.
I can re-sharpen them, put a better edge on them, but for people looking to get these swords,
yeah, you probably want to know you're not going to get a razor sharp sword from the
$25 edge they're going to put on it. So yes, I would love to see them offer an actual sharp
sword sharp edge on these guys that's more usable, but as of now it's not. It's this
very average sharpness that's more for show than anything I would say.
So next issue with it. Why did they change their design? It used to be closer to the movie version
sword and then they changed it. It was mostly the hilt that I noted. I've never owned one of those.
I've just seen pictures of them. The hilt was very different. It was quite similar,
almost exact to the movie version. Now you have this that's not. It's much different right in
here. So the rest is similar enough. I think this whole handle system is a little too wide
compared to the United Cutlery and movie version, but the biggest thing is it's just going to be
that hilt. It's just a totally different design. Really unlike anything,
unlike the movie version at all, unfortunately. So yeah, those are my biggest gripes with this,
the biggest issues I have. So overall, fantastic. I'm going to be giving out a rating score to
all these sword reviews I'm doing. Out of 10, it's a very subjective scale. I don't have exactly 10
classes broken down, but just out of all the spots that they can possibly lose points,
10 being the highest, I'm going to give this one a 7 out of 10. And to me, what I made it
lose a point for three points. First point is going to be the size and weight. Just too big
and heavy. Needs to be a pound lighter, a few inches shorter. So one point for the size and
weight. One point for the hilt tolerances. As I showed you before, they're okay, but they're not
the best. And again, I'll show you that. It's decent, especially this side here. There's a
decent gap in there. So it doesn't have any wiggle to it, but if you have a really good
sword company, they will have little to no gap in there. So yeah, the tolerances are a little off
for sure. I'd like to see better tolerances by them. And then the last point, so that's the
second point. The last point is the sharpness. So again, yeah, you're paying for that service
and I can run my finger on that and it's all day and it's not going to cut me. So
they need to up their game with their sharpness. So again, 7 out of 10, pretty good score.
Next big question then, is it worth the money? You can get this guy, I think it starts about
$525, somewhere in there for just the sword itself, a blunt version of the sword. You can
pay up to $700, out the door $700 if you want it with the scabbard, belt, and sharpen. So that's
what this was, $700 sharpened with the scabbard and the belt. And yeah, is it worth $700? I think
so. I mean, that's fine. It's better than most swords you can get in that range, I would say,
at least as good. So yeah, definitely worth the money. Big question, my next big question I'm
going to hit on with every sword I'm reviewing here. Would I take this into battle and trust it?
That's, I think that's a big question I have for any sword I get. I try not to buy any swords if
I can't bring it into battle and use it. Hypothetical battle, of course. I don't know if
this is going to be zombies, people, bears, not sure. But would I bring it to that battle and
trust it? Yes, I would. For sure, 100%. Only if I put a better edge on it. Right now, this is just
a glorified club and I would not want to take it into battle. If I put a good edge on it, which
the steel can handle since they use that good dual hardened steel with a good edge, then yes,
I will take this in a heartbeat into battle and swing it all day long until I'm exhausted because
it's so heavy. So that's all I have for this guy. I hope you enjoyed my video. If you have any
questions, either on this sword or any other dark sword armory products, I happen to have a lot of
them. I have no affiliation with them, but I have a lot of their swords. I've talked to them a decent
amount over the years. If you have any questions on their swords in general, please feel free to ask.
If you have any more questions on this sword, please ask down below and I'll try to get back
to you. If you want to see a review on a particular dark sword, armory sword, or any other swords,
I've got a lot of museum replica swords and knives, daggers as well. So that kind of stuff,
I can talk a lot about the quality of those as well as some of the Albion and other companies
out there I'll be trying to do some reviews on. So please, any questions of this other swords,
let me know and I'll do the best I can to get back to you on them. Thank you.
